Einstein Bros. Bagels Evanston, IL: Your Premier Bagel Shop, Cafe, and Caterer in Chicagoland

Einstein Bros. Bagels Introduce

Einstein Bros. Bagels: Your Daily Destination for Fresh-Baked Bagels and Brunch in Evanston, Illinois

For those in the Illinois region, especially the communities surrounding Evanston, Einstein Bros. Bagels on Sherman Avenue stands as a reliable and convenient destination for authentic bagels, hearty breakfast, and satisfying lunch options. More than just a simple Bagel shop, this location is a full-service Bakery, a robust Breakfast restaurant, a welcoming Cafe, and a professional Caterer, making it an essential part of the local dining landscape. Its expansive menu, centered around fresh, daily-baked bagels, ensures that whether you're starting your day or fueling a midday meeting, you have access to a quality, quick, and customizable meal.

The core offering, the bagels themselves, are a point of pride, available in a wide variety of Classic, Signature, and Gourmet flavors. Customers can select everything from a simple Single Bagel With Shmear to a value-packed Baker’s Dozen, perfect for sharing with family or coworkers. Beyond the basics, the shop excels in creative, fulfilling sandwiches. The menu features an impressive array of Egg Sandwiches, like the savory and complex Texas Brisket Sandwich or the fan-favorite Farmhouse Egg Sandwich. For those seeking something lighter or tailored to dietary preferences, options like the Santa Fe Egg White Sandwich or the Garden Avocado Egg Sandwich are readily available.

It is worth noting that, like many popular, high-volume fast-casual establishments in urban areas like Evanston, the customer experience can sometimes vary. A few local reviews have mentioned instances of slight confusion with orders or an atmosphere that can feel hurried, particularly during peak times, as the staff works to manage the consistent flow of demand. For example, one review highlighted a mix-up with the cream cheese order, even during a quiet moment. However, the consistent praise for the food's quality and the availability of helpful staff to correct any confusion, as another customer experienced, indicates a commitment to customer satisfaction. The key takeaway for locals is to utilize the available services to optimize their visit, especially during busy hours, while enjoying the signature crunch and freshness of a good bagel. The fact that the bagels remain "crunchy at arrival" even after a 15-minute ride home speaks volumes about the quality of the product itself.

Location and Accessibility in Evanston, Illinois

Einstein Bros. Bagels is strategically located at 1745 Sherman Ave, Evanston, IL 60201, USA. This is a prime spot within the downtown Evanston area, ensuring easy access for students, local professionals, and residents across the North Shore of Illinois.

The location on Sherman Avenue is central and caters well to customers seeking a Quick visit. Accessibility is a priority, with a Wheelchair accessible entrance and Wheelchair accessible parking lot to accommodate all patrons. The store also offers amenities like Wi-Fi and a Restroom, making it a convenient spot for a brief stop while working or running errands in the area. Customers can utilize various payment methods, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, ensuring a fast and seamless transaction process—a crucial feature for those grabbing Breakfast on their way to work.

The centralized, easy-to-find location, combined with the comprehensive service options and accessibility features, ensures that this Evanston bagel shop is a dependable choice for a wide demographic of Illinois residents looking for quality food quickly. The ease of access helps mitigate any rush, encouraging customers to use the convenient services for a smooth visit.

Services Offered

This Einstein Bros. Bagels location functions as a multi-faceted food service provider, with a wide array of options to serve individual customers and large groups throughout the Illinois region.

In-store Shopping & Takeout: Customers can order and purchase items for consumption in-store or take them to go, accommodating a Quick visit during breakfast or lunch.
In-store Pickup: Facilitates quick and efficient collection of online or phone orders, minimizing wait times for prepared meals and boxes of bagels.
Delivery: Provides the convenience of having fresh bagels, egg sandwiches, and lunch options delivered directly to homes or offices, ideal for the busy Evanston community.
Full-Service Catering: Serves as a dedicated Caterer specializing in feeding large groups for meetings, events, and family gatherings. Catering options include Brunch Box deals, Signature Egg Sandwich Nosh Boxes, and the Traditional Nova Lox Salmon & Bagels Platter.
Coffee Shop Services: Offers a full menu of beverages, including Hot Coffee, Cold Brew, Latte, Iced Caramel Macchiato, and unique Mocktails & Juice like the Passion Fruit Sunrise.
Onsite Services: Provides dining amenities like Wi-Fi and a comfortable space for customers who choose to stay for their meal.
Everyday Brunch Boxes: Features convenient, pre-selected meal deals like the Brunch Box For Two or the Nova Lox Brunch Special, simplifying group meal planning.

These services collectively underscore the store’s role as more than just a quick-stop bagel spot, but as a comprehensive food solution for the local community's daily and event-based needs.

Features / Highlights

Einstein Bros. Bagels stands out in the Evanston, IL, market thanks to several key features that drive its popularity and customer loyalty among Illinois residents.

Unbeatable Variety of Bagels & Shmear: Offers an expansive range of fresh-baked bagels and double-whipped cream cheese options, from classic flavors to unique seasonal and gourmet choices like the New! Pretzel Bagel Double Dipper and the Maplehouse Egg Sandwich on a Maple French Toast Bagel.
Hearty, Signature Egg Sandwiches: The menu is built on robust, chef-inspired breakfast sandwiches, such as the Texas Brisket Sandwich, the All-Nighter Egg Sandwich, and the Farmhouse Egg Sandwich, providing substantial, protein-rich morning meals.
Flexible Group and Catering Options: Specializes in making group ordering easy with various Everyday Brunch Boxes, Baker’s Dozen deals, and a full-scale catering menu suitable for events ranging from small office meetings to large conferences.
Nova Lox Specialty: Offers the classic Nova Lox sandwich and the Nova Lox Brunch Special, demonstrating a commitment to traditional bagel shop favorites and high-quality ingredients like cold smoked salmon.
All-Day Menu: Provides options for both breakfast and lunch, including classic Deli Lunch sandwiches like the Turkey, Bacon & Avocado Sandwich, the Avocado Veg Out Sandwich, and savory favorites like the Pizza Bagel Cheese.
Twice-Baked Hashbrown: A signature and highly praised side item, the Twice-Baked Hashbrown offers a crunchy, cheesy, and flavorful accompaniment to any sandwich or bagel order.

These features highlight the store's dedication to providing a broad, quality menu that exceeds the simple expectation of a Bagel shop, establishing it as a go-to spot for an all-day dining need in Evanston.

Contact Information

For customers in Evanston and the surrounding Illinois area looking to place an order, inquire about catering, or confirm a pickup time, the following contact information is essential:

Address: 1745 Sherman Ave, Evanston, IL 60201, USA
Phone (Landline): (847) 328-9888
Phone (Mobile/Direct): +1 847-328-9888

Customers are encouraged to use the phone or online ordering system for large group orders, such as the Baker's Dozen or catering boxes, to ensure maximum efficiency and guaranteed availability of their preferred items.

What is Worth Choosing at Einstein Bros. Bagels

When visiting the Einstein Bros. Bagels in Evanston, IL, the best choices reflect the shop’s reputation for both tradition and innovation in the bagel space.

The Signature Breakfast Sandwiches: The heartiest and most recommended item is one of the signature egg sandwiches. For an adventurous and filling start, choose the Texas Brisket Sandwich for its smoky flavor profile. For a classic that’s been enhanced, the Farmhouse Egg Sandwich offers a satisfying combination of meat, egg, cheese, and Country Pepper Shmear. Those who prefer a lighter, veggie-focused option should opt for the highly-rated Garden Avocado Egg Sandwich.

The Fresh-Baked Bagels and Lox: For a true taste of the classic Bagel shop experience, you must try the Nova Lox sandwich. This combination of cold smoked salmon, capers, onions, and cream cheese on a fresh bagel is a quintessential favorite. Alternatively, a simple Single Bagel With Shmear of your choice—perhaps the unique Jalapeno Salsa or Honey Almond—allows you to appreciate the freshness of the bake.

The Perfect Side and Pairing: Always pair your main meal with the acclaimed Twice-Baked Hashbrown; its crisp exterior and cheesy interior make it the ideal savory side. To drink, explore their coffee selection. A large Cold Brew or a sweet Iced Caramel Macchiato offers the necessary fuel to start your day in Evanston. The availability of convenient Brunch Boxes also makes the location the best choice for office meetings or family breakfasts in the Illinois area.

Einstein Bros. Bagels Food & drink

Egg Sandwiches
Chorizo Sunrise Egg Sandwich $11.28
Cage-free eggs with chorizo sausage, cheddar cheese, smashed avocado and Jalapeno Salsa Cream Cheese Shmear on a fresh-baked Green Chile Gourmet Bagel. If selected bagel is not available, sandwich will be made on a Plain Bagel.
Santa Fe Egg White Sandwich $10.29
Cage-free egg whites with turkey-sausage, cheddar cheese, salsa and Jalapeno Salsa Cream Cheese Shmear on a fresh-baked Asiago Bagel Thin. If selected bagel is not available, sandwich will be made on a Plain Bagel Thin.
New! Oktoberfest Egg Sandwich $11.28
Cage-free eggs with ham, bacon, Swiss cheese and Beer Cheese Shmear with a drizzle of mustard on a fresh-baked Pretzel Bagel. If selected bagel is not available, sandwich will be made on a Plain Bagel.
Texas Brisket Sandwich $12.68
Cage-free eggs with smoked beef brisket, cheddar cheese and smoky chipotle aioli on a fresh-baked Cheddar Jalapeno Gourmet Bagel. If selected bagel is not available, sandwich will be made on a Plain Bagel.
Maplehouse Egg Sandwich $11.58
Cage-free eggs with pork sausage, bacon, cheddar, Honey Almond Shmear and sweet syrup on a fresh-baked Maple French Toast Gourmet Bagel. If selected bagel is not available, sandwich will be made on a Plain Bagel.
Bacon & Cheddar Egg Sandwich $9.08
Cage-free eggs with bacon and cheddar cheese on a fresh-baked bagel of your choice. If selected bagel is not available, sandwich will be made on a Plain Bagel.
Ham & Swiss Egg Sandwich $9.08
Cage-free eggs with ham and Swiss cheese on a fresh-baked bagel of your choice. If selected bagel is not available, sandwich will be made on a Plain Bagel.
Bacon, Avocado, & Tomato Egg White Sandwich $9.88
Cage-free egg whites with bacon, smashed avocado, tomatoes and roasted tomato spread on a fresh-baked bagel thin of your choice. If selected bagel is not available, sandwich will be made on a Plain Bagel Thin.
Cheddar Cheese Egg Sandwich $8.48
Cage-free eggs with cheddar cheese on a fresh-baked bagel of your choice. If selected bagel is not available, sandwich will be made on a Plain Bagel.
Turkey-Sausage & Cheddar Sandwich $9.08
Cage-free eggs with turkey-sausage and cheddar cheese on a fresh-baked bagel of your choice. If selected bagel is not available, sandwich will be made on a Plain Bagel.
Garden Avocado Egg Sandwich $9.48
Cage-free eggs with smashed avocado, tomato, spinach and roasted tomato spread on a fresh-baked Everything Bagel. If selected bagel is not available, sandwich will be made on a Plain Bagel.
Farmhouse Egg Sandwich $11.58
Cage-free eggs with bacon, ham, cheddar cheese and Country Pepper Cream Cheese Shmear on a fresh-baked Cheesy Hash Brown Gourmet bagel. If selected bagel is not available, sandwich will be made on a Plain Bagel.
All-Nighter Egg Sandwich $10.59
Cage-free eggs with bacon, American cheese and chipotle mayo on a fresh-baked Cheesy Hash Brown Gourmet bagel. If selected bagel is not available, sandwich will be made on a Plain Bagel.
Pork Sausage & Cheddar Egg Sandwich $9.08
Cage-free eggs with pork sausage and cheddar cheese on a fresh-baked bagel of your choice. If selected bagel is not available, sandwich will be made on a Plain Bagel.

Bottled
Bottled - Dasani Water $3.59
16 oz
Bottled - Smart Water $4.89
33.8 oz
Monster Energy® $4.19
16oz
Bottled - Coke ® $4.49
20 oz
Bottled - Simply Orange $4.79
11.5 oz
Bottled - Chocolate Milk $3.29
7 oz
Bottled - Diet Coke ® $4.49
20 oz
Vitamin Water XXX $4.19
16.9oz

Mocktails & Juice
New! Passion Fruit Sunrise $0.00
Made-to-order orange juice, lemonade and natural passion fruit flavor served over ice.
Lemonade $0.00
Classic Lemonade.
Orange Juice $0.00
Free Pour Orange Juice.
New! Dragon Fruit Lemon Drop $0.00
Made-to-order lemonade with natural dragon fruit flavor served over ice.
New! Bros. Bay Breeze $0.00
Made-to-order cranberry juice, lemonade and natural passion fruit flavor served over ice.
New! Energy Spritz $0.00
Made-to-order Monster Energy® with natural dragon fruit flavor served over ice.

Iced Coffee & Tea
Cold Brew, Large $5.49
Classic cold brew coffee, swirled with vanilla, caramel or chocolate and cream, served over ice.
Iced Chai Tea Latte $0.00
Black tea infused with cinnamon, honey and spices, combined with cold milk and served over ice.
Iced Tea $0.00
Freshly-brewed iced black tea.
Iced Mocha $0.00
Espresso and cold milk, swirled with chocolate sauce, topped with whipped cream and chocolate drizzle. Served over ice.
Cold Brew, Small $4.59
Classic cold brew coffee, swirled with vanilla, caramel or chocolate and cream, served over ice.
Iced Latte $0.00
Espresso and cold milk, served over ice.
Iced Vanilla Latte $0.00
Espresso and cold milk swirled with vanilla, served over ice.
Iced Caramel Macchiato $0.00
Espresso and cold milk, swirled with caramel sauce, topped with whipped cream and caramel drizzle. Served over ice.

Hot Coffee & Tea
Hot Coffee $0.00
Premium coffee made with 100% Arabica beans and brewed fresh every hour. Choose Vanilla Hazelnut, Medium Roast, Dark Roast or Decaf.
Hot Tea $0.00
Hot Tea
Chai Tea Latte $0.00
Black tea infused with cinnamon, honey and spices, combined with steamed frothed milk.
Mocha $0.00
Espresso with steamed milk and chocolate sauce, topped with whipped cream and chocolate drizzle.
Latte $0.00
Espresso with steamed milk, topped with foam.
Hot Chocolate $0.00
Milk chocolate and steamed milk, topped with whipped cream.
Vanilla Latte $0.00
Espresso with steamed milk, swirled with vanilla.
Caramel Macchiato $0.00
Espresso with steamed milk, swirled with caramel sauce, topped with whipped cream and a caramel drizzle.

Deli Lunch
Turkey, Bacon & Avocado Sandwich $12.38
Turkey, bacon, smashed avocado, lettuce, tomatoes and roasted tomato spread on a fresh-baked Plain Bagel. Includes Sea Salt Chips.
Pizza Bagel Cheese $9.28
Fresh-baked Plain Bagel, topped with pizza sauce and a blend of mozzarella, provolone, cheddar, asiago, parmesan, and romano cheeses. Includes Sea Salt Chips.
Ham & Swiss Sandwich $11.59
Ham, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, mayo, and deli mustard on a fresh-baked Plain Bagel. Includes Sea Salt Chips. If selected Bagel is not available, sandwiches will be made on a Plain Bagel.
Pizza Bagel Pepperoni $9.88
Fresh-baked Plain Bagel topped with pizza sauce, pepperoni and a blend of mozzarella, provolone, cheddar, asiago, parmesan and romano cheeses. Includes Sea Salt Chips.
Turkey & Cheddar Sandwich $11.59
Turkey, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, mayo, and deli mustard on a fresh-baked Plain bagel. Includes Sea Salt Chips. If selected Bagel is not available, sandwiches will be made on a Plain bagel.
Tasty Turkey Sandwich $12.39
Turkey, spinach, cucumbers, lettuce, tomatoes Onion & Chive Cream Cheese Shmear on a fresh-baked Asiago Bagel. Includes Sea Salt Chips.
Nova Lox $13.98
Cold smoked salmon, red onions, capers, tomatoes and Plain Cream Cheese Shmear on a fresh-baked Plain Bagel. Includes Sea Salt Chips. If selected Bagel is not available, sandwiches will be made on a Plain Bagel.
Avocado Veg Out Sandwich $11.29
Smashed avocado, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, spinach, lettuce and Garden Veggie Cream Cheese Shmear on a fresh-baked Sesame Seed Bagel. Includes Sea Salt Chips.

Blended
Cold Brew Shake, Small $6.99
Cold brew coffee blended with sweet cream and your choice of vanilla, caramel, or chocolate, topped with whipped cream and a flavor drizzle.
Cold Brew Shake, Large $7.79
Cold brew coffee blended with sweet cream and your choice of vanilla, caramel, or chocolate, topped with whipped cream and a flavor drizzle.
Strawberry Banana Smoothie $0.00
Strawberries and bananas blended together with low-fat yogurt.

Sweets & Sides
Strawberry & Cream Strudel $3.99
Strawberries and sweet cream filling wrapped in a flaky pastry.
Heavenly Chocolate Chip Cookie $3.69
Fresh-baked cookie loaded with semisweet chocolate chunks.
Fruity Cereal Pop $1.29
Fruity cereal rice crisps swirled together with marshmallows and served on a stick for the perfect breakfast dessert.
New! White Chocolate Egg Sugar Cookie $4.09
A classic sugar cookie topped with chocolatey sweet icing.
Blueberry Muffin $3.99
Blueberries baked into a fresh-from-the-oven muffin and topped with cinnamon-streusel crumbles.
Twice-Baked Hashbrown $2.49
Shredded hash brown potatoes, twice-baked with double-whipped cream cheese shmear and grated cheeses.
Sea Salt Chips $2.49
Classic sea salt kettle-cooked potato chips.
Cinnamon Bliss Roll $6.09
Cinnamon roll topped with cream cheese frosting and served warm.
Cinnamon Chip Muffin $3.59
Cinnamon chips baked into a fresh-from-the-oven muffin. Topped with a cinnamon streusel topping.

Fresh Baked Bagels & Shmear
Single Bagel With Shmear $3.78
Choose any of our fresh-baked bagels topped with double-whipped cream cheese.
Nova Lox $13.98
Choice of bagel with shmear, red onion, capers, tomato and cold-smoked Nova Lox salmon. ***Cold Smoked Salmon is not cooked. Consuming raw or undercooked seafood may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.
Half Dozen & Shmear- Build Your Own $16.59
6 fresh-baked bagels and one tub of shmear of your choosing. Please select up to 3 bagel flavors. We bake our bagels fresh daily. If any selected flavors are not available, a team member will assist you on a replacement.
Avocado Toast $6.98
Fresh-baked Plain Bagel topped with smashed avocado and our Everything Bagel Seasoning.
Half Dozen- Build Your Own $13.69
6 fresh-baked bagels of your choosing. Please select up to 3 bagel flavors. We bake our bagels fresh daily. If any selected flavors are not available, a team member will assist you on a replacement.
New! Pretzel Bagel Double Dipper $5.59
Fresh-baked Pretzel Bagel served with Beer Cheese Shmear and mustard sides for dipping.
Shmear Tubs $6.49
Assorted flavors of double-whipped cream cheese.
Single Bagel $3.78
Choose any of our fresh-baked bagels.
Baker’s Dozen- Build Your Own $22.99
13 fresh-baked bagels of your choosing. Please select up to 4 bagel flavors. We bake our bagels fresh daily. If any selected flavors are not available, a team member will assist you on a replacement.
Fresh & Ready Baker’s Dozen & Shmear $24.99
13 of our most popular fresh-baked bagels (3 Plain, 2 Sesame, 2 Chocolate Chip, 2 Cinnamon Raisin, 2 Blueberry, 2 Asiago) with 2 tubs of double-whipped cream cheese shmear. If any of the pre-selected flavors are not available, a team member will assist you on a replacement.
Baker’s Dozen & Shmear- Build Your Own $26.89
13 fresh-baked bagels of your choosing and two tubs of shmear. Please select up to 4 bagel flavors. We bake our bagels fresh daily. If any selected flavors are not available, a team member will assist you on a replacement.
Fresh & Ready Baker’s Dozen $20.39
13 of our most popular fresh-baked bagels (3 Plain, 2 Sesame, 2 Chocolate Chip, 2 Cinnamon Raisin, 2 Blueberry and 2 Asiago). If any of the pre-selected flavors are not available, a team member will assist you on a replacement.

New! Fresh Baked Oktoberfest Favorites
New! Pretzel Bagel Double Dipper $5.59
Fresh-baked Pretzel Bagel served with Beer Cheese Shmear and mustard sides for dipping.
New! Oktoberfest Egg Sandwich $11.28
Cage-free eggs with ham, bacon, Swiss cheese and Beer Cheese Shmear with a drizzle of mustard on a fresh-baked Pretzel Bagel. If selected bagel is not available, sandwich will be made on a Plain Bagel.

Everyday Brunch Boxes
Nova Lox Brunch Special $15.69
Nova Lox Sandwich, Twice-Baked Hash Brown and a Blueberry Muffin.
Bacon & Cheddar Brunch Special $12.19
Bacon & Cheddar Egg Sandwich, Twice-Baked Hash Brown and a Blueberry Muffin.
Brunch Box $53.59
Brunch for the family taken care of. Box includes – 6 bagels (2 Plain, 1 Sesame, 1 Asiago, 1 Chocolate Chip, and 1 Cinnamon Raisin), 1 tub of Plain Shmear, 1 Farmhouse Egg Sandwich, 2 Bacon & Cheddar Egg Sandwiches, 4 Twice-Baked Hash Browns, and 4 Blueberry Muffins.
NEW! Brunch Box For Two $17.59
Includes 1 All-Nighter Egg Sandwich, 1 Bagel & Shmear, 1 Twice-Baked Hash Brown and 1 Blueberry Muffin.

Energy
New! Energy Spritz $0.00
Made-to-order Monster Energy® with natural dragon fruit flavor served over ice.
Monster Energy® $4.19
16oz

Einstein Bros. Bagels Details

Service options
Delivery
In-store pickup
In-store shopping
Onsite services
Takeout

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Breakfast

Amenities
Restroom
Wi-Fi

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Einstein Bros. Bagels Photos

Einstein Bros. Bagels Location

Einstein Bros. Bagels

Illinois Cook County Evanston Sherman Avenue

1745 Sherman Ave, Evanston, IL 60201, USA

Einstein Bros. Bagels Reviews

An average rating of ★3.6 from 247 user reviews.

morningcashierbaconbagel sandwichavocadoloxbrisketcateringefficientapp

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

For lunch I got myself a Santa Fee bagel, for my wife a avocado/egg/tomato bagel. Th ride home was about 15" and there were still crunchy at arrival. The staff was helpfull, I switched the bagel type (and back) and the confusion was corrected in no time and they were helpful. The atmosphere is a bit dated, wish they refreshed the decor a bit.
September 19 · Reto
Working in Evanston, I was excited to finally be near an Einstein’s again. I went once and never went back. I was the only customer in the store. The girl at the register was polite and took my order, but the other employees were just yapping away with each other.I got my food, went to work, and opened it up: correct bagel, but plain smear instead of the strawberry I ordered. I was the only customer there! I emailed with corporate and asked for a refund—which I’m pretty sure I never received. Horrible service.
September 04 · michelle firth
Some of the worst customer service I have ever experienced in my life. Employees have a terrible attitude and would talk about customers to one-another as if we can’t hear them. The food is fine but it is not enough to make me want to come back here. Leadership needs to have a retooling because whoever they are hiring really sucks
July 22 · RenegadeRasengan
Ordered breakfast for a group through the catering menu online. Process was smooth, everything was ready and correct when scheduled. Would consider them again for future group orders.
September 08 · Joshua Martell
This place used to have their act together, but the last two times I’ve been here it’s been an absolute nightmare. I pre-ordered both times and both were, literally, 20-30 minutes later than originally quoted. The employees couldn’t care less and had no urgency to help. Never again - this place needs to get their crap in gear. Maybe having more than two people on at a time may help.
May 31 · Patrick Hunt