Elsie Mae's Sweet Shop

Introduction / Overview

For Wisconsin food lovers, especially those traversing the scenic area around Lake Mills, Elsie Mae's Sweet Shop represents a delightful stop for handmade, quality baked goods. This local bakery has cultivated a reputation for specializing in the classic comfort of pies, ranging from full-size options perfect for holiday gatherings to convenient, single-serving mini pies that encourage patrons to sample a variety of seasonal flavors. Elsie Mae's is rooted in a commitment to scratch-made excellence, with seasonal offerings often featuring locally-sourced ingredients that are handcrafted in small batches. This attention to detail ensures a product that is consistently fresh and full of authentic flavor.

Beyond their famous fruit and dessert pies, the shop has also become a go-to source for artisan breads and savory options, including hearty pot pies. This diverse menu, paired with an atmosphere designed for quick, convenient visits, has made Elsie Mae's Sweet Shop a cherished part of the Lake Mills community. While some local customers have noted its location slightly tucked away in an industrial park, the quality of the products—which include highly sought-after weekend donuts that often sell out quickly—more than justifies the visit for anyone in the region seeking a genuinely delicious, locally-produced treat. The overall tone is one of friendly, professional dedication to high-quality baking, making every item worth the trip.

Location and Accessibility

Elsie Mae's Sweet Shop is strategically located at 360 Enterprise Dr, Lake Mills, WI 53551, USA. For Wisconsin residents planning a quick visit or a scheduled pickup, the address is easily locatable within the local business area of Lake Mills. Though one review suggests the location is 'hidden' within an industrial park, this provides the advantage of easy vehicular access for patrons coming from surrounding areas in Jefferson County and the greater Madison region.

A significant highlight of Elsie Mae's Sweet Shop is its robust commitment to accessibility, ensuring all customers in the Wisconsin community can enjoy their products with ease. The establishment offers a comprehensive suite of accessibility features, including a wheelchair accessible parking lot, a wheelchair accessible restroom, and designated wheelchair accessible seating. Furthermore, the provision of a free parking lot adds another layer of convenience for visitors, making the quick stop for coffee, pies, or bread hassle-free. The shop is also well-equipped to handle modern transactions, accepting credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments for a seamless checkout experience.

Services Offered

• Pies: A specialty offering fresh-baked or frozen pies, including full 9-inch sizes and convenient 5-inch mini pies, often featuring seasonal flavors and locally-sourced ingredients. Options include traditional, gluten-free, and vegan varieties.
• Savory Pot Pies and Quiches: Ready-to-bake frozen pot pies are available for a convenient homemade dinner, alongside vegetarian pot pie and quiche options.
• Artisan Breads: A wide selection of fresh-baked breads prepared daily, featuring varieties like classic sourdough, Asiago cheese, English muffin bread, artisan cheddar, sprouted grain, and cinnamon raisin.
• Specialty Baked Goods: Rotating daily and seasonal delights which can include donuts (often selling out quickly on weekends), pie tacos, pie fries, and crust crackers.
• Coffee Service: Freshly brewed coffee is offered, perfect for pairing with a morning pastry or for a quick pick-me-up during a visit.
• Takeout: All products are available for quick and efficient takeout, catering to customers on the go or those placing large orders.
• Drink Mixes and Concentrates: An expanded product line featuring their award-winning Bloody Mary Mix (in various heats), other cocktail mixes like Margarita and Mai Tai, and lemonade concentrates such as the popular Basil Lemonade.

Features / Highlights

• Commitment to Scratch-Made Quality: All sweets and breads are freshly baked daily, handcrafted in small batches, ensuring exceptional quality and flavor for the local Wisconsin market.
• Specialization in Pies and Mini Pies: Known for offering both large and small pies, which allows customers to easily sample a variety of the bakery’s sweet and seasonal creations.
• Comprehensive Accessibility: Features a full suite of accessibility options, including a wheelchair accessible parking lot, restroom, and seating, making the establishment welcoming to all patrons.
• Savory and Sweet Balance: Offers a unique combination of sweet treats (pies, donuts) and savory options (pot pies, artisan breads), making it a suitable stop for any meal of the day.
• Locally-Sourced Ingredients: Prioritizes the use of seasonal and locally-sourced ingredients, supporting other Wisconsin producers and enhancing the freshness of the final product.
• Positive Customer Feedback on Variety and Taste: Real customer reviews attest to the "amazing" quality of the products, praising the mini pie options for variety and the excellence of the sourdough feta bread and cornbread Italian sausage pie.
• Modern Payment Convenience: Accepts Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC mobile payments, facilitating a speedy and easy checkout process for a quick visit.

Contact Information

Address: 360 Enterprise Dr, Lake Mills, WI 53551, USA

Phone: (262) 914-9198

What is Worth Choosing

For residents across Wisconsin, especially those seeking authentic, high-quality baked goods in the Lake Mills area, Elsie Mae's Sweet Shop offers a compelling value proposition that makes it truly worth choosing. The core strength of this bakery lies in its unwavering dedication to producing fresh, scratch-made goods daily. This is not a place for mass-produced fare; it’s a commitment to the craft of baking, from the use of locally-sourced, seasonal ingredients to the small-batch production that ensures quality control. The result is a taste difference that customers rave about, whether it's the rich filling of a cherry or blueberry pie, or the deep flavor of their sourdough breads.

Furthermore, the shop’s unique dual focus on both sweet and savory items provides excellent versatility. Where else can you pick up an amazing custom dessert alongside a savory, ready-to-bake pot pie for dinner? The availability of specialty artisan breads, like the highly-regarded sourdough and Asiago cheese varieties, appeals directly to Wisconsin diners looking to upgrade their everyday meals. The unique concept of the mini pie is a genius feature, allowing individuals to indulge their curiosity and enjoy a variety of different flavors without committing to a large pie—perfect for a small gathering or a single, satisfying treat.

Finally, the operational excellence of Elsie Mae's, particularly its focus on customer convenience and inclusion, should not be overlooked. The business is built for a 'quick visit,' offering speedy takeout and accepting all major modern payment methods. Crucially, the dedication to full accessibility—with wheelchair accessible parking, seating, and restrooms—demonstrates a commendable commitment to serving all members of the Wisconsin community equally. This blend of scratch-made quality, menu variety, and inclusive customer service makes Elsie Mae's Sweet Shop a must-visit destination in the Lake Mills area.

Elsie Mae's Sweet Shop

360 Enterprise Dr, Lake Mills, WI 53551, USA