Key Lime To Happiness

For Florida locals and visitors alike, the quest for the quintessential Key Lime Pie experience often leads to a delightful discovery in West Palm Beach: Key Lime To Happiness. This isn't just another dessert stop; it is a dedicated pie shop specializing in South Florida’s most iconic dessert, lovingly prepared by a passionate, woman-owned small business. Founded in the summer of 2017, the bakery’s story began with a loving gesture—a homemade Key Lime Pie for a future husband—which evolved into a secret recipe that customers now "know and love." The mission is simple and clear: to bring everyone the best tasting pies with amazing customer service, creating a genuine sense of community and, quite literally, happiness.

The reputation of Key Lime To Happiness is built on the sheer quality and flavor of its products, consistently earning rave reviews that proclaim it has "the best Key Lime pie I've ever had! EVER!!" They make their pies fresh each week, ensuring every slice delivers that perfect balance of sweet, tart, and creamy texture that defines the state's favorite dessert. While they are renowned for their classic Key Lime Pie, the innovation doesn’t stop there. They expertly weave in tropical Florida flavors, offering unique creations like the famous Triple Key Lime—a three-layered sensation—along with Guava Key Lime and Mango Key Lime. This shop has quickly become known as a "hidden little secret in our area," celebrated not only for its world-class pies but also for its incredibly friendly and welcoming staff, making every visit a professional yet genuinely pleasant experience.

Key Lime To Happiness operates out of a clean, dedicated facility in West Palm Beach, providing a convenient location for in-store shopping and quick pickups for Florida residents in Palm Beach County and beyond.

The physical address is:

1253 Old Okeechobee Rd Suite A9, West Palm Beach, FL 33401, USA

Though the shop is nestled within an industrial complex, local users will appreciate the ease of access and the practical amenities provided. The bakery is committed to ensuring a comfortable visit for all members of the community, which is reflected in their accessibility provisions.

Key Accessibility and Planning Features:

• Wheelchair accessible entrance
• Wheelchair accessible parking lot and Free parking lot available
• Dedicated options for In-store pickup and Takeout
• Setup for a "Quick visit" for fast, easy purchases
• Accepts Credit cards and Debit cards for smooth transactions

The recommendation for local users is to pre-order online, especially for full-size pies or during peak seasons, as their fresh-baked treats often sell out due to high demand.

Key Lime To Happiness excels by focusing on its core specialty—the perfect pie—while also extending its culinary expertise into memorable, hands-on experiences for the community.

• Artisan Pie Production: Baking a diverse and rotating menu of full-sized pies and cheesecakes, including the signature Key Lime and its tropical variations, as well as seasonal favorites like Pecan Pie, Dutch Apple Pie, and a variety of gourmet cheesecakes (e.g., Oreo Cheesecake, Funfetti Cheesecake).
• Signature "Pie Bites": Offering individual, cupcake-sized portions of their full pie recipes, perfect for customizing variety boxes, events, or a personal indulgence. These "pie bites" allow customers to sample multiple flavors easily.
• Specialty Cheesecake Baking Classes: Hosting regular hands-on, adult-only classes where participants learn to bake and customize their own 9-inch cheesecake from start to finish. These classes are perfect for private groups or individual sign-ups and are offered during evening and weekend hours.
• Dedicated Gluten-Free Menu: Providing a strong selection of pies, cheesecakes, and baked goods, including Gluten Free Key Lime Pie and various gluten-free cookies, showing a commitment to catering to guests with dietary needs and allergies (with clear policies on cross-contamination for classes).
• Takeout and Convenient Pickup: Facilitating quick and easy in-store pickup and takeout options, making it simple to grab an order after placing it online.

The factors that cement Key Lime To Happiness as a West Palm Beach standout are its unique flavors, quality commitment, and strong community focus.

• The Triple Key Lime Pie: A highly celebrated, signature creation featuring three distinct layers of key lime filling: traditional, mango key lime, and guava key lime, offering an unforgettable taste of Florida's tropical side.
• Women-Owned and Small Business Identity: The business proudly identifies as women-owned, fostering a welcoming, supportive, and dedicated atmosphere that is deeply appreciated by the local community.
• Freshly Baked Commitment: Pies and baked goods are consistently made fresh each week, a practice that results in a noticeably superior taste and texture, as noted by customer reviews.
• Gourmet Cheesecake Variety: Beyond their famous pies, they offer an extensive, inventive menu of cheesecakes—such as Carrot Cake Cheesecake, Pecan Cheesecake, and Funfetti—which have also earned high praise from customers.
• Hands-On Learning Experience: The opportunity to participate in a "Cheesecake Baking Class," where guests can craft and customize their own dessert, offers a unique and memorable local activity (with a BYOB option for adults over 21).
• Highly-Rated for Quality: Customers rave about the pies' perfect balance, describing the crust as "thick" and the filling as perfectly tangy and creamy, positioning the shop as a contender for the best pie in the region.

For Florida users eager to order a pie, inquire about their gluten-free options, or book a private baking class, the professional and friendly team at Key Lime To Happiness is ready to assist.

Address: 1253 Old Okeechobee Rd Suite A9, West Palm Beach, FL 33401, USA

Phone: (561) 371-4167

Mobile Phone: +1 561-371-4167

The staff, including founder Lauren, is consistently described as "so sweet to help us," making initial contact a pleasant part of the experience. Email inquiries for baking classes can also be directed to Lauren@keylimetohappiness.com.

For anyone in Florida seeking the best version of the state's signature dessert, Key Lime To Happiness is unequivocally worth choosing. This establishment’s core value is simple but profound: to deliver happiness through a perfectly baked pie. You are supporting a small, local, women-owned business that has perfected its craft, creating a secret recipe that many consider to be the best Key Lime Pie they have ever tasted, "EVER!!"

What truly sets them apart is their dedication to both tradition and innovation. You can satisfy a craving for the traditional tart and sweet Key Lime or explore unique, delicious tropical twists like the Mango Key Lime and the layered marvel of the Triple Key Lime. Furthermore, their offerings go beyond pies, with an exciting menu of specialty cheesecakes and convenient "Pie Bites" that are ideal for any Florida gathering or personal treat. For those who want more than just a purchase, the hands-on Cheesecake Baking Classes provide a fun, educational, and delicious date night or group activity. Customers consistently highlight the ease of ordering online and the professional, friendly service received during pickup, which adds to the overall value. In a state that claims the Key Lime Pie as its own, choosing Key Lime To Happiness means opting for superior quality, heartfelt service, and the most delicious piece of Florida sunshine you can find. It is a true local treasure that is now no longer a "hidden secret."

Key Lime To Happiness

1253 Old Okeechobee Rd Suite A9, West Palm Beach, FL 33401, USA