Had the pleasure of visiting this bakery, and purchasing a birthday cake. It’s an experience here. The owner is great at what he does,and so personable!. Came in on a Thursday in need of a cake for Friday. My bad for being last minute, so I was going to get an assortment of cupcakes. I was gently steered towards one of his cakes, and he assured me he could make a simple one for me for Friday pickup. OMG, what a pretty cake he made! It was chocolate, with a raspberry filling and chocolate butter cream, and also a work of art. And the best thing was, it was absolutely delicious! I’m glad I got the bigger cake, because we only had a couple slices left once we finally shed eating it. Thank you!
Mar 1 · Holly BouleyTimothy Jay Sweets
97 Elm St, Millbury, MA 01527, USA
Directory information can change. Confirm current hours, prices, products, dietary needs, and custom-order requirements directly with the bakery.

Essential details
- Address
- 97 Elm St, Millbury, MA 01527, USA
- Phone
- (508) 581-4118
- Website
- Visit official site
- Rating signal
- 4.0 from 93 recorded reviews
Listed operating hours
- Monday9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
- TuesdayClosed
- Wednesday9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
- Thursday9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
- Friday9:00 AM – 6:00 PM
- Saturday10:00 AM – 3:00 PM
- Sunday10:00 AM – 2:00 PM
About and visit notes
Introduction / Overview
In the heart of Millbury, Massachusetts, a town known for its classic New England charm and tight-knit community, lies a true culinary treasure that is making a name for itself with artistry and flavor: Timothy Jay Sweets. This bakery is not just a place to buy a dessert; it is an experience, a destination where every cake, cupcake, and sweet treat is crafted with passion and precision. Timothy Jay Sweets has quickly become a beloved local spot, celebrated for its stunning custom cakes and the warm, personal touch of its owner. The reputation of the bakery is built on the foundation of quality ingredients, creative design, and a dedication to customer satisfaction that goes above and beyond. For residents of Millbury and the surrounding areas, Timothy Jay Sweets is the go-to destination for celebrating life's special moments, from birthdays to anniversaries and everything in between. The bakery's ability to turn a simple request into a work of art is a testament to the talent and expertise of its proprietor. Customers consistently rave about not only the beautiful presentation of the desserts but also their exceptional taste, with rich, balanced flavors that are both classic and innovative. The atmosphere is friendly and welcoming, making every visit a positive and memorable interaction. Timothy Jay Sweets embodies the spirit of a true artisan bakery, where every item tells a story of craftsmanship and a love for the art of baking. It's a place where a last-minute request is met with kindness and creativity, and where the end result is a delicious memory that lasts long after the last slice is eaten.
Location and Accessibility
Timothy Jay Sweets is conveniently situated at 97 Elm St in Millbury, MA 01527, making it an easily accessible destination for locals and visitors from across the region. Its location on Elm Street places it in a central part of Millbury, close to other local businesses and community hubs. For those traveling by car, the bakery is positioned with straightforward access from major roads, and parking is generally available, allowing for a stress-free and quick visit. The ease of getting to Timothy Jay Sweets is a significant advantage for customers who need to pick up a custom cake or a last-minute assortment of cupcakes. The bakery’s presence in this part of Millbury makes it an integral part of the local business landscape, contributing to the town's charming and vibrant character. Whether you're coming from a neighboring town or just down the street, finding Timothy Jay Sweets is a simple process, and the promise of a delicious, handcrafted dessert makes the trip well worth it. The accessibility of its location ensures that it remains a go-to spot for both everyday cravings and special occasion needs, further solidifying its role as a key member of the local community. The welcoming storefront invites passersby to stop in and discover the sweet delights that await inside.
Services Offered
- Custom-designed cakes for a variety of special occasions, including birthdays, anniversaries, and other celebrations, with an emphasis on both beautiful presentation and delicious flavor.
- An assortment of cupcakes, available for purchase individually or by the dozen, offering a perfect treat for smaller gatherings or a personal indulgence.
- Specialty cakes, such as the highly praised chocolate cake with raspberry filling and chocolate buttercream, showcasing unique flavor combinations and high-quality ingredients.
- Last-minute cake options, with the owner's willingness to create simple yet delicious cakes for those in a bind, demonstrating a commitment to customer service and satisfaction.
- Assorted sweets and desserts that change frequently, providing a constant variety of fresh and innovative treats for customers to discover.
- Consultations for custom orders, where the owner works personally with customers to bring their dessert vision to life.
Features / Highlights
- Artistic and Delicious Cakes: The bakery is renowned for creating cakes that are not only "a work of art" but are also "absolutely delicious." This balance of aesthetics and taste is a major highlight, setting Timothy Jay Sweets apart from other bakeries.
- Personalized Customer Service: The owner is described as "personable" and "great at what he does," providing a positive and engaging experience for every customer. This personal connection is a key feature that fosters customer loyalty.
- High-Quality Ingredients: The use of high-quality ingredients is a point of praise from customers, who note the rich, delicious flavor of the products. This commitment to quality is the foundation of the bakery's reputation.
- Flexibility and Accommodating Nature: The owner's willingness to help a customer in a last-minute bind, creating a simple but beautiful and delicious cake on short notice, showcases the bakery's flexibility and dedication to meeting customer needs.
- A Positive and Welcoming Experience: The atmosphere and interaction with the owner are consistently described as an "extremely positive experience." This warm and friendly environment makes customers feel valued and happy to return.
- Creative and Unique Flavors: The bakery excels at creating classic yet elevated flavor combinations, such as the chocolate cake with raspberry filling and chocolate buttercream, which delights the palate and keeps customers coming back for more.
Contact Information
For inquiries, to place a custom order, or for any other questions, you can reach Timothy Jay Sweets using the following contact details:
Address: 97 Elm St, Millbury, MA 01527, USA
Phone: (508) 581-4118
Conclusion: Why this place is suitable for locals
Timothy Jay Sweets is an ideal fit for the local community in Massachusetts, particularly for residents of Millbury and the surrounding towns, because it offers an unparalleled combination of artistic skill, delicious flavors, and personal service. It is a place where every dessert is made with care and passion, and where the customer is at the center of the experience. For locals, Timothy Jay Sweets is the perfect destination for celebrating life's milestones with a truly spectacular and memorable cake. The bakery’s commitment to high-quality ingredients and its fair pricing make it an accessible luxury for the community. The owner's personable nature and willingness to go the extra mile, as demonstrated by the ability to create beautiful cakes on short notice, have made it a trusted and beloved local business. The reputation of Timothy Jay Sweets has grown through word-of-mouth praise, a testament to the genuine satisfaction of its customers. For anyone in the area seeking a dessert that is both a work of art and a feast for the senses, or simply looking for a friendly and positive experience, a visit to Timothy Jay Sweets is a must. It represents the very best of a local, artisan business—one that contributes to the community not just with its products, but with its heart and soul.
Services and accessibility
These attributes come from the directory record and should be confirmed when essential.
Service options
- In-store pick-up
- In-store shopping
- On-site services
- Takeaway
Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible car park
- Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Crowd
- LGBTQ+ friendly
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
Parking
- Free of charge street parking
- Free parking lot
See the bakery
Reviews and recurring themes
Read individual comments as personal experiences, not verified guarantees.
First time visiting Timothy Jay’s this . Went in to purchase a birthday cupcake for my grandson . Had the pleasure of meeting and conversing with the owner. What an extremely positive experience and I will be back . ♥️. Connie C.
Jul 16 · Connie CollinsWe went to TImothy Jay Sweets recently with 2 of our granddaughters to pick out some cupcakes to celebrate the younger one's 3rd birthday. There were plenty of varieties to choose from, each one looking more delicious than the next!Timothy made sure to recognize her special day and included a little something extra for her older sister "just because"The cupcakes were delicious!
Mar 30 · Richard QuistAbsolutely loved this place! The owner was incredibly kind and welcoming making this experience more enjoyable and memorable. The desserts were so delicious, especially those lovely cake pops! The best experience and desserts ever.
Apr 22 · Deborah ChalakI ordered a gluten free cake for my son's baptism and it was SO delicious! Everyone kept asking where it was from and were surprised to find out it was gluten free. Everyone at Timothy Jay Sweets are so friendly and were so great to work with. Will definitely be back for future cake/dessert orders!
May 28 · Caitlyn SorensonCompare another bakery nearby
Sorted by geographic proximity from this bakery.
This page combines directory records, available business details, submitted photos, and visitor feedback. Information may be incomplete or change without notice. For corrections, contact server@heavenlydelightsbakery.com.












