McCrum's Bakery

Nestled in the heart of Elmwood Park, New Jersey, McCrum's Bakery stands as a true gem for anyone with a sweet tooth or a need for an extraordinary custom cake. This beloved local establishment has garnered a stellar reputation among residents across Bergen County and beyond for its exceptional quality, artistic designs, and incredibly delicious flavors. When you step into McCrum's, you're not just entering a bakery; you're entering a place where culinary passion meets precision, resulting in edible masterpieces that make any occasion truly special. From celebratory events to everyday indulgences, McCrum's Bakery has become the go-to destination for those seeking baked goods that truly stand out.

McCrum's Bakery is particularly celebrated for its custom cake creations, with rave reviews highlighting the flawless designs and delicious taste that consistently exceed expectations. What sets McCrum's apart is not just the delectable outcome but also the personalized and supportive experience customers receive throughout the ordering process. The dedication to perfection, whether it's matching a complex design from a reference photo or ensuring the perfect balance of flavors in a multi-layered cake, is evident in every bite. For locals in Elmwood Park and surrounding communities, McCrum's Bakery represents a trusted source for high-quality desserts that bring joy and unforgettable memories to countless events.

McCrum's Bakery is conveniently located at 378 Market St, Elmwood Park, NJ 07407, USA, making it highly accessible for residents throughout Elmwood Park and neighboring towns in Bergen County. Market Street is a well-known thoroughfare, ensuring that finding the bakery is a straightforward task, whether you're navigating by GPS or local knowledge. Its central location allows for easy access from various parts of Elmwood Park, as well as from nearby communities such as Saddle Brook, Fair Lawn, Garfield, and Paramus.

For those traveling by car, the bakery's spot on Market Street typically offers convenient parking options, making quick pick-ups or more leisurely Browse easy and stress-free. The neighborhood is generally well-connected, making it a viable destination for a short drive, even for those coming from a bit further away, as one customer noted making a "1hr trip" which was "always worth it." Public transportation in Elmwood Park may offer routes that pass near Market Street, providing an alternative for those who prefer not to drive. The clear address ensures that locals can effortlessly locate this trusted bakery for all their dessert needs, solidifying its role as a key community resource.

• Custom Cakes for All Occasions: McCrum's Bakery specializes in creating bespoke cakes for a wide range of events, including birthdays, weddings, anniversaries, and other significant celebrations. Customers consistently praise the bakery's ability to perfectly match reference photos and deliver flawless designs.
• Wedding Cakes: With a track record of creating successful wedding cakes, such as one mentioned from 2020 that was a "huge hit," McCrum's is a reliable choice for couples planning their special day.
• Variety of Delicious Flavors and Fillings: The bakery offers an impressive array of cake flavors and fillings, including highly praised options like super moist cake bases and light, balanced raspberry mousse.
• Specialty Pies: McCrum's offers delicious seasonal or specialty pies, such as the highly acclaimed blueberry crumb pie, which is a popular choice for holiday gatherings like Thanksgiving.
• Cannoli Cake and Individual Cannolis: Customers can order unique creations like a cannoli cake, in addition to traditional individual cannolis, perfect for parties or personal enjoyment.
• Last-Minute Orders (where feasible): As demonstrated by pulling through "last minute" for a 60th birthday cake, McCrum's, specifically Randy, appears to be accommodating for urgent requests when possible.
• Fair Pricing: McCrum's Bakery is noted for its "most fair pricing by far" compared to other bakeries, offering excellent value for the quality and craftsmanship provided.
• Friendly and Helpful Customer Service: The owner, Randy, and other employees are consistently described as kind, helpful, and cheerful, ensuring a positive and supportive experience for customers from inquiry to pick-up.

• Exceptional Custom Cake Design: A standout feature is the bakery's ability to create custom cakes with "flawless design," precisely matching customer-provided reference photos.
• Insanely Delicious Flavor and Moist Texture: Customers consistently rave about the "insanely delicious flavor" and "super moist" quality of the cakes, highlighting the superior taste and texture.
• Perfectly Balanced Fillings: Specific praise is given to fillings like the raspberry mousse, noted for its "perfect balance of sweet and light."
• Randy's Expertise and Kindness: Randy, the individual often cited for making the cakes, is highlighted for his incredible kindness, helpfulness, and talent, making the ordering process a pleasure.
• Consistent High Quality Over Time: The bakery demonstrates "unmatched quality and care" even over several years, indicating a consistent standard of excellence.
• Highly Recommended by Patrons: Customers are enthusiastic about recommending McCrum's to everyone they know, a strong indicator of satisfaction and trust.
• Fair and Transparent Pricing: McCrum's is recognized for having "the most fair pricing by far," offering great value without compromising on quality.
• Versatility for Various Occasions: From significant life events like weddings to holiday gatherings and personal indulgences, McCrum's caters to a wide array of dessert needs.
• Cheerfully Service: Employees are consistently described as "cheerful," adding to the pleasant experience of visiting the bakery.

To experience the exceptional baked goods and custom cake services of McCrum's Bakery, you can reach out to them directly.

Address: 378 Market St, Elmwood Park, NJ 07407, USA

Phone: (201) 797-2470

Mobile Phone: +1 201-797-2470

For residents of Elmwood Park and the broader New Jersey region, McCrum's Bakery is unequivocally an ideal local choice for all dessert needs, particularly when it comes to custom cakes. The consistent outpouring of positive feedback from customers underscores its status as a reliable and high-quality establishment. Locals can trust McCrum's to deliver not just a cake, but a centerpiece that truly elevates any celebration. The bakery's ability to execute complex designs with precision, coupled with the consistently delicious and moist flavors, means that every order is a guaranteed success.

Beyond the products themselves, the customer experience at McCrum's is a significant draw. The warm, helpful, and accommodating nature of Randy and the staff, as frequently praised, makes the entire process, from initial inquiry to final pick-up, a genuinely pleasant one. This personal touch fosters a sense of community and trust that is invaluable in a local business. Furthermore, the fair pricing makes McCrum's an accessible option without compromising on the premium quality they offer. Whether you're planning an elaborate wedding, a landmark birthday, a family holiday gathering, or simply craving a delicious treat, McCrum's Bakery provides an unmatched combination of artistry, flavor, and friendly service right here in Elmwood Park. It's truly a local gem that New Jersey residents will continue to cherish and recommend for years to come.

McCrum's Bakery

378 Market St, Elmwood Park, NJ 07407, USA