Creighton's Bakery Cafe

Creighton's Bakery Cafe stands as a cherished and unassuming culinary cornerstone within San Francisco's Diamond Heights neighborhood. Far more than just a place for baked goods, this cafe and sandwich shop is a true local haven, combining the warmth of a neighborhood hangout with a diverse and satisfying menu that caters to every time of day, from early morning rushes to leisurely lunchtime breaks. Known for its dedication to fresh, high-quality ingredients and friendly service, Creighton's has earned a loyal following among California residents looking for exceptional value and delicious, made-to-order meals.

The essence of Creighton's lies in its dual identity as a professional bakery and a robust sandwich and bagel shop. This combination provides patrons with the best of both worlds: flakily fresh pastries for a sweet start to the day, and generously portioned, expertly crafted sandwiches for a hearty midday meal. The menu is a testament to comfort food, elevated by the evident quality of the components—from thick slices of fresh meat on their sandwiches to the chewy, homemade texture of their cookies and other baked creations.

One of the cafe’s most celebrated offerings is its extensive range of sandwiches, which are customizable with bread choices like rye, white, sourdough, French roll, or the San Francisco-favorite Dutch Crunch. Customers frequently rave about the richness of the ingredients, such as the Chicken Pesto Sandwich featuring substantial chicken slices and excellent pesto, and the legendary Hot Roast Beef and Cheese Melt—a dish often described in glowing terms by repeat visitors. These are not just simple sandwiches; they are thoughtfully constructed meals designed to fuel a busy California day.

For those starting their day, Creighton's excels in breakfast options. The menu features a strong selection of breakfast burritos, egg and cheese croissants, and a variety of loaded bagels. Favorites like the Bacon, Egg, and Cheese Bagel, or the Lox Bagel with smoked salmon, capers, and cream cheese, provide the perfect grab-and-go solution or a relaxing dine-in experience. They consistently deliver hearty, well-portioned, and fresh-tasting morning fuel, which is a major draw for the local community.

The atmosphere at Creighton's Bakery Cafe is notably welcoming and inclusive. The establishment is recognized as LGBTQ+ friendly, cultivating an environment where everyone feels comfortable enjoying a quick coffee or a full meal. Its design is perfect for a quick visit, but with seating available both inside and in a potential outdoor area, it also offers a pleasant space to pause, people-watch, and enjoy a freshly brewed coffee or specialty drink like Vietnamese Coffee or an Ice Mocha. The clean, well-maintained space and the consistent praise for the kind staff contribute significantly to its high standing as a neighborhood gem in San Francisco.

In addition to its savory staples, Creighton's maintains a compelling selection of baked goods. While operating as a cafe and sandwich shop, the bakery component is strong, with offerings like Almond Croissants, various muffins (Chocolate Chip, Blueberry, Cranberry, Bran), and turnovers (Apple, Blueberry). The homemade cookies, described by customers as "chewy and home made," are a particular delight, making it an excellent stop for an afternoon treat or dessert. The diversity across its full menu—from sandwiches and bagels to Vietnamese-inspired Banh Mi and hearty salads—ensures that Creighton's successfully meets the varied dietary needs and cravings of its eclectic California clientele.

Location and Accessibility

Creighton's Bakery Cafe is perfectly situated to serve the Diamond Heights community in San Francisco. Its location offers crucial convenience, particularly regarding accessibility and parking in a dense urban area.

Address: 5214D Diamond Heights Blvd, San Francisco, CA 94131, USA

The cafe ensures a comfortable visit for all patrons by providing accessibility features. Parking is straightforward with a complimentary free parking lot available nearby, making it an easy destination for both drive-up and walk-in customers.

Services Offered

• Takeout: Quick service for customers who prefer to enjoy their food elsewhere.
• In-Store Pickup: Convenient ordering for a seamless collection experience.
• Breakfast and Lunch/Dinner Dining: Providing freshly prepared meals throughout the operating hours.
• Coffee Service: Serving a variety of coffee, espresso, and specialty drinks.
• NFC Mobile Payments: Accepting modern payment options like Apple Pay and Google Pay for speedy transactions.
• Bagel and Sandwich Customization: Offering various bread types including sourdough, rye, and Dutch Crunch for sandwich orders.

Features / Highlights

• Hearty and Fresh Sandwiches: Celebrated for its generous portions and top-notch ingredients in classic and signature creations like the Chicken Pesto.
• Exceptional Breakfast Menu: Wide range of popular morning options including savory breakfast burritos, egg and cheese croissants, and various meat and veggie bagels.
• Diverse Menu Variety: Offering more than traditional bakery items, including Banh Mi sandwiches, full salads, and Korean-style noodles and rice entrees (at some locations).
• Bakery Excellence: Featuring freshly baked goods such as chewy cookies, flaky croissants, muffins, and savory hand pies.
• Local Neighborhood Vibe: Known as a comfortable, friendly, and LGBTQ+ inclusive space for a quick meal or a short break.
• Accessibility and Parking: Equipped with a wheelchair accessible entrance and a free parking lot for customer convenience.

Contact Information

Address: 5214D Diamond Heights Blvd, San Francisco, CA 94131, USA

Phone: (415) 282-2366

What is Worth Choosing

For any California local visiting Creighton's Bakery Cafe, a visit here is all about selecting a meal that highlights the generous portions and commitment to fresh flavor. It is highly recommended to choose one of their celebrated savory items. The Chicken Pesto Sandwich is a standout choice, praised by customers for its high-quality ingredients, thick chicken slices, and excellent pesto on toasted bread. For those who enjoy a hot, comforting meal, the Hot Roast Beef and Cheese Melt (or a similar grilled melt) is frequently described as "heavenly" and is a perfect indulgence.

For the morning crowd, the Breakfast Burrito is a popular, hearty option, and any of the Breakfast Bagels—especially with sausage and cheese—are excellent choices for a quick, filling start. Crucially, don't overlook the fresh-baked sweets; grabbing a handful of their Homemade, Chewy Cookies or a flaky Almond Croissant to enjoy with their coffee is the perfect way to cap off your visit. Creighton’s is a destination where you can confidently order across the menu, knowing you will receive a fresh, satisfying, and neighborhood-approved meal.

Creighton's Bakery Cafe

5214D Diamond Heights Blvd, San Francisco, CA 94131, USA