Holland American Bakery

Hello, New Jersey locals! If your sweet tooth is calling and you're searching for a bakery experience that’s rich in history, flavor, and tradition, then you absolutely must pay a visit to **Holland American Bakery**. Tucked away in Sussex, this beloved family-owned establishment has been a cornerstone of our community since 1954, serving up an irresistible array of baked goods that beautifully blend authentic Dutch recipes with classic American favorites.

Holland American Bakery isn't just a place to grab a quick pastry; it's a destination. Founded by the Valkema family, immigrants from the Netherlands, it has grown from a small garage storefront into a renowned bakery, still run by the third generation. This deep-rooted heritage is evident in every delicious bite, from their famed cronuts and old-fashioned donuts to their rich, traditional Dutch pastries. For those who believe a cheat day is a necessary part of life, or simply want to indulge in something truly special, Holland American Bakery promises a delightful experience that will leave you wanting more. It’s a place where calories count for naught when faced with such an abundance of deliciousness!

Many New Jersey residents will tell you that finding a bakery of this caliber, with such a unique blend of offerings and a long-standing commitment to quality, is a rare treat. Holland American Bakery consistently leaves a lasting impression, solidifying its status as a top-tier bakery in our Garden State.

Holland American Bakery is conveniently located at **246 NJ-23, Sussex, NJ 07461, USA**. This address places it directly on New Jersey Route 23, a main artery through Sussex County, making it easily accessible for customers traveling from various parts of the region. Sussex Borough is a charming area within Sussex County, and the bakery's location on this well-trafficked road ensures high visibility and ease of access.

For those driving, being situated on a state highway means straightforward navigation and usually ample parking for customers, making a stop at the bakery a hassle-free experience. Whether you're a local resident running errands, or passing through Sussex County on a scenic drive, the bakery's prominent location on Route 23 ensures it's a convenient and tempting stop for anyone craving fresh, delicious baked goods. Its enduring presence at this location speaks to its established role within the community.

Holland American Bakery provides a wide variety of baked goods, specializing in both traditional American and authentic Dutch pastries and desserts. Their offerings cater to everyday cravings as well as special occasions.

• Pies: A broad selection of freshly baked pies, perfect for holidays, family gatherings, or just a sweet treat.
• Cakes: They create cakes for every occasion, including birthdays, anniversaries, and other celebrations. Prices typically include buttercream frosting and basic decoration, with options for upgrades like whipped cream, hand-drawn designs, fresh fruit filling, or gluten-free recipes (though their website currently states they do not offer gluten-free options, it's worth inquiring directly for custom orders).
• Cronuts: A highly addictive specialty, these popular pastries are available in various flavors such as glazed, cinnamon sugar, and maple.
• Donuts: Known for their delicious "old-fashioned donuts," a classic American favorite.
• Crumb Cake: A highly sought-after item, praised by customers for its exceptional taste and quality.
• Traditional Dutch Baked Goods: This is a key differentiator, as they offer authentic Dutch treats like Speculaas, Krakelingen, Almond Tarts, Boterkoek (Butter Cake), Honeycake, and Banket/Almond Rings, providing a taste of the Netherlands right here in New Jersey.
• Cookies and Pastries: A diverse selection of other cookies and pastries to satisfy various sweet cravings.
• Bread Counter: For those who prefer savory options, they offer hearty nut-and-seed filled breads, perfect for traditional Dutch sandwiches.
• Special Occasion Orders: Customers can pre-order specific items like pies or cakes, which is especially useful for ensuring availability for events or family gatherings.

Holland American Bakery's long-standing presence and unique offerings contribute to its status as a highly regarded establishment in New Jersey.

• Authentic Dutch Heritage: Since 1954, the bakery has been owned and operated by the Valkema family, who emigrated from the Netherlands. This deep-rooted Dutch heritage is reflected in their authentic traditional Dutch baked goods, offering a unique culinary experience not easily found elsewhere in New Jersey. The windmill outside the bakery is a visual nod to this heritage.
• Addictive Cronuts: Their cronuts are a definite crowd-pleaser and are frequently mentioned in reviews as being "addictive" and impossible to eat just one. Available in various glazes, they are a modern highlight.
• Delicious Old-Fashioned Donuts: For fans of classic American baked goods, their old-fashioned donuts are a beloved staple, consistently praised for their quality.
• Exceptional Crumb Cake: The crumb cake receives high praise, with customers actively seeking it out due to its reputation for being "great."
• Wide Variety of Offerings: From traditional Dutch pastries to classic American pies, cakes, and cookies, the bakery offers a diverse selection that caters to a broad range of tastes, ensuring there's something for everyone.
• "Top Tier Bakery": As one customer succinctly put it, Holland American Bakery leaves "no questions about how they are top tier Bakery in New Jersey," indicating a consistent level of quality and satisfaction.
• Long-Standing Community Staple: Coming up on 70 years in business, the bakery has a long history of serving the Sussex community, building trust and loyalty through generations.
• Seasonal Menu Changes: While consistent in quality, the menu adapts with the seasons, keeping offerings fresh and exciting for returning customers.
• Mail Order Options: For those unable to visit in person, they offer mail-order for some popular items like Speculaas, allowing customers from across the US to enjoy their treats.

To indulge in the delicious offerings of Holland American Bakery or to inquire about custom orders, you can reach them using the following details:

• Phone: (973) 875-5258
• Mobile Phone: +1 973-875-5258
• Address: 246 NJ-23, Sussex, NJ 07461, USA

Their general hours are Tuesday through Saturday from 6 AM to 6 PM, with Sundays and Mondays typically closed. However, it's always advisable to confirm specific hours or holiday schedules, especially if you plan to visit from a distance or for a large order.

For New Jersey residents, Holland American Bakery is far more than just a place to buy sweets; it's an institution. Its multi-generational legacy, dating back to 1954, imbues every pastry with a sense of history and tradition. This bakery perfectly bridges the gap between cherished American classics and unique, authentic Dutch treats, offering a distinct flavor profile that sets it apart from other bakeries in the state. Whether you're craving a light, airy cronut, a rich crumb cake, or a taste of traditional Speculaas, you'll find an item that transports you.

Locals appreciate the quality and the wide variety, knowing that each item is baked with decades of expertise and family recipes. It's a place where "leaving your calorie count at the door" is encouraged, allowing for pure, unadulterated enjoyment. For those seeking something truly special for a family gathering, a delightful treat for themselves, or a unique culinary experience rooted in New Jersey's diverse heritage, Holland American Bakery is a must-visit. It remains a shining example of a local business that not only serves delicious food but also enriches the community with its unique story and commitment to quality.

Holland American Bakery

246 NJ-23, Sussex, NJ 07461, USA