The Pie Store

For New Jersey residents with a discerning palate and a love for comforting, expertly crafted baked goods, "The Pie Store" in Montclair is truly "an absolute gem!" This beloved bakery has established itself as a premier destination for both savory and sweet pies, bringing a unique taste of authentic British baking to the Garden State. From the moment you step through its doors, you're "hit with the warm, comforting aroma of freshly baked pies," an immediate indication that you're "about to experience something special." It's more than just a place to pick up a dessert; it's a culinary experience that combines traditional recipes with a heartfelt passion for baking, making it a cherished spot for many families and individuals across New Jersey.

The Pie Store has carved out a distinct niche in the New Jersey food scene by focusing on the art of pie-making, a craft they execute with remarkable precision and dedication. Their commitment to high-quality ingredients and time-honored techniques ensures that every pie, whether it's a hearty savory option or a classic sweet treat, delivers on flavor and texture. This dedication to excellence has fostered a loyal customer base who consistently rave about the superior quality and taste of their offerings. For anyone in the New Jersey area seeking a unique and satisfying culinary experience, especially those with an appreciation for authentic British flavors and the comforting appeal of a perfectly baked pie, The Pie Store stands as an undisputed leader, promising a "slice of heaven" with every visit.

The Pie Store is conveniently located at 100 Watchung Ave, Montclair, NJ 07043, USA. This prime address places it in Upper Montclair, a charming and highly accessible section of town. Watchung Avenue is a well-known thoroughfare, making it easy to find for residents throughout Montclair and surrounding communities in Essex County, including Verona, Cedar Grove, and Glen Ridge. The bakery is tucked into the curve where Park Street meets Watchung Avenue near the train trestle, giving it a distinctive and recognizable presence within the local landscape. Its location allows for straightforward navigation, whether you're traveling by car or on foot, and is often a convenient stop for those in the Watchung Plaza area.

The accessibility of The Pie Store is further enhanced by its placement within a walkable and vibrant community. While specific parking details aren't explicitly provided, being located on a main avenue in Upper Montclair generally means street parking or nearby public parking options are available, typical for this type of local business. The pleasant vibe of the entire area makes visiting the store an enjoyable outing in itself, encouraging customers to linger and explore. This combination of a prominent location, ease of navigation, and a welcoming neighborhood feel makes The Pie Store a highly accessible and frequently visited destination for New Jersey residents looking for an authentic and delightful pie experience.

The Pie Store offers an exquisite range of both savory and sweet pies, alongside other British-inspired baked goods, all crafted with meticulous attention to detail and authentic recipes. Their menu is designed to cater to diverse tastes and occasions.

• Savory Pies: A standout category, highly praised by customers. Options include their "chicken pie," described as "a revelation—savory, perfectly seasoned, and packed with tender, flavorful chicken wrapped in a golden, flaky crust that’s sheer perfection." Other popular savory pies often include Shepherd's Pie, Steak, Ale & Mushroom Pie, Cheese, Potato & Onion Pie, and seasonal favorites like their much-anticipated "turkey pie."
• Seasonal Turkey Pie: Available exclusively around Thanksgiving and Christmas, this pie is described as a "holiday miracle in pie form," featuring "tender turkey, rich gravy, and just the right mix of veggies all encased in that legendary crust."
• Sweet Pies: A delectable selection of classic dessert pies. Their "apple pie" is lauded as "everything you dream an apple pie should be—sweet, tangy apples, a touch of cinnamon, and a buttery, crumbly crust that melts in your mouth." Other sweet options often include mince pie, which customers find "absolutely delicious" and "so fresh, baked perfectly, with such tasty filling," as well as Key Lime Pie, Chocolate Mousse Pie, Coconut Custard Pie, and Banoffee.
• Pocket Pasties & Sausage Rolls: Smaller, handheld savory options such as Cornish Pasties, Steak & Cheddar Pasties, BBQ Pork & Cheddar Pasties, Chana Masala Pasties, Lamb & Feta Pasties, and Gourmet Sausage Rolls.
• Scones: Offerings often include a variety of scones, perfect for a traditional British tea experience.
• Soups: The Pie Store also offers a selection of comforting soups, making for a complete meal when paired with their savory pies or pasties.
• British Groceries and Novelties: In addition to freshly baked goods, The Pie Store is known to stock a selection of hard-to-find British chocolates, biscuits, crisps, jams, savory sauces, curry mixes, and drinks, enhancing the authentic British experience.

The Pie Store has garnered a stellar reputation among New Jersey residents, distinguished by several key features and highlights that consistently receive glowing praise from its devoted customer base.

• "Absolute Gem" with Unforgettable Aromas: The immediate impression is the "warm, comforting aroma of freshly baked pies" that greets customers, setting the stage for a special experience. This inviting ambiance contributes significantly to the overall positive perception.
• Exceptional Savory Pies: Their "chicken pie is a revelation," lauded for its "savory, perfectly seasoned" filling and "golden, flaky crust that’s sheer perfection." The "turkey pie" is an annual "holiday miracle in pie form," so anticipated that customers "literally count down the days" for its seasonal availability. These savory options are clearly a major draw.
• Perfectly Crafted Sweet Pies: The "apple pie" is described as "everything you dream an apple pie should be," with "sweet, tangy apples, a touch of cinnamon, and a buttery, crumbly crust that melts in your mouth." Even traditional "mince pie" is "absolutely delicious! So fresh, baked perfectly, with such tasty filling." This commitment to classic perfection ensures a satisfying experience for sweet tooths.
• Legendary, Flaky Crust: The crust is consistently highlighted as "sheer perfection" and "legendary," indicating a consistent mastery of this fundamental element of pie making, which elevates all their offerings.
• Friendly and Passionate Staff: "The staff is always friendly, and you can tell they put so much love into every single thing they make." This personal touch makes customers "feel like part of the family" and contributes significantly to the pleasant "vibe" of the whole place.
• Consistent Quality and Reliability: Customers repeatedly state that "The Pie Store never disappoints," and express strong loyalty, with one vowing to be a "loyal customer for life." This consistency in product quality and service builds immense trust.
• Convenient Heating Instructions: For certain items like the mince pie, the simplicity of "Just had to put it in the oven for 15 mins and done!" adds to the convenience and appeal for busy households.
• Authentic British Experience: Beyond pies, the availability of "British groceries and British Meat Pies" offers an authentic cultural experience, making it a unique specialty food market in the area.

For inquiries, to place an order, or to learn more about their daily specials and seasonal offerings, The Pie Store can be reached at the following contact points:

Address: 100 Watchung Ave, Montclair, NJ 07043, USA

Phone: (973) 744-4424

Mobile Phone: +1 973-744-4424

These contact details provide convenient and direct ways for New Jersey residents to connect with The Pie Store. Whether you're planning a holiday feast and need to pre-order a turkey pie, have questions about their daily savory pie selection, or simply want to inquire about their business hours, the availability of both a landline and a mobile number ensures easy communication. The friendly staff are ready to assist you in selecting the perfect pie for any occasion or just for a comforting treat.

In conclusion, The Pie Store in Montclair is undeniably a cherished culinary institution for New Jersey residents, offering an authentic taste of British pie-making that consistently earns rave reviews. Its mastery of both savory and sweet pies, highlighted by the "revelation" of its chicken pie and the "holiday miracle" of its turkey pie, combined with its consistently perfect, flaky crust, sets it apart as a true specialist in its craft. The welcoming atmosphere and the friendly staff who infuse "so much love into every single thing they make" further enhance the experience, making every visit a comforting and satisfying one.

For locals, The Pie Store is not just suitable; it's an indispensable part of their community. It provides a unique and high-quality option for everything from a quick, delicious lunch to the centerpiece of a holiday meal. Its reliability, diverse offerings, and the undeniable passion behind every pie ensure that it "never disappoints." Whether you're a long-time fan or a newcomer eager to discover "a slice of heaven," The Pie Store offers a consistent, delightful experience that resonates deeply with New Jersey's appreciation for quality, comfort, and a touch of something truly special, cementing its status as a loyal customer magnet for life.

The Pie Store

100 Watchung Ave, Montclair, NJ 07043, USA