Nettie's Country Bakery

There’s a certain magic to a true country bakery, a place where the aroma of fresh-baked goods is a warm embrace and every item tells a story of tradition and love. On the eastern end of Long Island, in the charming town of Center Moriches, Nettie's Country Bakery embodies this spirit completely. Founded in 2014 by Joe and Jeanette McHeffey, this bakery is the culmination of decades of experience and a vision to create a space that feels authentic, traditional, and deeply rooted in its community. More than just a place to buy a treat, Nettie's is a destination where locals can gather, relax, and enjoy handcrafted baked goods that are made with passion and a commitment to quality.

The atmosphere at Nettie's is a key part of its allure. Customers consistently describe it as "absolutely comforting," with a "fun, light and cheerful vibe." The bakery offers ample seating, both indoors and outdoors, which includes rocking chairs and Adirondack chairs on a large lawn. This unique setting allows patrons to truly settle in, sip on a cold brew, and savor their treats in a relaxed, country environment. The thoughtful details, such as the mellow music and a cozy barn for shade, create an experience that one reviewer called "one of my favorite places to visit."

While the atmosphere is a major draw, the food is what keeps customers coming back. The reviews are filled with glowing praise for a wide variety of items. From the "Naked cake and strawberry shortcake" to the "donuts, apple strudels, and pies," the menu is a celebration of classic bakery delights. The "Smores Brownies" are described as "the ultimate version of marshmallow pinwheel cookies," with one customer admitting they couldn't resist and ate both packs they bought. The deliciousness extends to their pies, with a reviewer exclaiming that the "peach cobbler and blueberry pie are to die for." This consistent quality and wide range of offerings have made Nettie’s a reliable and cherished part of the Long Island food scene.

Nettie's Country Bakery is located at 366 Railroad Ave, Center Moriches, NY 11934, USA. This address places it in the heart of Center Moriches, a town that offers a more relaxed, country feel compared to the bustling Hamptons. The bakery is situated on a local road, providing a sense of a hidden gem while still being easily accessible.

For residents of Center Moriches and surrounding towns like Manorville, Moriches, and East Moriches, Nettie's is a convenient local stop. The location is easily reachable by car and offers a peaceful setting away from the main highway traffic. The bakery's unique outdoor spaces, including a large lawn with seating, make it a destination for those looking to linger and enjoy their purchases on-site. For those who prefer to shop from home, Nettie's has a modern and user-friendly website that allows customers to browse their full menu and place orders in advance for in-store pickup. They also offer nationwide shipping for their most popular items, including monthly specials, making it possible for people all over the country to enjoy a taste of Long Island.

Nettie's Country Bakery provides a wide array of baked goods and related products, catering to both in-store visitors and online customers.

• Classic Baked Goods: The bakery specializes in a wide range of traditional baked goods. This includes cakes (such as their popular Naked cake and Strawberry Shortcake), pies (like the highly-praised Peach Cobbler and Blueberry Pie), donuts, cookies, pastries, and their signature apple strudel.
• Signature Brownie Bites: A major highlight of their menu is the assortment of handcrafted brownie bites. These are available in a variety of year-round flavors like Classic, Peanut Butter, White Chocolate, and Sea Salt. They also offer seasonal flavors, such as S'mores Brownie Bites in the summer and Pumpkin Spice in the fall, providing a reason for customers to visit throughout the year.
• Custom & Catering Services: Nettie's is a popular choice for event catering, offering their chocolate-dipped brownie bites as wedding or baby shower favors. They can customize the packaging and flavors to match a theme, providing a personalized and memorable treat for guests.
• Coffee and Beverages: To complement their baked goods, Nettie's serves coffee from a locally sourced roaster, Tend Coffee. This commitment to local partnerships adds to their community-centric appeal. They also offer a variety of other cold and hot beverages.
• Local Products & Mixes: In addition to their own creations, the bakery offers a selection of locally made items like homemade jams and jellies, olive oils, and weekly changing homemade soups. For the home baker, they even sell their own cookie mixes, allowing customers to replicate the Nettie's experience in their own kitchens.

Nettie's Country Bakery stands out in the local market due to its unique features and strong sense of identity.

• Unique Atmosphere and Seating: The bakery's setting is a major highlight. With a cozy indoor space, a large outdoor lawn with Adirondack chairs, and a "barn" area, it offers a welcoming and relaxing environment that encourages customers to stay and enjoy their treats. This makes it a great meeting spot for friends or a quiet place for some personal time.
• Commitment to Freshness and Local Sourcing: Everything is baked on the premises, with the owners dedicating weekdays to prepping to ensure everything is fresh for the weekend. The use of local products like Tend Coffee and Amagansett Sea Salt demonstrates a commitment to supporting other small businesses and providing high-quality, fresh ingredients.
• Family-Owned Tradition: As a family-owned and operated business, Nettie's embodies a sense of community and tradition. The owners, Joe and Jeanette McHeffey, and their son, Brendan, have created a business that feels personal and genuine, which resonates strongly with locals.
• Diverse Product Range: While many bakeries focus on a few specialties, Nettie's offers a wide range of products, from classic cakes and pies to an extensive selection of flavored brownie bites, donuts, and even savory soups. This variety ensures there's something to please every palate.
• Community and Social Responsibility: The bakery is not just about making great food; it’s also about giving back to the community through weekly donations and a commitment to sustainability efforts. This sense of social responsibility makes it a business that locals are proud to support.

For all inquiries, including placing a pickup order or learning more about their products, you can contact Nettie's Country Bakery:

Address: 366 Railroad Ave, Center Moriches, NY 11934, USA

Phone: (631) 400-9900

Nettie's Country Bakery is perfectly suited for locals in and around Center Moriches. It serves as a community hub, a place to meet friends, and a reliable source for heartwarming, delicious baked goods. For a region that cherishes its small-town feel and local businesses, Nettie's provides an authentic and high-quality experience that is hard to find elsewhere. The combination of their welcoming country atmosphere, diverse menu of fresh-baked goods, and commitment to supporting local suppliers makes them a treasured part of the community.

The reviews from loyal customers underscore the bakery's success in creating a business that is both a source of excellent food and a source of comfort. Whether a local is craving a classic apple strudel, a birthday cake, or a box of gourmet brownie bites to share, Nettie's offers a wide selection that caters to all needs. The ability to relax on a rocking chair with a cold brew, knowing that you're supporting a family-owned business that values tradition and community, is what makes Nettie's Country Bakery a true gem on Long Island.

Nettie's Country Bakery

366 Railroad Ave, Center Moriches, NY 11934, USA