Amy has an amazing talent. Not exactly sure where she obtained her recipes, but I honestly don’t care. She seems to experiment with new ideas, and most times the results are darn right yummy! Seek her out, pay her, and ENJOY...
Feb 19 · Curt PetersenGoodafbakedgoods
5604 Delridge Wy SW, Seattle, WA 98106, USA
Directory information can change. Confirm current hours, prices, products, dietary needs, and custom-order requirements directly with the bakery.

Essential details
- Address
- 5604 Delridge Wy SW, Seattle, WA 98106, USA
- Phone
- (206) 450-4256
- Rating signal
- 5.0 from 3 recorded reviews
Listed operating hours
Operating hours are not available in this directory record. Contact the bakery before visiting.
About and visit notes
Introduction / Overview
For Washington State locals in search of comforting, homemade quality that goes beyond the typical sweet pastry, Goodafbakedgoods stands out as a unique and compelling local bakery. Situated in the West Seattle neighborhood, this establishment has carved a specialized niche by focusing on hearty, savory items—particularly artisan Pot Pies—alongside distinctive gourmet cookies.
The operation, led by owner Amy, is celebrated for its inventive ideas and consistently "darn right yummy" results, as noted by enthusiastic patrons. Unlike a traditional European-style bakery, Goodafbakedgoods centers its menu around savory comfort meals, making it a perfect spot for busy individuals or families looking for a quick, high-quality, and satisfying meal solution. The commitment to crafting both traditional and Gluten-Free versions of their pot pies demonstrates a dedication to inclusivity and accessibility for all local users.
While the pot pies are the main event, the bakery is also known for its special cookie selections, such as the Earl Grey Shortbread, which have quickly become customer favorites, complementing the rich savory fare with a perfect sweet finish. Goodafbakedgoods represents a modern approach to the neighborhood bakery, specializing in delicious, handcrafted goods that simplify mealtime without sacrificing flavor.
Location and Accessibility
Goodafbakedgoods is conveniently located on Delridge Way SW, placing it in a well-trafficked and easily accessible area of West Seattle, making it a handy resource for the surrounding community.
Address: 5604 Delridge Wy SW, Seattle, WA 98106, USA
The primary mode of service is designed for maximum convenience and quick transactions for Washington residents:
- In-store Pickup Focus: The business primarily operates through In-store pickup, meaning customers place their orders ahead of time or stop by for available selections, ensuring a streamlined and fast service experience.
- Central West Seattle Access: The Delridge Way SW location is on a major thoroughfare, which is well-served by local transit options, and easily reachable by car for quick stops. This makes it convenient for local residents to grab a homemade meal or treat on their commute.
- Quick Visit Planning: Given the specialty takeout nature of the business—focusing on prepared pot pies, customers can plan for a quick visit to pick up their meals and baked goods.
Services Offered
Goodafbakedgoods has a highly specialized service model focused on providing comforting, easy-to-manage meals and unique sweets.
- Specialty Savory Pot Pies: Offering a core menu of substantial, homemade savory pot pies, including customer-acclaimed varieties like the Shepherd's Pot Pie and Chili Pot Pie with Cheddar Cornmeal Crust.
- Dedicated Gluten-Free Options: A major service feature is the provision of a full line of Gluten-Free Pot Pies, such as Gluten-Free Chicken, Chili, and Veggie options, ensuring those with dietary restrictions can also enjoy the savory offerings.
- Gourmet Cookie Selection: Providing unique, often tea-infused cookies to pair with the savory meals. The signature selections are the Ginger Chai Molasses Cookie and the highly-praised Earl Grey Shortbread.
- Meal Bundles/Promotions: Offering a "Choice of Free Cookie" with the purchase of a savory or gluten-free pot pie, encouraging customers to try the different cookie flavors and creating an attractive, complete meal package.
- Dessert Mini Pies: Featuring small dessert items like the Cheddar Apple Pie (noted as refrigerated, suggesting easy storage and reheating), perfect for a smaller sweet craving.
- In-Store Pickup Ordering: Streamlining the ordering and fulfillment process by focusing on in-store pickup at the 5604 Delridge Wy SW location.
Features / Highlights
The distinctive features of Goodafbakedgoods lie in its commitment to hearty, savory baking and inventive flavor pairings that delight the local Seattle community.
- Unique Savory Specialization: Unlike most bakeries that focus heavily on sweets, Goodafbakedgoods specializes in Savory Pot Pies—a niche that offers local users high-quality, homemade comfort food that is ready to eat or easily prepared at home.
- Creative Crust and Flavor Combinations: Highlighting specific creative touches, such as the Cheddar Cornmeal Crust on the Chili Pot Pie and the inventive fillings in the Stuffed Mushroom Pie, showcasing the owner's "amazing talent" and experimental approach.
- Dietary Inclusivity: The extensive and equally delicious Gluten-Free Pot Pie menu is a major highlight, demonstrating a commitment to catering to modern dietary needs without compromising on the deeply satisfying nature of the food.
- Gourmet Tea-Inspired Cookies: The unique flavor profile of the cookies, especially the Earl Grey Shortbread and Ginger Chai Molasses Cookie, elevates the typical cookie offering into a sophisticated, highly craved treat.
- Homemade Quality Assurance: Customer testimonials consistently reinforce the feeling of homemade quality and deliciousness across the entire menu, from the "Chili pie, Shepard’s, pot pies" to the cookies.
Contact Information
For Washington residents interested in ordering or learning more about the menu and pickup times, please use the following contact information:
Address: 5604 Delridge Wy SW, Seattle, WA 98106, USA
Phone: (206) 450-4256
What is Worth Choosing
For any local in Washington State looking for an easy, high-quality, and deeply satisfying comfort meal, Goodafbakedgoods is unequivocally worth choosing. This bakery stands out because it solves the problem of needing a wholesome, homemade meal without the time commitment.
The primary reason to choose Goodafbakedgoods is its mastery of the savory pot pie. These are not mass-produced, bland meals; they are individually crafted, hearty, and flavorful, as evidenced by the high praise for their Chili Pie and Shepherd’s Pot Pie. This specialization makes it the ultimate go-to for comfort food in the Seattle area.
Furthermore, the commitment to Gluten-Free excellence means that people with dietary restrictions don't have to settle for less—they can enjoy the same level of satisfying, homemade quality. By seeking out this Delridge Way bakery and indulging in a pot pie paired with an irresistible treat like the Earl Grey Shortbread, customers are supporting a local talent and guaranteeing themselves a delicious, hassle-free meal that is "darn right yummy!"
Services and accessibility
These attributes come from the directory record and should be confirmed when essential.
Service options
- In-store pickup
See the bakery
Reviews and recurring themes
Read individual comments as personal experiences, not verified guarantees.
Chili pie, Shepard’s, pot pies - all great. Have tried cookies - all good but my favorite is earl grey tea cookie. Yum!
Feb 19 · Christine GardnerWe tried chicken & chili & both were AMAZING!! The flavors & crust were 👌🏼👌🏼👌🏼
Feb 18 · ariana Johnson 54Compare another bakery nearby
Sorted by geographic proximity from this bakery.




Little Prague European Bakery
6045 California Ave SW, Seattle, WA 98136, USA








This page combines directory records, available business details, submitted photos, and visitor feedback. Information may be incomplete or change without notice. For corrections, contact server@heavenlydelightsbakery.com.
