Ordering from gimme smore was so easy and seamless. They made the cake for my daughter’s baptism in December and it was the best cake I’ve ever had and had many people tell me the same. It was exactly what I wanted and they made everything a breeze from ordering to pickup. My cake was ready at the time we had agreed upon and we even chatted for a bit and Victoria is just a lovely person. Will definitely be ordering from here again and would highly recommend using them for your next event!
Apr 14 · Briana ArochoGimme S'more Bakery
1109 Englishtown Rd Unit 1, Old Bridge, NJ 08857, USA
Directory information can change. Confirm current hours, prices, products, dietary needs, and custom-order requirements directly with the bakery.

Essential details
- Address
- 1109 Englishtown Rd Unit 1, Old Bridge, NJ 08857, USA
- Phone
- (732) 210-7777
- Website
- Visit official site
- Rating signal
- 4.0 from 66 recorded reviews
Listed operating hours
- MondayClosed
- TuesdayClosed
- WednesdayClosed
- ThursdayClosed
- FridayClosed
- Saturday10:00 AM – 2:00 PM
- Sunday10:00 AM – 2:00 PM
About and visit notes
Welcome to the heart of sweet indulgence in Central New Jersey! For residents of Middlesex County and beyond, finding that perfect bakery—one that delivers on both stunning design and unforgettable flavor—is essential, especially when planning a special event. Allow us to introduce you to Gimme S'more Bakery, a local small business that has quickly become a beloved spot in the community, renowned for its commitment to quality, freshness, and truly exceptional customer service.
This is more than just a place to grab a quick treat; Gimme S'more Bakery is where artistry meets confectionery, resulting in creations that make any occasion—from a child's birthday to a sacred event like a baptism or First Holy Communion—extra special. Operating right here in Old Bridge, this establishment focuses on providing a seamless, enjoyable experience from the moment you place an order to the last delicious bite. For anyone in New Jersey seeking a reliable, high-quality bakery experience, this local gem should be at the top of your list.
Location and Accessibility
Gimme S'more Bakery is conveniently situated to serve the greater Old Bridge area and surrounding New Jersey communities. You can find this sweet spot at the following address: 1109 Englishtown Rd Unit 1, Old Bridge, NJ 08857, USA. Located in a spot that allows for relatively easy access, it serves as a great destination for both quick stops and planned pickups.
For all local patrons, accessibility is a key consideration, and Gimme S'more Bakery has taken steps to ensure a welcoming experience for everyone. The establishment features a wheelchair accessible parking lot, removing a common hurdle for guests with mobility needs and ensuring that every member of the New Jersey community can visit the bakery without undue stress. Furthermore, for those on a tight schedule, the planning options indicate that the bakery is set up for a quick visit, making it efficient for customers who need to pop in, grab their order, and be on their way.
Services Offered
As a modern, customer-focused small business, Gimme S'more Bakery offers a comprehensive array of service options designed to provide maximum convenience for its New Jersey clientele. Whether you prefer to pick up your order in person or have it brought right to your door, the team has implemented flexible solutions to meet various needs.
The full range of available service options includes:
- Delivery: Perfect for busy local residents or for sending a sweet surprise without leaving your home or office. This service brings the bakery’s fresh products directly to your location.
- Curbside Pickup: An exceptionally convenient option for those who want to save time. Customers can simply pull up, and their order will be brought out to their vehicle. This minimizes contact and maximizes efficiency, which is a major benefit for quick event planning.
- In-Store Pickup: The traditional method for retrieving pre-ordered items, allowing customers to step inside, confirm their details, and collect their freshly baked goods.
- In-Store Shopping: For those who enjoy browsing the daily selection or need a spontaneous treat, the bakery invites customers to come inside and shop their available offerings.
- Takeout: A straightforward option for purchasing items to enjoy elsewhere.
The variety of service options reflects the bakery’s dedication to a high-level, A1 customer experience. They aim to make the process of ordering, from initial contact to final consumption, as easy and seamless as possible for all New Jersey customers.
Features / Highlights
Gimme S'more Bakery distinguishes itself through several key features that contribute to its highly positive reputation within the New Jersey community. These highlights often revolve around the quality of their creations and the personalized attention provided by the team.
The standout features that make this bakery a preferred choice include:
- Exceptional Custom Cake Artistry: The bakery specializes in making custom cakes that are not only delicious but also exact interpretations of the customer’s vision. Whether for a baptism, a milestone birthday, or a First Holy Communion, the team demonstrates remarkable detail and artistic skill in bringing designs to life.
- Out-of-This-World Flavors and Freshness: Customers consistently rave about the quality of the cakes, calling them the "best cake I’ve ever had." This highlights a strong commitment to using fresh ingredients and creating flavors that stand out, ensuring every item is a treat for the taste buds.
- A1 Customer Service and Personal Touch: The team is frequently praised for being 'absolutely A1' in customer service. This includes making the ordering process 'easy and seamless,' being friendly, and communicating clearly. Specific team members, like Victoria, are noted for being 'lovely people' who enhance the overall, personal customer experience.
- Local, Small Business Dedication: As a small, local business, Gimme S'more offers a level of personalized care and attention that larger chains often cannot match, directly benefiting the local Old Bridge and wider New Jersey community.
- Efficient and Modern Payment Options: For convenience, the bakery accepts both major Credit Cards and Debit Cards, simplifying the payment process for pre-orders and in-store purchases alike.
Contact Information
To connect with Gimme S'more Bakery for inquiries, custom orders, or to discuss your next special event, please use the following contact details.
Address: 1109 Englishtown Rd Unit 1, Old Bridge, NJ 08857, USA
Phone: (732) 210-7777
Mobile Phone: +1 732-210-7777
The team looks forward to helping you make your event memorable with fresh, artistic, and flavorful baked goods.
What is Worth Choosing Gimme S'more Bakery
In a state as diverse as New Jersey, where options abound, choosing a bakery for a pivotal event is a decision that requires confidence. Gimme S'more Bakery earns this confidence through a demonstrated track record of excellence in both product and process. What is truly worth choosing here is the complete package: the seamless experience, the artistic skill, and the guarantee of a truly delicious product.
The positive feedback from local customers is a powerful testament to their quality. Reviewers mention that the bakery "really made my daughter’s birthday and First Holy Communion so much more special," indicating that their work goes beyond mere baking—it contributes significantly to the joy and memory of the event. The dedication to detail and freshness, which is consistently rated "10000/10" and "spot on," means that local patrons do not have to compromise between a visually stunning cake and a flavor that wows every guest.
Moreover, the ease of ordering and pickup—with services like curbside pickup and clear communication—removes the stress often associated with event preparation. When customers describe the experience as "exactly what I wanted" and that the team "made everything a breeze," it’s a clear signal that this small business is focused on relieving, not adding to, the pressure of planning. The sentiment is clear: for the best bakery experience in New Jersey, one that offers both world-class flavor and truly stellar service, local patrons "would be a fool not to use this establishment."
Whether you are planning a large celebration, or simply need a quick, delicious treat, Gimme S'more Bakery stands ready in Old Bridge to provide top-tier baked goods with a friendly, professional, and highly efficient service model.
Services and accessibility
These attributes come from the directory record and should be confirmed when essential.
From the business
- Small business
Service options
- Curbside pickup
- Delivery
- In-store pickup
- In-store shopping
- Takeout
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- Credit cards
See the bakery
Reviews and recurring themes
Read individual comments as personal experiences, not verified guarantees.
WE LOVE THE GIMME S’MORE TEAM!!!!! First off the customer service is absolutely A1, highly recommend just off the strength of that. Detail, Artistic Skill and Freshness, 10000/10 just amazing and spot on! They really made my daughter’s birthday and First Holy Communion so much more special. Flavors out of this world. The best bakery around NJ, you’d be a fool not to use this establishment.
May 5 · nicole sorensenFrom a foodie who loves and appreciates foods of all kinds, please let me tell you about Gimme S’more Bakery. From the initial phone call to the finished product, every point of planning (for a surprise 75th birthday party for mom) was pleasant and engaging. The cake aesthetically pristine and the most delicious cake i’ve ever had at any event. Ever. Customized specifically to mom’s liking. Amazing. Everything was delicious and not just in the way someone would say ‘everything was delicious. Everything. Was. Delicious. 10 out of 10 highly recommend!
Jun 17 · Domenica FrattoI ordered from this bakery for both of my sons' birthday parties. I ordered two large cakes and a bunch of other treats. Everything looked beautiful, however, both times when we cut into the cake it was extremely dry and just crumbled into pieces. Most of the cake was thrown out and no one enjoyed it. When I picked up the order, I was given instructions to take the cake out of the fridge about 3 hours prior to cutting it which I did. The first time, I was disappointed but did not say anything to the owner because I thought it was how I cut it or some other reason. The second time around, I made sure to take pictures and send them to her. The response I got was pretty much, "sorry, but can't help you." She said that I did not take it out of the fridge early enough and it was too cold. After researching a little about why a cake would crumble, I read that there are many reasons such as over or under baking, over-mixing, lack of moisture, unbalanced recipe, etc. Most of the reasons are not from anything I could have done differently. Our family does not do big parties for our kids like this every year because they are just so expensive, so it's extremely upsetting for the cake to be a complete disaster for our past two parties. Not a moment we can get back.
Apr 15 · Melissa NeupaneIf you’re looking for someone to make your kid’s birthday extra special, look no further than Gimme S’more! 💕 I used them for my son’s 5th birthday and I was blown away. The owner was such a great communicator and seriously went above and beyond. She even ordered the monster trucks herself to make my son's cake vision come to life! and let me tell you, a monster truck crashing into the cake is about as cool as it gets for a 5-year-old boy. 🛞💥🎂 My son was obsessed!And the Funfetti cupcakes? Oh. My. Gosh. SO moist, so yummy, and they disappeared faster than I could grab one for myself 😂. To top it off, she delivered everything right to the party which made life 100x easier.Highly recommend!! Gimme S’more CRUSHED 🏁 it! 🧁✨
Sep 7 · Gina MeyerCompare another bakery nearby
Sorted by geographic proximity from this bakery.







Brunswick Brunch & Bagels Formerly Crazy bagels
310 Rues Ln, East Brunswick, NJ 08816, USA





This page combines directory records, available business details, submitted photos, and visitor feedback. Information may be incomplete or change without notice. For corrections, contact server@heavenlydelightsbakery.com.
