Behind the Times Bakery

Introduction / Overview

Behind the Times Bakery is a beloved fixture in the heart of Tell City, Indiana, serving as both a dedicated Bakery and an exceptional Coffee Shop. Located at 411 Main St, this local gem has carved out a unique identity based on quality, charm, and a deeply welcoming atmosphere. As a business that proudly identifies as women-owned, it is a testament to local Hoosier entrepreneurship and dedication.

The experience at Behind the Times Bakery is defined by its commitment to scratch-made excellence. Patrons consistently rave about the quality, noting that the food is "delicious and made to perfection" with an evident effort put into every dish. Beyond the savory breakfast items like the "FABULOUS" bacon egg and gouda biscuit, the bakery is highly celebrated for its extensive coffee menu, often praised as the "hands down the best around," featuring diverse flavors and brews. This blend of quality food, premium coffee, and a distinctly "homey" and "nostalgic" setting makes it an essential stop for anyone traveling through or residing in Perry County, Indiana.

Location and Accessibility

Behind the Times Bakery is perfectly situated in downtown Tell City at 411 Main St, Tell City, IN 47586, USA. Its prime Main Street location places it at the center of local activity, making it an easy-to-find and convenient destination for both daily regulars and travelers exploring Southern Indiana. The bakery has been thoughtfully established in the historic Van Bakery Building, contributing to its cherished, antique atmosphere.

The business ensures a convenient visit for all patrons by offering flexible parking solutions, including a dedicated Free Parking Lot and readily available Free Street Parking nearby. While the specific details on a wheelchair accessible entrance are not publicly listed, the general ease of access is a notable amenity for a downtown establishment. The location, paired with service options like In-store Pickup and Takeout, ensures that customers can quickly grab their coffee and breakfast or choose to settle in for a relaxed Dine-in experience.

Services Offered

Behind the Times Bakery offers a comprehensive menu that seamlessly blends high-quality baked goods with a full-service coffee shop experience, covering breakfast and light lunch options.

• Scratch-Made Baked Goods: Specializing in products made from scratch in their own kitchen. Signature items include the oversized homemade cinnamon rolls and various pastries, all praised for their superior flavor and texture.
• Breakfast and Brunch: Serving a full breakfast menu, which includes highly-rated breakfast sandwiches like the popular Bacon Egg and Gouda Biscuit (noted for its large, buttery, and flaky biscuit), along with daily lunch specials and brunch on Saturdays.
• Gourmet Coffee and Specialty Drinks: A full coffee bar featuring a wide array of flavors and brews. Specialty drinks include the Red Velvet Latte and the nostalgic Snickerdoodle Coffee, confirming the baristas are "well-trained in all things coffee."
• Custom Orders: The bakery specializes in Custom Cakes for various occasions (birthdays, weddings) as well as gourmet donuts and personalized baked goods.
• Flexible Service Options: Patrons can choose between Takeout, In-store Pickup, or a comfortable Dine-in experience, making it perfect for a "Quick visit" or a longer stay.

Features / Highlights

The core highlights of Behind the Times Bakery distinguish it as a must-visit location in the Indiana region, going beyond the basic offerings of a standard coffee or donut shop.

• Nostalgic and Homey Atmosphere: The building’s ambiance is a major highlight, consistently described as having the "coolest nostalgic atmosphere" and a "homey feel," which encourages patrons to "stay awhile" and is welcoming to families.
• Exceptional Coffee Quality: The coffee is frequently touted as "hands down the best around," with creative and well-executed flavor choices that appeal to all coffee enthusiasts in Tell City and beyond.
• Commitment to Scratch Baking: Every baked good is made from scratch in-house, a dedication to authenticity and quality that customers can taste in every bite, from the flaky biscuits to the perfected recipes.
• Woman-Owned Business: The proud identification as a women-owned enterprise resonates strongly with the community, offering Hoosiers a high-quality local business to support.
• Full Digital Convenience: Accepting Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC Mobile Payments, along with providing free Wi-Fi, makes the establishment modern, accessible, and convenient for today’s customer.

Contact Information

For Indiana residents in the Tell City area, connecting with Behind the Times Bakery for custom orders, catering, or current hours is easy using the following contact details.

Address: 411 Main St, Tell City, IN 47586, USA

Phone: (812) 772-2095

What is Worth Choosing

For anyone in the Indiana region, choosing Behind the Times Bakery is a choice for quality, comfort, and community. It is worth choosing for the unmatched coffee—praised as the "best around"—that perfectly complements the phenomenal scratch-made breakfast. The Bacon Egg and Gouda Biscuit alone is a reason to visit, offering a hearty, buttery, and flaky start to any day that surpasses typical fast-food offerings.

Furthermore, the atmosphere is a strong draw; this is a place where you are greeted by "friendly staff and owner," making you feel at home the moment you step inside. This bakery is perfect for the local user who appreciates tradition but demands modern quality and convenience, offering free Wi-Fi and flexible payment options. Located right on Main Street, supporting this women-owned business means investing in the character and flavor of Tell City, making Behind the Times Bakery a favorite for families and a treasured daily routine for regulars.

Behind the Times Bakery

411 Main St, Tell City, IN 47586, USA