$12 for a bagel with tuna on it. The picture shows maybe 3oz of tuna. This is at most $8. Insane prices, will never be back.
Sep 3 · Tom SBagel Buster
700 Arthur Kill Rd, Staten Island, NY 10308, USA
Directory information can change. Confirm current hours, prices, products, dietary needs, and custom-order requirements directly with the bakery.

Essential details
- Address
- 700 Arthur Kill Rd, Staten Island, NY 10308, USA
- Phone
- (718) 967-3354
- Rating signal
- 4.0 from 123 recorded reviews
Listed operating hours
- Monday6:00 AM – 0:00 AM
- Tuesday6:00 AM – 0:00 AM
- Wednesday6:00 AM – 0:00 AM
- Thursday6:00 AM – 0:00 AM
- Friday6:00 AM – 0:00 AM
- Saturday6:00 AM – 0:00 AM
- Sunday6:00 AM – 0:00 AM
About and visit notes
When it comes to starting your day the New York way, nothing beats a fresh, perfectly toasted bagel. For residents and workers in Staten Island, finding a reliable spot for that morning ritual is essential. Bagel Buster, located on Arthur Kill Road, is a local bagel shop that provides the classic breakfast experience, focusing on speed, convenience, and those essential morning staples that get the city moving. More than just a place to grab a quick bite, Bagel Buster represents a foundational part of the New York deli and bagel culture.
Bagel Buster positions itself as a straightforward, no-fuss purveyor of breakfast and deli items. While the name itself promises that satisfying, dense chew that New Yorkers expect from a great bagel, the establishment offers a broader menu to cover a complete breakfast for those on the go. The focus is squarely on efficiency and quality in core items, making it an ideal choice for a quick visit before tackling the day’s demands. It’s a local hub where you can find everything from a simple buttered bagel to a full egg sandwich, all made to order.
In a city with countless bagel options, Bagel Buster carved out its niche by emphasizing the classic offerings that appeal to a neighborhood crowd. Whether you're craving a classic toasted bagel with a schmear of cream cheese or a more substantial, protein-packed sandwich, this local establishment aims to deliver with speed and professionalism. This focus on the essentials ensures that patrons can count on a consistently good product without the wait often associated with larger, more formal dining experiences.
Bagel Buster is situated in a convenient and accessible location for Staten Island residents, making it a natural stop for the morning commute or a weekend breakfast run. The shop’s address places it directly in a community hub, ensuring it serves a broad segment of the local population. The physical location is: 700 Arthur Kill Rd, Staten Island, NY 10308, USA.
Accessibility is a key advantage for this location. Recognizing the needs of all community members, Bagel Buster provides a wheelchair-accessible entrance, ensuring that all patrons can access their morning meal comfortably and easily. The shop is clearly designed for a quick-service model, catering to individuals needing to grab their food and be on their way. The atmosphere is centered around efficiency, appealing directly to the New York lifestyle where time is of the essence, especially during peak breakfast hours. The simple, direct setup supports a speedy transaction and pickup process, further cementing its role as a quick-visit destination.
Bagel Buster provides a concise and effective range of services and menu items, primarily focused on breakfast and quick deli options. The offerings reflect a commitment to covering all the traditional bases for a satisfying start to the day. Key services and offerings include:
- Breakfast Service: The primary dining option is breakfast, catering to the crucial morning rush. This focus allows the shop to specialize and perfect its most popular morning items.
- Takeout and Delivery: For maximum convenience, customers have the option of either picking up their order directly or utilizing a delivery service to enjoy their meal at home or work.
- Hot and Cold Beverages: Essential morning beverages are on offer, including freshly brewed Coffee, along with popular cold drinks such as Snapple and Gatorade.
- Bagel and Spread Options: A selection of bagels with classic toppings, including Butter and Cream Cheese, are available to satisfy traditional bagel cravings.
- Egg Sandwiches: Quick, satisfying breakfast sandwiches, with options for Eggs Sandwich and Eggs and Cheese Sandwich.
- Classic Deli Cold Cuts: For a protein-packed meal, the menu includes traditional deli items like Ham Cold Cut and Turkey Cold Cut.
- Pastries: Selections like Croissants and Cheese Danish are available for those looking for a sweet complement to their coffee or a lighter breakfast choice.
- Multiple Payment Options: The shop accepts modern and convenient forms of payment, including Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC mobile payments, making transactions fast and seamless.
Several features make Bagel Buster a practical and appealing choice for local New Yorkers in the Staten Island area. These highlights underscore the shop's local appeal and its functional advantages:
- Emphasis on a Quick Visit: The entire operation is structured for speed. For the busy commuter, the ability to order, pay, and receive a high-quality breakfast item in a minimal amount of time is a major draw.
- Wheelchair Accessible Entrance: Commitment to accessibility ensures that the shop is welcoming and convenient for all members of the community.
- Core Breakfast Menu Focus: By centering the menu on essential breakfast staples—bagels, egg sandwiches, and coffee—the shop ensures quality control and minimal waiting times for its most popular products.
- Convenient Operating Models: The inclusion of both Delivery and Takeout options provides flexibility for customers who may be unable to visit the physical store, fitting perfectly with the demanding schedule of New York life.
- Fresh Bagel and Cream Cheese Experience: As noted in customer feedback, the quality of the core product—the bagel and the "generous portion of cream cheese"—is a definitive positive point that drives repeat business and local loyalty.
- Modern Payment Acceptance: Accepting major credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments (like Apple Pay or Google Pay) aligns with modern consumer expectations for swift and tap-to-pay transactions.
For any inquiries, to place an order, or to learn more about their daily specials, you can contact Bagel Buster directly:
Address: 700 Arthur Kill Rd, Staten Island, NY 10308, USA
Phone: (718) 967-3354
What makes Bagel Buster a place worth choosing in the competitive New York bagel market is its dedication to the fundamentals of a great morning meal. This establishment understands the necessity of a quick, satisfying, and quality breakfast. For many in Staten Island, the routine of stopping by for a bagel is not just about the food, but about getting a reliable, familiar product with speed and efficiency.
The classic menu items are where Bagel Buster truly shines. The basic combination of a fresh bagel, such as an everything whole wheat variety, paired with a generous application of cream cheese, has received praise from patrons who appreciate the classic preparation done right. In a city where a bagel must be more than just bread, that perfect balance of chewiness and flavor is paramount. Their egg sandwiches, at an accessible price point, offer a fast, hot, and fulfilling breakfast option that's a cornerstone of the local food scene.
While prices on some specialty items may be a point of discussion for a handful of customers, the value in the core products and the overall convenience of the quick-service model stand out. The ability to grab an affordable Eggs Sandwich for $3.50 or an Eggs and Cheese Sandwich for $4.50, especially when combined with a fresh coffee, solidifies Bagel Buster's position as a practical and essential local stop. For New Yorkers needing to fuel up fast, the focus on quick service, an accessible location, and reliable breakfast staples makes Bagel Buster a dependable choice on Arthur Kill Road. It’s the quintessential local spot designed to fit seamlessly into the busy, demanding rhythm of life in New York.
Services and accessibility
These attributes come from the directory record and should be confirmed when essential.
Service options
- Delivery
- Takeout
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
Offerings
- Coffee
Dining options
- Breakfast
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
See the bakery
Reviews and recurring themes
Read individual comments as personal experiences, not verified guarantees.
I stopped in to get a container of coffee and a bagel before my doctor's appointment. The everything whole wheat bagel with a generous portion of cream cheese was exceptional. Really enjoyed it with the coffee 👍
Jun 10 · Frank CastellanoWent here to buy a Powerball ticket. On my way out I saw some chocolate and I was going to purchase a Hershey with almond candy bar. When he rang this up at $2.50 I put it back. The person who worked here a middle aged to older man got very snotty and passive aggressively said "bye bye then," He continued to taunt me as I left the store, saying goodbye! Goodbye and mocking me. I am not giving them one star because of the price gouging but because of the attitude of the person that works in there. I believe this is a family business. This wasn't some young kid but a man who should know better than to speak to customers that way. I will never come to the store ever again. I will always support small businesses but they have to be respectful of their customers and the customer's choices to not be price gouged. The candy had some dust on it and I was going to put it back anyway. Not even sure if it was expired or not.
Jul 11 · Rosemarie ArcherOverall, it was a good place to grab a bagel with something if you are in a rush. But I feel they can improve on bagels. They are good but not as good as bagel boy. They have potential they just need to try harder. Bagels are not as soft when you bite into them they are a little chewy. But maybe it's just my preference so I will give them the benefit of the doubt. Also they don't have a big variety of Bagels.
Jun 1 · Viktor LisnyakDefinitely one of my top bagel spots. Very tasty large bagel. Plenty of other items you would expect to find in a deli. The afternoon cashier guy didn't seem fond of taking care of lotto customers. Probably my only complaint.
Oct 29 · brendan kaneCompare another bakery nearby
Sorted by geographic proximity from this bakery.








Sundae Donuts Staten Island
3830 Richmond Ave Suite B, Staten Island, NY 10312, USA




This page combines directory records, available business details, submitted photos, and visitor feedback. Information may be incomplete or change without notice. For corrections, contact server@heavenlydelightsbakery.com.
