Bittersweet Bake Shoppe Staten Island: Custom Cakes, Cookies & Wedding Treats

Bittersweet Bake Shoppe Introduce

Welcome to the sweet side of Staten Island! For New Yorkers searching for that perfect custom-made dessert to celebrate life's major milestones—or simply to satisfy a craving for high-quality baked goods—look no further than the

Bittersweet Bake Shoppe

. This local gem has firmly established itself as a premier destination for those who believe that every celebration deserves a spectacular, delicious centerpiece. Located right here in the borough, the

Bittersweet Bake Shoppe

is a dedicated specialty shop that combines the craft of traditional baking with stunning, modern design. From the intricate details of a tiered wedding cake to the whimsical artistry of custom-decorated cookies and the rich indulgence of fine chocolate, this Staten Island bakery serves up sweetness tailored to your exact needs. It’s more than just a place to buy a dessert; it’s where your sweet vision comes to life.

The focus on personalized, high-quality products is what truly sets this shop apart in the busy New York dessert scene. Whether you are planning a grand wedding reception, a small birthday party, a corporate event, or just looking for a quick treat, the team at

Bittersweet Bake Shoppe

is committed to providing baked goods that not only look beautiful but taste absolutely amazing. This dedication is often highlighted in the glowing reviews from local customers, who frequently praise the staff for their attentiveness to detail and the sheer deliciousness of their creations. For residents of Staten Island and beyond, this bake shoppe offers a reliable, professional, and friendly service that makes ordering custom treats a truly enjoyable experience.

The versatility of their offerings, spanning from a full-service wedding bakery to a dedicated cookie and chocolate shop, means that you can find the perfect confection for any occasion, no matter how formal or casual. This variety, combined with a local, neighborhood feel, makes

Bittersweet Bake Shoppe

a true standout in New York City’s vast culinary landscape. By specializing in custom work, they ensure that your dessert will be as unique as your event.

Location and Accessibility

The

Bittersweet Bake Shoppe

is conveniently situated in the Charleston neighborhood of Staten Island, providing easy access for residents throughout the borough and even those commuting from other parts of New York. You can find this fantastic dessert destination at:

Bittersweet Bake Shoppe

4275 Arthur Kill Rd Store 3
Staten Island, NY 10309, USA

Its location on Arthur Kill Road, a major thoroughfare in this part of Staten Island, makes it simple to locate. For New York drivers, accessibility is significantly enhanced by the provision of a

free parking lot

, a welcome amenity that makes quick pickups or detailed consultation appointments stress-free. The shop caters specifically to those looking to make a quick visit for a convenient takeout order, making it an excellent stop when you are running errands or are on your way to an event.

Based on available public information, the operational schedule for

Bittersweet Bake Shoppe

on a Sunday is from

10:00 am until 01:00 pm

. For visits and orders on other days of the week, it is highly recommended that New York customers call ahead to confirm the current business hours, as specialized bake shops often operate on seasonal or custom-order schedules.

Services Offered

Bittersweet Bake Shoppe

provides a comprehensive range of sweet services, catering to both everyday cravings and the most elaborate special events. Their expertise covers multiple dessert categories, ensuring a high-quality product no matter what you are ordering.

Bakery: Offering a selection of freshly baked goods and desserts, perfect for a daily treat or spontaneous gathering.
Wedding Bakery: Specializing in designing and creating custom wedding cakes, bridal shower treats, and other high-end desserts for New York City's most memorable days. This includes a dedicated consultation process for couples.
Cookie Shop: Crafting a wide variety of custom-decorated cookies, which customers have described as "amazing and beautiful," and are perfect for personalized gifts, party favors, or themed events. This includes custom cookie bouquets, as praised in local reviews.
Chocolate Shop: Featuring fine chocolate products, which could include truffles, bonbons, chocolate-covered items, and other specialty confections for the true chocolate enthusiast.
Takeout Service: Offering quick and convenient service options for New Yorkers on the go who need to pick up their orders efficiently.
Custom Cakes and Special Occasion Desserts: Beyond weddings, they create custom cakes for birthdays, anniversaries, graduations, and other special events, ensuring a personalized design for every customer.
Dessert Catering: Providing sweet tables and dessert options that match event themes and designs, although further details on full catering are best discussed directly with the shop.

Features / Highlights

What makes

Bittersweet Bake Shoppe

a must-visit location for New Yorkers looking for top-tier desserts? It is a combination of quality, service, and convenience that elevates the entire customer experience.

Specialization in Custom Work: The bakery excels at creating custom-designed items, including detailed cakes and highly personalized cookies, ensuring a unique product for every customer. As one reviewer noted, the team "listen to every detail you want/need for your special day."
Positive Customer Endorsements: The shop receives high praise for its staff being "the sweetest" and the products "absolutely amazing & beautiful," with the desserts consistently exceeding customer expectations in both appearance and taste.
Diverse Payment Options: To accommodate the modern New York shopper, the bake shoppe accepts all major payment methods, including
Credit cards
,
Debit cards
, and
NFC mobile payments
.
Focus on Quality and Taste: The core business strength is delivering products that are not only visually stunning but also unequivocally
delicious
, a fundamental requirement for a successful New York bakery.
Dedicated Parking: A highly valuable feature in New York City, the availability of a
free parking lot
simplifies the process of picking up large, delicate custom orders, such as tiered cakes or expansive cookie trays.
Local Staten Island Establishment: Located in the heart of the Charleston neighborhood, it serves as a reliable, high-quality, local provider of specialty desserts, contributing to the vibrant local business community.
Ideal for
Quick Visits
and Pre-Planning: Whether you are stopping in for a quick item or sitting down to plan a major event, the shop is set up to handle different customer needs efficiently.

Contact Information

For New Yorkers ready to place an order or schedule a consultation, here is the essential contact information for

Bittersweet Bake Shoppe

Address:

Bittersweet Bake Shoppe

, 4275 Arthur Kill Rd Store 3, Staten Island, NY 10309, USA

Phone Number:
(347) 215-2336 (or +1 347-215-2336)

Remember that for highly customized orders, especially for wedding cakes or large cookie orders, it is always best to contact the shop via phone to discuss your needs and set up an appointment well in advance of your event date.

What is Worth Choosing at Bittersweet Bake Shoppe?

Choosing

Bittersweet Bake Shoppe

means selecting a truly personalized and professional dessert experience right in your local New York area. For couples planning a wedding, the fact that this is a dedicated

Wedding bakery

means you can trust their experience in handling one of the most important elements of your reception. They specialize in creating cakes that are customized down to the very last detail, ensuring it perfectly complements your special day’s theme and flavor preferences. The feedback from real customers confirms that their wedding cakes not only look magnificent but are also incredibly delicious, a crucial combination for any happy couple.

Beyond weddings, the custom cookies are a signature product that is worth seeking out. Forget the standard, store-bought treats; the

Bittersweet Bake Shoppe

transforms cookies into edible art. One customer’s experience with a 'beautiful dance cookie bouquet' highlights how these creative arrangements can serve as meaningful, unique alternatives to traditional gifts like flowers, offering a memorable surprise for recipients of all ages. Whether you need a corporate logo reproduced, a themed birthday set, or a unique party favor, their cookie artistry is a major highlight.

Finally, for those simply seeking indulgence, their distinction as a

Chocolate shop

suggests a commitment to high-quality ingredients and rich, decadent flavors. For any New Yorker looking to treat themselves or pick up a thoughtful, upscale gift, the chocolate and other spontaneous bakery items available for

Takeout

make for a perfect quick indulgence. Ultimately,

Bittersweet Bake Shoppe

should be your choice in Staten Island when you demand the highest level of customization, taste, and friendly, professional service for all your celebratory sweets.

Bittersweet Bake Shoppe Details

Service options
Takeout

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Parking
Free parking lot

Bittersweet Bake Shoppe Photos

Bittersweet Bake Shoppe Location

Bittersweet Bake Shoppe

New York Richmond County Charleston Arthur Kill Road

Bittersweet Bake Shoppe, 4275 Arthur Kill Rd Store 3, Staten Island, NY 10309, USA

Bittersweet Bake Shoppe Reviews

An average rating of ★5 from 10 user reviews.

cookiesbridal showergluten freesisterlaws

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Absolutely amazing & beautiful cakes/ cookies! They are the sweetest and listen to every detail you want/need for your special day! The cake & cookies they made absolutely exceeded my expectations and it was delicious!
September 16 · Tina DeLury
Such a beautiful dance cookie bouquet. This was for my 11 year old 1st dance recital. She loved them so much better than flowers. Thank you so much Bittersweet Bake Shoppe
June 23 · Marc
I absolutely loved the cookies I got for my sister-in-laws bridal shower! Not only were they designed exactly the way I wanted them, they were delicious!! I got so many compliments. I would definitely order again!!
June 11 · Nicole Cali
I could not be happier with the "Aperol Spritz" themed cookies I ordered for my sister-in-laws bridal shower. From placing the order, to requesting a change, to the guests enjoying the cookies- I could not be happier with my experience. They aren't cheap, but worth it! I definitely recommend!
June 12 · Kelly Callaghan
They are wonderful & execute exactly what you want! Had custom cookies and cupcakes done for my son’s baptism & will order again decorative cookies tend to be bland or icing to sweet these were amazing such a nice balanced taste!
October 16 · Ashley Kusturic