ElMar's NY Bagels (a pop-up at ElMar's NY Pizza)

## Introduction / Overview: Bringing Authentic New York Bagels to Minnesota

For Minnesota residents who crave a truly authentic, New York-style bagel, the search often leads to the western suburbs and the celebrated **ElMar's NY Bagels** pop-up. Operating out of the established ElMar's NY Pizza location in Plymouth, this venture has quickly garnered attention for its commitment to traditional bagel-making methods. It's a specialist **Bagel shop** that focuses on quality over quantity, carving out a dedicated niche in the local breakfast scene.

Unlike many large chain bagel stores, ElMar's is praised for producing a distinctive product: a bagel that is **soft and fluffy inside** with a **slightly crunchy on the outside** crust—hallmarks of a traditional, properly boiled and baked creation. Customers consistently report a marked difference, noting that these bagels offer an excellent alternative to the more widely available options in the Twin Cities. The secret, according to local reports, is the use of a specially rigged system that re-creates New York’s tap water, providing that unique texture that New Yorkers swear by.

As a **pop-up** shop, ElMar's NY Bagels operates with specific, limited morning hours within the pizza establishment. This means that access to their acclaimed bagels and simple, satisfying breakfast fare is a limited-time opportunity each week, adding a sense of urgency and excitement for local bagel enthusiasts. The simple menu is focused but high-quality, featuring classic bagel flavors, generous cream cheese **shmears** (like the tasty **scallion cream cheese**), and excellent **breakfast bagel sandwiches** with egg, bacon, and cheese.

If you're in the Plymouth area and looking for a morning treat that aims for genuine NYC quality, ElMar's NY Bagels is a must-try. Be sure to check the specific pop-up hours to ensure you catch them while they're baking!

---

## Location and Accessibility

ElMar's NY Bagels is located within the same facility as ElMar's NY Pizza in a convenient commercial hub of Plymouth. The exact address is **15725 37th Ave N Suite 5, Plymouth, MN 55446, USA**.

The physical space, though operating on limited hours for bagels, is designed to be fully accessible for all members of the Minnesota community. Key accessibility features include a **Wheelchair accessible entrance** and a **Wheelchair accessible parking lot**. These amenities ensure that customers can easily and comfortably visit the shop for pickup or to enjoy a quick bite on-site.

The shop supports multiple service options, including **In-store shopping**, **Takeout**, and even **Delivery**, providing flexibility for customers. The nature of the operation is built for a **Quick visit**, where locals can grab their dozen bagels or a hot breakfast sandwich efficiently before starting their day.

---

## Services Offered

The services at ElMar's NY Bagels are tailored around the concept of a high-quality, morning-focused pop-up, offering the essential elements for a great breakfast.

• **Limited-Time Bagel Sales:** Providing freshly baked, hand-rolled, and kettle-boiled bagels during specific pop-up hours: **Thursdays & Fridays (7:30 AM–10:00 AM)**, **Saturdays (8:00 AM–10:00 AM)**, and **Sundays (9:00 AM–11:00 AM)**.
• **Online Pre-Ordering for Loose Bagels:** Customers can reserve loose bagels (singles, halves, or dozens) online, with ordering typically opening the evening before each pop-up, highly recommended to avoid the lines and ensure availability.
• **Classic Bagel Selection:** Offering foundational bagel flavors only, including **plain**, **everything**, **sesame**, **poppyseed**, and sometimes **garlic**.
• **Specialty Cream Cheese Spreads:** Serving classic whipped cream cheese with generous portions (a "good shmear"), including flavors such as **plain**, **scallion**, **jalapeno**, **garden vegetable**, and **brown sugar cinnamon**.
• **Breakfast Sandwiches:** A simple menu of excellent breakfast bagel sandwiches, typically featuring **egg, bacon, and cheese**, available for in-person order and sometimes online pre-order on Thursdays and Fridays.
• **Beverage Service:** Offering **Coffee** to complement the breakfast fare, along with other items that may be available from the host ElMar's NY Pizza menu.
• **Dine-in and Takeout Options:** Customers can eat their bagels on-site or quickly grab them to go.
• **Delivery:** The option for delivery adds convenience, allowing locals to enjoy the bagels without leaving home.

---

## Features / Highlights

ElMar's NY Bagels stands out in the Minnesota market due to its commitment to authentic preparation and the high quality of its ingredients.

• **Authentic New York Preparation:** The bagels are hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked to produce the desired "soft and fluffy inside, slightly crunchy on the outside" texture, often attributed to the process and the reported use of a New York water re-creation system.
• **Quality and Generosity of Cream Cheese:** Customers consistently praise the "classic whipped style cream cheese" and note that the staff does not "skimp on quantity," providing a satisfying and complimentary "schmear."
• **Limited, High-Quality Menu:** The focus on a few classic flavors (**plain, everything, sesame, poppyseed**) ensures quality control and mastery over the core product, appealing to purists.
• **Convenient Pre-Order System:** For the dedicated bagel enthusiast, the option to pre-order bagels online starting the evening before the pop-up is a critical feature, guaranteeing a dozen bagels for pickup without the risk of selling out.
• **Praise for Employees:** Staff are noted as being "really nice and polite," ensuring a pleasant, friendly experience for customers who choose to stand in line during the pop-up window.
• **Accessibility and Payment:** Accepts modern payment methods including **Credit cards** and **Debit cards**, alongside a fully accessible location.

---

## Contact Information

Given its pop-up nature, prospective customers are strongly encouraged to check the bakery's website or social media for the most current information, especially regarding online pre-ordering.

• **Address:** 15725 37th Ave N Suite 5, Plymouth, MN 55446, USA (Located inside ElMar's NY Pizza)
• **Note:** Phone and email contacts are generally associated with the main pizza business. The best way to engage for bagel ordering is through their dedicated online portal during the pre-order window.

---

## What is Worth Choosing: The True Bagel Experience

For Minnesota locals, **ElMar's NY Bagels** is unequivocally worth choosing for one main reason: it delivers the closest experience to a traditional, high-quality New York City bagel available in the Twin Cities metro. While one reviewer noted that "you’ll have to go to New York" for the absolute original, the consensus is that ElMar’s produces a "darn good bagel" that stands well above mass-produced options.

The core selling point is the **Authenticity and Texture**. The hand-rolled, kettle-boiled method is not just a marketing claim; it translates directly into the celebrated texture: a chewy, soft interior encased by a satisfyingly crusty exterior. This makes the ElMar’s bagel fundamentally **different from Bruegger's**, offering a premium, denser, and more artisan alternative. This is the place for the local who "loves good bread" and seeks the genuine article.

The dedication to quality also extends to the fillings. The commitment to a **generous, classic whipped cream cheese**—specifically the highly rated **scallion cream cheese**—ensures that the entire breakfast experience is premium. Furthermore, the simple but hearty **breakfast bagel sandwich** is an excellent option, though customers are advised to customize it with a schmear and seasoning to achieve the highest satisfaction.

To maximize the experience, locals should remember the **limited pop-up hours** and utilize the **online pre-ordering system** for loose bagels. ElMar's NY Bagels provides a truly special, high-demand breakfast treat that is a welcome addition to the Plymouth food scene.

ElMar's NY Bagels (a pop-up at ElMar's NY Pizza)

15725 37th Ave N Suite 5, Plymouth, MN 55446, USA