Bakehouse 23

Introduction / Overview

For residents of Wisconsin and the greater Milwaukee area, finding a genuine, neighborhood bakery that blends old-school charm with a fresh, contemporary approach can be a true delight. Enter Bakehouse 23, a beloved spot nestled in the heart of South Milwaukee. This establishment is not your average grocery store counter; it stands proudly as a dedicated, from-scratch, small-batch bakery. By committing to using real ingredients and avoiding pre-made mixes or bucket frostings, Bakehouse 23 ensures a quality and flavor that truly elevates the everyday treat and the most special occasion cake.

The philosophy here is simple but powerful: bake in small batches to maintain a high level of freshness, variety, and seasonal creativity. This commitment results in a constantly rotating menu that keeps local patrons excited to stop in and see what new creation has emerged from the oven. The atmosphere at Bakehouse 23 is consistently described as one of an "all around amazing vibe," supported by friendly and helpful staff who treat every customer like a neighbor. Beyond the delicious baked goods, the bakery intentionally fosters an inclusive, welcoming community space. This focus on both product and people has firmly established Bakehouse 23 as a local cornerstone, a place that South Milwaukee residents and visitors from across Wisconsin rely on for their daily coffee, morning pastry, or their next big event dessert.

A unique twist that sets Bakehouse 23 apart is their specialization in nostalgic treats, drawing inspiration from the iconic snack classics of the 1980s and 1990s. Imagine an elevated take on beloved items such as Oatmeal Cream Pies, HoHo Cake, and Kosmic Brownies—these are the sweet memories they are crafting in their modern kitchen. But the menu extends beyond the purely sweet, offering savory options that make it a perfect stop for breakfast or lunch, not just dessert. This includes grab-and-go sandwiches, rotating daily soups, and their signature, much-talked-about Godzilla Chili. Whether you're a long-time resident who grew up on the street or a Wisconsinite seeking a genuine local experience, Bakehouse 23 offers something that feels both familiar and excitingly new.

Location and Accessibility

Bakehouse 23 is conveniently situated to serve the South Milwaukee community and surrounding regions. You can find this charming local business at the following location:

1309 Milwaukee Ave, South Milwaukee, WI 53172, USA

The accessibility of the location is a significant benefit for patrons. For those driving, free street parking is available, making a quick stop for a coffee and pastry easy and stress-free. The bakery focuses on streamlined service options tailored for people who are planning a quick visit. Both in-store shopping and takeout options are available, catering to the busy local user who wants to grab a fresh treat and be on their way. Located on Milwaukee Avenue, it is a straightforward destination for anyone coming from other parts of the city or a short drive from greater Milwaukee County.

Services Offered

Bakehouse 23 provides a comprehensive suite of services that cater to both walk-in customers and those planning special occasions. The focus on customization and quality ensures they can meet a wide variety of local needs.

• In-Store Shopping: Enjoy the full atmosphere and choose from the daily rotating selection of pastries, sweets, and savory items right from the display case.
• Takeout Service: Quick and efficient service for customers who prefer to grab their treats and go, perfect for a busy workday or a morning commute.
• Custom Cakes and Desserts: Specializing in bespoke creations for birthdays, weddings, anniversaries, and other events, including custom cakes, cupcakes, cookies, brownies, pies, and unique requests like a giant 'brookie' (brownie/cookie mashup).
• Catering: Offering dessert tables and unique savory/sweet packages for parties, events, and weddings, with the ability to handle large orders with seven-day advance notice for planning.
• Coffee Service: Serving quality, locally-sourced coffee to pair perfectly with any breakfast item or sweet treat.
• Breakfast Offerings: Providing a great way to start the day with fresh-baked pastries and a rotating menu of breakfast options.

Features / Highlights

Bakehouse 23 distinguishes itself through several key features that resonate strongly with the local Wisconsin community, from its business identity to its product quality.

• Authentic From-Scratch Baking: A foundational commitment to never using pre-made mixes or commercial frostings, ensuring a difference in taste that customers can immediately recognize, as one review noted, 'this isn't a Pic n Save or grocery store cake.'
• Nostalgic Treat Specialization: Offering modern, high-quality interpretations of classic 80s and 90s lunchbox favorites and snack foods, appealing to a sense of regional history and childhood memory.
• Savory and Sweet Variety: Beyond the typical bakery fare, the menu includes hearty options like grab-and-go sandwiches, daily soups, and the locally famous 'Godzilla Chili,' making it a lunch destination as well.
• Community and Inclusivity Focus: Proudly identifies as a women-owned business and actively promotes an LGBTQ+ friendly and Transgender safespace environment, ensuring a welcoming atmosphere for all Milwaukee-area residents.
• Dietary Flexibility: Features a rotation of options, including gluten-free and vegan baked goods, ensuring that customers with various dietary needs can still enjoy a delicious treat.
• Supporting Local Partners: Commitment to the Wisconsin economy by partnering with local artisans and businesses, such as offering fresh-baked breads daily from North Shore Boulangerie / Wildflour and crackers from Empress Baking Company.
• Affordable Options: Offers 'day olds' for more affordable, yummy-looking treats, a thoughtful consideration for budget-conscious customers.
• Convenient Payment Methods: Accepts all major payment types, including Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and modern NFC mobile payments for a quick, hassle-free transaction.

Contact Information

For custom orders, catering consultations, or inquiries about the daily menu, the team at Bakehouse 23 is readily available:

Address: 1309 Milwaukee Ave, South Milwaukee, WI 53172, USA

Phone: (414) 304-5151

What is Worth Choosing

Bakehouse 23 is worth choosing for Wisconsin residents because it masterfully combines superior product quality with a deeply rooted sense of local community. The core value of 'from-scratch, small-batch' baking is a guarantee of freshness and flavor that truly elevates their offerings above mass-produced alternatives. As demonstrated by customer testimonials, their custom cakes are not just visually 'cool' but are universally lauded as 'one of the best cakes' guests have ever had, providing a genuine and memorable highlight for any event.

Furthermore, the bakery offers more than just dessert. It serves as a true community hub and a welcoming space. Being a women-owned establishment and an acknowledged LGBTQ+ friendly, Transgender safespace makes it a comfortable destination for all individuals in the greater Milwaukee area. Whether you are looking for a show-stopping custom cake that goes 'super fast' at a party, a daily dose of high-quality coffee and a fresh croissant, a nostalgic Peanut Butter Cup Brownie, or a hearty bowl of their signature Godzilla Chili for lunch, Bakehouse 23 delivers. It is a place where you can taste the quality ingredients, experience genuinely friendly service, and support a local business that is dedicated to making its community a little sweeter and a lot more inclusive. By choosing Bakehouse 23, you are selecting a neighborhood gem that truly elevates every baked good it creates.

Bakehouse 23

1309 Milwaukee Ave, South Milwaukee, WI 53172, USA