We visited Bagel Boy based on its respectable Google Maps rating. I ordered the toasted egg sandwich with bacon on a poppy seed bagel. Priced at $7.25, it included two eggs. Unfortunately, it was quite dry and didn’t leave much of an impression. On the other hand, the plain bagel with cream cheese, tomato, and cucumber ($3.65 + $0.50 + $0.50) was simple yet tastier. Freshly squeezed OJ ($4.25 for 12 oz) rounded out the meal. With tax, the total came to $17.58. All in all, it was an average breakfast—not bad, but not noteworthy either.
Jun 17 · Ozge UstundagBAKERY PROFILE
Bagel Boy
★ 4.01,455 recorded reviewsUS$10–20
2601 East 16th Street, Brooklyn, NY 11235, USA
Directory information can change. Confirm current hours, prices, products, dietary needs, and custom-order requirements directly with the bakery.
PLAN THE VISIT
Essential details
- Address
- 2601 East 16th Street, Brooklyn, NY 11235, USA
- Phone
- (718) 332-3444
- Website
- Visit official site
- Rating signal
- 4.0 from 1,455 recorded reviews
HOURS
Listed operating hours
- Monday5:00 AM – 7:00 PM
- Tuesday5:00 AM – 7:00 PM
- Wednesday5:00 AM – 7:00 PM
- Thursday5:00 AM – 7:00 PM
- Friday5:00 AM – 7:00 PM
- Saturday5:00 AM – 5:00 PM
- Sunday5:00 AM – 5:00 PM
About and visit notes
Introduction / Overview
Bagel Boy, located in a bustling part of Brooklyn on East 16th Street, is a local bagel shop that has become a familiar presence for residents in the Sheepshead Bay area. With a name that promises a focus on a New York staple, this establishment offers a wide variety of bagels and spreads, catering to the classic New Yorker's breakfast and lunch needs. Beyond the bagels, the shop provides a menu that includes a range of sandwiches, breakfast items, and even an oatmeal bar. Customer experiences at Bagel Boy can vary, with some items receiving more praise than others. The classic combination of a plain bagel with cream cheese, tomato, and cucumber is often noted as a fresh and tasty option, while a toasted egg sandwich with bacon may be considered less impressive, described as "dry" and "noteworthy." This mixed feedback highlights the importance of choosing wisely from the menu. However, the spot's overall appeal is bolstered by its extensive selection of bagel types and spreads, ensuring that there is always something to suit every taste. The addition of an oatmeal bar is a unique and "cute" feature that offers a different kind of breakfast option for patrons. The presence of fresh-squeezed orange juice is another highlight, adding a touch of quality to the beverage offerings. Overall, Bagel Boy serves as a solid, dependable, if sometimes average, spot for locals seeking a quick and convenient breakfast. Its reputation, as seen on platforms like Google Maps, indicates a generally respectable standing within the community, making it a viable and common choice for those in the neighborhood.
Location and Accessibility
Bagel Boy is conveniently located at 2601 East 16th Street in Brooklyn, New York. This location places it squarely in the residential neighborhood of Sheepshead Bay, making it an ideal destination for local residents. East 16th Street is a well-known thoroughfare, and the shop's position on it ensures that it is easily found and accessed. For those who drive, street parking is available in the vicinity, though it can be competitive depending on the time of day, a common challenge in many parts of Brooklyn. However, for the majority of locals who rely on public transportation or simply walk, the bakery is highly accessible. It is within a reasonable walking distance from major bus routes and subway stations, making it a seamless part of a commuter's daily routine. The neighborhood is a mix of residential homes and local businesses, and Bagel Boy fits perfectly into this fabric, serving as a trusted stop for a morning coffee and bagel run. Its accessibility is a significant factor in its suitability for the local New Yorker. It allows residents to easily get their breakfast without a long detour, whether they are on their way to work, running errands, or enjoying a weekend morning. The address, 2601 East 16th Street, is a simple and memorable one that has been associated with this local business for years, cementing its status as a familiar and reliable neighborhood fixture.
Services Offered
- A vast selection of fresh bagels baked daily, with a wide variety of classic and specialty flavors.
- An extensive range of cream cheese and other spreads to accompany the bagels, including a low-fat veggie cream cheese option.
- A menu of breakfast sandwiches, including egg sandwiches with various protein additions like bacon.
- Classic deli sandwiches for lunch, providing a full meal option beyond just bagels.
- A unique oatmeal bar, offering a different and customizable breakfast choice.
- Freshly squeezed orange juice and other beverages to complement any meal.
- Catering services for larger orders and events, providing a convenient solution for local gatherings.
- In-store and takeout services for quick and easy ordering.
Features / Highlights
- The impressive variety of bagels and spreads, which ensures that every customer can find their favorite combination.
- The fresh-squeezed orange juice, which is noted as a delicious and high-quality beverage option.
- The "cute" oatmeal bar, a unique and appealing feature that sets it apart from many other traditional bagel shops.
- The option for customization, allowing customers to order their bagels with specific preparations, such as a "scooped" bagel.
- The quality of the bacon on their breakfast sandwiches is specifically highlighted as being "done to the perfect crispness."
- The prices are reasonable for the size and variety, making it an affordable option for a quick meal.
- The bakery's solid reputation, as seen in its respectable Google Maps rating, indicating its consistent quality and local popularity.
Contact Information
Address: 2601 East 16th Street, Brooklyn, NY 11235, USA
Phone: (718) 332-3444
Conclusion: Why this place is suitable for locals
Bagel Boy is a highly suitable spot for the local residents of Brooklyn's Sheepshead Bay neighborhood due to its versatility, convenience, and commitment to the classic New York bagel. For a local, having a dependable bagel shop that offers a wide variety of bagels and spreads is a daily necessity, and Bagel Boy fulfills that role admirably. The extensive menu, which goes beyond just bagels to include sandwiches, an oatmeal bar, and fresh-squeezed juice, ensures that it can cater to the diverse tastes and needs of the community at any time of day. While some menu items may have mixed reviews, the overall quality and variety make it a safe and reliable choice. The location on East 16th Street is a major advantage, as it is easily accessible by foot, bus, or subway, making it a seamless part of a resident's routine. It's the kind of place you can quickly pop into for a morning coffee and bagel, or grab a full lunch to take to work. The fact that it has a solid reputation in the community, as reflected in its respectable online ratings, indicates that it is a trusted and valued local business. Bagel Boy embodies the spirit of a true neighborhood spot—it may not always be a destination for a gourmet meal, but it is a consistent, convenient, and reliable option that provides the foundational New York food that locals love. This combination of variety, accessibility, and dependability is precisely why Bagel Boy is an essential and cherished part of the local food scene.
VISIT FEATURES
Services and accessibility
These attributes come from the directory record and should be confirmed when essential.
Service options
- Delivery
- In-store pick-up
- On-site services
- Takeaway
- Dine-in
Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Offerings
- Coffee
Dining options
- Breakfast
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Parking
- Free of charge street parking
- Paid parking lot
- Paid street parking
PHOTOS
See the bakery
VISITOR FEEDBACK
Reviews and recurring themes
Read individual comments as personal experiences, not verified guarantees.
everything bagel 18deli 13spreads 13soup 12bagel with cream cheese 11cashier 10salmon 7fresh food 6best bagel & coffee 6catering 5
Stopped in on a Monday Morning, ordered a scooped egg bagel with low fat veggie cream cheese and bacon. The bacon was done to the perfect crispness. Yum! They had a lot of options for types of bagels and spreads. It was nice to see that they had an oatmeal bar, cute!
Jun 22 · Jiang LamBiting into Bagel Boy's Bacon Egg & Cheese on an Egg Everything Bagel made me feel like a Young Boy again! It was very delicious and grounding. First place I've been to that offers an Egg Everything Bagel, which is very good.
Apr 19 · AndreyIf you don’t know about this place, you are not from Brooklyn. I cannot stress how delicious the Peter Luger roast beef sandwiches. Iced coffees are on point. Bagels are always fresh. And they give you just the right attitude in the morning to piss you off like on some New York shit but then make you happy they made your food good!
Jul 9 · C PazThe local neighborhood bagel spot. Clean, spacious and quick service. Space is busy with orders togo. Seating available bar seats for quick bites on the go.I ordered egg ham and cheese on onion bagel and same on sesame bagel, both were to our liking.Variety of coffees beans, clean self service coffee area, I usually get dark roast coffee and never disappoints. Will recommend to everyone.
Dec 31 · Farooq SirajNEARBY ALTERNATIVES
Compare another bakery nearby
Sorted by geographic proximity from this bakery.
★ 4.0 · 182 reviews · 0.5 mi
PEP Bakehouse and Coffee Shop
1601 Gravesend Neck Rd, Brooklyn, NY 11229, USA
This page combines directory records, available business details, submitted photos, and visitor feedback. Information may be incomplete or change without notice. For corrections, contact server@heavenlydelightsbakery.com.