Cookies by Sarah Introduce
### Introduction / Overview
For those in Tampa and across the Florida region seeking a dessert that truly stands out, Cookies by Sarah offers a unique and highly personalized experience. This woman-owned local bakery is not a typical storefront but a cottage food business specializing exclusively in exquisite, custom-designed sugar cookies for every special occasion. From the vibrant color schemes of a birthday party to the elegant themes of a wedding or the corporate branding of a business event, Sarah is renowned for taking inspiration—be it a color palette, an invitation design, or even a Pinterest board—and transforming it into a delightful set of edible art.
Located centrally in Tampa, Cookies by Sarah has built a stellar reputation not just on the visual appeal of her work, but on the superior quality and taste of the final product. Customers frequently rave about the buttery, mouthwatering flavor of the cookies, noting that they are easily some of the best sugar cookies they have ever had. The process is professional, creative, and centered entirely around the client’s vision, ensuring the treats become a memorable highlight of any event.
Whether you are planning a large celebration and need personalized party favors or a smaller gathering that simply requires that extra 'wow' factor, Cookies by Sarah is the Tampa Bay area's go-to destination for high-end, delicious custom cookie creations. The level of detail and commitment to flavor ensures that every order exceeds expectations, making this local baker a true gem in Florida's dessert landscape.
### Location and Accessibility
Cookies by Sarah operates from its base in the heart of Tampa, strategically located to serve the greater Tampa Bay area. While specializing in custom, pre-ordered creations—necessitating an Appointment required model for planning—the physical location is set up for maximum customer convenience.
Address: 3119 W North St, Tampa, FL 33614, USA
This centralized location in the Tampa area simplifies logistics for both pickup and delivery across the region. Furthermore, the bakery has taken proactive steps to ensure accessibility for all clients during the pickup process, which is especially important when handling large or delicate orders:
- Wheelchair accessible entrance: Provides easy entry for all customers.
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot: Ensures convenient and safe parking for customers with mobility considerations.
The operation model is designed to be as smooth as possible, allowing clients to focus on the excitement of their upcoming event rather than the stress of logistics.
### Services Offered
Cookies by Sarah focuses on a streamlined range of services dedicated to the craft of custom-decorated sugar cookies and associated sweet experiences:
- Custom Hand Decorated Sugar Cookies: Creating personalized cut-out sugar cookies for all occasions (e.g., weddings, birthdays, baby showers, graduations), starting with the client's theme, colors, and design inspiration. This includes intricate 3D details and complex artistic piping.
- Custom Printed Logo Cookies: Offering printed cookies, which are ideal for corporate events, marketing promotions, business gifts, or a more budget-friendly option for high-volume orders, perfect for reproducing logos or photos.
- Wedding and Event Favors: Providing individually wrapped and heat-sealed cookies with ingredient labels, available for use as unique, personal favors or stunning additions to a dessert table.
- Private Cookie Decorating Classes/Parties: Hosting engaging, hands-on decorating sessions for special occasions, team-building, or just a fun activity with friends and family. All supplies and materials are provided.
- Curbside Pickup and In-store Pickup: Offering flexible options for clients to retrieve their orders, including the convenience of Curbside pickup for speed and ease.
- Delivery Services: Coordinating local Delivery options to bring the sweet treats straight to the event venue or home.
- Payment Flexibility: Accepts major Credit cards and Debit cards.
### Features / Highlights
Cookies by Sarah’s reputation as a top Tampa bakery is built on several key features that set it apart from standard bakeries:
- Unmatched Artistic Detail and Creativity: Customers consistently highlight Sarah's "creative genius" in designing cookies that perfectly match a party's color theme and style, often exceeding expectations by "knocking it out of the park" with flawless, beautiful details.
- Gourmet Flavor and Texture: The cookies are not just visually stunning; they are praised as being "some of the best sugar cookies I’ve had," with a distinctly buttery, mouthwatering taste that complements the beautiful royal icing decoration.
- Personalized Client Relationship: The owner, Sarah, strives to build a relationship with each client, ensuring a collaborative and personal service that brings their exact vision—no matter how detailed—to life, from the initial consultation to the final product.
- Ideal for High-End Events: Her work is frequently sought after for significant Florida milestones, including travel-themed baby showers, 50th wedding anniversaries, and high-stakes corporate celebrations where attention to detail is paramount.
- Comprehensive Service Options: Offering multiple service modes, including Curbside pickup and Delivery, alongside a clear, organized ordering process that includes inspiration picture submissions and detailed policies, ensures a seamless customer experience.
- Experience and Passion: The bakery is helmed by an individual who left a teaching career to pursue this passion full-time, infusing a high level of dedication and creative energy into every batch.
### Contact Information
To secure custom cookies for your next Florida event, planning ahead is strongly recommended as slots fill up quickly due to high demand. All custom orders require an appointment for consultation and placement.
Address: 3119 W North St, Tampa, FL 33614, USA
Phone: (813) 530-5135 (or +1 813-530-5135)
### What is Worth Choosing
For Tampa Bay locals, choosing Cookies by Sarah is worth it because it delivers a rare combination: artistry you can eat. This is not the place for a last-minute, generic treat; this is where you go when the dessert must be a showstopper and a delicious indulgence all at once. The consistent, glowing feedback from Floridians emphasizes that these cookies are not just "stinking cute," they taste AMAZING.
What sets this local business apart is the complete faith customers place in Sarah's creative hands. Clients simply provide a theme or color scheme, and the resulting cookies are described as exceeding all expectations, with one reviewer noting that the beautiful cookies were the "talk of the meeting." This high-trust, high-reward approach is invaluable for busy event planners or individuals who want a stress-free experience knowing their dessert will be a flawless, customized masterpiece.
Furthermore, the customer-first operational features—including multiple pickup/delivery options, easy payment via credit or debit cards, and important accessibility provisions like a Wheelchair accessible entrance—demonstrate a commitment to professional service that matches the quality of the product. When you need a dessert that is personal, flavorful, and unforgettable for any celebration in Florida, Cookies by Sarah is the clear choice.
Cookies by Sarah Details
Service options
- Curbside pickup
- Delivery
- In-store pickup
- Dine-in
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Planning
- Appointment required
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
Cookies by Sarah Photos










Cookies by Sarah Location
Cookies by Sarah
3119 W North St, Tampa, FL 33614, USA
Cookies by Sarah Reviews
birthdaycommunicationbaby showercreativedesign
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1These were the best tasting gourmet cookies I’ve ever had! Sarah did an amazing job with decorating the cookies. I just gave her the ribbon color, party color theme and a couple examples of styles I liked. With that she used her own creative genius to create some amazing cookies for my husband birthday party. Thank you!Tanisha Dodson
August 24 · Tanisha & Shon DodsonThese cookies exceeded my expectations! We provided inspiration pics and she absolutely knocked it out of the park. My girlfriends couldn’t stop ooh-ing and ahh-ing over them. On top of the cookies looking SO stinking cute they taste AMAZING!! Some of the best sugar cookies I’ve had. Cannot recommend enough!
February 20 · Megan RisserSarah did an unbelievably amazing job on my cookies! Booking was easy and communication and pick up were smooth. I couldn’t believe how gorgeous my cookies came out for my travel themed baby shower. Totally exceeded my expectations because she nailed every gorgeous detail! Not to mention they were absolutely delicious! So thankful and highly recommend!
August 06 · Amanda StrangeCookies by Sarah are not only absolutely beautiful but also so incredibly delicious! She will take your vision and bring it to life for any special occasion! I have placed an order for a baby shower, several birthdays and now for my parents 50th wedding anniversary and have been over the top impressed every single time! You will LOVE these cookies, guaranteed!!
August 24 · Mimi HenryBeautiful, delicious and glamorous! Sarah did an incredible job with these cookies, they were a gift for my sister and she was absolutely obsessed! Would definitely recommend!
September 23 · hannan danon
More Bakery Near Me
Housewife Bakery & Cafe4.0 (525 reviews)6821 N Armenia Ave Back Lot, Tampa, FL 33604, USA
Mochi Donuts Tampa4.0 (114 reviews)2202 W Waters Ave suite 6, Tampa, FL 33604, USA
El Trigal Bakery & Restaurant4.0 (244 reviews)2159 W Busch Blvd, Tampa, FL 33612, USA
Flowers Baking Co4.0 (115 reviews)901 W Waters Ave, Tampa, FL 33604, USA
The Salty Donut4.0 (93 reviews)5808 N Florida Ave, Tampa, FL 33604, USA
Angel Sweet Bakery4.0 (87 reviews)4042 N Armenia Ave, Tampa, FL 33607, USA
Bamboozle Bakes5.0 (2 reviews)7107 N Florida Ave, Tampa, FL 33604, USA
Nicola's Donuts4.0 (688 reviews)902 W Busch Blvd, Tampa, FL 33612, USA
Krispy Kreme4.0 (2559 reviews)8425 N Florida Ave, Tampa, FL 33604, USA
Matt's Fat Cookies4.0 (10 reviews)1812 E 15th Ave, Tampa, FL 33605, USA
Pia Bakery5.0 (4 reviews)3202 N Armenia Ave, Tampa, FL 33607, USA
Sliceadelic pizza food truck5.0 (33 reviews)6809 N Nebraska Ave, Tampa, FL 33604, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites
BIRD Bakery3.0 (429 reviews)
Chip City - Corporate Offices3.0 (9 reviews)
Kasadiva’s5.0 (4 reviews)
Bamford Bakeshop4.0 (70 reviews)
Gonyek0.0 (0 reviews)
Auntie Anne's4.0 (7 reviews)Top Searches
Trending Bakery Tales Posts
How to Create the Perfect Caramel Apple Pie: Expert Tips and Flavor Secrets
How to Create a Perfect Dessert Buffet with Your Favorite Pastries
How to Make the Best Pumpkin Churros from Scratch at Home
How to Make the Perfect Homemade Cinnamon Roll Cake
How to Bake the Best Homemade Apple Crisp with Real Flavor
How to Make Perfect Chocolate Lava Cakes from Scratch 
