Bagel Boutique Mechanicsburg: Authentic East Coast Bagels in PA

Bagel Boutique Introduce

Introduction / Overview

For Pennsylvania locals with a discerning taste for authentic bagels, finding a true East Coast-style bagel outside of major metropolitan hubs can often feel like a quest. Thankfully, Bagel Boutique in Mechanicsburg has emerged as a shining beacon, bringing the genuine experience of hand-made, boiled, and baked bagels right to our doorstep. This isn't just another shop selling circular bread; Bagel Boutique embodies the very essence of what makes a bagel truly great: a chewy interior, a slightly crisp crust, and a depth of flavor that can only come from traditional preparation methods. From the moment you step inside, you're greeted with an ambiance that one customer described as "cool, cute, and original," instantly setting it apart from more generic establishments.

What truly distinguishes Bagel Boutique is its commitment to the craft. They are celebrated for making bagels "like a true East Coast bagel," a claim that resonates deeply with anyone who appreciates the distinct quality found in New York, Philadelphia, or Jersey-style bagels. Beyond their stellar plain and savory options, they also offer adventurous choices like the "very well garlic, and Butter stuffed bagel" which one reviewer enthusiastically called "mind blowing." And it's not just about the bagels; their menu extends to creative and hearty breakfast sandwiches, famously featuring "pork roll," a beloved East Coast staple. The combination of exceptional food, a welcoming atmosphere, and genuinely passionate staff makes Bagel Boutique a must-visit destination for any Pennsylvanian seeking an authentic bagel experience that feels just like home.

Location and Accessibility

Bagel Boutique is conveniently located at 6581 Carlisle Pike, Mechanicsburg, PA 17050, USA. This address places it directly on a major thoroughfare in Mechanicsburg, making it highly accessible for residents not only within Mechanicsburg but also from surrounding communities across Central Pennsylvania. Carlisle Pike is a well-known commercial corridor, meaning the bagel shop is easy to find, whether you're using GPS or simply navigating by familiar landmarks. Its prominent location ensures that commuters, local shoppers, and those specifically seeking out authentic bagels will have no trouble reaching this delightful establishment.

The accessibility of Bagel Boutique is a significant advantage for Pennsylvanians. Being on Carlisle Pike, there is typically ample parking available in the vicinity, which is a crucial convenience, especially during peak hours. This ease of access means you can quickly pop in for your morning coffee and bagel, pick up a dozen for the office, or enjoy a leisurely breakfast without the stress of urban parking woes. For locals from Harrisburg, Camp Hill, Carlisle, and other nearby towns, the short drive to Mechanicsburg is well worth it for the promise of genuinely exceptional bagels. The comfortable and inviting location contributes to the overall positive experience, making Bagel Boutique a go-to spot for an authentic East Coast taste right here in Pennsylvania.

Services Offered

Hand-Made, Boiled, and Baked Bagels: Bagel Boutique prides itself on its traditional East Coast bagel preparation, ensuring authenticity in taste and texture.
Wide Variety of Bagel Flavors: They offer both traditional options (like plain bagel with cream cheese) and more adventurous, specialty bagels (e.g., the "very well garlic, and Butter stuffed bagel").
Diverse Topping Options: Customers can choose from classic cream cheese options to a range of other toppings for their bagels.
Breakfast Sandwiches: A highly recommended service is their breakfast sandwiches, notably featuring "pork roll, egg, and cheese" on various bagel types, showcasing a true East Coast staple.
Lunch/Hoagie Options: Beyond breakfast, they also serve lunch items, as evidenced by the "A Bronx Tale" chicken cutlet on a hoagie roll, indicating a broader menu.
Dine-In Seating: The establishment provides a comfortable and "cute" ambiance with tables for customers to enjoy their food on-site.
Takeout and Pick-Up Orders: They accommodate a "good bit of pick up to go order," making it convenient for customers to grab their food quickly.
Family-Friendly Options: They offer "little sugary flavored type bagels with different toppings" that are designed to satisfy "even the pickiest of appetite" among children.
Catering/Bulk Orders: While not explicitly stated, the mention of "a good bit of pick up to go order" suggests they can handle larger orders for events or offices.

Features / Highlights

Authentic East Coast Bagels: This is the paramount highlight. Customers rave that their bagels are "hand made boiled and baked like a true east coast bagel," delivering the taste of "Jersey, Philly, or New York" right in Central PA. This authenticity is unparalleled in the region.
Exceptional Taste and Quality: Their bagels are described as "incredibly good" and "best in central pa by far." Specific items like the garlic and butter stuffed bagel are called "mind blowing" and "one of the best bagels I think I’ve ever had."
Unique and Flavorful Menu Items: Beyond classic bagels, the inclusion of "pork roll" on their breakfast sandwiches is a significant draw for East Coast natives. The "A Bronx Tale" hoagie also receives extremely high praise, blowing "every Italian place in the area out of the water."
Welcoming and Unique Ambiance: The "cute" and "original" decor, along with an "up to date and refreshing" atmosphere, contributes to a very positive dining experience, making customers "feel at home."
Friendly and Engaging Staff: The staff are consistently described as "cool as shit," "great people," and "willing to talk about food and the business," fostering a comforting and inspiring environment.
Generous Portion Sizes: The "very well garlic, and Butter stuffed bagel" was noted as "big," suggesting satisfying portion sizes for their offerings.
Family-Friendly Options: The availability of "little sugary flavored type bagels" with various toppings makes it a suitable and appealing destination for families with children.
Strong Local Support and Customer Loyalty: Customers express a strong desire for the place to succeed ("I just hope this place makes it") and an intention to become regulars, indicating significant local appeal and a dedicated customer base.

Contact Information

For Pennsylvanians eager to experience the authentic taste of East Coast bagels and more, Bagel Boutique in Mechanicsburg welcomes you. Here’s how you can get in touch:

Address: 6581 Carlisle Pike, Mechanicsburg, PA 17050, USA

Phone: (717) 631-3131

Mobile Phone: +1 717-631-3131

Whether you're calling to inquire about their daily specials, planning a larger order, or simply confirming their hours, these contact details provide direct access to their friendly and accommodating team. Don't hesitate to reach out and prepare yourself for a truly exceptional bagel experience that brings the spirit of New York, Philly, and Jersey right here to your neighborhood in Pennsylvania.

Conclusion: Why this place is suitable for locals

For Pennsylvania residents, particularly those in Central PA, Bagel Boutique is not just suitable—it's an essential destination for a multitude of compelling reasons. Firstly, and perhaps most importantly, it delivers an unparalleled authentic East Coast bagel experience. In a region where finding a genuinely "hand made boiled and baked" bagel can be a challenge, Bagel Boutique fills that void perfectly, offering a taste of New York, Philly, or Jersey right here in Mechanicsburg. This authenticity resonates deeply with locals who appreciate traditional preparation and superior flavor, making their bagels the "best in central PA by far."

Beyond the exceptional bagels, the establishment creates a profoundly comforting and welcoming atmosphere. The "cool, cute, and original" ambiance, combined with "up to date and refreshing" decor, makes every visit a pleasant experience. This inviting environment is further enhanced by the staff, who are described as "cool as shit," "great people," and genuinely passionate about their food and business. This level of personal connection and friendliness makes customers "feel at home" and inspires loyalty, a quality highly valued by local patrons. The menu's versatility, offering not just diverse bagel flavors but also unique and highly praised items like the "pork roll egg and cheese" sandwich and "A Bronx Tale" chicken cutlet, ensures there's something to satisfy every craving, from traditionalists to the more adventurous. The availability of "sugary flavored type bagels" also makes it a fantastic spot for families with "little kids," catering to even the pickiest eaters. Given its convenient location on Carlisle Pike and the evident high volume of walk-in and pick-up orders, Bagel Boutique has clearly become a beloved fixture in the community. For any Pennsylvanian seeking incredible food, a great atmosphere, and a truly authentic experience, Bagel Boutique stands as a testament to quality and a well-deserved local favorite.

Bagel Boutique Food & drink

Cappuccino & Lattes
Iced Latte US$5.40
A creamier coffee made with espresso and steamed milk Milk options include: (Almond, Oat, & Whole)
Hot Latte US$5.40
A creamier coffee made with espresso and steamed milk Milk options include: (Almond, Oat, & Whole)
Specialty Iced Latte US$6.60
A creamier coffee made with espresso and steamed milk. In addition, specialty flavors, syrups, and toppings are included. Milk options include: (Almond, Oat, & Whole) Add a flavored syrup & cold foam Choice of flavored & syrup and cold foam
Specialty Hot Latte US$6.60
A creamier coffee made with espresso and steamed milk. In addition, specialty flavors, syrups, and toppings are included. Milk options include: (Almond, Oat, & Whole)
Cappuccino US$5.40
A stronger coffee (double shot of espresso) with equal parts steamed and foamed milk. Milk Options: (almond, oat, & whole milk)
Specialty Cappuccino US$6.60
A stronger coffee (double shot of espresso) with equal parts steamed and foamed milk. In addition, specialty flavors, syrups, and toppings are included. Milk Options: (almond, oat, & whole milk)

Chai Tea Lattes
Chai Latte US$6.60
Decaf Chai Latte US$6.60
Matcha Green Tea Latte US$6.60

Cold Brew
20 Oz. Cold Brew US$6.00
20 oz. steeped coarse ground coffee, served over ice Choose a flavor & sweet cream cold foam
32 Oz. Cold Brew US$7.20
32 oz. steeped coarse ground coffee, served over ice Choose a flavor & sweet cream cold foam

Cold Brew Freeze
Cold Brew Caramel Freeze US$6.60
Cold Brew Mocha Freeze US$6.60

Espresso Shot
Single Espresso Shot US$3.00
1 oz.
Double Espresso Shot US$5.40
2 oz.

Fountain Soda
Coke US$3.60
Coke Zero US$3.60
Dr. Pepper US$3.60
Powerade Mountain Blast US$3.60
Sprite US$3.60
Diet Coke US$3.60

Trending Drinks
Chocolate Chai Tea Latte US$6.60
20 oz. Rich chocolate, smooth black tea, and a bold blend of chai spices

Hot Chocolate
Hot Chocolate US$5.40
Milk of your choice, topped with whipped cream and mini marshmallows

Hot Coffee
Decaf US$4.20
16 oz.
Jamaican Me Crazy US$4.20
16 oz. An island blend of caramel and vanilla with a pop of Kahlua combined with our signature blended coffee.
Royal Sumatra US$4.20
16 oz. Dark Roast, bold flavors from Columbia, Costa Rica, Guatemala, & Mexico

Hot Tea
Chamomile US$4.20
This robust blend of USDA organic tea combines chamomile flowers, hibiscus flowers, spearmint leaves, rose petals, lemongrass, and blackberry leaves.
Earl Grey US$4.20
This blend features a bold, full-bodied black tea base, featuring a delicate floral essence of bergamot, perfectly complemented by hints of bright citrus.
English Breakfast US$4.20
Tazo Awake English Breakfast Black Tea is an unsweetened, caffeinated tea to help give you a bold and energizing boost with your morning tea.
Green Tea US$4.20
TAZO Zen Green Tea Bags is a delicious green tea blend infused with crisp notes of spearmint, lemongrass, and lemon verbena to help you experience a true moment of Zen during the day. This invigorating blend of green tea also includes hints of bright lemongrass and crisp spearmint.
Tazo Joy US$4.20
TAZO JOY is a limited-edition seasonal blend of subtle yet complex notes of black, green, and oolong tea that mingle happily with soft peach flavor notes.

Juice
Apple Juice US$4.20
12 oz.
Fresh Squeezed OJ US$7.20
12 oz. Fresh squeezed OJ made from oranges imported from California & Florida
Mango Juice US$4.20
1/2 Gallon OJ US$20.40
Gallon OJ US$42.00

Lemonades & Teas
Arnold Palmer US$4.20
Iced Team & Lemonade Combined Choice of 20 oz. or 32 oz. Choice of Sweetened or Unsweetened Iced Tea
Unsweetened Iced Tea US$4.20
Fresh brewed iced tea, no sugar added Choice of 20 oz. or 32 oz.
Flavored Unsweetened Tea US$4.80
Sweet Tea US$4.20
Fresh brewed iced tea Choice of 20 oz. or 32 oz.
Flavored Sweet Tea US$4.80
Fresh brewed iced tea. Choice of 20 0z. or 32 oz. Flavors include: Blood Orange, Blueberry Lavender, Strawberry, Raspberry, Blue Raspberry
Lemonade US$4.20
Fresh lemonade made on site. Choice of 20 oz or 32 oz.
Flavored Lemonade US$4.80
Fresh lemonade made on site. Choice of 20 0z. or 32 oz. Flavors include: Blood Orange, Blueberry Lavender, Strawberry, Raspberry, Blue Raspberry, Pickle, or Sour Candy
Carnival Lemonade US$5.40
Lemons are muddled, water and sugar cane syrup are added, and shaken to taste just like one you would get at a carnival. Size: 32 oz.
Flavored Carnival Lemonade US$6.00
Lemons are muddled, water and sugar cane syrup are added, and shaken to taste just like one you would get at a carnival. Flavors include: blood orange, blueberry lavender, raspberry, strawberry, pickle, sour candy, blue raspberry

Milk
Almond Milk US$3.60
12 oz.
Oat Milk US$3.60
12 oz.
White Milk US$3.60
12 oz.

Smoothies
Cotton Candy US$7.20
Cotton Candy Frappe (no caffeine), topped with whipped cream, vanilla drizzle, and cotton candy pieces
Strawberry Banana US$8.40
Chocolate Peanut Butter Protein Smoothie US$8.40
Vanilla Bean Smoothie US$8.40

Specialty Cold Brew
Specialty Cold Brew US$6.60

Togo Drinks
Fiji Water US$3.60
Life Water US$3.60
Good And Gather US$2.40
Flavors Vary

Sandwiches
A Bronx's Tale US$14.40
Toasted garlic sesame seed hoagie roll, fried chicken cutlet, provolone cheese, vodka sauce, fresh basil, grated parm cheese
Big Bambino US$15.60
Toasted seed hoagie roll, fried chicken cutlet, crispy prosciutto, fresh mozzarella cheese, arugula, sundried tomatoes, balsamic glaze
BLTS US$16.80
Grilled salmon, applewood smoked bacon, avocado, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, lemon aioli, thick sliced sourdough bread
Buffalo Ranch Chicken Wrap US$15.60
Buttermilk fried chicken, Romaine lettuce, shredded cheddar cheese, frizzled onions, homemade ranch, buffalo sauce, grilled tortilla
Chipotle Chicken Wrap US$14.40
Toasted flour tortilla, pepper jack cheese, grilled marinated chicken, applewood smoked bacon, shredded lettuce, tomato, onion, avocado, & chipotle mayo
Chopped Italian Hoagie US$14.40
Sesame seed hoagie roll stuffed with chopped ham, capicola, salami, provolone cheese, shredded lettuce, tomato, red onion, mayo, oil & red wine vinegar, banana peppers, salt, pepper, & oregano
Deli Turkey & Cheese Bagel US$14.40
Sliced turkey breast, cheese of choice, bagel of your choice, lettuce, tomato, mayo Add additional toppings under "mods."
Hail Caesar US$14.40
Toasted garlic sesame seed hoagie roll, shredded romaine lettuce, Caesar dressing, croutons, shaved parm cheese, fried chicken **Add fried prosciutto +2.00** (substitute grilled chicken at no additional cost)
Hey Gouda Lookin US$15.60
Toasted sesame seed hoagie roll, mushroom & peppercorn spread, grilled seasoned steak, sauteed onions, gouda cheese
MJ's Smash Burger US$14.40
Toasted brioche bun, 2) 4 oz. angus seasoned patties, diced sauteed onions, american cheese, secret smash sauce, pickles
Philly Jawn US$14.40
Toasted sesame seed hoagie roll, shaved rib eye, caramelized onions, sweet peppers, and your choice of copper american cheese, cheese sauce, or provolone cheese (substitute chicken at no additional cost)
Stella's Pizza Bagel US$12.00
Plain bagel, marinara sauce, shredded mozzarella cheese, pepperoni cups, pickled jalapenos, hot honey drizzle
The Big Dill US$14.40
Kosher dill pickle, havarti dill cheese, smoked turkey breast, applewood smoked bacon, shredded lettuce, cherry pepper spread
The Gyro US$14.40
Shaved gyro meat, tzatziki sauce, tomato, onion, stuffed with fries, and topped with feta cheese, served in a warm, grilled pita
The Tipsy Chicken US$15.60
Buttermilk fried chicken, house made beer cheese, frizzled onions, jalapenos, topped with arugula, and served in a warm toasted hoagie
Turkey & Bacon Sammie US$14.40
Grilled sourdough bread, smoked turkey breast, applewood smoked bacon, gouda cheese, smoked maple bacon jam, smashed avocado, shredded lettuce

Salads
Big Caesar's Salad US$15.60
Blackened Chicken, romaine lettuce, shaved parm. cheese, garlic toasted croutons, grated parm. cheese, Caesar dressing Sub grilled or blackened salmon +$4.00 Sub grilled blackened salmon +$4.
Greek Salad US$16.80
Grilled marinated chicken, romaine lettuce, cherry tomatoes, red onion, kalamata olives, feta cheese, pepperoncini, served with a grilled warm pita, side of tzatziki sauce, and creamy feta dressing Sub gyro meat +$1.00 Sub grilled or blackened salmon +$4.00
Steak Salad US$18.00
Grilled seasoned steak, romaine lettuce, shredded cheddar cheese, cherry tomatoes, crispy onions, topped with fries, and served with chipotle ranch
Sweet Glazed Salmon Salad US$18.00
Grilled Miso Glazed Salmon, romaine lettuce, cucumbers, red onion, crumbled bacon, cherry tomatoes, feta cheese, served with ranch dressing

Lunch Sides
French Fries US$4.80
Side Of Beer Cheese US$2.10
Side Of Cheese Sauce US$2.10
Tater Tots US$4.80
Dipping Sauce US$1.80

Bagels
12 Bagels US$26.40
6 Bagels US$13.20
6 GF Bagels US$24.00
Asiago US$2.34
Blueberry US$2.34
Chocolate Chip US$2.34
Churro US$2.70
Cinnamon Sugar Crunch US$2.70
Egg US$2.34
Egg Everything US$2.34
Everything US$2.34
French Toast US$2.70
Fruity Pebble US$2.70
Garlic US$2.34
GF Bagel US$3.60
Jalapeno Cheddar US$2.70
Onion US$2.34
Plain US$2.34
Poppy Seed US$2.34
Pumpernickle Rye US$2.34
Rainbow US$2.70
Raisin US$2.70
Salt US$2.34
Sesame US$2.34
Spinach US$2.70
Sundried Tomato US$2.70
Whole Grain US$2.34
Whole Grain Everything US$2.34

Boutique Bagels
Berry Chic US$8.40
Blueberry bagel, blueberry crumb pie schmear, graham cracker crumble, fresh strawberries
Cookie Monster US$8.40
Chocolate chip bagel, cookie monster schmear, oreo cookies, chocolate chip cookie
Over The Rainbow US$8.40
Rainbow bagel, birthday cake schmear, crumbled cake, sliced banana, rainbow sprinkles
Peanut Butter Heaven US$8.40
Chocolate chip bagel bagel, peanut butter schmear, peanut butter crumble, Reese's Pieces
The Fireside US$8.40
Chocolate chip bagel, s'mores schmear, Hershey's chocolate bar pieces, graham cracker crumble
Yabba Dabba Doo US$8.40
Fruity Pebble bagel, strawberry schmear, fresh strawberries & bananas, Fruity Pebble crumble

Breakfast Bowl
Tater Tot Breakfast Bowl US$13.20

Breakfast Sandwiches
California BLT US$12.00
Everything bagel, chive & onion schmear, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and avocado option: add egg for $1.50
Chicken & Waffle Tower US$15.60
Sugar pearl waffles, buttermilk fried chicken, applewood smoked bacon, cheddar cheese, over easy egg, served with a side of real maple syrup.
Egg & Cheese Sandwich US$8.40
Egg White Delight US$12.00
Toasted wheat bagel, egg whites, turkey sausage, provolone cheese, avocado mayo
French Toast Burger US$13.20
French toast bagel, hamburger patty, cooper american cheese, applewood smoked bacon, over easy egg, & served with a side of real maple syrup
Freshie Veggie US$12.00
Everything wheat bagel, loaded veggie schmear, avocado, cucumber, romaine lettuce, tomato, red onion
Gianna's Classic US$10.80
Choice of bagel, meat, & cheese (folded egg included) Make it "The Jersey Way" by adding salt, pepper, and ketchup
Hollywood US$14.40
Toasted sesame seed hoagie roll, seasoned steak, two sunny side up eggs, gouda cheese, lettuce & tomato
Lox Of Love US$16.80
Everything bagel, atlantic nova lox, plain schmear ,cucumbers, capers, sliced avocado, pickled onions, lemon dill aioli
Meat & Cheese Sandwich US$9.60
Nashville Dill Delight US$13.20
Jalapeno bagel, Nashville hot buffalo chicken, dill pickle schmear, dill pickles, hot honey
Papi Chulo US$13.20
Chorizo sausage, scrambled egg, avocado, shredded cheddar, sauteed onions & peppers, tater tots, chipotle ranch, toasted plain tortilla
Pastrami Mami US$13.20
Toasted everything bagel, smoked pepper bacon jam, egg over easy, pepper jack cheese, pastrami
Philly Burrito US$13.20
Flour tortilla, shaved rib eye, sauteed onions & sweet peppers, scrambled egg, tater tots, cheese sauce
Porky Pig US$12.00
Bagel of your choice, sausage, pork roll, bacon, folded egg, cooper american cheese
The Guido US$13.20
Toasted sesame bagel, folded egg, chicken cutlet, provolone cheese, sundried tomato cream cheese, arugula, roasted red peppers, balsamic drizzle
The Stinger US$12.00
Toasted everything bagel, chive & onions schmear, folded egg, applewood smoked bacon, cheddar cheese, hot honey drizzle
Waffles With Syrup US$8.40

Breakfast Sides
Hashbrowns US$4.80
Tater Tots US$4.80
Side Pastrami Lox US$8.40
Pastrami Lox is crafted from the belly of a salmon. Its unique flavor profile is achieved through a meticulous curing and smoking process that infuses it with an irresistible blend of smokiness and savory spices. The result is a salmon with a firm, yet tender texture and a deep reddish-brown hue.
Side Nova Lox US$8.40
Side Bacon US$4.80
Side Of Turkey Sausage US$4.80
Side Pork Sausage US$4.80
Side Pork Roll US$4.80
Taylor ham boasts a savory, slightly sweet flavor, described as rich and hearty.
Side Of Schmear US$4.20
Side Of Butter US$0.90
Side Of Maple Pepper Bacon US$4.80
Side Of Single Egg US$1.50
Side Of 2 Eggs US$2.95

Gourmet Muffins
Banana Nut Muffin US$4.50
Blueberry Muffin US$4.50
Chocolate Chip Muffin US$4.50
Cranberry Orange Walnut Muffin US$4.50
Lemon Poppy Seed Muffin US$4.50

Schmear/Butter Tubs
Schmear Tub Flavors US$0.00
Butter Tub Flavors

Stuffed Bagels
Garlic Butter Cream Cheese Stuffed Bagel US$7.20
Plain bagel, stuffed with plain cream cheese, topped with a garlic butter sauce, toasted, and finished with shredded asiago cheese

Dipped Croissants
Chocolate & Strawberry Dipped Croissant US$6.00
Dubai Chocolate Croissant US$7.00
Pistachio Dipped Croissant US$6.00
Strawberry Dipped Croissant US$6.00
Vanilla & Chocolate Dipped Croissant US$7.00

Cookie Bars
Chocolate Chip Cookie Bar US$6.00
Oreo Overload Brownie US$6.00

Desserts
Chocolate Spoon Lovin US$7.00
Lemon Burst US$7.00
Mile High Carrot Cake US$7.00
Vanilla Caramel Crunch Cake US$7.00
Hot Honey Peach US$7.00

Gluten Free
Gluten Free Strawberry Shortcake US$7.00

Bagel Boutique Details

From the business
Identifies as women-owned
Small Business

Service options
In-store pick-up
Takeaway
Dine-in
Delivery

Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Wheelchair-accessible toilet

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Breakfast

Amenities
Toilet

Crowd
LGBTQ+ friendly
Transgender safe space

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments

Parking
Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot

Bagel Boutique Photos

Bagel Boutique Location

Bagel Boutique

Pennsylvania Cumberland County Mechanicsburg Carlisle Pike

6581 Carlisle Pike, Mechanicsburg, PA 17050, USA

Bagel Boutique Reviews

An average rating of ★4.5 from 275 user reviews.

atmosphereto choosebagel sandwichthe menuschmearparkingorange juice30 minutessmoothiedecor

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Came here a few weeks ago for a bagel heard about it even though I live on the opposite side of town we decide to go and check it out. This place is so cute. I’m a little more adventurous. She’s a little more traditional. She got the bag and cream cheese I got there very well garlic, and Butter stuffed bagel, which was mine blowing literally one of the best bagels. I think I’ve ever had and this thing is big probably could’ve split it or at least I eat 3/4 and she ate a quarter but the ambience the staff just the whole thing I got going on here is just really cool cute and original. I don’t know if this is a chain, I didn’t look it up. I think it’s a standalone. I definitely would come back here. I don’t have Little’s but if you have little kids, they have a bunch of little sugary flavored type bagels you know with different toppings and stuff that would satisfying even the pickiest of appetite. I just hope this place makes it it did seem like it was doing pretty well while we were there a lot of people coming and going and they do looks like a good bit of pick up to go order. I know over the years has been places in this spot that I’ve come and gone, but I really do hope this place stands the test of time. I will definitely be back.
May 27 · J T
Bagel boutique is the definition of the east coast, you want a taste of jersey philly or new york? They got it. Their bagels are hand made boiled and baked like a true east coast bagel and they are incredibly good, best in central pa by far. They also have pork roll which is super cool to see, highly recommend getting a porkroll egg and cheese on everything bagel with salt pepper and ketchup, you wont be disappointed! Today i got "A Bronx Tale" chicken cutlet on a hoagie roll and my god it blows every Italian place in the area out of the water! The staff are cool as shit too, great people willing to talk about food and the business and how everything started, truly inspiring! If i could rate 6 stars i would because this place makes me feel at home, its comforting, the food is incredible, the staff are great, and the atmosphere is up to date and refreshing. I absolutely love this place and will become a regular at this joint for sure. Thanks for such a great experience ❤️🇺🇸🦅
April 08 · Ethan Adams
First time eating here today and it lived up to the reviews. I got a bacon, egg and cheese on a sesame bagel (and hash brown) which was soft and very fresh. They have a great selection of daily made bagels and freshly brewed coffee. You can order a single, half dozen or dozen bagels of all varieties. I waited roughly 5 minutes after ordering at kiosk so I can skip the lines! Great service and atmosphere. I’ll be back and I encourage everyone to try!
February 14 · Matt
Today was my first time and honestly it won’t be my last, the food is excellent the service was great and the restaurant was exceptionally clean. I have never been more satisfied with a bagel ever. Since it was my first time I wanted to try 2 different bagels and I’m glad I did. I got the pork roll egg and cheese with black pepper and ketchup on a plain bagel, and I also got a onion bagel with chive and onion cream cheese lightly toasted 😋😋😋 and either way you go they don’t miss 😩😩 what’s more satisfying is the fact that the crew was in the middle of doing a large catering order which the staff made me aware of, and was still able to crank out a great breakfast in under 5 min 😳. And I’m not sure who decorated the place, but they paid great attention to detail even down to the cleanliness of the bathroom and as I was coming in, they had a gentleman cleaning the windows window washing. The restaurant was spotless. The service was great. 😊 👍🏾 i’m originally from Brooklyn, New York. I know good bagels. You guys are definitely in my top three
April 17 · Joshua Graham
Tasty bagles. Ordered 2 bacon, egg and cheese sandwiches. Very good portions for the bacon. However, the egg was a light and even ordered a second egg on one of the sandwiches. No option for cheese, so i'm not sure which kind of cheese I got. Had to order off a kiosk which was kind of a pain and took longer than providing an order to a person.
July 19 · Marco2000