BAKERY PROFILE

Sweets By SHAY.

★ 4.018 recorded reviews

Jefferson Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11216, USA

DirectionsCall

Directory information can change. Confirm current hours, prices, products, dietary needs, and custom-order requirements directly with the bakery.

Sweets By SHAY.
PLAN THE VISIT

Essential details

Address
Jefferson Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11216, USA
Phone
(929) 269-5087
Rating signal
4.0 from 18 recorded reviews
HOURS

Listed operating hours

  • MondayClosed
  • Tuesday11:00 AM – 6:00 PM
  • Wednesday11:00 AM – 6:00 PM
  • Thursday11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
  • Friday11:00 AM – 8:00 PM
  • Saturday12:00 AM – 8:00 PM
  • SundayClosed
About and visit notes

Brooklyn is a borough celebrated for its vibrant community and a rich tapestry of local businesses that give the neighborhood its unique flavor. Among the many hidden gems, a special place for sweet-toothed New Yorkers is Sweets By SHAY, a bakery that has carved out a reputation for creating delectable, custom-made treats. This isn’t just a place to grab a quick pastry; it's where residents turn to for desserts that are as memorable as the occasions they celebrate. From birthday parties to intimate gatherings, or simply a day when you need a little something to brighten your mood, Sweets By SHAY offers a range of options designed to delight. The bakery prides itself on using quality ingredients to craft a variety of desserts, from classic favorites to custom creations tailored to individual tastes.

The ethos of Sweets By SHAY is rooted in the belief that every dessert should be a work of art, both in taste and appearance. This is a business built on passion, and it shows in the care taken with each order. For many local customers, Sweets By SHAY has become a go-to for special moments, a trusted source for sweetening life's milestones. The focus on personalized service means that they work with clients to bring their dessert visions to life, ensuring that the final product is not only delicious but also perfectly suited to the event. In a city full of options, the dedication to a personal touch and the consistent quality of their products are what make this bakery stand out. They understand that a great dessert is more than just food—it's an experience, and they strive to make that experience exceptional every time.

The importance of a local bakery like Sweets By SHAY cannot be overstated. It’s more than just a place of commerce; it's a part of the community fabric. These are the businesses that give a neighborhood its character and provide a sense of familiarity and comfort. In a city as vast as New York, having a go-to spot for something as simple as a delicious dessert creates a connection and a sense of belonging. The fact that the owner, Shay, has been baking for over a decade for her community speaks to a deep-seated commitment to her craft and her customers. This long-standing presence in the area has allowed her to build relationships and become a familiar and trusted name for all things sweet.

While the bakery's offerings are certainly a major draw, the convenience of its location and services also contributes to its popularity. Sweets By SHAY is designed to be accessible to a busy, urban clientele. They understand that New Yorkers value both quality and efficiency, and they have structured their business to meet those needs. This includes a focus on made-to-order creations, which ensures freshness and allows for customization. The bakery is more than just a business; it’s a service provider that aims to simplify the process of getting high-quality, delicious desserts for any occasion.

The heart of this bakery is its commitment to creating everything from scratch. This dedication to traditional methods and fresh ingredients is a key factor in the high praise it receives for taste. When a dessert is made with care and without shortcuts, the difference is palpable. This is especially true for items like banana pudding and chocolate-covered strawberries, which are often cited by customers as being exceptionally good. This attention to detail and a refusal to compromise on quality is a testament to the baker's skill and passion. It’s a philosophy that resonates with customers who are looking for authentic, homemade flavor in a world dominated by mass-produced goods.

Sweets By SHAY is an embodiment of the local, artisan business model that thrives in neighborhoods like Brooklyn. It’s a business that operates on word-of-mouth, repeat customers, and a genuine connection to the people it serves. The glowing reviews from long-time patrons speak to the trust and loyalty that have been built over years of providing excellent products. This kind of relationship is invaluable and is the foundation of a successful community-based business. For those new to the area or looking for a new favorite, Sweets By SHAY presents a welcoming and reliable option for all dessert needs, big or small.

In conclusion, Sweets By SHAY is more than just a place that sells desserts. It's a local institution that provides a crucial service to the community: the creation of delicious, beautiful sweets that mark and enhance life's special moments. Its blend of traditional baking methods, personalized service, and a convenient location makes it a standout choice for anyone in the Brooklyn area looking for a bakery they can count on. It’s a testament to the idea that small businesses, driven by passion and a commitment to quality, can make a significant impact on their community, one delicious treat at a time.

Location and Accessibility

Sweets By SHAY is conveniently located on Jefferson Ave in Brooklyn, New York. This puts it at the heart of a bustling residential area, making it easily accessible for locals. The neighborhood is well-serviced by public transportation, with several bus lines and subway stations within a reasonable distance, allowing customers from different parts of the borough to reach the bakery without a car. For those who do drive, the street is part of a residential area, and while parking can be a typical New York challenge, there are usually options available on surrounding streets. Being situated in a residential part of Brooklyn means that it’s a familiar landmark for many who live nearby, making it a simple stop on their daily commute or a planned visit for a special order. The central location also allows for efficient delivery services to be offered throughout the surrounding neighborhoods, extending the bakery’s reach beyond just walk-in traffic.

Services Offered

  • Custom Cakes: Specializing in personalized cakes for birthdays, weddings, baby showers, and other significant events.
  • Chocolate-Covered Strawberries: A popular specialty item, often noted for their beautiful presentation and delicious taste.
  • Dessert Jars: Unique and convenient, these are perfect for individual servings or gifts, like the praised banana pudding jars.
  • Made-from-Scratch Desserts: A commitment to creating all products using fresh, high-quality ingredients from the ground up.
  • Custom Design and Decoration: A focus on working with customers to create visually stunning desserts that match the theme of their event.
  • Pickup and Delivery Options: Offering flexibility for customers to either pick up their orders or have them delivered to their location.

Features / Highlights

  • High-Quality Ingredients: A commitment to using fresh, made-from-scratch components is a consistent theme in customer feedback.
  • Artistic Decoration: The bakery is known for its detailed and aesthetically pleasing designs on cakes and other treats.
  • Customer Loyalty: The business has a strong base of repeat customers, with some mentioning they have been ordering for years, indicating a high level of trust and satisfaction.
  • Positive Word-of-Mouth: Many new customers are referred by existing ones, highlighting the strong reputation Sweets By SHAY has built in the community.
  • Responsiveness to Custom Requests: The bakery is known for being accommodating and collaborative in bringing customers’ unique ideas to fruition for their custom orders.
  • Attention to Detail: The careful preparation of each dessert, from the flavor to the final decorations, is a defining characteristic of the business.

Contact Information

Address: Jefferson Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11216, USA

Phone: (929) 269-5087

Conclusion: Why Sweets By SHAY is Suitable for Locals

For New Yorkers in Brooklyn, Sweets By SHAY is more than just a bakery—it's a reliable partner for all things sweet. Its location on Jefferson Avenue makes it a convenient spot for local residents, and its services are tailored to the needs of a community that values quality and convenience. The bakery’s reputation is built on a foundation of delicious, made-from-scratch desserts and an exceptional ability to create personalized treats for any occasion. Whether it’s for a last-minute craving or a carefully planned celebration, the range of services, from custom cakes to dessert jars and chocolate-covered strawberries, ensures there is something for everyone. This local business has proven its commitment to the community by consistently delivering on its promises of great taste and beautiful presentation. By supporting Sweets By SHAY, locals are not just buying a dessert; they are investing in a business that genuinely cares about its customers and adds a little more joy to their neighborhood, one perfect cake or sweet treat at a time. The loyalty of its customers speaks for itself, and for those yet to discover it, a visit to Sweets By SHAY promises to be a delightful introduction to one of Brooklyn's sweetest local treasures.

VISIT FEATURES

Services and accessibility

These attributes come from the directory record and should be confirmed when essential.

From the business

  • Identifies as Black-owned
  • Identifies as women-owned

Service options

  • Kerbside pickup
  • Delivery
  • Takeaway

Accessibility

    Amenities

      Crowd

      • LGBTQ+ friendly

      Planning

      • Appointment required
      • Quick visit

      Payments

      • NFC mobile payments
      PHOTOS

      See the bakery

      VISITOR FEEDBACK

      Reviews and recurring themes

      Read individual comments as personal experiences, not verified guarantees.

      banana pudding 3mother’s day 3cupcakes 2
      ★ 2.0

      The cakes, besides being very small, were not good. While the flavor and design weren’t bad, the decoration on the cakes was dangerous, as it was inedible and shaped like spheres that could easily choke someone. Regarding service, even though we didn’t stay, they were refusing to serve us at 4 PM, despite it clearly stating on Maps that they close at 6 PM.

      Nov 20 · Julio Jiménez
      ★ 5.0

      Everything is Delicious & made from scratch, I LOVE IT ... I Ordered a banana Pudding Jar & Chocolate covered strawberries for my mom for for mother’s day & I can say SweetsbyShay Never goes wrong with these desserts! Me & My Mothered Loved EVERYTHING ❤️ & This isn’t my first time ordering from here. I give sweets by shay a five star rating For taste & decoration ❤️ Everything was beautiful & Delicious

      May 12 · Sheena Beena
      ★ 5.0

      Sweets By SHAY cakes, cupcakes and edible arrangement designs are very creative and designed the way you like. Each time I ordered I was impressed with not only how beautiful the cakes and arrangements were but they were also very delicious. The Jell-O shots were a big hit. All cakes are made from scratch and with love. This is my new cake spot, great customer service and the price is right.

      May 11 · Monique Lovander
      ★ 2.0

      My mother bought a cake for my twin brother 4th birthday. First of all the cake was late and we were told that the oven was not working. She rush the cake and gave it to us the next day. The box that has the cake inside smells like weed and when my dad went to get the cake from her car there was a dog next to the cake. And like I said the car smelled like weed. This is a children’s cake and I am so disappointed, the fact that this place have all 5 stars is shocking. We were then told that we will be getting cupcakes for the lateness of the cake, but then she said they were no more cupcakes and brought Rice crispy‘s. And to sum this up my brothers names are not even on the cake so this was completely rushed. The quality of the cake we got compared to every else is just bad very bad.

      Apr 15 · Krystal Barrie
      ★ 5.0

      I absolutely loveddd my banana pudding ! I couldn’t put it down I will definitely be placing another order my grandmother and mother loved them it was like the cherry on top for Mother’s Day ! Thank you sooo much she replied in a timely manner, kept me posted with my order, and she’s so nice !!!

      May 11 · Chardonnay Gittens
      NEARBY ALTERNATIVES

      Compare another bakery nearby

      Sorted by geographic proximity from this bakery.

      Bagel Nest
      ★ 4.0 · 405 reviews · 0.2 mi

      Bagel Nest

      1237 Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY 11216, USA

      Details
      Cinnabon
      ★ 3.0 · 9 reviews · 0.2 mi

      Cinnabon

      1194 Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY 11216, USA

      Details
      Welcome Home
      ★ 4.0 · 132 reviews · 0.4 mi

      Welcome Home

      1047 Bedford Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11216, USA

      Details
      Miss Bagel
      ★ 4.0 · 99 reviews · 0.4 mi

      Miss Bagel

      1351 Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY 11216, USA

      Details
      Royal Bakery
      ★ 4.0 · 347 reviews · 0.4 mi

      Royal Bakery

      575 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11216, USA

      Details
      About this listing

      This page combines directory records, available business details, submitted photos, and visitor feedback. Information may be incomplete or change without notice. For corrections, contact server@heavenlydelightsbakery.com.

      SIDE-BY-SIDE

      Bakery comparison

      Expanded bakery photo