Alyssa's Custom Cakes and Treats

For residents across the Hoosier State looking for a truly personalized touch for their celebrations, Alyssa's Custom Cakes and Treats stands out as a dedicated, specialty dessert provider based in Sullivan, Indiana. This is not a traditional walk-in bakery; instead, Alyssa’s operates on a streamlined, order-ahead model, focusing intensely on creating high-quality, custom-designed cakes and a variety of sweet treats. This specialization allows them to focus their energy on artistic design and incredible flavor, ensuring every order is a masterpiece tailored for a special event.

Alyssa, the woman behind the business, brings over 10 years of experience to her craft, focusing on "stunning buttercream cakes" that are both beautiful and delicious. Her artistic approach means that every custom cake is unique, designed to perfectly match the theme and tone of your special occasion, whether it’s a birthday, a baby shower, or a wedding. For Indiana customers, this business model provides the convenience of professional, high-end cake artistry right here in the region, without the overhead of a storefront.

The quality and customer service are consistently praised, especially for large-scale orders. One customer, delighted with their three-tiered wedding cake, reported that "The look and the taste were amazing!" and that friends kept asking where the cake was from. They highlighted the exceptional flavor combinations, specifically praising the lemon cake with lemon custard as a favorite, alongside red velvet with strawberries and chocolate cake with walnuts. Customers also note that "Alyssa is super friendly and easy to work with," emphasizing the personalized and stress-free experience of ordering a custom dessert for a major event.

While the business model is highly focused on custom orders, their expansive menu proves that they are a full-service bakery specializing in complex dessert offerings, from tiered wedding cakes down to individually wrapped treats like cookies, brownies, and fudge. This range of products confirms their place as a key resource for any Indiana family planning a gathering or simply craving a high-quality, homemade sweet treat. The ability to manage orders for weddings and other significant events underscores their professional capability and reliability.

Location and Accessibility

Alyssa's Custom Cakes and Treats is located in Sullivan, IN 47882, USA, but operates with a unique and convenient business model: Phone Orders Only. This means there is no traditional public storefront to visit for browsing, which is key information for local Indiana users. All orders must be placed remotely, typically via phone or online inquiry, and then fulfilled through delivery or designated in-store pickup (or an equivalent predetermined pickup spot, based on the specific arrangement).

The address is primarily a fulfillment location, designed to facilitate the smooth transfer of the ordered goods. While the business model is not focused on walk-in traffic, accessibility for pickup is considered. The location features a Wheelchair accessible parking lot, which ensures that customers utilizing the in-store pickup option have convenient and accessible parking to easily retrieve their often large or delicate custom orders. This streamlined system is specifically designed for the convenience of custom ordering, allowing customers to arrange the creation of their perfect cake from the comfort of their home or office.

Services Offered

Alyssa's Custom Cakes and Treats provides specialized services focused entirely on custom orders, high-quality baking, and customer convenience:

• Custom Tiered Cakes: Specializing in beautiful, multi-layered cakes perfect for weddings, anniversaries, and large parties (e.g., 4”/6”/8” tiered cakes).
• Single-Layer and Double-Layer Cakes: Available in various sizes (6" and 8" rounds) for smaller, intimate gatherings or smash cakes.
• Cupcakes: Offered by the dozen with optional fillings, perfect for parties and corporate events.
• Cookies and Sweet Treats: Includes a variety of homemade cookies (like chocolate chip and iced sugar cookies), brownies, bars (e.g., Peanut Butter, Magic Bars), and different flavors of fudge.
• Dessert Boxes and Bars: Pre-selected assortments of treats to simplify ordering for gatherings of up to 24 people.
• Delivery: Provides the ultimate convenience of having custom orders safely transported to the customer’s specified location.
• In-store pickup: A designated arrangement for customers to collect their orders at the Sullivan fulfillment location.
• Extensive Flavor Selection: Offers a wide range of cake flavors (Vanilla, Red Velvet, Lemon, Confetti, etc.) and delicious fillings (Salted Caramel, Lemon Custard, Cream Cheese Buttercream, etc.) for full customization.
• Flexible Payment Options: Accepts Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments for seamless remote transactions.

Features / Highlights

The value proposition of Alyssa's Custom Cakes and Treats lies in their custom focus, quality, and personalized service.

• Wedding Cake Expertise: Proven track record of creating beautiful, highly-praised three-tiered wedding cakes with amazing look and taste.
• Specialty Flavor Combinations: Known for delicious and unique flavor pairings, with the lemon cake and lemon custard combination being a popular favorite among customers.
• Personalized Customer Experience: Alyssa is highlighted as "super friendly and easy to work with," ensuring a smooth and pleasant ordering process.
• Artistic Customization: Brings over 10 years of experience in creating "stunning buttercream cakes," allowing for unique designs tailored to specific occasions.
• Order-Ahead Model: Focuses business operations entirely on fulfilling custom orders, maximizing product quality and personalization, as the business is Phone Orders Only.
• Accessibility for Pickups: Provides a wheelchair accessible parking lot for convenient and safe retrieval of large or delicate custom orders.
• Diverse Product Range: Functions as more than just a cake shop, offering cupcakes, cookies, bars, and fudge, making it a one-stop-shop for various dessert needs.

Contact Information

To discuss your custom cake or treat order, please contact Alyssa's Custom Cakes and Treats directly. Remember, this business operates by phone orders only.

Address (Fulfillment Location): Phone Orders Only, Sullivan, IN 47882, USA

Phone: (812) 638-2997

What Is Worth Choosing

For Indiana residents seeking truly custom and professionally executed desserts, Alyssa's Custom Cakes and Treats is the premier choice. It is worth choosing because the business model is built around one single priority: creating the perfect product for your specific event. Unlike traditional bakeries that split their attention between daily retail and custom orders, Alyssa's dedication to the "Phone Orders Only" system guarantees focused, specialized attention on every custom piece.

The reviews speak volumes about the quality you receive. When a wedding cake—the centerpiece of a major life event—is described as having an "amazing" look and taste, and is the topic of conversation among guests, it confirms that Alyssa delivers on her promise of creating cakes that are both stunning and delicious. The fact that the lemon cake and lemon custard were a distinct favorite among a variety of complex flavors highlights the depth and quality of her recipes and fillings. Furthermore, the positive comments about her being "super friendly and easy to work with" are crucial, particularly for stressful processes like wedding planning, offering a reliable, calm, and professional experience.

While there was one mixed review regarding the size and a minor structural issue with external decoration on a smaller cake, the overwhelming success stories of her tiered wedding cakes and the consistency of her praised flavors suggest that for complex, high-value custom work, she excels. The business's ability to offer a massive variety of desserts—from gourmet fudge to specialty bars and multiple cake flavors—under a flexible system of both delivery and in-store pickup (with accessible parking) only increases its value. By choosing Alyssa's Custom Cakes and Treats, you are opting for a seasoned artisan who will craft a bespoke, memorable centerpiece for your next Indiana celebration.

Alyssa's Custom Cakes and Treats

Phone Orders Only, Sullivan, IN 47882, USA