Poppy's Bagel

For New Yorkers, especially those residing in or passing through Long Island, a great bagel shop is more than just a place to grab breakfast; it's a cornerstone of the community. Poppy's Bagel, located right in Amityville, NY, stands out as a beloved local institution that consistently delivers on the promise of fresh, delicious food and friendly service. This isn't just a place for a quick bite; it's a spot where customers feel valued, even amidst the busiest rushes. From their acclaimed Bacon, Egg, and Cheese (BEC) sandwiches to a wide array of bagels, spreads, and specialty items, Poppy's Bagel has cultivated a loyal following. This overview aims to provide New Yorkers with a comprehensive look at what makes Poppy's Bagel a highly recommended destination, from its convenient location to its extensive menu and commitment to customer satisfaction, ensuring that your next visit will be filled with "goodness."

Poppy's Bagel has garnered a reputation for being a truly amazing bagel shop, a sentiment echoed by its dedicated clientele. Customers frequently highlight the sheer variety of options available, from classic bagels to an impressive selection of sandwiches and other baked goods. The emphasis on freshness is consistently praised, with patrons noting that both bagels and sandwiches always taste fresh and are consistently "GOOD" – a strong endorsement in the competitive New York food scene. Beyond the food, the service at Poppy's Bagel receives high marks for being "very nice, courteous and helpful," with staff even assisting customers by bringing orders to their cars if needed. This dedication to customer experience, combined with a clean environment and fresh coffee, creates a welcoming atmosphere that encourages repeat visits, often becoming a cherished Sunday ritual for many families. It's a testament to their hard work and commitment that even when busy, they are quick to fix any rare mistakes, reinforcing their amazing and kind approach to service.

Poppy's Bagel is conveniently located at 112 Broadway, Amityville, NY 11701, USA. Broadway is a prominent thoroughfare in Amityville, ensuring that the bagel shop is easy to spot and access for both local residents and those passing through the area. Amityville itself is a village in Suffolk County, Long Island, making Poppy's Bagel an accessible destination for a wide range of communities within the region. Its street-level presence on a main road means good visibility and straightforward navigation, whether you're driving or arriving on foot.

For New Yorkers utilizing public transportation on Long Island, establishments on major roads like Broadway are typically well-served by local bus routes, offering a convenient option for daily visits. The location within Amityville places it within a vibrant community, allowing it to serve as a hub for daily breakfast and lunch rushes. While parking can sometimes be a consideration in busy areas, the ease of finding Poppy's Bagel's location itself contributes to its convenience. Its strategic placement allows it to be a consistent and reliable option for residents and visitors alike, solidifying its role as a neighborhood staple for fresh bagels and delicious sandwiches. As customers often note, it's "easy to pass but if you stop in… you WILL be amazed!"

Poppy's Bagel offers an extensive menu that goes well beyond just bagels, providing a comprehensive range of breakfast and lunch options to satisfy diverse cravings.

• Freshly Baked Bagels: A wide variety of classic New York-style bagels, including plain, everything, sesame, poppy, garlic, onion, salt & pepper, cinnamon golden raisin, and more. Available individually, by the half-dozen, or by the dozen.
• Gourmet Cream Cheeses: A diverse selection of cream cheese spreads, ranging from plain and scallion to unique flavors like jalapeño serrano, briny (pickles & capers), black truffle, and chivey lemony lox. Housemade vegan cashew cream cheese is also an option.
• Breakfast Sandwiches: A highly popular category featuring classic Bacon, Egg, and Cheese (BEC), Sausage Egg and Cheese (SEC), and a variety of specialty egg sandwiches such as Eggs Benedict, Eggs Florentine, Smoked Salmon Eggs Benedict, Poppy's California Egg Sandwich (with avocado, tomato, Swiss), and the substantial Hungryman Wrap.
• Specialty Sandwiches: An impressive range of lunch sandwiches served on bagels, rolls, wraps, or bread, including options like Lox Works (cream cheese, nova lox, red onion, capers), whitefish salad, tuna salad, chicken salad BLT, Italian Hero, All American, Uptown Charlotte, The Dagwood, Poppy's Club, and The New Yorker (roast turkey, Swiss, coleslaw, Russian dressing).
• Paninis: A selection of pressed paninis such as Godfather (prosciutto, breaded eggplant, fresh mozzarella), Godmother (grilled chicken, prosciutto, fresh mozzarella), Fredo (chicken or eggplant parmigiana), and various other creative combinations.
• Omelets: Customizable 3-egg omelets with various fillings like meat and cheese, Western (ham, peppers, onions), Lo Cal Egg Whites & Turkey, served with a buttered bagel.
• Soups and Salads: Homemade chicken noodle soup, house salads (field greens, walnuts, dried cranberries, Gorgonzola), Chef Salad, and Greek Salad.
• Baked Goods & Desserts: In addition to bagels, they offer other baked goods, including a "SO GOOD" fudge bar, assorted pastries, and likely other sweet treats.
• Coffee and Beverages: Freshly brewed coffee (hot and iced), cold brew, tea, fresh-squeezed orange juice, lemonade, and chocolate milk.
• Catering Services: Comprehensive catering options for breakfast and lunch, including bagel and cream cheese platters, lox platters, hot food options like egg sandwiches by the person, fresh fruit bowls, yogurt parfait cups, coffee boxes, and sandwich platters.

This extensive menu ensures that Poppy's Bagel is a one-stop shop for breakfast, lunch, and catering needs for the Amityville community and beyond.

Poppy's Bagel has cultivated a strong reputation in Amityville, thanks to several key features and highlights that consistently impress its clientele.

• Exceptional Food Quality: Described as having "delicious" food, with bagels and sandwiches that "always taste fresh" and are "always a GOOD sandwich." The BEC (Bacon, Egg, and Cheese) is particularly highlighted as a favorite.
• Wide Variety of Offerings: Customers consistently praise the "amazing" variety of bagels, sandwiches (breakfast and lunch), and baked goods, ensuring there's something for everyone, from traditionalists to those seeking unique flavors like their "SO GOOD" fudge bar.
• Fresh Ingredients: A commitment to using quality ingredients, including "tops" ingredients for all their offerings, contributing to the overall deliciousness.
• Friendly and Courteous Staff: The team is consistently described as "very nice, courteous and helpful," creating a welcoming environment that makes every visit pleasant. Their willingness to "even help bring stuff to your car if you need help!" is a notable testament to their service.
• Quick and Efficient Service: Even when "extremely busy," the staff are "amazing hardworking" and "quick to fix the issue" if a mistake occurs, demonstrating their dedication to customer satisfaction.
• Clean Environment: Customers appreciate the "clean place," which adds to the positive dining experience.
• Fresh Coffee: The coffee is consistently fresh, making it a perfect complement to their breakfast offerings.
• Catering Expertise: With extensive catering options for various events, they are a reliable choice for larger gatherings, from office breakfasts to family brunches.
• Hidden Gem Status: Despite its prominent location, one review noted it's "easy to pass but if you stop in… you WILL be amazed!" hinting at a delightful discovery for newcomers.

These highlights collectively paint a picture of a well-run, customer-focused bagel shop that has earned its loyal local following.

For New Yorkers in Amityville and surrounding Long Island communities looking to experience the goodness of Poppy's Bagel, here is their essential contact information:

Address: 112 Broadway, Amityville, NY 11701, USA

Phone: (631) 532-6529

Mobile Phone: +1 631-532-6529

Customers frequently call ahead to place "big orders," especially on busy mornings like Sunday, so utilizing the provided phone numbers is a highly recommended way to ensure your order is ready when you arrive and to minimize wait times during peak hours. You can also inquire about their extensive catering services for your next event or gathering. The friendly staff are always ready to assist with orders and any questions you might have, ensuring a smooth and pleasant experience from the moment you contact them to when you pick up your delicious food.

In conclusion, Poppy's Bagel in Amityville is undeniably a highly suitable and cherished establishment for locals in New York's Long Island region. Its core appeal lies in its unwavering commitment to delivering consistently "delicious" and fresh food, from their perfectly prepared bagels and a vast array of sandwiches to their tempting baked goods. For New Yorkers, the presence of a bagel shop that not only provides quality sustenance but also fosters a warm and welcoming atmosphere is invaluable.

The glowing customer reviews highlight not just the food's excellence, but also the exemplary service, where staff are described as "amazing hardworking and kind," going above and beyond to ensure customer satisfaction, even helping to bring orders to cars. This blend of high-quality products, diverse menu options (including extensive catering), efficient service, and a genuine commitment to the community makes Poppy's Bagel more than just a place to eat; it's a neighborhood staple, a reliable spot for morning rituals, family meals, and special occasions. For anyone in Amityville or passing through, doing yourself "a favor" and stopping in to "taste GOODNESS" at Poppy's Bagel is a recommendation well worth taking.

Poppy's Bagel

112 Broadway, Amityville, NY 11701, USA