Maddie Rae's Bakery

Introduction / Overview

For residents of Overland Park and the entire Kansas City metro area seeking a truly special sweet treat, Maddie Rae's Bakery stands as a local landmark. Located conveniently on Metcalf Avenue, this bakery has dedicated itself to creating "wonderful sweet surprises" that have delighted generations of local families. The business was originally established in 2006 under the name Connie's Cookies, and while its name has evolved, it proudly maintains the original, beloved recipes that made it a draw for nearly two decades, including the famous cut-out sugar cookies.

Maddie Rae's Bakery is distinguished by its specialty in custom cut-out sugar cookies, boasting an incredible selection of over 180 different shapes. These cookies are known across the Kansas region for their incredibly soft, melt-in-your-mouth texture and unforgettable taste. Beyond their cookie expertise, the bakery offers a comprehensive menu of classic baked goods, custom cakes, and the universally adored cinnamon rolls—a particularly highlighted item by loyal customers. The atmosphere is centered around quick, friendly service, making it an ideal stop for a daily indulgence or for picking up a custom order for a major event.

The bakery is a locally and family-owned business that proudly identifies as women-owned. Led by Maddie Callicott, who has a background in pastry and baking and a passion that started in her youth, the shop blends tradition with personalized, professional service. This commitment to quality and the ability to customize items—from detailed gender reveal cakes to dozens of classic cookies—has made Maddie Rae's a trusted resource for every celebration in Johnson County, from baby showers to major corporate events.

The customer loyalty speaks volumes; reviews frequently celebrate the "BEST baked goods" and specifically praise the quality of Maddie’s frosting and the dream-worthy taste of their red velvet cake and cinnamon rolls. This high level of quality and customization sets Maddie Rae's Bakery apart as a premier destination for sweet celebrations in Kansas.

Location and Accessibility

Maddie Rae's Bakery is centrally located at 9224 Metcalf Ave, Overland Park, KS 66212, USA. Situated on a major artery in Overland Park, the bakery is easily accessible from various parts of Johnson County and the surrounding Kansas City area, making it a convenient stop for locals.

The location is designed to be accessible and accommodate all visitors, offering several convenience features:

• Wheelchair Accessible Entrance: Ensures smooth entry and exit for all patrons.
• Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lot: Provides reserved parking spaces for easy access to the shop.
• In-Store Shopping and Quick Visit Planning: The bakery facilitates a seamless shopping experience for those looking to grab a quick treat, coffee, or pre-packaged items.
• Multiple Service Options: Customers have the flexibility to choose from In-store pickup, In-store shopping, Takeout, and Delivery services, catering to both spontaneous visits and custom order collections.

Services Offered

Maddie Rae's Bakery specializes in custom confections and classic baked goods, offering a comprehensive menu of items and services:

• Custom Cut-Out Sugar Cookies: The signature item, available in over 180 shapes (including angel, cat, KC helmet, butterfly, and rainbow), hand-rolled, hand-cut, and hand-frosted with tinted buttercream for personalized events.
• Classic Cookies: A variety of timeless flavors, sold individually, by the half-dozen, or dozen, including Chocolate Chip, Chocolate Chocolate Chip, M&M Chocolate Chip, Oatmeal Raisin, Peanut Butter, Snickerdoodle, and Sugar Sprinkled Cookies.
• Cakes and Cupcakes: Offering custom cakes (including the popular Red Velvet) and cupcakes for special events like baby showers, gender reveals, and birthdays, praised for being both beautiful and delicious.
• Specialty Baked Goods: Featuring other beloved items like rich, moist brownies (available individually or by the half-dozen), Peanut Butter Frosted Cookies, and the highly demanded Cinnamon Rolls.
• Seasonal/Limited-Time Treats: Regularly featuring a Cookie of the Month and experimenting with new additions like Coffee Cake Crumble Muffins, Lemon Poppyseed, and Chocolate Chip Zucchini Muffins based on customer feedback.
• Beverages: Offering a selection of drinks including Coffee (regular and large), Latte, Hot Tea, Milk, and various bottled drinks.
• Delivery and Takeout: Convenient options for customers to receive their orders, with delivery services available in the Overland Park area.

Features / Highlights

The distinguishing features and highlights that make Maddie Rae's Bakery a favorite among Kansas locals include:

• Melt-In-Your-Mouth Cut-Outs: Specialization in the softest, best-tasting sugar cookies in the area, available in an unparalleled variety of shapes for total event customization.
• The Red Velvet and Cinnamon Roll Crave: Two items that inspire extreme customer loyalty, with reviews stating people "dream about the red velvet cake and cinnamon rolls" due to their exceptional quality and flavor.
• Superior Frosting: Maddie’s frosting is a key component of the bakery's popularity, frequently singled out by customers as "the best" they have ever tasted, perfectly complementing the cakes and cookies.
• Women-Owned Local Business: A locally and family-owned enterprise that contributes to the Overland Park community and is proudly led by women.
• Adaptation and Legacy: The bakery honors its history by using the original, beloved Connie’s Cookies recipes, while simultaneously introducing new, high-quality items and custom confections to meet modern customer demand.
• Convenient Payment Options: Accepting Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments for quick and easy transactions.

Contact Information

For Overland Park residents and Kansas clients ready to place an order or stop by, here is the essential contact information:

Address: 9224 Metcalf Ave, Overland Park, KS 66212, USA

Phone: (913) 649-6700

What is Worth Choosing

For Kansas locals, choosing Maddie Rae's Bakery means selecting a business that seamlessly blends professional customization with deeply loved, high-quality recipes. It is worth choosing Maddie Rae's because they have perfected the iconic cut-out sugar cookie—an essential part of countless celebrations—ensuring every treat is hand-crafted, beautiful, and remarkably soft.

The bakery's commitment to creating truly delicious products is evidenced by the intense, positive customer feedback, particularly regarding their signature items like the cinnamon rolls and red velvet cake. Whether you need an intricate, professional cake for a milestone event like a gender reveal or a large corporate order of custom-shaped cookies, the team at Maddie Rae's is known for being "very professional" and working closely with clients to realize their perfect vision. Furthermore, supporting this establishment means backing a local, women-owned business that has been a reliable source of sweet surprises in the Overland Park community for years. When you visit Maddie Rae's, you are guaranteed a quick, satisfying visit and a treat that you, too, might find yourself dreaming about.

Maddie Rae's Bakery

9224 Metcalf Ave, Overland Park, KS 66212, USA