BAKERY PROFILE

Castleton Farm To Bagel

★ 4.043 recorded reviews$10–20

857 Castleton Ave, Staten Island, NY 10310, USA

DirectionsCallWebsite

Directory information can change. Confirm current hours, prices, products, dietary needs, and custom-order requirements directly with the bakery.

Castleton Farm To Bagel
PLAN THE VISIT

Essential details

Address
857 Castleton Ave, Staten Island, NY 10310, USA
Phone
(718) 885-4414
Website
Visit official site
Rating signal
4.0 from 43 recorded reviews
HOURS

Listed operating hours

  • Monday7:00 AM – 5:00 PM
  • Tuesday7:00 AM – 5:00 PM
  • Wednesday7:00 AM – 5:00 PM
  • Thursday7:00 AM – 5:00 PM
  • Friday7:00 AM – 5:00 PM
  • Saturday7:00 AM – 5:00 PM
  • Sunday7:00 AM – 4:00 PM
About and visit notes

Castleton Farm To Bagel: Staten Island's Premier Farm-to-Table Bagel and Breakfast Destination

If you live in or are visiting New York's Staten Island and are looking for a breakfast or lunch spot that goes above and beyond the typical deli, look no further than Castleton Farm To Bagel. This local gem is more than just a bagel shop; it’s a commitment to fresh, high-quality, farm-to-table dining that brings the best of local ingredients right to your plate. Proudly featuring products like pasture-raised eggs, this establishment has quickly become a favorite for New Yorkers seeking a delicious and wholesome start to their day.

The concept behind Castleton Farm To Bagel is simple yet profound: elevating everyday favorites by using the freshest available ingredients, some of which are sourced directly from Cardinale Acres Farm. This dedication to quality shines through in every item, from their classic bagels to their unique specialty dishes and extensive selection of light, healthy options. It’s the perfect place for a quick, satisfying meal during a busy morning or a leisurely lunch break, offering an atmosphere that is both welcoming and sanitary, as noted by enthusiastic local patrons.

This unique blend of a traditional New York bagel bakery with a modern, health-conscious, farm-sourced menu sets Castleton Farm To Bagel apart in the competitive NYC food scene. Their diverse menu ensures that whether you're craving a classic Bagel with Lox and Red Onions, an adventurous Rodrigo Big Boy scramble, or a nutritious Avocado Toast, you’ll find something to love. Plus, with a strong focus on friendly service and an exceptionally clean environment, Castleton Farm To Bagel truly delivers an all-around excellent experience for the community.

---

Location and Accessibility

Castleton Farm To Bagel is conveniently located on Staten Island, making it an accessible and essential stop for locals and visitors alike. The shop sits at a busy, well-known location, ensuring it's easy to find and reach. Its operation within the New York region caters to the hustle and flow of local life, prioritizing fast, friendly service without sacrificing food quality.

The shop is situated at 857 Castleton Ave, Staten Island, NY 10310, USA. For those driving, the location is beneficial as it offers free street parking, a highly valued convenience in the city. When it comes to accessibility, the premises are designed to be inclusive, offering a wheelchair-accessible entrance, ensuring everyone in the community can easily enjoy their offerings. The central location in Staten Island also means it’s well-integrated into the local neighborhood, fostering a true sense of community and making it a routine stop for many New Yorkers on their daily commutes or weekend outings.

---

Services Offered

Castleton Farm To Bagel offers a comprehensive array of services designed to meet the needs of all customers in the New York area, whether they're looking for a quick bite or planning a large gathering. Their offerings go well beyond a typical bagel shop, encompassing a full spectrum of breakfast, lunch, and catering needs. Key services include:

  • Full Breakfast Menu: A vast selection of meals, from their classic 'From the Coop' items like the Two Egg Sandwich and 3 Egg Omelet to creative 'Breakfast/Scrambles' like the Chicken & Waffles Breakfast, Farmers Scramble, and Nova Scotia Omelette.
  • Lunch and Specialty Meals: A full range of options including Specialty Sandwiches (like the Nashville Sandwich and Chimichurri), gourmet Paninis (such as the Cuban Panini and The Reuben Panini), fresh-made Salads (including Cobb and Jordan Salads), and hearty items 'From the Kitchen' like Pernil and Street Tacos.
  • Grab-and-Go Bagels and Pastries: The core offerings, including fresh-baked Bagels, Bialys, Croissants, and a variety of pastries such as Rasp Crumbcake and Traditional Crumbcake.
  • Gluten-Free and Vegan Options: A conscious effort to cater to diverse dietary needs with items like the Vegan Scramble, Gluten Free French Toast, GF Plain/Everything Bagels Pack, and the Vegan Taco Salad.
  • Fresh Beverages: A wide selection of drinks, including Coffee, Iced Coffee, Iced Lattes, and a popular line of Juices and Smoothies, which customers rave about for their freshness.
  • Delivery and Takeout: Convenient service options for customers in a rush or those preferring to enjoy their meal at home or the office.
  • Full-Service Catering: Providing large-format meals for events and parties, with options like the Assorted Bagel Platter, Assorted Muffin Platter, and hot entrees like HT Chicken Francese, HT Penne Vodka, and various salads.
  • Grocery Items: Offering a select range of essential and specialty grocery products, from Boars Head Bacon and Breakstone Butter to various milks, cheeses, and unique items like Hot Honey Large and Molino Grassi Italian Flour.

---

Features / Highlights

What truly makes Castleton Farm To Bagel stand out for New Yorkers is their unique dedication to the 'farm-to-bagel' philosophy. This commitment is woven into the very fabric of their operation, differentiating them from other bagel shops and bakeries in the Staten Island area. The following highlights showcase the quality and variety customers can expect:

  • Farm-Sourced Ingredients: A core principle is using locally sourced, fresh ingredients, including their very own pasture-raised eggs, which elevate the flavor of their extensive egg dishes, scrambles, and breakfast sandwiches.
  • Incredibly Diverse Menu: While a top-tier bagel shop, the menu expands into a full-service eatery, featuring burgers (Cowboy Killer, Harvest Burger), Tex-Mex (Street Tacos, Quesadilla), and classic deli-style Boars Head Sandwiches (like Roast Beef and Honey Turkey), ensuring an option for any time of day or craving.
  • Specialty and Gourmet Breakfasts: Unique, generously portioned breakfast plates such as the massive Rodrigo Big Boy, the flavor-packed Hash It Out, and the savory Nova Scotia Omelette provide a sophisticated breakfast experience beyond the standard egg sandwich.
  • Healthy and Accommodating Options: A strong presence of wholesome choices, including a variety of oatmeal bowls with mix-ins, specialty toasts (Avocado Toast, Caprese Toast), and a robust selection of Gluten-Free baked goods and menu items, including muffins and the aforementioned French Toast and Vegan Scramble.
  • Fresh Juices and Smoothies: Praised by customers, their selection of fresh-squeezed juices and smoothies is a major draw, providing a vibrant, nutrient-dense beverage to complement any meal.

---

Contact Information

For New York customers looking to place an order, inquire about catering, or simply find the location, the essential contact details for Castleton Farm To Bagel are:

  • Address: 857 Castleton Ave, Staten Island, NY 10310, USA
  • Phone: (718) 885-4414

---

What is Worth Choosing

For both first-time visitors and lifelong New Yorkers, Castleton Farm To Bagel offers a compelling choice for breakfast and lunch. The standout reason to choose this location is its unique combination of uncompromising freshness and unparalleled menu variety. In a city famous for its bagel shops, Castleton Farm To Bagel elevates the experience by linking their high-quality food to local farming. The dedication to using farm-sourced products, like their pasture-raised eggs, results in food that is noticeably better and fresher, setting a new standard for a quick-service bakery.

If you are planning your order, highly recommended menu items include a classic Bagel cc, Lox & Red Onions to experience the quality of their baked goods, any of the sophisticated breakfast scrambles like the Nova Scotia Omelette, or the celebrated fresh squeezed juices or smoothies. For a heartier lunch, options like the Nashville Sandwich or one of their satisfying paninis are a must-try. Finally, for those hosting a group, the Catering service is an excellent choice, offering everything from bagel and muffin platters to full hot trays of Italian classics, all built on the same foundation of quality ingredients. Castleton Farm To Bagel is a true destination for fresh, delicious, and diverse dining on Staten Island.

VISIT FEATURES

Services and accessibility

These attributes come from the directory record and should be confirmed when essential.

Service options

  • Delivery
  • Takeout

Accessibility

  • Wheelchair accessible entrance

Offerings

  • Coffee

Dining options

  • Breakfast

Planning

  • Quick visit

Payments

  • Credit cards
  • Debit cards

Parking

  • Free street parking
PHOTOS

See the bakery

VISITOR FEEDBACK

Reviews and recurring themes

Read individual comments as personal experiences, not verified guarantees.

gluten free 8sandwich 7muffins 4cooked 4menu 4island 2grilled 2delivery 2bacon 2
★ 5.0

I’m new to Farm To Bagel and I’m glad I came across this establishment. The staff is extremely friendly, atmosphere is cool and more importantly the food is excellent. I can buy a breakfast sandwich at a wide array of deli’s but if you’re looking for freshness than stop by Farm To Bagel.Nice variety of menu items as well.

Aug 18 · Joe
★ 5.0

I love Farm to Bagel. To start off everyone is so friendly! It’s very clean and sanitary. I come here every Sunday morning and their bagels bring me joy. I also love their fresh squeezed juices. Personally, I would recommend the green apple juice fresh squeezed!!

Mar 1 · Crystal Giardina
★ 5.0

Nice menu selection with some gluten free and healthy options. Ordered the avocado toast which was delicious and the staff was friendly and helpful. I'm looking forward to returning to try their smoothies, jam, hash and paninis.

Apr 15 · Lauren
★ 5.0

This restaurant is amazing. The food was delicious and fresh. The chicken and waffles was delicious. The chicken was juicy and cooked to perfection. The Belgian waffles were warm fluffy and delicious. The bagel with cream cheese was yummy. I loved it also their muffins are spectacular. It was a very fresh muffin Delicious. There’s smoothies and fresh juices are also amazing. Very delicious. My favorite flavor was the detox flavor and the delivery driver was a sweetheart. Very kind very respectful. This place is amazing 10 out of 10.😁

Nov 12 · WonderManUltra
★ 2.0

The guy behind the grill consistently gets my order wrong. It’s genuinely disappointing because I want to support this business. 3 times in a row I’ve asked for something off the menu, it’s bagged up before I see the bag, and it’s something entirely different. Other than that, the hot bar items and salads are excellent. Baked goods are great. Jams and marmalade are great. Just becoming frustrated with the made to order food.

Mar 2 · Cliff Jackson
NEARBY ALTERNATIVES

Compare another bakery nearby

Sorted by geographic proximity from this bakery.

Problem baker
★ 4.0 · 90 reviews · 0 mi

Problem baker

870 Castleton Ave, Staten Island, NY 10310, USA

Details
Bagel Bin
★ 4.0 · 165 reviews · 0.4 mi

Bagel Bin

486 Forest Ave # 5, Staten Island, NY 10310, USA

Details
Walmart Bakery
★ 3.0 · 5 reviews · 1.7 mi

Walmart Bakery

500 Bayonne Crossing Way, Bayonne, NJ 07002, USA

Details
Nurys Cakes
★ 4.0 · 79 reviews · 1.8 mi

Nurys Cakes

367 Broadway, Bayonne, NJ 07002, USA

Details
About this listing

This page combines directory records, available business details, submitted photos, and visitor feedback. Information may be incomplete or change without notice. For corrections, contact server@heavenlydelightsbakery.com.

SIDE-BY-SIDE

Bakery comparison

Expanded bakery photo