A Slice of Heaven: Discovering Gardners Gourmet Baking Co in Harlem

Gardners Gourmet Baking Co LLC Introduce

In a city known for its endless culinary options, finding a bakery that truly lives up to the hype is a rare and wonderful discovery. In the heart of Harlem, New York, Gardners Gourmet Baking Co LLC has not only met but exceeded this expectation, earning a reputation for having some of the most "fantastic" and "amazing" cakes in the city. This is not just another bakery; it is a destination for true cake connoisseurs, a place where every slice is a memorable experience. The passion and artistry of Mr. Gardner shine through in every baked good, creating a loyal following of customers who consider this their absolute favorite spot.

The customer reviews are a testament to the exceptional quality and flavor that Gardners Gourmet Baking Co consistently delivers. From the "ultimate strawberry cake" that is "absolutely to die for" to a chocolate cake that leaves no crumbs behind, the praise is universal and enthusiastic. This article will provide a comprehensive look at what makes Gardners Gourmet a must-visit for any New Yorker with a sweet tooth. We will delve into its convenient Harlem location, the specialized services it offers, and the unique features that have created such a dedicated fan base. It is a business that perfectly embodies the spirit of a successful local enterprise: built on an unwavering commitment to quality and a genuine love for the craft of baking.

Gardners Gourmet Baking Co is strategically located in the vibrant and historic neighborhood of Harlem, making it an accessible and convenient choice for many New York residents. The address, 2289 5th Ave, New York, NY 10037, USA, places it on a well-known avenue that is central to the community's daily life. This prime location in Harlem allows it to serve a diverse customer base, from local families planning birthday parties to individuals simply looking for a sweet treat to get them through a long day of work or grad school, as one review mentions.

Accessibility is a key advantage for this business. For those traveling by public transportation, the bakery is easily reachable via multiple bus routes that run along 5th Avenue and nearby cross streets. It is also a reasonable distance from several subway stations, including those on the 2 and 3 lines at 135th Street and the 4, 5, and 6 lines at 125th Street. This makes it a practical option for customers from various parts of Manhattan and beyond. While street parking can sometimes be a challenge in New York City, the central location on a major thoroughfare makes it a well-known and easy-to-find destination. The convenience of its location solidifies its role as a true neighborhood bakery, integrated into the fabric of daily life in Harlem.

Gardners Gourmet Baking Co offers a range of services centered around its core mission: creating unforgettable cakes. Their services are a reflection of their commitment to quality and customer satisfaction.

Custom Cake Orders: They specialize in creating custom cakes for birthdays, special events, and other celebrations. The ability to produce a "last minute rush order," as highlighted in a review, is a particularly valuable service for busy New Yorkers.
Retail Cake Slices: For customers who don't need a whole cake, the bakery offers individual slices. This is a popular option, as noted by a long-time customer who ordered slices with roommates, making it accessible for a quick indulgence.
Catering and Large Orders: While not a traditional catering service, the bakery's ability to produce whole cakes that are loved by entire families makes them an excellent choice for parties and gatherings of any size.
A Focus on Specific Flavors: The bakery has a strong reputation for specific cake flavors, such as the chocolate cake, the ultimate strawberry cake, and the chocolate bundt cake. This specialization ensures that each product is a perfected masterpiece.
Customer Support: The personal attention from "Mr. Gardener," as suggested by the name and customer interaction, provides a high level of customer service that is a hallmark of a great small business.

These services showcase a business that is not just selling baked goods, but providing a personalized and reliable service for life's most celebratory moments.

Gardners Gourmet Baking Co stands out in the crowded New York food scene for several key highlights that make it a truly special place.

Unmatched Cake Quality: The overwhelming consensus from customers is that the cakes are of the highest quality. One customer's declaration that it was "the best cake I’ve had in my entire life" is a powerful testament to the exceptional taste and texture.
Ability to Handle Last-Minute Orders: In a fast-paced city like New York, the ability to accommodate a "last minute rush order" is a significant advantage. This shows flexibility and a commitment to helping customers in a pinch.
Consistently Fantastic Products: The fact that a long-time customer has consistently found "everything we’ve tried has been so fantastic" speaks volumes about the bakery's consistent quality and reliability.
Beautiful Presentation: The "ultimate strawberry cake" was not only delicious but "absolutely beautiful." This attention to both flavor and aesthetics is crucial for celebration cakes.
Loyal and Enthusiastic Fan Base: The passionate reviews from customers who promise to "continue ordering" and recommend the bakery to others are a powerful highlight, indicating a strong community and a beloved brand.

These features highlight a business that is built on a foundation of exceptional products and a deep appreciation for its customers.

For those looking to visit or get in touch with Gardners Gourmet Baking Co, here is the essential contact information:

Address: 2289 5th Ave, New York, NY 10037, USA

Phone: (347) 683-4619

This information provides a direct way for New Yorkers to reach out and place an order for a single slice or a whole cake for a special occasion.

In conclusion, Gardners Gourmet Baking Co LLC is the perfect fit for New York locals, especially those in and around Harlem. Its reputation for having some of the best cakes in the city is not just marketing; it is a genuine reflection of its commitment to quality. For a New Yorker who needs a celebratory cake for a special event, whether it's a planned birthday or a last-minute request, this bakery provides an exceptional and reliable service. The personal touch from Mr. Gardner and the consistent quality of the products create a sense of trust and loyalty that is invaluable in a large city.

The ease of access and the availability of both whole cakes and individual slices make it a versatile choice for any occasion, from a grand party to a simple, sweet indulgence. Gardners Gourmet Baking Co is more than just a business; it's a neighborhood treasure that brings joy and deliciousness to the community, one perfect slice at a time. For anyone in New York searching for a truly phenomenal cake, the hype is real, and this is the place to be.

Gardners Gourmet Baking Co LLC Food & drink

Hunk of the Ultimate Pound Cake
The Ultimate Lemon Lime Pound Cake US$9.15
Sweet and tart and buttery and delicious. this cake will bring a smile to your face. allow it to come to room temp or microwave for a few seconds and enjoy
The Ultimate Sweet Potato Honey Bun Pound Cake US$12.00
All butter moist pound cake. Loaded with oven roasted sweet potato and swirled with our delicious cinnamon, nutmeg and brown sugar and if that wasn’t enough it’s lavished with our signature Madagascar vanilla glaze. Perfection
The Ultimate Cookies&Cream Butter Pound Cake US$12.79
Rich buttery cake filled with Oreo cookie pieces and chocolate chips and baked until golden brown……then lavished with our signature butter sauce and more Oreos. Then topped with more chocolate chips. Unbelievably delicious. Allow to come to room temperature or microwave for a few seconds and enjoy!
The Ultimate HoneyBun Pound Cake US$11.79
Our rich buttery, moist pound cake with a brown sugar and cinnamon center swirled in combined to make one mouth watering cake…then it’s topped with our vanilla sauce while it’s still warm…. Reminds you of a honey bun!
The Ultimate Butter Pecan Pound Cake US$12.00
Loaded with oven roasted pecans. Swirled in brown sugar, cinnamon and nutmeg and rich buttery cake with pecan amazing pecan flavor. Then it’s lavished with our signature Madagascar vanilla glaze. Epic!
The Ultimate Peach Cobbler Pound Cake US$12.79
Rich buttery pound cake, layered on top of peaches mixed with brown sugar and butter….then topped with a peach homemade syrup…Allow to come to room temperature or microwave for a few seconds and enjoy!
The Ultimate Henny Infused Pineapple Upside Down Cake US$10.50
Henny gives our perfect pineapple cake a depth that you won’t believe… Comes with an extra shot of Henny sauce! This slice is for adults only! Allow to come to room temperature or microwave for 10secs and enjoy!
The Ultimate All Chocolate Bundt Cake US$12.99
Intensely dark, rich and chocolatey. Impossibly moist hunk of delicious chocolate cake drowned in our milk chocolate ganache and topped with chocolate chips and chocolate cookies.Chocolate heaven!
The Ultimate Henny Infused Peach Cobbler Pound Cake US$11.00
Henny gives this peach cobbler pound cake a depth of flavor that is so delicious. Rich buttery pound cake, layered on top of peaches mixed with brown sugar and butter….then topped with a peach homemade syrup…Allow to come to room temperature or microwave for a few seconds and enjoy!
The Ultimate All Butter Lemon Lime Pound Cake US$10.79
Sweet and tart and buttery and delicious. This cake will bring a smile to your face. Allow it to come to room temp or microwave for a few seconds and enjoy!
The Ultimate Creamy Coconut Cake US$12.00
Buttery soft and moist with a hint of coconut and lavished in a delicious buttercream and topped with sweet coconut and drizzled with our signature white chocolate ganache. Allow to come to room temperature or microwave for a few seconds and enjoy!
The Ultimate Lemon Kiss Pound Cake US$12.00
Buttery, sweet and just the hint of tartness mingle together to make the perfect hunk of cake. Allow to come to room temperature or microwave for a 10secs and enjoy!
The Ultimate Butter Crunch Cake US$12.00
A hunk of our delicious, buttery and moist pound cake smothered in a sweet and crunchy glaze. Allow to come to room temperature or microwave for a few secs and enjoy!
The Ultimate All Butter Strawberry Pound Cake US$12.79
All butter pound cake. Fresh strawberries swirled in and then lavished in a delicious vanilla glaze and a shot of fresh strawberry compote in the side. Simple yet delicious!
The Ultimate All Butter Pineapple Pound Cake US$12.79
You won’t believe your mouth! Fresh pineapple in a rich buttery sweet sauced over our insanely delicious pineapple pound cake. Allow to come to room temperature or microwave for a few seconds and enjoy! Please don’t forget to rate and give us 5 stars. When you do you get a chance for a $off discount and it really helps my small business compete with the larger stores. Follow us on instagram or if you ever have any issues, call me first and I will make it right…. Always!

The Ultimate Cake
The Ultimate Sumptuous Strawberry Cake US$12.79
Get More Cake! Fresh strawberry cake layers, creamy white chocolate buttercream, fresh strawberry purée and finally topped with white chocolate ganache….Epic. Please don’t forget to rate and give us 5 stars. When you do you get a chance for a $off discount and it really helps my small business compete with the larger stores. Follow us on instagram or if you ever have any issues, call me first and I will make it right…. Always!
The Ultimate Classic Yellow Cake/Chocolate Frosting US$12.79
Get More Cake! The classic we all grew up loving, done the ultimate way….rich, moist yellow cake drenched in our signature milk chocolate buttercream and then lavished with our signature chocolate ganache! Please don’t forget to rate and give us 5 stars. When you do you get a chance for a $off discount and it really helps my small business compete with the larger stores. Follow us on instagram or if you ever have any issues, call me first and I will make it right…. Always!
The Ultimate White Chocolate Chip Macadamia Nut Raspberry Cake US$12.00
White chocolate chips butter cake swirled with raspberry goodness topped with raspberry purée buttercream frosting and our signature white chocolate ganache and finished with white chocolate chips. Please don’t forget to rate and give us 5 stars. When you do you get a chance for a $off discount and it really helps my small business compete with the larger stores. Follow us on instagram or if you ever have any issues, call me first and I will make it right…. Always!
The Ultimate Coconut Pineapple Cake US$12.79
It’s crazy how insanely good this cake is…. Rich coconut cake layers topped with pineapple compote and smothered in our white chocolate buttercream frosting with a hint of coconut and then dowsed in sweet coconut flakes. Allow to come to room temperature or microwave for a few seconds and enjoy!
The Ultimate Carrot Cake US$12.79
Flavor personified and just a hint of spice makes this moist cake mouthwateringly delicious…Smothered in the most delicious white chocolate cream cheese frosting and topped with our silky signature white chocolate ganache. Wow! Allow to come to room temperature or microwave for 10secs and enjoy. Please don’t forget to rate and give us 5 stars. When you do you get a chance for a $off discount and it really helps my small business compete with the larger stores. Follow us on instagram or if you ever have any issues, call me first and I will make it right…. Always!
The Ultimate Red Velvet Cake US$11.79
If the color red is sinful, this cake is worth that sin! Moist, buttery and oh so rich. Lavished in our signature white chocolate cream cheese frosting and then topped with our signature white chocolate ganache…. May have come in contact with nuts! Please don’t forget to rate and give us 5 stars. When you do you get a chance for a $off discount and it really helps my small business compete with the larger stores. Follow us on instagram or if you ever have any issues, call me first and I will make it right…. Always!
The Ultimate Butter Pecan Cake/Cream Cheese Frosting US$12.00
Delicious, moist cake filled with pecans roasted in butter and made into a paste so that it permeates through the entire cake….Lavished in our white chocolate cream cheese frosting and topped with our signature white chocolate ganache and then the top is covered in pecans….sheesh! Please don’t forget to rate and give us 5 stars. When you do you get a chance for a $off discount and it really helps my small business compete with the larger stores. Follow us on instagram or if you ever have any issues, call me first and I will make it right…. Always!
The Ultimate Triple Chocolate Cake US$12.79
Get More Cake!A hunk of the most sinfully delicious chocolate cake you have ever tasted. Incredibly moist and rich chocolate cake layers, chocolate chips baked in,creamy buttercream and silky chocolate ganache. Please don’t forget to rate and give us 5 stars. When you do you get a chance for a $off discount and it really helps my small business compete with the larger stores. Follow us on instagram or if you ever have any issues, call me first and I will make it right…. Always!
The Ultimate Dulce De Leche Layer Cake US$11.25
Get More Cake! The classic we all grew up loving, done the ultimate way….rich, moist yellow cake drenched in our signature milk chocolate buttercream and then lavished with our signature chocolate ganache! Please don’t forget to rate and give us 5 stars. When you do you get a chance for a $off discount and it really helps my small business compete with the larger stores. Follow us on instagram or if you ever have any issues, call me first and I will make it right…. Always!

Gardners Gourmet Baking Co LLC Details

From the business
Identifies as Black-owned

Service options
Kerbside pickup
Delivery
In-store pick-up
Takeaway
Dine-in

Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
Credit cards

Gardners Gourmet Baking Co LLC Photos

Gardners Gourmet Baking Co LLC Picture 1

Gardners Gourmet Baking Co LLC Picture 2

Gardners Gourmet Baking Co LLC Picture 3

Gardners Gourmet Baking Co LLC Picture 4

Gardners Gourmet Baking Co LLC Picture 5

Gardners Gourmet Baking Co LLC Picture 6

Gardners Gourmet Baking Co LLC Picture 7

Gardners Gourmet Baking Co LLC Picture 8

Gardners Gourmet Baking Co LLC Picture 9

Gardners Gourmet Baking Co LLC Location

Gardners Gourmet Baking Co LLC

New York New York County New York 5th Avenue

2289 5th Ave, New York, NY 10037, USA

Gardners Gourmet Baking Co LLC Reviews

An average rating of ★4.9 from 54 user reviews.

birthdaycarrot cakestrawberry cakepound cakepineapplefrostingpresentationlemon glazeslicesvanilla

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

All I have to say is BABY!!! believe the hype if they said it’s good I’m telling you it’s good the best cake I’ve had in my entire life…. All the cakes I’ve eaten don’t got nothing on Mr Gardener’s cakes ok!!!every slice of cake including the whole chocolate cake was Amazing hands down my entire family loved it no crumbs were left at all you have definitely gained a new customer I also appreciate you completing this last minute rush order for my husband’s birthday ❤️❤️❤️ go ahead and place yall order i promise you will not regret it. Thank you again🙏
March 10 · Makieba Taylor
Absolutely my favorite cake in the city!! I’ve been a long time customer, ordering slices with roommates to get through grad school lol and everything we’ve tried has been so fantastic.I just celebrated a birthday and decided to order my cake from my favorite place! Got the ultimate strawberry cake and not only was it absolutely to die for it was absolutely beautiful. My friends couldn’t stop talking about it and I was sad when the last slice was gone. Can’t wait to continue ordering - the strawberry cake and the chocolate bundt cake are my absolute favorites.
January 17 · Milan Riddick
I'm so happy to have finally found a good dessert shop! Since moving to the US two years ago, I haven't had a single dessert that wasn't absolutely loaded with sugar & low quality ingredients. Everything seems to taste overly processed regardless of the price. This is the first time I've had REAL cake that isn't overloaded with sugar & preservatives. They're moist, fresh, & definitely made with pride & love. I'll be ordering every flavour they have!
June 06 · AN
Omg this cake was soooooooo good! I bought the chocolate slime, lemon iced pound cake and the coconut pound cake. BANGING!! Super moist, homemade taste and it was still warm when I received 🥺…. My fiancé said the lemon pound cake is close to her late grandmother’s recipe and it confirmed we will be returning loyal customers! Thank you so much for these amazing cakes
April 05 · C M
GOOD LORD the flavors in these cakes are euphoric. I originally ordered the carrot cake and my sister ordered the ultimate chocolate. We ended up tasting each others cake choices and had to share, hence the reason I have two different types of cake.We also called the owner to let him know our thoughts IMMEDIATELY!!!
January 11 · Anita W