Four & Twenty Blackbirds

For New Yorkers who believe that pie is a serious art form, Four & Twenty Blackbirds stands as a veritable mecca of pastry perfection. Located at 439 3rd Ave in Brooklyn, straddling the vibrant neighborhoods of Gowanus and Park Slope, this isn't just a coffee shop that happens to sell pie; it's a dedicated haven for truly exceptional, handcrafted pies that often leave customers declaring them "some of the best pie of my life." The meticulous attention to detail, from the "perfect" flakey crust to the "smooth custard fillings," sets this establishment apart. While their reputation for pies is legendary – with specific accolades for their "ABSOLUTELY the best pecan pie" and a "brilliant" use of bittersweet chocolate to achieve perfect sweetness – Four & Twenty Blackbirds also offers an inviting atmosphere for enjoying expertly brewed coffee and other delightful baked goods. It's a place where flavors are "sharp, strong, balanced," and every visit promises a delicious discovery. Whether you're a devoted pie connoisseur or simply seeking a cozy spot for a high-quality coffee and treat, this fine establishment is a celebration destination that consistently delivers on its promise of magical, dream-like deliciousness.

Four & Twenty Blackbirds is ideally situated at 439 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215, placing it in a dynamic and increasingly popular area that borders the creative hub of Gowanus and the residential charm of Park Slope. This location makes it a convenient destination for Brooklynites and Manhattan visitors alike, serving as a delightful pit stop amidst a day of work or exploration. The area itself has a unique industrial-chic aesthetic, blending warehouses with burgeoning local businesses, giving the pie shop a distinct character. Accessibility to Four & Twenty Blackbirds is quite good, thanks to Brooklyn's extensive public transportation network. The R train at Union Street is just a short walk away, providing direct access to and from Manhattan and other key Brooklyn neighborhoods. Additionally, the F and G trains at Carroll Street are also within a reasonable walking distance, offering further transit options. Numerous local bus lines run along 3rd Avenue and surrounding streets, making it simple to reach the shop from various points in Brooklyn. For those who enjoy walking, the surrounding streets offer interesting views of industrial architecture mixed with burgeoning creative spaces. While street parking can sometimes be found, public transportation or ride-sharing services are generally recommended for navigating this busy part of Brooklyn. The inviting and accessible location, combined with its reputation for excellence, makes Four & Twenty Blackbirds a highly desirable destination for anyone seeking an exceptional pie and coffee experience in New York City.

• Artisanal Pies: Four & Twenty Blackbirds specializes in handcrafted, high-quality pies. Their offerings include a wide array of flavors, from classics like "Pecan Pie" (praised as the "best I've ever had") to more unique and seasonal options like "Lemon," "Matcha," "Chocolate Pecan," and "Cranberry Sage." They are known for perfectly balanced flavors and smooth custard fillings.
• Perfect Pie Crusts: A significant highlight is their "perfect" and "flakey gold crust," which is a foundational element of their renowned pies. This dedication to the crust contributes significantly to the overall exceptional quality.
• Individual Slices and Whole Pies: Customers can purchase individual slices for an immediate treat or order whole pies for gatherings, special occasions, or simply to enjoy at home. This flexibility caters to both spontaneous cravings and planned celebrations.
• High-Quality Coffee Program: Beyond pies, Four & Twenty Blackbirds offers a thoughtful coffee program, specifically featuring "cappuccino from Variety Coffee." They are praised for making cappuccinos "right" and at the "perfect temperature," avoiding the common issue of overheating.
• Complementary Baked Goods: In addition to their pies, the shop also offers a selection of other scrumptious baked goods. Reviews mention items like "Blueberry Lemon Muffin" and "Brown Butter Apple Strudel," suggesting a seasonal rotation of delightful pastries that pair well with their coffee.
• Take-Home Whipped Cream: A charming and customer-delighting service, they offer "a to-go cup of whipped cream" with pie purchases, enhancing the at-home dessert experience.
• Rustic and Comfortable Seating: The place is described as "pretty and rustic with plenty of seating," providing a comfortable environment for customers to relax, read, or enjoy their treats on-site.
• Friendly and Welcoming Staff: The staff are consistently praised for being "always friendly," contributing to a positive and inviting atmosphere that encourages repeat visits.

• World-Class Pie Quality: This is the absolute paramount highlight. Customers repeatedly call their pies "some of the best pie of my life" and specifically laud the Pecan Pie as "ABSOLUTELY the best." The combination of "smooth custard fillings," "flakey gold crust," and perfectly "balanced" flavors (e.g., tart without being sour, sweet without being too sweet using bittersweet chocolate) sets them apart.
• Diverse and Inventive Pie Flavors: Beyond traditional options, their menu features unique and expertly executed flavors like Matcha, Cranberry Sage, and Lemon Chess Pie (hailed as "the best!"). This variety encourages exploration and caters to different palates.
• Perfectly Crafted Coffee: Their coffee program, featuring "Variety Coffee," is celebrated for its quality, particularly their cappuccinos, which are noted for being made "right" and at the "perfect temperature." This attention to detail elevates the overall cafe experience.
• Rustic and Inviting Ambiance: The description of the place as "pretty and rustic with plenty of seating" creates a welcoming and comfortable environment. It's a place where you can relax and truly savor your treats, distinguishing it from quick grab-and-go spots.
• Exceptional Customer Service: The staff are consistently praised for being "always friendly" and going the extra mile, such as offering "a to-go cup of whipped cream." This positive interaction significantly enhances the customer experience.
• Beyond Pie Delights: While pie is the star, the presence of other "scrumptious" baked goods like Blueberry Lemon Muffins and Brown Butter Apple Strudel means there are always new seasonal treats to discover and enjoy.
• Ideal for Celebrations and Indulgence: Described as a "celebration destination," it's clearly a go-to spot for treating oneself or marking special occasions, reinforcing its status as a high-quality establishment.
• Commitment to Quality Ingredients: The depth of flavor and balance in their pies suggests a strong commitment to using high-quality ingredients, which is crucial for achieving such rave reviews.

Address: 439 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215, USA

Phone: (718) 499-2917

Mobile Phone: +1 718-499-2917

For New Yorkers with a serious appreciation for culinary excellence, Four & Twenty Blackbirds on 3rd Avenue in Brooklyn stands as an undisputed beacon of exceptional pie and quality coffee. Its location, bridging the creative pulse of Gowanus and the charming residential streets of Park Slope, makes it conveniently accessible via multiple subway lines, ensuring that this delightful destination is within easy reach for locals across the city. What truly cements Four & Twenty Blackbirds as a beloved landmark is its unparalleled commitment to crafting pies that customers universally declare "some of the best pie of my life." From the "perfect" flakey crust to the "smooth custard fillings" and masterfully "balanced" flavors – whether it's the "ABSOLUTELY the best pecan pie" or the intriguing Matcha and Cranberry Sage creations – every slice is a testament to their artisanal mastery. Beyond the pie, their dedication extends to an expertly curated coffee program, exemplified by "Variety Coffee" cappuccinos brewed at the "perfect temperature," and other "scrumptious" seasonal baked goods like the Blueberry Lemon Muffin and Brown Butter Apple Strudel. The atmosphere itself, described as "pretty and rustic with plenty of seating," provides a welcoming and comfortable space for a leisurely indulgence, further enhanced by the "always friendly" staff who even offer thoughtful touches like "a to-go cup of whipped cream." This combination of world-class baked goods, high-quality beverages, a charming ambiance, and exceptional service makes Four & Twenty Blackbirds far more than just a cafe; it’s a "celebration destination" and an indispensable part of Brooklyn's vibrant food scene. For any New Yorker seeking an authentic, unforgettable dessert experience or simply a perfect coffee break, Four & Twenty Blackbirds is unequivocally the place to look.

Four & Twenty Blackbirds

439 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215, USA