Brown Sugar Bakery: Chicago's Premier Black-Owned Source for Legendary Caramel Cake and Nationwide Shipping

Brown Sugar Bakery Introduce

Introduction / Overview

For sweet-toothed Chicagoans and dessert lovers across the state of Illinois, Brown Sugar Bakery stands as a culinary landmark and a genuine

community treasure

located right on 75th Street. This esteemed

Bakery

has cultivated a loyal following not only through its extensive and inventive menu but also because it is a proud

Black-owned

and

women-owned

establishment, injecting heart and soul into every treat. The passion for baking is evident in the quality of their creations, making it a beloved institution throughout the Chicago area.

The reputation of Brown Sugar Bakery precedes it, particularly when it comes to their star confection. As one devoted customer stated,

When it comes to caramel cake, there’s only one place that comes to mind—Brown Sugar Bakery. I’ve never tasted anything better

. This legendary caramel recipe is a testament to their commitment to

pure perfection

across their entire product line, from the smallest cupcake to the grandest four-layer cake.

The experience of visiting and tasting their creations is consistently praised by local users. Customers describe feeling

super excited to satisfy this sweet tooth

, only to find that their expectations are exceeded. The treats are heralded for their texture and flavor profile, with one reviewer noting that the cake was not only

moist

but it

did a dance on my taste buds. Delicious in every way!

This level of quality ensures that Brown Sugar Bakery is truly

more than a bakery

; it is a purveyor of high-quality, unforgettable dessert experiences in Chicago.

Beyond the famous cakes, the menu offers a diverse exploration of flavors, including rich cheesecakes (like the

Red Velvet Cheesecake

and

Turtle Cheesecake

), innovative cupcakes, and handcrafted chocolates. Furthermore, their accessibility through

Nationwide Shipping

allows former Chicago residents and distant fans across the U.S. to still enjoy a taste of home. They truly are

Family-owned, full of heart, and consistently blessing us with the sweetest treats around

Location and Accessibility

Brown Sugar Bakery is conveniently situated in a central, accessible location in the heart of Chicago’s South Side, making it a key stop for local residents and those traveling to the area.

Address: 328 E 75th St, Chicago, IL 60619, USA

The address on East 75th Street ensures easy navigation for customers throughout the city and surrounding suburbs of Illinois.

Accessibility Features: The bakery demonstrates a commitment to serving all members of the community by providing a
Wheelchair accessible entrance
, ensuring a smooth and inclusive experience for every visitor.
Parking Convenience: Patrons can take advantage of
Free street parking
in the vicinity, which simplifies the process of making a
Quick visit
for a slice of cake or picking up a full order.
Community Presence: The 75th Street location is easily accessible via major city routes and public transportation lines, firmly establishing it as a local hub and a true destination for desserts in the Chicago area.
Easy Access: Whether you are popping in for a slice, picking up
Coffee
, or utilizing
In-store shopping
, the location is optimized for an efficient experience.

Services Offered

Brown Sugar Bakery offers an extensive array of services tailored to meet both daily cravings and grand celebration needs, both locally in Illinois and across the country.

The key services provided are:

Local Purchase Options: Customers can enjoy maximum flexibility with options for
In-store shopping
, speedy
Takeout
, and convenient local
Delivery
to bring their favorite
Caramel Cake Slice
or
Turtle Cupcake
directly to their door.
Full Cake Pre-Ordering: For special occasions, the bakery provides a wide selection of multi-layer cakes, including
4 Layer Cakes
and
2 Layer Cakes
in unique flavors like
Obama
,
Porgy & Bess
, and
Rainbow Sherbet
. Full cakes require
48 hours advanced notice required for pickup
.
Daily Desserts and Specialty Items: Customers can easily find immediate gratification with
Cake Slices
,
Cheesecake Slice - Plain
,
Jumbo Cupcake
varieties,
Parfaits
(like
Banana Pudding Parfait
),
Brownies
, and
Ice Cream Bars
for an anytime indulgence.
Nationwide Reach: For distant fans or special gifts, the bakery offers
Nationwide Shipping
on select items, including the famous
Caramel Cake
and
German Chocolate Cake
, as well as premium handcrafted
Chocolate
(like
Sea Salt Caramels
and
Tortue Assortment
). Shipping occurs weekly on Monday, Tuesday, and Wednesday.
Financial Inclusivity: Demonstrating deep community commitment, Brown Sugar Bakery accepts a wide range of payment methods, including
Credit cards
,
Debit cards
,
NFC mobile payments
, and crucially,
SNAP/EBT
, ensuring that their high-quality products are accessible to all socioeconomic levels in the area.
Onsite and Beverage Offerings: The bakery provides
Onsite services
and offers fresh
Coffee
to perfectly complement their sweet treats, making it a cozy spot for a quick break.

Features / Highlights

The identity and menu depth of Brown Sugar Bakery are its most compelling features, making it a must-visit destination in Illinois.

The Legendary Caramel Cake: The single most acclaimed item is the Caramel Cake, which is considered by many locals to be the best, inspiring testimonials like,
I’ve never tasted anything better
, and is available in multiple formats, including slice, two-layer, four-layer, and for
Nationwide Shipping
.
Black-Owned and Women-Owned Heritage: The bakery's identity as a
Black-owned
and
women-owned
business adds significant community value, reinforcing its status as a
community treasure
with
full of heart
dedication to its Chicago roots.
Vast and Inventive Menu: The sheer variety of unique flavors—including the
Obama
cake,
Porgy & Bess
,
Rainbow Sherbet
cupcakes, and specialty items like
Chocolate Dipped Potato Chips
and various
Parfaits
—ensures there is a delicious option for every palate and occasion.
Commitment to Accessibility and Inclusivity: The acceptance of
SNAP/EBT
for payment, combined with local
Delivery
options and a
Wheelchair accessible entrance
, demonstrates a profound commitment to serving and supporting the entire local Chicago community.
Handcrafted Premium Chocolates: The dedication to quality extends to their
Premium chocolates handcrafted and made fresh daily, never frozen
, using
only the finest ingredients, dairy cream and butter, premium nuts, real chocolate, and all-natural flavors
, which are available in seasonally-themed gift boxes perfect for any occasion.

Contact Information

To satisfy your sweet tooth with a slice of the famous Caramel Cake, place a custom order, or inquire about

Nationwide Shipping

, please use the contact information provided below.

Address: 328 E 75th St, Chicago, IL 60619, USA

Phone: (773) 224-6262

What is worth choosing

Brown Sugar Bakery is unequivocally worth choosing for any Illinois resident seeking the best in quality, flavor, and community value. It is more than a bakery; it is an experience that resonates with the heart of Chicago.

The primary reason to choose Brown Sugar Bakery is the unparalleled quality of their treats, particularly the

Caramel Cake

, which is legendary. The consistently high praise—from the cake being

moist

and doing a

dance on my taste buds

to the acknowledgment that their products are

all pure perfection

—guarantees a satisfying experience that you

You’ll thank me later

for.

Furthermore, choosing Brown Sugar Bakery means supporting a valuable

Black-owned

and

women-owned

community treasure

that actively supports its patrons. The acceptance of

SNAP/EBT

is a powerful statement of local commitment, ensuring that financial access does not prevent the community from enjoying high-quality, delicious baked goods. When you combine this social responsibility with a vast menu of innovative flavors and the convenience of local

Delivery

and

Nationwide Shipping

, Brown Sugar Bakery is clearly the premier destination for all your sweet treat needs in Chicago and across Illinois.

Brown Sugar Bakery Menu

Cheesecake
Carmel Cheesecake Slice $9.80
Cheesecake Slice - Plain $8.64
Strawberry Cheesecake Slice $9.80
Turtle Cheesecake $9.80

Cake Slices
Caramel Cake Slice $6.58
Carrot Cake Slice $7.88
Double Dark Chocolate Cake Slice $7.18
German Dark Chocolate Cake Slice $7.88
Lemon Cake Slice $6.53
Pineapple Coconut Cake Slice $7.88
Turtle Cake Slice $7.18
Vanilla Cream & Caramel Cake Slice $6.58
Yellow Chocolate Cake Slice $6.58

Cupcakes
Caramel Jumbo Cupcake $3.88
Dark Chocolate Jumbo Cupcake $4.15
German Chocolate Jumbo Cupcake $4.58
Lemon Jumbo Cupcake $3.88
Rainbow Sherbet Jumbo Cupcake $3.88
Red Velvet Jumbo Cupcake $4.58
Strawberry Jumbo Cupcake $3.88
Turtle Cupcake $4.58
Yellow Chocolate Jumbo Cupcake $3.88

Cake
By the Slice
Carmel
German Dark Chocolate $3.85
Double Chocolate Dark
Obama
Pineapple Coconut
Rainbow Sherbet $0.00
Red Velvet (With Nuts)
Red Velvet (No Nuts)
Lemon
Porgy & Bess
Strawberry
Vanilla Cream Carmel
Turtle
Yellow Chocolate
Carrot

Cheesecake
By the Slice
Plain Cheesecake
Carrot Cheesecake
Strawberry Cheesecake $0.00
Carmel Cheesecake
Turtle Cheesecake $8.25
Oreo Cheesecake
Red Velvet Cheesecake

Cupcakes
Chocolate Turtle
Cookie Monster
Elmo
German Chocolate (Dark)
German Chocolate (Blond)
Hostess
Lemon w/Candied Lemon Rind
Oreo
PB&J
Potato Chip
Reese's Peanut Butter
Strawberry Shortcake
Sundae (Chocolate)
Sundae (Yellow Cake)
Twinkie
Vanilla Cream Carmel (VCC)

Candies
Tortue Assortment
Mint Meltaways
Raspberry Meltaways
Chocolate Dipped Potato Chips

Parfaits
Carmel Parfait
Strawberry Parfait
Chocolate Parfait
Banana Pudding Parfait

Ice Cream Bars
Milk Chocolate Vanilla
Dark Chocolate Strawberry $3.85
Mint Chocolate

Brownies
Turtle Brownie
Carmel Cream Cheese Brownie $6.50
Plain Brownie

Nationwide Shipping - Cakes
Ships NationwideNo deliveries Saturdays or Sundays.Orders cannot be shipped to a P.o.box.Cakes ship weekly on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday.Accepting orders for pickup::Full cakes: 48 hours advanced notice required for pickup.Slices & cupcakes: 24 hours advanced notice for pickup.Pick-up Available at 75th Street Location only:Tuesday - Saturday, 12:00PM to 6:00PM
Caramel Cake $79.99
8. Accepting orders for shipping. Brown Sugar Bakery ships their award-winning Caramel and German Chocolate Cake on Monday, Tuesday, and Wednesday of each week. To ensure freshness and timely delivery be sure to place your order the week prior to your event.
German Chocolate Cake $84.99
8. Accepting orders for shipping. Brown Sugar Bakery ships their award-winning German Chocolate Cake on Monday, Tuesday, and Wednesday of each week. To ensure freshness and timely delivery be sure to place your order the week prior to your event.

Nationwide Shipping - Chocolate
Premium chocolates handcrafted and made fresh daily, never frozenOur secret family recipes are made with only the finest ingredients, dairy cream and butter, premium nuts, real chocolate, and all-natural flavors - a practice we still use today.All orders include seasonally-themed wrapped gift boxes at no extra charge. Just right for any occasion!Wholesale and custom-created boxes are available with all your favorites.For details contact us.
Tortue Assortment
Our famous Tortue Assortment is filled with jumbo fancy pecans, creamy caramel, and smothered in pure white, dark & milk chocolate. Tortues the perfect gift for any occasion. Made fresh daily. Never frozen. No preservatives. Available in a 6-piece or 12-piece custom wrapped box
Raspberry Meltaways
Raspberry melt-a-ways. A layer of creamy raspberry sandwiched between rich dark chocolate. Made fresh daily, never frozen. No preservatives.Available in 15-piece or 24-piece custom wrapped boxingredients: dark chocolate, sugar, cocoa butter, chocolate liquor, milk fat, soya lethicin (an emulsifier), vanilla, white chocolate, (sugar, hydrogenated coconut oil, non-fat milk powder, oil of peppermint, and all-natural colors.
Tortues - Milk Chocolate $24.95
Our famous Milke Chocolate Tortues are filled with jumbo fancy pecans, creamy caramel, and smothered in pure milk chocolate.Tortues the perfect gift for any occasion. Made fresh daily. Never frozen. No preservatives. Available in 1/2 # custom wrapped box. Net Weight: 8 oz / 227 grams.Ingredients: sugar, corn syrup, evaporated milk, chocolate (sugar, chocolate liquor, cocoa butter, milk fat, soya lecithin (an emulsifier), vanilla) pecans, dairy cream & butter, salt, and natural flavors.
Mint Meltaways
Mint Melt-a-ways. A layer of smooth creamy pastel-green mint chocolate sandwiched between rich dark chocolate. Made fresh daily, never frozen. No preservatives. Available in 15-piece or 24-piece custom wrapped box.Ingredients: dark chocolate, sugar, cocoa butter, chocolate liquor, milk fat, soya lethicin (an emulsifier), vanilla, white chocolate, (sugar, hydrogenated coconut oil, non-fat milk powder, oil of raspberry, and all-natural colors.
Sea Salt Caramels
Each piece filled with rich caramel dipped in our finest dark chocolate and sprinkled with sea salt. Made fresh daily, no preservatives. Available in a 15-piece and 24-piece custom-wrapped box. Net weight: 8 oz (227 g), 14 oz. (397 g).Ingredients: sugar, corn syrup, evaporated milk, chocolate (sugar, chocolate liquor, cocoa butter, milk fat, soya lecithin (an emulsifier), vanilla) dairy cream & butter, salt, and natural flavors.

4 Layer Cakes
Cakes 4 Layer - Caramel Pecan $79.88
Cakes 4 Layer - Coconut $79.88
Cakes 4 Layer - Dark German Chocolate $65.32
Cakes 4 Layer - Double Dark Chocolate $79.88
Cakes 4 Layer - Neapolitan $79.88
Cakes 4 Layer - Obama $79.88
Cakes 4 Layer - Pineapple Coconut $79.88
Cakes 4 Layer - Rainbow Sherbet $79.88
Cakes 4 Layer - Red Velvet $79.88
Cakes 4 Layers - Caramel $72.88
Cakes 4 layers - Dreamsicle $72.88
Cakes 4 layers - Lemon $72.88
Cakes 4 layers - Porgy & Bess $53.98
Cakes 4 layers - Strawberry $72.88
Cakes 4 Layers - Vanilla Cream & Caramel $72.88
Cakes 4 Layer - Turtle $79.15
Cakes 4 Layer - Yellow Chocolate $72.88

2 Layer Cakes
2 Layer Cake - Caramel $44.58
2 layer Cake - Coconut $53.48
2 layer Cake- Dark German Chocolate $53.48
2 layer Cake- Double Dark Chocolate $53.48
2 Layer Cake - Dreamsicle $53.48
2 layer Cake - Lemon $44.58
2 layer Cake - Pineapple Coconut $53.48
2 layer Cake - Porgy & Bess $53.48
2 Layer Cake - Rainbow Sherbet $44.58
2 layer Cake - Red Velvet $53.48
2 layer Cake - Strawberry $44.58
2 layer Cake - Turtle $53.48
2 Layer Cake - Vanilla Cream & Caramel $44.58
2 Layer Cake - Yellow Chocolate $44.58

Premium Cakes / 2 Layer
2 layer Cake - Red Velvet $35.99
2 layer Cake - Coconut $35.99
2 layer Cake- Rainbow Sherbet $35.99
2 layer Cake- Double Dark Chocolate $35.99
2 layer Cake - Neapolitan $35.99
Premium Flavors: Turtle, Carmel Pecan, Double Dark Chocolate, Red Velvet, Pineapple Coconut, Dark German Chocolate, Coconut, Neapolitan, Rainbow Sherbet, Obama
2 layer Cake- Dark German Chocolate $35.99
2 layer Cake - Pineapple Coconut $35.99
Premium Flavors: Turtle, Carmel Pecan, Double Dark Chocolate, Red Velvet, Pineapple Coconut, Dark German Chocolate, Coconut, Neapolitan, Rainbow Sherbet, Obama
2 layer Cake - Turtle $35.99

Premium Cakes / 4 Layer
Cakes 4 Layer - Rainbow Sherbet $54.99
Cakes 4 Layer - Carmel Pecan $54.99
Cakes 4 Layer - Red Velvet $54.99
Cakes 4 Layer - Dark German Chocolate $54.99
Cakes 4 Layer - Neapolitan $54.99
Cakes 4 Layer - Pineapple Coconut $54.99
Cakes 4 Layer - Turtle $54.99
Cakes 4 Layer - Coconut $54.99
Cakes 4 Layer - Obama $54.99
Cakes 4 Layer - Double Dark Chocolate $54.99

Cake Slices
Cake Slice - Pineapple Coconut $5.50
Cake Slice - Carmel $5.00
Pound Cake Slice - Lemon $5.00
Cake Slice - Turtle $5.50
Cake Slice - Vanilla Cream & Carmel $5.00
Cake Slice - Red Velvet $5.50
Cake Slice - Yellow Chocolate $5.00
Pound Cake Slice - Plain $5.00
Cake Slice - Carrot $6.00
Cake Slice - Taffy Apple $5.50
Cake Slice - Lemon $5.00
Cake Slice - Dark Chocolate $5.50
Cake Slice - German Chocolate $5.50
Pound Cake Slice - Carmel $5.00

Cupcakes
Jumbo Cupcake - Red Velvet $3.50
Jumbo Cupcake - Turtle $3.50
Jumbo Cupcake - Dark Chocolate $3.50
Jumbo Cupcake - Yellow Chocolate $2.99
Jumbo Cupcake - German Chocolate $3.50
Jumbo Cupcake - Strawberry $2.99
Jumbo Cupcake - Carmel $2.99
Jumbo Cupcake - Lemon $2.99
Jumbo Cupcake - Rainbow Sherbert $3.50
Jumbo Cupcake - Vanilla Cream & Carmel $2.99

House Cakes / 4 Layer
Cakes 4 layers - Vanilla Cream & Carmel $49.99
Cakes 4 layers - Strawberry $49.99
Cakes 4 layers - Lemon $49.99
Cakes 4 layers - Carmel $49.99
Cakes 4 layers - Porgy & Bess $49.99
Cakes 4 Layer - Yellow Chocolate $49.99
Cakes 4 layers - Dreamsicle $49.99

Cheese Cake
Cheese Cake Cake Slice $7.00
Cheese Cake Slice - Carmel $7.50
Cheese Cake Slice - Turtle $7.50
Cheese Cake - Chocolate $7.50

House Cakes / 2 Layer
2 layer Cake - Carmel $29.99
2 layers Cake - Vanilla Cream & Carmel $29.99
2 layer Cake - Dreamsicl $29.99
2 layer Cake - Porgy & Bess $29.99
2 layer Cake - Lemon $29.99
2 layers Cake - Yellow Chocolate $29.99
2 layer Cake - Strawberry $29.99

No Category Specified
Holiday Special: 2 layer Carmel Cake and Sweet Potato Pie $40.00
No substitutions, decoration or writing on cakes Pick up Monday Nov 23, Tues Nov 24th or Wednesday Nov 25th only Pick Up form 75th street store only We will run strict to pick up times so please confirm a time that works for you on your order. Please ensure your order has the following information or it will be considered incomplete: First and Last name Telephone Number Email Pick Up Time

Brown Sugar Bakery Details

From the business
Identifies as Black-owned
Identifies as women-owned

Service options
Delivery
In-store pickup
In-store shopping
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance

Offerings
Coffee

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
SNAP/EBT
Credit cards

Parking
Free street parking

Brown Sugar Bakery Photos

Brown Sugar Bakery Location

Brown Sugar Bakery

Illinois Cook County Chicago Greater Grand Crossing East 75th Street

328 E 75th St, Chicago, IL 60619, USA

Brown Sugar Bakery Reviews

An average rating of ★4.4 from 2009 user reviews.

caramel cakegerman chocolate cakepound caketurtlesweet potato pieobamabread puddingbanana puddinglemon cakegoldbelly

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

I finally made it here!! I was super excited to satisfy this sweet tooth! Presentation was simple but the treats spoke for themselves. Everything was perfect! Not only was the cake moist but it did a dance on my taste buds. Delicious in every way!
June 01 · Mary Lavetta
When it comes to caramel cake, there’s only one place that comes to mind—Brown Sugar Bakery. I’ve never tasted anything better. From their cupcakes to their four-layer cakes, even their sheet cakes—it’s all pure perfection. This place is more than a bakery; it’s a community treasure. Family-owned, full of heart, and consistently blessing us with the sweetest treats around. If you haven’t been, do yourself a favor and go. You’ll thank me later
June 19 · JUNITO Harris Jr.
Drove an hour to try their sweets. Found them on social media. The caramel is so good. Pretty dull looking inside. Wish it was more bright and lively for the type of offerings. I’d buy again if out that way. I’d recommend them as well.
April 18 · Venita Nance
I heard and read so much about this bakery that I was anxious to purchase. I travelled forty mikes to get there. I bought two butter cookies that I could not eat as they were so HARD. They were wrapped in plastic wrap and appeared to be the bottom of the barrel. So disappointing. The caramel cheesecake was not at all appealing/appetizing as the presentation was lopsided and the caramel was thick and spilling over, unlike what I am accustomed to. Perhaps I should have checked it out before purchasing and leaving the store. I was afraid, literally to try the double chocolate cupcake after what I experienced with the other two items. I won't be back nor encourage others to go. The shop itself is not appealing: cardboard on the floor met me at the door or was it a tattered carpet, not sure which, one way to enter and exit; dilapidated counter, one employee wearing what appeared to be a bonnet. It was too much for me personally. I do wish them continued success, however. The employees were somewhat pleasant.. The atmosphere very poor. Cleanliness did not appear up to par. Just my opinion, is all...
March 23 · Goldfish Loves
I have seen it on Instagram many times and wanted to visit a local bakery for the longest time. We got 2 cupcakes, and a cheesecake. It was a warm place, busy with a lot of people getting their birthday orders. So we knew it would be a good place, and when we had the cheesecake..it was divine. My sister and I ate it so fast. It was so scrumptious, well worth a trip. The cupcakes were sweet, and had a nice caramel that didn't overpower the cake. The cake itself was quite spongy and tender. Definitely a place I will revisit.
August 15 · Uttara Thanigaivasan