SusieCakes - San Carlos

SusieCakes San Carlos: A Taste of Nostalgia on Laurel Street

For Bay Area residents seeking the pure, comforting taste of classic American desserts, SusieCakes - San Carlos stands out as a true local gem. More than just a simple bakery, this vibrant shop is a dedicated cake shop, cupcake shop, cookie shop, dessert shop, and pie shop rolled into one, specializing in timeless, from-scratch baked goods that evoke the warmth of a grandmother’s kitchen.

Founded by Susan Sarich, who brought her two grandmothers’ handwritten recipes from Chicago to the West Coast, SusieCakes operates on a simple, yet powerful promise: using only simple, back-to-basics ingredients—think creamy butter, whole milk, fresh eggs, and all-purpose flour—without any artificial preservatives, high-fructose corn syrups, or trans-fats. This dedication to quality is immediately apparent in every bite, from the perfectly balanced sweetness of the frosting to the moist crumb of their famous layer cakes.

Located on the bustling Laurel Street, the San Carlos bakery has become the go-to destination for local residents celebrating everything from birthdays and weddings to gender reveals and corporate events. Customers consistently rave about the superior quality and fresh taste, noting that the cupcakes and cakes are "absolutely delicious" and "taste fresh and amazing every single time." Moreover, SusieCakes is proudly an identifies as women-owned business, adding another layer of community pride for those looking to support local, purpose-driven establishments in California. Whether you need a stunning, custom-decorated cake or just a single, perfect cupcake for a moment of self-indulgence, SusieCakes delivers a genuinely memorable experience.

Location and Effortless Accessibility on the Peninsula

The location of SusieCakes in San Carlos ensures convenience for residents across the mid-Peninsula, making it an easy stop for a quick visit or scheduled pickup. Laurel Street is a recognized local hub, offering a lively and accessible environment.

Full Address:649 Laurel St, San Carlos, CA 94070, USA

The bakery is committed to ensuring a comfortable visit for all customers, with key accessibility features in place:

• Wheelchair Accessible Entrance: The storefront is designed to welcome all visitors.
• Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lot: Convenient parking is provided to accommodate guests with mobility needs.

In addition to physical accessibility, the bakery provides modern payment flexibility, accepting Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC Mobile Payments, streamlining the checkout process for maximum efficiency.

Comprehensive Services for Every Celebration

SusieCakes - San Carlos excels in offering a complete suite of services designed to make celebrating any occasion as easy and delicious as possible.

Customer Service Options:

• In-store Shopping: Experience the cheerful, bright interior and select your treats directly from the display case.
• In-store Pickup: Place your custom or large order ahead of time and pick it up quickly and efficiently.
• Takeout: Perfect for grabbing a favorite cupcake or a slice of cake on the go.
• Local Delivery: The bakery offers Delivery to homes and businesses in the surrounding area, ensuring your treats arrive fresh and on time for your event.

Product Offerings:

• Signature Layer Cakes: Specializing in classic favorites like the famous six-layer Vanilla Celebration Cake (with its retro-blue vanilla frosting), Old-Fashioned Chocolate Cake, Luscious Lemon Cake, and the beloved Carrot Cake with its unique praline filling.
• Cupcakes & Mini Cupcakes: A daily assortment of freshly baked, frosting-filled cupcakes available individually, in themed boxes (like Happy Birthday and Thank You assortments), or in dozens for parties. Options often include Red Velvet, Chocolate, and the signature SusieBlue Vanilla.
• Nostalgic Cookies & Bars: A rotating selection of cookies, including the classic Chocolate Chip, Snickerdoodle, and flourless options like the Peanut Butter Cookie. Take & Bake Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough is also available for baking fresh at home.
• Pies: Seasonal pie offerings, such as the best-selling Apple Crumble Pie, often available during holidays and special times of the year.
• Custom and Wedding Cakes: The bakery specializes in creating custom cakes for weddings, baby showers, gender reveals, and corporate gifting, complete with consultation and tasting services.

Features and Highlights That Define the Experience

The dedication to traditional recipes and superior customer experience elevates SusieCakes above a standard commercial bakery, creating a truly special local highlight in San Carlos.

• Grandmothers' Authentic Recipes: The foundation of every dessert is the carefully preserved, handwritten recipes of founder Susan Sarich’s grandmothers, ensuring an authentic, nostalgic taste that is both comforting and familiar.
• Commitment to Clean Baking: A firm rule of "If you can't spell it, we don't bake with it" means all items are baked from scratch on-site daily, using only simple, fresh ingredients—a huge draw for health-conscious Bay Area consumers.
• The Perfect Frosting: Customers consistently call out the frosting, describing it as "made to perfection," not overly sweet, but just sweet enough, a hallmark of their quality ingredients and classic technique.
• Exceptional Customer Service: The staff, often referred to as "the girls," are frequently highlighted in reviews for being "kind, helpful, and genuinely nice," making the entire in-store experience warm and delightful.
• One-Stop Party Shop: For the less organized planner, the San Carlos location often carries party essentials like birthday candles and hats, turning a dessert run into a complete celebration solution.
• Specialty Celebration Cakes: The Vanilla Celebration Cake, known for its colorful sugar confetti and retro-blue vanilla frosting, is a legendary party dessert often seen and requested at Bay Area events.

Contact Information

To place an order for your next celebration, inquire about custom cakes, or simply check on the day's fresh selection, please use the following contact details:

Address:649 Laurel St, San Carlos, CA 94070, USA

Phone:(650) 282-2253

Mobile Phone:+1 650-282-2253

What Makes SusieCakes the Best Choice on the Peninsula

For anyone in California's Peninsula region—from San Mateo to Redwood City and Belmont—seeking the perfect dessert, SusieCakes in San Carlos is the unequivocally best choice. It transcends the typical bakery experience by combining the high standards of a women-owned entrepreneurial venture with the nostalgic purity of old-fashioned American baking.

Choosing SusieCakes means choosing quality you can taste, knowing that every cake, cookie, and cupcake is made from scratch with simple, natural ingredients. The proof is in the loyal customer base, with families returning year after year for their signature Celebration Cakes. The convenience of their Delivery and In-store pickup options, paired with an accessible Laurel Street location and incredibly friendly staff, solidifies its position as the premier celebratory dessert shop. Whether you are planning an elaborate wedding or simply need a quick pick-me-up treat, SusieCakes - San Carlos guarantees a delicious moment that honors tradition and always tastes "THAT good."