Extraordinary Cupcakes

Introduction / Overview

For residents of Williamsburg and visitors exploring the rich historical area, Extraordinary Cupcakes stands out as a destination for high-quality, intensely flavored baked goods. Operating from a location right in the heart of Merchant’s Square, this bakery lives up to its name by elevating the simple cupcake to an art form. Since opening in 2011, their core focus has been achieving the perfect balance of a wonderfully moist cake with just the right amount of delicious, not-too-sweet frosting. They proudly state that they use only extraordinary ingredients, such as King Arthur flour, fine chocolate from France, and pure Madagascar vanilla, resulting in a product where the cake's richness and the depth of flavor are immediately noticeable.

Extraordinary Cupcakes is more than just a purveyor of its namesake treat. The bakery also offers custom cakes for special occasions, from wedding cakes to elaborate birthday creations, alongside a rotating menu of other delectable desserts. The business identifies as women-owned and commits to using no artificial flavorings or colorings (with the notable exception of red velvet), a detail that appeals to health-conscious local consumers. While the physical presence for pickup and in-store shopping is found within the charming setting of Illy Caffe, the spirit of the bakery remains dedicated to "Helping others escape the ordinary, one cupcake at a time." It serves as a convenient and quick stop for a morning treat, a sophisticated dessert, or a meeting spot for those seeking high-quality coffee and a baked-fresh start to their day in historic Williamsburg.

Location and Accessibility

The Extraordinary Cupcakes bakery has a unique and highly central presence in one of Williamsburg's most desirable areas. It is conveniently located inside the Illy Caffe at 435 W Duke of Gloucester St, Williamsburg, VA 23185, USA, which is right in Merchant's Square. This placement makes it highly accessible for students from the College of William & Mary, local residents enjoying downtown, and tourists exploring Colonial Williamsburg.

The location’s accessibility is thoughtfully addressed, making a visit comfortable for all patrons. The facility features a wheelchair-accessible entrance, ensuring ease of entry. While being situated in a busy downtown area, the presence of wheelchair-accessible parking nearby simplifies logistics for patrons with mobility challenges. The setup is perfect for a quick visit, whether you're rushing to grab a pre-ordered cake or stopping for a spontaneous in-store pickup of a few cupcakes. Furthermore, the commitment to modern payment convenience is evident: customers can use credit cards, debit cards, and seamless NFC mobile payments. The bakery also promotes an inclusive environment, proudly identifying as LGBTQ+ friendly.

Services Offered

Extraordinary Cupcakes offers a wide array of gourmet products and flexible services to the Virginia community.

• Gourmet Cupcakes: A daily selection of signature flavors (such as Wicked Chocolate, Remarkable Red Velvet, and Marvelous Madagascar Vanilla) and a rotating menu of monthly and seasonal specials (like Sensational S'mores and Awesome Almond Blackberry).
• Custom and Wedding Cakes: Full-sized custom cakes for special events, including tiered wedding cakes and groom's cakes, with private tasting and consultation services available for design and flavor customization.
• Gluten-Free Options: Dedicated gluten-free cupcakes, available in vanilla and chocolate, made with high-quality gluten-free flour, which can be customized with various icings and fillings. Gluten-free Whoopie Pies are also available with advance ordering.
• Other Extraordinary Desserts: A selection of non-cupcake gourmet treats, including OMG NY Cheesecake (made from a famous New York recipe), Walnut Mousse Bars (a gluten-free option), Whoopie Pies, Mom's Breathtaking Banana Pudding (available on select days), and Tiramisu.
• Coffee and Beverages: Offering high-quality coffee and other beverages through its shared space with Illy Caffe, making it an ideal destination for breakfast or a mid-day pick-me-up.
• Dining and Pickup Options: Services include dine-in space (within Illy Caffe), in-store shopping for immediate purchases, pre-ordered in-store pickup, and takeout for maximum convenience.
• Corporate and Special Event Orders: Providing tailored options for corporate events and large parties, with the ability to provide consultation and delivery services for wedding and large event orders.

Features / Highlights

The Williamsburg location of Extraordinary Cupcakes distinguishes itself through a strong focus on ingredient quality and a specialty product line.

• Ingredient Quality Focus: The bakery prides itself on using "extraordinary ingredients" such as Noel Chocolate from France and pure Madagascar Vanilla, ensuring a rich depth of flavor and a superior, moist texture that prevents the icing from being overly sweet or needing to be scraped off.
• Dedicated Gluten-Free Program: Their commitment to accommodating dietary needs is a significant highlight, offering freshly baked gluten-free cupcakes and other desserts using professional-grade gluten-free flour.
• Signature New York Cheesecake: The inclusion of an authentic, super-rich, extra-tall OMG NY Cheesecake, crafted from a famous New York recipe, is a major draw for dessert connoisseurs in the Virginia area.
• Diverse and Rotating Menu: Beyond the classic flavors, the constantly changing monthly and seasonal specials keep the offerings exciting and fresh for repeat local customers, encouraging frequent visits.
• Central and Convenient Location: Situated inside Illy Caffe in Merchant's Square, the location provides both a quick grab-and-go experience and a pleasant dine-in option, perfectly situated for local shopping and historical excursions.
• Women-Owned and Inclusive: Identifying as a women-owned business that is also LGBTQ+ friendly, the bakery contributes to the culture of diversity and inclusivity in the Williamsburg commercial landscape.

Contact Information

For those in the Virginia area wishing to place a custom cake order, inquire about daily flavors, or set up a wedding tasting, here is the contact information for Extraordinary Cupcakes:

Address: 435 W Duke of Gloucester St, Williamsburg, VA 23185, USA (Inside Illy Caffe in Merchant's Square)

Phone: (757) 208-0006

Mobile Phone: +1 757-208-0006

Customers are encouraged to call ahead for custom cake details and specific flavor availability, as their production process focuses on baking fresh to order.

What is Worth Choosing

Extraordinary Cupcakes is unequivocally worth choosing for Virginia residents who prioritize the quality of ingredients and an exceptional, balanced flavor profile in their baked goods. The dedication to a perfectly moist cake and a rich, not-too-sweet frosting is the primary reason for their loyal customer base and high ratings for wedding services. When local users need a special cake, they often want a product that truly feels gourmet, not mass-produced. The fact that their baker can take a brief theme mention, like "tropical flamingos," and transform it into a "most perfect" and "beautiful" custom cake demonstrates a high level of artistic skill and customer attentiveness, offering a superior service for local celebrations.

Furthermore, the comprehensive offerings—from daily coffee and breakfast options to essential gluten-free choices and signature items like the NY Cheesecake—make it a versatile destination. While some customers have noted challenges with the online ordering for custom items requiring complex coordination, the consensus on the taste and the impressive visual execution for many special orders, coupled with the convenient, central location in Merchant's Square, makes Extraordinary Cupcakes an essential and trusted choice for a genuinely extraordinary dessert experience in the Williamsburg area.

Extraordinary Cupcakes

435 W Duke of Gloucester St, Williamsburg, VA 23185, USA