The Proper Pie Company

For Florida residents seeking a truly unique and authentic culinary experience, The Proper Pie Company in Haines City is the premier destination for genuine British fare. Operating as a specialized Pie shop, Bakery, and Restaurant, this establishment brings the comforting, hearty flavors of the United Kingdom right to the heart of Polk County. This company is celebrated for its commitment to high-quality, baked-on-demand savory and sweet pies, offering a delicious alternative to standard American bakery and restaurant options.

The core identity of The Proper Pie Company is built around traditional British recipes and an unwavering commitment to flavor. They offer an extensive menu of both handheld and large savory pies, including iconic favorites like the Steak and Ale Pie and the Cornish Pasty. Beyond the pies, the restaurant side is famous for delivering what many customers wholeheartedly believe is the best Fish and Chips in Polk County, FL. The ambiance is described as bright and welcoming, focusing on good food and friendly, helpful staff. This is the place to visit for locals who have traveled to the UK and miss the comfort food, or for those simply looking to explore a truly authentic international menu right in their own state. It's a proper British tea shop and eatery, accessible to everyone in the Florida region.

The Proper Pie Company is ideally situated to serve both the local Haines City community and those traveling on the main routes through Central Florida.

The restaurant and bakery is located at:

511 US-17 92 W, Unit 520, Haines City, FL 33844, USA

This address places the business right on a major Florida highway intersection (US-17/92), ensuring ease of access from all directions. The company has made a dedicated effort to ensure a convenient experience for all guests. Amenities include a Wheelchair accessible entrance and a Wheelchair accessible parking lot. Parking is made simple with both a Free parking lot and Free street parking available. Furthermore, the interior features a Gender-neutral restroom and Wi-Fi, demonstrating a commitment to comfort and modern inclusivity. Its focus on facilitating a Quick visit ensures that even busy Florida locals can enjoy a high-quality meal or treat without delay.

The Proper Pie Company offers a diverse range of services, making it a flexible dining option for the Florida community:

• Multiple Service Options: Customers can enjoy their British favorites through Dine-in, quick Takeout, local Delivery, and even Onsite services for local catering needs.
• Unbaked Pie Sales: A unique service that allows customers to purchase unbaked pies to take home, offering the ultimate convenience for a home-cooked British dinner any night of the week.
• Signature Meals: Offering traditional Fish and Chips with authentic Homemade Tartar Sauce and Chips (fries).
• Specialty British Sides: Serving authentic UK sides such as Mushy Peas, Heinz Baked Beans, and Curry Sauce, which is a popular accompaniment to savory pies and chips.
• Retail of UK Products: The company offers a selection of UK products and drinks, allowing customers to purchase specialty items to enjoy at home.
• Payment Convenience: Accepting modern payment options, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

The distinct appeal of The Proper Pie Company lies in its authentic adherence to British culinary traditions and its incredibly diverse pie selection.

• Extensive Savory Pie Menu: The heart of the restaurant is its selection of savory pies, which are categorized for easy choosing:
  • Proper Steak Pies: Including the highly-rated Steak And Ale, Steak And Mushroom, and Steak & Kidney.
  • Proper Chicken Pies: Featuring classic comfort flavors like Chicken, Broccoli, And Cheese and the exotic Chicken Curry and Buffalo Chicken.
  • Proper Vegetarian Pies: Offering delicious non-meat options such as Cheese, Potato & Onion and Vegetable Curry.
• Authentic British Snacks: Serving classic UK snacks that are hard to find locally, including Scotch Eggs (hard-boiled eggs wrapped in sausage meat and breadcrumbs), Sausage In Batter, and Banger Rolls.
• Traditional Desserts and Baked Goods (Proper Homemade Sweets): Offering quintessential British baked treats like the buttery Scottish Shortbread, the currant-filled Eccles Cake, and classic Fruit Pies (Cherry, Blueberry, and Apple).
• The Best Fish and Chips: Customers consistently rave about the quality of the Cod And Chips, establishing the restaurant's reputation for this national favorite in Polk County.
• Kid-Friendly Options: Providing specific Kids Favorites like Kids Mini Pie & Chips and Fish Fingers & Chips, making it a great family dining spot.

To place a takeout or delivery order, purchase unbaked pies, or inquire about daily specials, Florida residents can easily reach The Proper Pie Company using the contact details below:

Address: 511 US-17 92 W, Unit 520, Haines City, FL 33844, USA

Phone: (863) 438-2705

Mobile Phone: +1 863-438-2705

The availability of a landline and mobile phone number makes contacting the restaurant straightforward and efficient for the local community.

The Proper Pie Company is the essential choice for Florida residents looking for authentic, high-quality international comfort food. What makes it truly worth choosing is its unwavering commitment to the culinary tradition of the UK, offering an unparalleled level of specialization in pies. The ability to offer not only a wide variety of perfectly baked savory pies—from the classic Steak And Ale to the specialty Chicken Curry—but also the ability to take unbaked pies home is a unique and highly convenient service that appeals to the local market.

Furthermore, the establishment is locally famous for its non-pie offerings, notably the best Fish and Chips in Polk County, FL, as vouched for by loyal customers. This consistent quality across their entire menu, from the main course to the traditional Scottish Shortbread and Cream Teas, solidifies its status as a top-tier local eatery. For a delicious, authentic, and satisfying British meal, whether dining in, taking out, or preparing at home, The Proper Pie Company is the definitive choice in Haines City.