Cookie Jar

For New Yorkers searching for the ultimate sweet treat experience, look no further than The Cookie Jar, a beloved local institution nestled in the heart of Staten Island. More than just a simple bakery, this destination has firmly established itself as a premier cookie shop, dessert haven, and a reliable coffee shop for the neighborhood and visitors alike. It's the kind of establishment that inspires loyalty, with one customer even noting they travel nearly 200 miles one way just to "procure a shipment of exceptional cookies," attributing their unmatched quality to the distinctive New York water and the expertise of their bakers. For those living closer, this level of quality is a daily luxury.

The Cookie Jar, sometimes referred to as Cake Chef's Cookie Jar, is a celebrated bakeshop that offers an astounding array of over 60 kinds of cookies, from cherished traditional recipes to unique and inventive creations. The focus is squarely on crafting delectable, fresh-baked goods—each one a perfect blend of "gooey centers and crispy edges," as one delighted patron described it. But the experience doesn't stop at their world-class cookies. The aroma of freshly brewed coffee, a "delightful" companion to any sweet, signals that this spot is a fully integrated dessert and coffee destination, ideal for a quick visit or a leisurely treat. Whether you're a local resident or just passing through the borough, The Cookie Jar promises a delightful culinary experience that embodies the best of New York’s local baking scene.

The commitment to quality and variety makes The Cookie Jar an essential stop for anyone with a sweet tooth in the New York metropolitan area. It's a place where the community gathers for a taste of pure, handmade indulgence, proving that sometimes, the best flavors require a trip to a local gem.

Location and Accessibility

The Cookie Jar is conveniently located at 1226 Forest Ave, making it an accessible spot for Staten Island locals and those venturing across the Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge. The Forest Avenue location places it in a busy, accessible part of the borough, easily reachable for a quick stop to satisfy a craving or to pick up a treat for a special occasion.

Understanding the need for convenience in a dynamic city like New York, the shop is well-equipped to welcome all patrons. Accessibility is a priority, as the location features a wheelchair accessible entrance. For those traveling by car, parking options are plentiful, a welcome feature in NYC. Customers have the choice of a free parking lot, free street parking, or paid street parking, offering flexibility regardless of how long you plan to stay. This combination of an accessible location and multiple parking choices ensures that getting your hands on their exceptional cookies is a hassle-free experience.

Services Offered

The Cookie Jar provides a comprehensive range of services to accommodate all customer needs, from a quick coffee break to full-service catering for an event. Their versatile service model ensures everyone can enjoy their baked goods and coffee, whether at home or in-store.

• In-store shopping and Dine-in: Customers are welcome to enjoy the full experience inside the brick-walled bakeshop, with the option to sit down and savor their desserts with a fresh cup of coffee.
• Takeout and In-store pickup: For those on a tight schedule, baked goods and beverages can be quickly picked up to enjoy on the go.
• Delivery: The convenience of having their famous cookies and cupcakes brought directly to your home or office is available for the local New York area.
• Special Occasion Gift Containers and Trays: They offer a variety of themed containers and trays for holidays and special events, including Happy Birthday, Sympathy, Just Because, and Welcome Baby. These customizable options are perfect for gifting.
• Payment Options: The shop accepts modern and traditional payment methods for a quick checkout, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.
• Offerings Beyond Cookies: While famous for their cookies, The Cookie Jar also offers a menu of cupcakes, shakes, and various coffees and teas.

Features / Highlights

What truly sets The Cookie Jar apart is its commitment to both exceptional baking and creating a unique, welcoming environment. The shop has garnered a dedicated following for several distinctive qualities.

• Extensive Cookie Selection: Pastry chef James Carrozza's bakeshop is known for featuring more than 60 kinds of handmade cookies, ensuring a flavor for every palate. The selection ranges from classic Italian cookies and chocolate chip to unique inventions.
• Famous Signature Cookies: Among the massive selection, a few items stand out as local favorites. The Rainbow Petit Fours (AKA 7 Layer Cookies) are consistently highlighted by customers for their quality. Other highly-praised items include Homemade Oreo, Maria Cookies, melt-a-ways, Italian cookies, and cannoli cookies—a must-try pairing of two Italian dessert favorites. The Nutella Delight, made with hazelnuts, marshmallows, and chocolate with a Nutella spread inside, is another best-seller.
• Unique Milkshake Menu: In addition to traditional shakes, they feature a signature 7 Layer Rainbow Cookie Shake and a Red Velvet Cake Shake, transforming their best-selling desserts into decadent frozen beverages.
• Whimsical Cookie Jar Collection: The brick-walled bakeshop is famous for displaying a wide array of nostalgic and whimsical cookie jars, which are also available for purchase. These jars often come with a free pound of cookies, making them a unique and memorable gift.
• Coffee and Espresso Excellence: Customers frequently praise the quality of their espresso and coffee, calling it the "ideal companion" to their delectable treats. They also offer a Frozen Cappuccino, made with vanilla ice cream, espresso, and cinnamon.
• Community and Inclusivity: The Cookie Jar fosters a welcoming environment and is listed as LGBTQ+ friendly, ensuring all New Yorkers feel comfortable making a quick visit.

Contact Information

You can find The Cookie Jar at their Staten Island location or reach out to them by phone:

Address: 1226 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10310, USA

Phone: (718) 448-3500

Mobile Phone: +1 718-448-3500

What is Worth Choosing

If you are visiting The Cookie Jar, the choices can be overwhelming given the breadth of the menu, but a few categories and specific items consistently rise to the top as "worth choosing" to experience the very best of this New York gem.

For the Cookie Enthusiast: Your trip is incomplete without trying the Rainbow Petit Fours AKA 7 Layer Cookies. Praised as some of the best in the city, their layers of almond cake and raspberry jam, coated in dark chocolate, are a perfect representation of classic Italian-American baking. For a true Staten Island experience, seek out the Cannoli Cookies, which capture the essence of a classic cannoli filling in a unique cookie form. The Homemade Oreo and melt-a-ways also consistently receive rave reviews, and for those who love nuts, the pre-packed Nuts Gone Crazy selection is a delightful assortment of their best nut-based cookies.

For a Quick Gourmet Dessert: Don't overlook the popular specialty cookie assortments. The Chocolate Explosion selection is perfect for true chocoholics, featuring cookies all covered or dipped in chocolate. For a taste of everything, their Best Selling Mix is a reliable choice, often including a mix of their top-selling cookies and cupcakes (red velvet, vanilla, and chocolate).

For the Perfect Pairing: The experience is truly elevated when you pair a fresh-baked cookie with their espresso or a creamy Frozen Cappuccino. For a decadent twist, indulge in the famous 7 Layer Rainbow Cookie Shake, a sweet fusion that captures two favorite treats in one fun and delicious beverage.

For Gifting and Celebrations: The Cookie Jar is an ideal spot to pick up a gift. Their classic cookie trays, available in sizes like two-pound and four-pound options, are beautifully wrapped and ready for any event, from a birthday to a sympathy occasion. Furthermore, the selection of whimsical Cookie Jars, filled with a free pound of assorted cookies, is a unique and cherished gift that adds a touch of nostalgia and charm to any New York home. Whether you need a quick pick-me-up or a substantial dessert for a gathering, The Cookie Jar delivers an unmatched combination of quality, variety, and local New York flavor.

Cookie Jar

1226 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10310, USA