My Three Sons Bagel CaféSure, it’s a deli—but don’t let that fool you. My Three Sons Bagel Café runs like a well-oiled machine. Even when the place is hopping, they keep things moving with zero chaos and total confidence. You’ll be in and out with a fresh, delicious bagel before you can even check your texts.And let’s talk about those bagels: every single one hits the mark. Fresh, flavorful, and made just how you like it. Bonus points for the fact that the person who takes your order is the same one who makes it—meaning fewer mistakes, faster service, and no sad surprises when you unwrap your sandwich.The staff is on it. Friendly, focused, and clearly invested in getting your order right the first time. Plenty of parking, zero hassle, and none of that all-too-common “wait… this isn’t what I ordered” disappointment.Bottom line? My Three Sons isn’t just a deli—it’s the real deal. Give them a shot, especially if you’re tired of playing deli roulette.
Jun 9 · John FuentesMy Three Sons Bagel Cafe (Nassau Blvd)
295 Nassau Blvd, Garden City South, NY 11530, USA
Directory information can change. Confirm current hours, prices, products, dietary needs, and custom-order requirements directly with the bakery.

Essential details
- Address
- 295 Nassau Blvd, Garden City South, NY 11530, USA
- Phone
- (516) 408-9998
- Website
- Visit official site
- Rating signal
- 4.0 from 220 recorded reviews
Listed operating hours
- Monday6:00 AM – 4:00 PM
- Tuesday6:00 AM – 4:00 PM
- Wednesday6:00 AM – 4:00 PM
- Thursday6:00 AM – 4:00 PM
- Friday6:00 AM – 4:00 PM
- Saturday6:00 AM – 3:00 PM
- Sunday6:00 AM – 3:00 PM
About and visit notes
For many New Yorkers, the quest for the perfect bagel is a lifelong journey. In Garden City South, that journey often leads to My Three Sons Bagel Cafe on Nassau Boulevard. This local institution has earned a reputation that extends far beyond a simple deli. It’s a place where the art of the bagel is respected, and the service is as sharp as a freshly sliced knife. The moment you step inside, you can feel the energy of a well-oiled machine in operation. The aroma of freshly baked bagels and brewing coffee fills the air, creating a quintessential New York breakfast experience that is both comforting and exciting.
The core of My Three Sons' success lies in its unwavering commitment to quality. Their bagels are hand-rolled and baked to perfection, possessing that ideal combination of a satisfyingly chewy interior and a crisp exterior. This dedication to tradition is what sets them apart and keeps a steady stream of loyal customers coming back for more. Beyond the bagels themselves, the menu is a testament to their versatility. It's not just a bagel shop; it's a full-fledged deli and cafe. You can get everything from classic breakfast sandwiches and omelettes to specialty wraps and deli items, all made with fresh ingredients. This diverse offering ensures that there is something for every member of the family, no matter their preference.
What truly makes this specific location shine, as noted by local patrons, is the efficiency and confidence of its staff. Even during the busiest morning rush, they manage to keep things moving with a sense of calm and control. The direct line of communication, where the person taking your order is often the same person making it, minimizes errors and speeds up the entire process. This focus on customer experience, from the moment you order to the final bite of your delicious meal, is what transforms a simple deli visit into a seamless and enjoyable part of your day. This article will explore the location, services, and unique highlights that make My Three Sons Bagel Cafe a true local treasure in Garden City South.
My Three Sons Bagel Cafe is conveniently located at 295 Nassau Blvd, in the heart of Garden City South. This prime location places it within easy reach for residents of Garden City, Franklin Square, and other neighboring Long Island communities. The store is situated on a well-known thoroughfare, making it a familiar and easy-to-find spot for both regulars and new customers.
Accessibility is a key advantage of this location. For those traveling by car, there is plenty of parking available, which is a major convenience in the sometimes-crowded New York area. This makes it a hassle-free destination for a quick breakfast pickup on the way to work or a weekend stop with the family. The location on Nassau Boulevard also provides straightforward access from major roads, allowing for a smooth and efficient trip.
For those who rely on public transportation, the cafe is situated along a bus route, providing an alternative way to get there. Its central position in the community ensures that it is a gathering place and a hub of local activity. The easy access, combined with the reputation for quality, makes this particular My Three Sons location a highly desirable destination for anyone on Long Island looking for an authentic and satisfying bagel experience.
My Three Sons Bagel Cafe on Nassau Boulevard offers a range of services designed to meet the needs of its diverse clientele, ensuring convenience and satisfaction with every visit.
In-Store Ordering: The traditional and most popular service, allowing customers to place their orders at the counter and witness the efficient operation of the staff in a bustling and friendly environment.
Online and App Ordering: For maximum convenience, customers can place their orders ahead of time through the cafe's website or popular third-party delivery apps. This option is ideal for those who want to skip the line and have their order ready for a quick pickup.
Delivery: In partnership with various delivery services, My Three Sons brings its delicious bagels, sandwiches, and coffee directly to your home or office. This ensures you can enjoy their food from anywhere within their delivery radius.
Catering Services: The cafe offers extensive catering options, including breakfast platters, bagel assortments, sandwich wraps, and deli hero platters. This is a perfect solution for office meetings, family gatherings, or any event that requires high-quality, crowd-pleasing food.
My Three Sons Bagel Cafe is known for several key features and highlights that have cemented its place as a local favorite.
Fresh, Hand-Rolled Bagels: The foundation of the business is its bagels, which are consistently praised for being fresh, flavorful, and possessing the perfect New York texture. They are the "real deal" and a cut above the rest.
Efficient and Confident Staff: The staff at this location is highly regarded for their speed and accuracy. They are focused, friendly, and invested in getting orders right the first time, which provides a sense of confidence and trust for customers.
Extensive Menu: Beyond bagels, the cafe offers a wide variety of food and drinks. The menu includes omelettes, breakfast wraps, griddle items like Brioche French toast, a full deli with paninis and wraps, and a coffee bar with both hot and iced specialty drinks.
Signature Dishes: The cafe has a reputation for certain standout items, such as their Brioche French toast with bananas and caramel, and their delicious Raspberry lemonade. These dishes showcase their ability to create memorable and satisfying meals beyond the standard bagel.
Commitment to Quality: Despite the fast-paced environment, the cafe is noted for its attention to detail and commitment to using fresh ingredients, as seen in their willingness to rectify any issues to ensure customer satisfaction.
For more information or to place an order, you can contact My Three Sons Bagel Cafe using the following details.
Address: 295 Nassau Blvd, Garden City South, NY 11530, USA
Phone: (516) 408-9998
My Three Sons Bagel Cafe is the perfect spot for locals in New York, especially those in the Garden City South area, because it seamlessly blends traditional quality with modern convenience. The commitment to fresh, hand-rolled bagels and an extensive menu ensures that it’s a one-stop-shop for all breakfast and lunch needs. For busy New Yorkers, the cafe's efficient service and accurate order fulfillment are invaluable, saving time and preventing the disappointment of a messed-up meal.
The accessibility of its Nassau Boulevard location, complete with ample parking, makes it an easy and convenient part of any daily routine. Whether you're heading to work, taking the kids to school, or just craving a delicious snack, My Three Sons provides a consistent and high-quality experience. It’s more than just a bagel shop; it's a reliable community fixture that serves up delicious food with confidence and care. For anyone tired of "deli roulette" and looking for a trustworthy local spot, My Three Sons Bagel Cafe is the real deal.
Services and accessibility
These attributes come from the directory record and should be confirmed when essential.
Service options
- Delivery
- In-store pick-up
- In-store shopping
- Takeaway
- Dine-in
Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible car park
- Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Offerings
- Coffee
Dining options
- Breakfast
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
See the bakery
Reviews and recurring themes
Read individual comments as personal experiences, not verified guarantees.
So, my review for this Nassau Blvd location is mixed. I will start with the positives. Now the taste of my food was amazing. The Brioche french toast with caramel and bananas. Like IHOP used to have this dish and it was my favorite...the Banana Foster, so I just recreated it, and Oh was I satisfied.Now the issue here was.....I may not have been satisfied if I didn't watch and check the people. The young lady opened my banana maybe 5-7 minutes before the French toast was ready....and flies were landing and coming back. So when the lady was about to put that old banana, I had to say No.. New banana or No banana. They cut a fresh one and solved.The potato salad given to me as a side to my sandwich dish was a fail, but they easily replaced with a chips when it did not taste well. The sandwich was also good.The Raspberry lemonade was delicious. So in total... I would say, I am satisfied, but maybe I will order in store always to keep an eye...and only this location do I approve. Because I tried the Covert location after and their French Toast was so dry.Will I be back? Yes...they mastered that Banana Foster dish. Even with the hiccup, I was pleased.
Mar 25 · J LoveThe best tasting Bagels! I’m a Pharma rep and order from them all the time! The food is amazing and so is their coffee! There is 5 stairs…. Patricia, especially for helping me out and going the extra mile!
Jun 24 · Eric SanfordSmall shop, does not have a lot of variety of cream cheese. Ordered omelette on a roll. Spinach was not fresh at all. Didn’t chop the spinach, put the entire leaf on the omelette. Food is expensive. Service is very slow. Paid 5.97 only for the roll with omelette.
Oct 24 · Faryal ChaudhryI am not somebody to write reviews because i hate negative stuff but I’ve had it:I’ve given this place more than enough try’s to like it and get a better taste in my mouth for the individuals whom work behind the counter but i’ve truly only had one great interaction with an employee there. The woman with the black hair and tattoos is by far the most sweetest outgoing employee there. You can see she is NOT LAZY. All other employees make things up as they go and make their own rules is pathetic. Where is the owner of this business ?? It seems to be self ran by the employees themselves because this is not the same place that i knew a couple years back. It is a mess and the food is a mess. The bagels are incredible but the cooking is awful by the employees.It’s extremely unfortunate that the employees at the nassau blvd location are lazy and cut corners resulting in terrible reviews and terrible tasting food. The audacity to ruin a businesses reputation in a wealthy & high consumer area is very sad.My fiancé ordered a BEC and the bacon was RAW on some pieces. This is absolutely unacceptable and completely unsanitary serving people raw food. This place needs a serious revaluation and the owner needs to take charge and read how negative these reviews are before hiring employees that are lazy and get too comfortable serving half raw food and not even being ableto butter a bagel !!!! The amount of times I have ordered a bagel with butter and all i’ve tasted was bread is enough to be unable to count on both of my hands. -This is a very fast paced business and extremely busy but that doesn’t give any employee the green light to slack in the food industry and serve uncooked raw food or not meeting the services standards that businesses 10x more busy meet on a regular basis. If you are unable to serve food meeting protocol (unless someone asks for RARE bacon) then do not take it upon yourself to serve such a things without considering potential health consequences. Ultimately if you’re unable to serve decent food when rush occurs you probably don’t belong in the food industry considering the amount of stress that comes with rushes and a fast pace environment.To the owner - you need to reevaluate this location because it’s disgusting considering i am paying as a consumer for a great place i once loved to now throwing my breakfast in the trash because its raw and tastes terrible.
Mar 18 · Emily SmithCompare another bakery nearby
Sorted by geographic proximity from this bakery.



Bagel Craft of West Hempstead
118 Hempstead Turnpike, West Hempstead, NY 11552, USA






My Three Sons Bagel Cafe (Covert Ave)
88 Covert Ave, Stewart Manor, NY 11530, USA



GEMMIES, INC. u2014 BAKED GOODS. ONLINE STORE. PICK-UP ONLY. LONG ISLAND, NY
734 Franklin Ave Suite 753, Garden City, NY 11530, USA
This page combines directory records, available business details, submitted photos, and visitor feedback. Information may be incomplete or change without notice. For corrections, contact server@heavenlydelightsbakery.com.
