BAKERY PROFILE

Noble Pies

★ 4.083 recorded reviews$10–20

Best Pies in New York, 38 Main St, Tarrytown, NY 10591, USA

DirectionsCallWebsite

Directory information can change. Confirm current hours, prices, products, dietary needs, and custom-order requirements directly with the bakery.

Noble Pies
PLAN THE VISIT

Essential details

Address
Best Pies in New York, 38 Main St, Tarrytown, NY 10591, USA
Phone
(914) 418-5649
Website
Visit official site
Rating signal
4.0 from 83 recorded reviews
HOURS

Listed operating hours

  • Monday9:00 AM – 8:00 PM
  • Tuesday9:00 AM – 8:00 PM
  • Wednesday9:00 AM – 8:00 PM
  • Thursday9:00 AM – 8:00 PM
  • Friday9:00 AM – 9:00 PM
  • Saturday9:00 AM – 9:00 PM
  • Sunday9:00 AM – 8:00 PM
About and visit notes

For residents and visitors in the dynamic Hudson Valley region of New York, finding a local spot that excels in multiple dessert categories is a rare and welcome treat. Noble Pies in Tarrytown, NY, is a unique establishment that defies simple categorization. While its reputation is built on its expertly crafted, award-winning pies, the business is officially designated as a multi-faceted destination, including an "Ice cream shop," a "Pie shop," a "Bakery," and a "Dessert shop." This comprehensive offering makes it a must-visit location for anyone in Westchester County seeking both comfort food and artisanal confections.

Positioned centrally in the historic village of Tarrytown, Noble Pies offers a compelling reason to pause your day, whether you are commuting via the nearby train station or simply enjoying the local charm. Its inclusion of an ice cream selection is a thoughtful addition, providing the perfect cool complement to its famous warm baked goods, especially appealing during the warm New York summers or as a rich counterpoint to a savory meal. This detailed overview will explore all the services, highlights, and practical details that make Noble Pies a standout establishment for New Yorkers looking for their next great dessert.

***

Introduction / Overview: Noble Pies – More Than Just the 'Best Pies in New York'

Noble Pies, proudly self-described as offering the "Best Pies in New York," operates from a charming location in Tarrytown, NY. The establishment’s business profile extends far beyond the traditional pie shop, embracing roles as a comprehensive dessert provider. Crucially, it is recognized as a full-service "Ice cream shop." This integration means patrons are not limited to just a slice of pie; they can enjoy a scoop of rich, creamy ice cream on its own or, as many connoisseurs suggest, perfectly paired with a warm slice of their signature sweet pies.

The reviews confirm that the ice cream is an exceptional quality offering, described by one happy customer as "thick and creamy," and specifically recommended to "go well with pies that can be warmed up." This focus on high-quality ingredients extends to everything on the menu, from the flaky crusts of their pies to the rich texture of their ice cream, upholding the high expectations of the New York consumer for fresh, superior products. Noble Pies successfully marries the rustic comfort of homemade pies with the refreshing delight of premium ice cream, all in one convenient Tarrytown location.

***

Location and Accessibility on Main Street, Tarrytown

Noble Pies is situated in a highly desirable and accessible location in Westchester County, right on the bustling Main Street of Tarrytown, a village known for its blend of historic architecture and vibrant local commerce.

Address: 38 Main St, Tarrytown, NY 10591, USA

This address positions the shop conveniently near the Tarrytown train station, a major transportation hub for Metro-North commuters. As one satisfied customer noted, it is a "Great spot to take some pie home before or after traveling," a key advantage for New Yorkers who rely on efficient travel. The 10591 zip code further places it within easy reach of residents in Irvington, Sleepy Hollow, and other neighboring Hudson Valley communities.

Accessibility Features:

The shop demonstrates a commitment to public access, a vital consideration for any New York business serving a diverse clientele.

  • Wheelchair Accessible Parking: Noble Pies provides a "Wheelchair accessible parking lot," which greatly enhances convenience and ensures that patrons with mobility needs can visit the shop comfortably, a necessary feature for serving the wide Westchester demographic.

  • Transit Convenience: Its proximity to the Tarrytown train station makes it highly accessible for foot traffic and those utilizing public transportation from New York City or other upstate locations.

***

Services Offered by Your Local Ice Cream and Pie Destination

Noble Pies provides a wide array of services that cater to both quick visits and large orders for events across the New York region.

  • Ice Cream Sales: The core offering in this category is high-quality, rich, and creamy ice cream, often sold by the scoop and intended as an ideal complement to their famous baked goods.

  • Takeout and In-Store Pickup: Confirmed service options include "In-store pickup" and "Takeout," perfect for busy New Yorkers needing an efficient way to grab their desserts or savory meals.

  • Delivery Service: Noble Pies also offers a "Delivery" service, providing maximum convenience for customers within their service radius who wish to enjoy their desserts or savory pot pies at home without leaving the house.

  • Diverse Dessert Menu: Beyond ice cream, the business operates as a full "Dessert shop," offering a massive selection of sweet pies (like Hudson Valley Apple and Mixed Berry), cream pies (such as Key Lime Pie and Black Dirt Chocolate Cream), and individual "Sweet Pie Slices" for instant gratification.

  • Savory and Meal Options: They also function as a "Bakery" and "Pie shop" offering substantial savory meals like "Chicken Pot Pie," "Shepherds Pie With Beef," and "Vegetable Quiche," catering to full-meal needs as well as dessert.

  • Coffee Service: Confirmed "Offerings" include "Coffee," making it a perfect spot for a quick morning visit or an afternoon pairing of a warm beverage with a sweet slice.

***

Features / Highlights for the New York Patron

Noble Pies distinguishes itself in the highly competitive New York dessert scene through a combination of product quality and practical convenience:

  • Premium Ice Cream Quality: Customer feedback highlights the ice cream as "thick and creamy," suggesting a high butterfat content and artisanal preparation that elevates it above mass-market options.

  • Exceptional Pie and Dessert Range: The immense variety of both sweet and savory pies, using local names like 'Hudson Valley Apple' and 'Black Dirt Chocolate Cream,' underscores a commitment to local sourcing and a deep, specialized menu.

  • Whip Cream Recommendation: The homemade "whipped cream" is highlighted as a major "plus plus plus" that customers "highly recommend adding," indicating an attention to detail in presentation and flavor complements.

  • Payment Flexibility: The acceptance of "Credit cards," "Debit cards," and "NFC mobile payments" provides maximum payment convenience, essential for a modern, quick-stop location.

  • Planning for Quick Visits: The stated goal of facilitating a "Quick visit" confirms the business is structured for efficiency, perfect for busy Westchester commuters or those grabbing a treat on the go.

***

Contact Information for Noble Pies Tarrytown

For New Yorkers planning a visit, placing a delivery order, or inquiring about custom or large-volume dessert orders, the verified contact details for Noble Pies are as follows:

Address: Best Pies in New York, 38 Main St, Tarrytown, NY 10591, USA

Phone: (914) 418-5649

Mobile Phone: +1 914-418-5649

***

What is Worth Choosing Noble Pies? A New York Perspective

Choosing Noble Pies over other dessert vendors in the highly saturated New York market is a choice for quality, convenience, and a unique product combination. For the New York resident, the value proposition is threefold:

Firstly, as a verified "Ice cream shop" that operates within a premier "Pie shop," Noble Pies offers a unique, one-stop dessert experience. The ability to pair high-quality, creamy ice cream with a warm, artisanal slice of pie—a classic pairing—in a single, local venue is a major convenience. This dual specialty means they are an ideal choice for both a quick refreshing scoop and a sophisticated holiday dessert order. The confirmed quality of the ice cream itself ensures satisfaction, especially when seeking a reliable dairy treat in Westchester County.

Secondly, the immense range of high-quality products, including both savory pot pies and the celebrated sweet pies, makes Noble Pies an indispensable resource for local entertaining. New Yorkers value efficiency; the ability to pick up an entire dinner (like a Chicken Pot Pie) along with a world-class dessert (a full pie or ice cream) is a significant time-saver. Furthermore, the numerous confirmed service options—Delivery, In-store pickup, and Takeout—cater perfectly to the fast-paced, urban-adjacent lifestyle of the Hudson Valley.

Finally, the prime location on Main Street, coupled with accessibility features like wheelchair-accessible parking, makes the visit hassle-free. The convenience of being located near the Tarrytown train station seals the deal for commuters. When seeking a combination of handcrafted quality, culinary versatility, and optimal convenience for dessert and more in the New York area, Noble Pies in Tarrytown stands out as a reliable and highly recommended local gem.

VISIT FEATURES

Services and accessibility

These attributes come from the directory record and should be confirmed when essential.

Service options

  • Delivery
  • In-store pickup
  • Takeout

Accessibility

  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings

  • Coffee

Planning

  • Quick visit

Payments

  • Credit cards
  • Debit cards
  • NFC mobile payments
PHOTOS

See the bakery

VISITOR FEEDBACK

Reviews and recurring themes

Read individual comments as personal experiences, not verified guarantees.

crust 10chicken pot pie 7ingredients 7whipped cream 6blueberry pie 6sweet 6chocolate pie 5key lime pie 5cherry pie 5apple 5
★ 2.0

For a pie shop, I would think they would be good at baking pies. We got the pumpkin pie and it was the worst pie I ever had. Shoprite has better pies. The crust was pale, pretty much white, and the bottom crust wasn't even baked. The filing was cracked so it looks to have been baked too long but the crust wasn't baked at all. For $8 a slice they need to do better. Also we got charged for whipped cream we never got. Save your money and don't be disappointed.

Sep 14 · Lisa S
★ 4.0

Feeling happy to find this place nearby the train station. Great spot to take some pie home before or after traveling.🍑🥧🧡Peach pie was delicious. I loved the crust a lot. It was crispy on the top with a pliable texture. The peach filling was sweet at the right level with peach chunks.Key lime pie was a classic, not my favorite but didn’t go wrong.The 🪄whipped cream was a plus plus plus! I highly recommend adding it.🍨💛The ice cream they got was thick and creamy. It will go well with pies that can be warmed up.

Jul 9 · Julia H
★ 2.0

In 90 degree heat, the pie milkshakes sound really good! Be sure to ask the price before ordering though since prices aren’t on the menu. $12 for such a small cup is awfully high. Still, a blended pie milkshake is pretty delicious although maybe their fridge for the milk isn’t powerful enough because it wasn’t very cold. It wasn’t warm, but it wasn’t ice-cream cold like I was hoping for.

Aug 13 · Nahja Noweh
★ 4.0

The one person show was nothing but great on a holiday. Place was kept smelling amazing and cleaned. It’s a cute spot to relax a bit. The chicken pie so good and the cherry pie yum. I am not a huge pie person but this was really pretty good pies! They have a market stand at 79th and Columbus Sunday farmers market in Manhattan as well.

Sep 5 · Cat Meows
★ 3.0

Pies are absolutly delicious, scones are average. First day(photos) everything was great in regular plates, but we went the days after to eat slices there. Not the same experience, we had to insist at every step for waste-free options - still were treated as take-out clients. Disposable dishes, barely warmed up pie and soaking wet wax paper took the enjoyment out of the experience.

Jan 2 · Vincent Beaudet
NEARBY ALTERNATIVES

Compare another bakery nearby

Sorted by geographic proximity from this bakery.

About this listing

This page combines directory records, available business details, submitted photos, and visitor feedback. Information may be incomplete or change without notice. For corrections, contact server@heavenlydelightsbakery.com.

SIDE-BY-SIDE

Bakery comparison

Expanded bakery photo