She creates beautiful and delicious works of art, and her vegan carrot cake is the best I've ever had. 😋 I got beautiful, and most importantly, absolutely delicious cupcakes for my daughter's birthday. Phenomenal!
Sep 2 · Shannon FullerTamarasTastyCakess
828 Crescent St., Brooklyn, NY 11208, USA
Directory information can change. Confirm current hours, prices, products, dietary needs, and custom-order requirements directly with the bakery.

Essential details
- Address
- 828 Crescent St., Brooklyn, NY 11208, USA
- Phone
- (917) 257-0834
- Website
- Visit official site
- Rating signal
- 4.0 from 22 recorded reviews
Listed operating hours
Operating hours are not available in this directory record. Contact the bakery before visiting.
About and visit notes
For New Yorkers with a discerning palate and a desire for truly exceptional baked goods, TamarasTastyCakess in Brooklyn stands out as a hidden gem. This bespoke bakery specializes in turning sweet dreams into reality, crafting custom cakes and cupcakes that are not only visually stunning but also incredibly delicious. It's a place where artistry meets flavor, resulting in "works of art" that consistently delight customers and leave a lasting impression.
What truly sets TamarasTastyCakess apart is its commitment to both aesthetic perfection and unparalleled taste. Whether it's a birthday celebration, a wedding, or simply a craving for something extraordinary, this bakery delivers with cakes and cupcakes that are consistently moist and often described as "exact replicas" of any design presented. Their reputation extends to catering to diverse dietary needs, notably for their "best vegan carrot cake ever," making them a versatile choice for a wide range of New York residents.
The enthusiasm from loyal customers speaks volumes. One patron raves about the "beautiful and delicious works of art" and highlights the vegan carrot cake as "the best I've ever had." Another reviewer, a long-time client since 2017, passionately urges others to "ORDER ORDER ORDER!!!!!!" emphasizing the consistent moistness and precision in replicating designs, solidifying TamarasTastyCakess as a top-tier choice for custom baked goods in Brooklyn.
TamarasTastyCakess is located at 828 Crescent St., Brooklyn, NY 11208, USA. This address places the bakery in the East New York area of Brooklyn. As a specialized custom cake and cupcake establishment, it primarily operates on an order-ahead basis, rather than being a walk-in retail storefront with daily selections. This is typical for businesses focusing on bespoke creations, ensuring fresh preparation for each individual order.
For New Yorkers, accessibility to 828 Crescent Street is facilitated by local public transportation. The area is served by several MTA bus routes, which can connect patrons to nearby subway stations, such as those on the L train line (e.g., Crescent Street station or Norwood Avenue station, depending on the exact route). While not directly adjacent to a major subway hub, the location is within a residential neighborhood, making it a convenient pick-up point for those residing in East New York and surrounding areas. For customers driving for pick-up, street parking is generally available in residential parts of Brooklyn, although it may vary in ease of finding a spot. Given the nature of a custom bakery, customers typically arrange a specific pick-up time, which helps manage traffic and ensures a smooth experience.
Custom Cakes for All Occasions: TamarasTastyCakess specializes in creating bespoke cakes for a wide array of events, including birthdays, anniversaries, graduations, baby showers, and more. They are praised for crafting cakes that are "exact replicas" of designs provided by clients, ensuring a personalized touch for every celebration.
Custom Cupcakes: In addition to full-sized cakes, the bakery offers custom cupcakes, perfect for individual servings at parties or as delightful treats. Like their cakes, these can be tailored in flavor and decoration to match themes and preferences.
Vegan Options: A significant highlight is their highly acclaimed "vegan carrot cake," which a customer calls "the best I've ever had." This indicates a strong commitment to providing delicious plant-based alternatives, catering to a growing demand for vegan-friendly desserts in New York.
Variety of Flavors: While the reviews emphasize the quality and customization, it's clear they offer a range of cake and cupcake flavors to suit different tastes, ensuring there's a perfect base for every artistic creation. The quality of their baking ensures all products are consistently "moist."
Artistic Decoration: The bakery is noted for creating "beautiful works of art." This implies a high level of skill in cake decorating, including intricate designs, fondant work, and creative presentations that elevate their desserts beyond simple baked goods.
Pre-Order and Consultation: Given the custom nature of their business, TamarasTastyCakess operates primarily on a pre-order basis. Customers likely engage in a consultation process to discuss their design ideas, flavor preferences, and event details to ensure the final product perfectly matches their vision.
Delivery/Pickup Coordination: As a custom bakery, they would coordinate specific pick-up times for orders, and potentially offer delivery services within the Brooklyn area, adding convenience for their clientele.
Exceptional Customization: TamarasTastyCakess stands out for its ability to create "exact replicas" of desired cake designs, making them a top choice for personalized and unique celebratory desserts. This level of precision and artistry is a significant draw for customers seeking something truly special.
Outstanding Vegan Carrot Cake: The enthusiastic praise for their vegan carrot cake, described as "the best I've ever had," highlights a standout product that caters to specific dietary needs without compromising on flavor or texture. This makes them a preferred option for vegan New Yorkers.
Consistently Moist Products: Repeat customers consistently laud the moistness of their cakes and cupcakes, a critical factor for any high-quality baked good. This commitment to perfect texture ensures a delightful eating experience every time.
Artistic Presentation: Beyond taste, the bakery is recognized for producing "beautiful works of art." This focus on aesthetic appeal ensures that their cakes and cupcakes are not just desserts but also centerpieces for any event, adding to the visual spectacle.
Strong Customer Loyalty: The review from a long-time client since 2017 underscores a deep level of trust and satisfaction, indicative of outstanding customer service and consistent product quality that fosters strong relationships with patrons.
Word-of-Mouth Recommendation: The fact that customers are "referred on Facebook" and passionately recommend ordering from TamarasTastyCakess speaks volumes about their reputation and the positive experiences they consistently deliver.
Dedication to Quality: From the choice of ingredients to the final decoration, every aspect of their process seems geared towards delivering a premium product that looks as good as it tastes.
Address: 828 Crescent St., Brooklyn, NY 11208, USA
Phone: (917) 257-0834
For New Yorkers, especially those in Brooklyn, TamarasTastyCakess offers a truly exceptional and personalized bakery experience. In a city where special occasions are a frequent occurrence, having a dedicated custom cake creator like Tamara is an invaluable asset. Locals seeking a dessert that is not only incredibly delicious but also a unique reflection of their celebration will find TamarasTastyCakess to be their ideal partner.
The commitment to consistent moistness, artistic precision, and the availability of highly praised vegan options means that a wide range of New Yorkers can confidently turn to this bakery for their needs. Whether it's a birthday for a loved one with specific dietary preferences or a desire for a show-stopping cake that perfectly matches a party theme, TamarasTastyCakess delivers. Its strong word-of-mouth reputation and loyal customer base are testaments to the quality and care put into every "work of art." For any Brooklynite looking to elevate their next celebration with a truly phenomenal and personalized dessert, TamarasTastyCakess is the unequivocal choice.
Services and accessibility
These attributes come from the directory record and should be confirmed when essential.
From the business
- Identifies as Black-owned
- Identifies as women-owned
Service options
- In-store pick-up
- Takeaway
Crowd
- LGBTQ+ friendly
Planning
- Appointment required
Payments
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
See the bakery
Reviews and recurring themes
Read individual comments as personal experiences, not verified guarantees.
I CANT SCREAM ANY LOUDER TO PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE ORDER FROM HER. I was referred on Facebook from an employee back in 2017 & She’s My Number 1 !!! They are always moist and exact replicas of anything I show her. ORDER ORDER ORDER !!!!!!
Apr 19 · Nataysia BradyI had a problem with one of my order. Once I contacted Tamara about the issue, she was so sweet and prompt about it. She immediately resolved the issue and I could've ask for a better outcome! I and my mom are super happy with the purchase and will continue to buy from her! (P.S the rice Kripsies and brownies were so tasty!!)
Dec 8 · Keitra *TravisSeamless and easy process for a couple dozen Apple Spice cupcakes. A perfect choice for our Fall get together. Flavors were on point and our guests thoroughly enjoyed them. Would order again!
Oct 16 · Kathya ChiluizaI have been sitting on what to say for a few days. I have read the reviews and saw the photos of the other beautiful creations and decided to give her a try. I've paid for my cake on time and what I've asked for was not what I received. I'm so disappointed the I received one cake on my bornday but received the other 3 days later. So now I have an old cake that isn't good anymore. I've asked for a refund for one sneaker cake that I did receive since I didn't even want the other. For $200+, this was a waste of my money. Unfortunately I can't upload the final product on here but it is very disappointing!
Oct 7 · Sharonda AyersCompare another bakery nearby
Sorted by geographic proximity from this bakery.







All American Bagel & Barista Company
82-43 153rd Ave, Howard Beach, NY 11414, USA





This page combines directory records, available business details, submitted photos, and visitor feedback. Information may be incomplete or change without notice. For corrections, contact server@heavenlydelightsbakery.com.
