Petee's Pie Company

In a city filled with countless dessert options, from high-end pastry shops to cozy neighborhood bakeries, finding a place that specializes in one thing and does it to perfection is a true delight. Petee's Pie Company, located in the bustling Lower East Side, has become that very destination for New Yorkers craving a classic, impeccably made slice of pie. This isn't just any pie shop; it's a place where tradition meets a modern commitment to quality, a place where every pie tells a story of local farms, seasonal ingredients, and a passion for the craft. For a city that moves at a breakneck pace, Petee's offers a moment of sweet, comforting simplicity.

The story of Petee's Pie Company is rooted in a family legacy of pie-making. The owner, Petra "Petee" Paredez, grew up in her family's acclaimed pie company in Virginia, learning the secrets of flaky crusts and perfectly balanced fillings from a young age. She brought that rich heritage and a wealth of experience to New York City, founding a bakery dedicated to the simple concept of making the best pie money can buy using real ingredients. This means sourcing produce from local farms, using natural fair-trade sweeteners, and crafting their crust with organic New York State flour and grass-fed butter. This unwavering dedication to quality is evident in every single slice, from the perfectly tart New York sour cherry pie to the indulgent Salty Chocolate Chess. The result is a bakery that feels both timeless and perfectly suited for the discerning palates of New York locals.

Petee's Pie Company has a central and easily accessible location on the Lower East Side, making it a convenient stop for a wide range of New Yorkers. The bakery is situated at 61 Delancey St, New York, NY 10002, placing it right in the heart of one of the city's most dynamic neighborhoods. The location is a short walk from several key subway stations, ensuring that it is highly accessible via public transportation. The Delancey St-Essex St station, which serves the F, M, J, and Z lines, is just a few minutes away. The proximity to these major subway hubs makes it easy for people from Manhattan, Brooklyn, and Queens to visit. The surrounding neighborhood is a hub of activity, with art galleries, boutiques, and other eateries, making a trip to Petee's part of a larger outing.

The accessibility of Petee's is a significant advantage for locals. It's a prime spot to grab a pie for a last-minute dinner party, a slice to enjoy on a walk through the neighborhood, or to simply satisfy a late-night craving, given their generous hours of operation (11 AM to 11 PM, seven days a week). The central location means that whether you're coming from the Financial District, Midtown, or across the bridge from Brooklyn, a great slice of pie is never too far away. The bakery has also expanded its reach through multiple locations, including one in Brooklyn, further enhancing its accessibility for residents throughout the city. This widespread presence solidifies its status as a local favorite and a convenient option for anyone seeking a truly great pie.

Petee's Pie Company is a destination for all things pie, but their services extend beyond just delicious slices. They are a full-service bakery focused on providing a high-quality experience to every customer, whether they are dining in, picking up an order, or having a pie delivered.

Services Offered:

• Dine-In and Takeout: Customers can visit the cozy shop to enjoy a slice of pie and a cup of coffee, or they can take home whole pies or individual slices to share.
• Whole Pie Orders: They specialize in whole pies, which can be pre-ordered for pickup or delivery. This is a popular service for holidays, special events, or family gatherings.
• Delivery Services: Petee's Pie Company partners with various delivery services, allowing customers to get their favorite pies delivered directly to their door. This is a huge convenience for those who can't make it to the shop.
• Catering: The bakery offers catering services for large orders and events, including weddings and corporate functions. This is a perfect option for anyone looking to add a unique, delicious, and local touch to their celebration.
• Menu Variety: The menu includes a wide variety of pies, from classic fruit pies to rich cream pies and tarts. They also offer a selection of savory items like quiche and pot pies, as well as house-made ice cream to complement their pies.
• Online and Phone Orders: For maximum convenience, customers can place orders through their website or by calling the provided phone number, making it easy to secure a specific pie without worrying about it selling out.

What truly makes Petee's Pie Company a standout in the crowded New York food scene are its unique features and highlights. These are the details that showcase their passion and commitment to their craft.

Features and Highlights:

• Local and Seasonal Ingredients: A key highlight is their unwavering commitment to sourcing ingredients from local farms in New York State whenever possible. They use local apples, Montmorency cherries, and organic flour, which ensures freshness and supports the local agricultural economy.
• Classic and Innovative Flavors: The menu strikes a perfect balance between classic favorites, like the Hudson Valley Apple Pie, and more unique creations, such as the Lavish Chocolate Cream or the Strawberry Rhubarb. This variety appeals to both traditionalists and those looking for something new.
• Flaky, High-Quality Crust: The crust is a major highlight, made with organic flour and grass-fed butter. A flaky, buttery crust is the foundation of a great pie, and Petee's has perfected it.
• Not-Too-Sweet Fillings: Customers consistently praise the pies for not being overly sweet. The fillings are balanced, allowing the natural flavor of the fruit to take center stage, as is the case with their acclaimed NY sour cherry pie.
• Artisanal Craftsmanship: Every pie is a result of meticulous craftsmanship. The attention to detail is evident in the beautiful lattice work, the rich fillings, and the overall quality of each item.
• In-House Ice Cream: Serving their own house-made ice cream is a fantastic feature that elevates the pie-eating experience. Flavors like vanilla bean and chocolate chess swirl ice cream are the perfect accompaniment to a warm slice of pie.

For those ready to visit or place an order from Petee's Pie Company, here is the essential contact information.

Contact Information:

Address: 61 Delancey St, New York, NY 10002, USA

Phone: (646) 494-3630

Petee's Pie Company is an ideal place for New York locals because it offers a perfect blend of tradition, quality, and convenience that is hard to find. In a city where quick and easy is often prioritized over quality, Petee's stands as a beacon of artisanal excellence. It’s a place where you can get a slice of pie that tastes like it was made with love in a family kitchen, but with the added benefit of a professional, modern operation. The commitment to sourcing local ingredients resonates deeply with New Yorkers who are increasingly conscious of where their food comes from and want to support local farms. The wide variety of pies ensures that there's always something new to try, while the consistent quality of the classics ensures a reliable and satisfying experience every time. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion with a whole pie, or simply treating yourself to a slice after a long day, Petee's provides a comforting and delicious escape. The ability to order online and have a whole pie delivered makes it a perfect solution for busy urbanites. Petee's Pie Company is more than just a bakery; it's a piece of New York's culinary fabric, a place that brings a taste of honest, homemade goodness to the heart of the city.