Mickey's Pastry Shop

## Introduction / Overview: A Sweet North Carolina Legacy Since 1946

For generations of North Carolinians, particularly those in the Goldsboro area, Mickey's Pastry Shop isn't just a business; it's a foundational part of family memories and local tradition. This storied establishment has been baking scratch-made goods since January 1946, when founder Mickey McClenny returned from WWII and purchased the existing local bakery. His experience as a pastry cook during the war laid the foundation for a legacy that now spans nearly 80 years. This history makes Mickey's one of the longest-running and most cherished bakeries in Eastern North Carolina.

Today, the business is a testament to enduring quality and tradition, proudly carrying on the original recipes and values established by its founder. It continues to be a family-run operation, now led by the third generation. A visit to Mickey's is a step back into a simpler, sweeter time, offering a sense of nostalgia that keeps customers—from childhood patrons to new families—coming back year after year. The shop is widely known for its commitment to making products fresh from scratch daily and has cemented its reputation for offering truly Great Desserts that define local celebratory moments, from birthday cakes to everyday treats.

---

## Location and Accessibility

Mickey's Pastry Shop is conveniently located to serve the Goldsboro community and surrounding counties, making it an easy and accessible stop for anyone in Eastern North Carolina needing a quick sweet fix or picking up a larger order.

• The shop is situated at 2704 Graves Dr, Goldsboro, NC 27534, USA.

Located across town from its original downtown location, the current facility was custom-built in 2002 to handle the high volume of production while maintaining the quality customers have always loved. The property is designed with customer comfort in mind, offering:

• A Wheelchair accessible entrance, ensuring all members of the community can visit.
• Wheelchair accessible parking lot for easy access.
• A Wheelchair accessible restroom, providing complete convenience.

The bakery is perfectly suited for a Quick visit, whether you're rushing to grab a morning coffee and pastry or swinging by after work for a dessert to share with the family.

---

## Services Offered

As a full-service pastry shop and bakery, Mickey's provides a comprehensive range of products and services to meet both everyday cravings and special occasion needs. Their offerings focus primarily on high-quality, scratch-made baked goods, from their renowned cakes to their popular pastries.

• In-Store Pickup: Customers can easily place an order and collect it directly from the shop.
• Takeout: All menu items are available for takeout, perfect for enjoying at home, at the office, or at any North Carolina gathering.
• Specialty Cakes and Custom Orders: The bakery specializes in cakes for all occasions, including birthday cakes, wedding cakes, and other specialty designs. They are known for both classic tiered cakes and custom-themed cakes, though customers should be mindful of the minimum notice required for intricate fondant work.
• Daily Fresh Pastries and Desserts: A vast selection of items like cream puffs, brownies, cookies, and their famous Long Johns are baked fresh every day for immediate purchase.
• Wholesale Distribution: Mickey's popular Long Johns and other baked goods are distributed and sold in convenience stores and grocery outlets across five surrounding counties in Eastern North Carolina, extending their reach far beyond Goldsboro.
• Beverage Service: The shop offers Coffee to pair perfectly with your freshly baked morning pastry or dessert.

---

## Features / Highlights

The enduring success and local renown of Mickey's Pastry Shop can be attributed to several unique and impressive features:

• Three Generations of Certified Master Bakers (CMB): This is a profoundly rare achievement. Mickey's Pastry Shop is one of a handful of bakeries in America that has employed three generations of Certified Master Bakers—Mickey McClenny, his son-in-law Jerry Ray, and his granddaughter Melanie Daniels. Melanie is noted as the first third-generation CMB in the country, showcasing an unparalleled commitment to baking excellence and professionalism.
• Decades-Old, Scratch-Made Recipes: The bakery still uses original, handwritten recipes from the founder, with 98-99 percent of the recipes remaining unchanged since the beginning. Many products, like their famous yeast pastries, are made using a starter dough that is older than the current owner.
• Extensive Menu Variety: With over 60 different products baked fresh daily, customers can find everything from yeast-raised donuts and sticky buns to Southern-favorite pies (like Sweet Potato Pie and Pecan Pie) and an array of specialty layer cakes (e.g., German Chocolate, Caramel, and Red Velvet).
• Community Institution: The business has served generations of local families, building a deep connection with the community. The founder, Mickey McClenny, was a strong local advocate who welcomed every person through the same door, even before the Civil Rights Era of the 1960s.
• Modern Amenities and Payments: Despite its history, the shop offers contemporary comforts, including an on-site Restroom and Wi-Fi. Payments are easy with acceptance of Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC mobile payments.

---

## Contact Information

For North Carolina residents looking to place an order, inquire about a custom cake, or simply confirm hours of operation, you can reach Mickey's Pastry Shop directly:

• Address: 2704 Graves Dr, Goldsboro, NC 27534, USA
• Phone: (919) 759-4741

---

## What is Worth Choosing

Choosing Mickey's Pastry Shop is choosing a piece of North Carolina's culinary history. What sets this Goldsboro bakery apart and makes it an absolute must-visit is its rare combination of tradition, expertise, and volume.

First and foremost, the expertise is unmatched: with three generations of Certified Master Bakers in the family, the technical skill and quality control are exceptionally high. You can trust that the baked goods you receive, from the smallest cookie to the largest wedding cake, are made by highly qualified professionals.

Secondly, their adherence to decades-old, scratch-made recipes means they offer an authentic, nostalgic flavor profile that many long for. This tradition is why customers feel compelled to compare every cake, cookie, or pie they eat to Mickey's. Their legendary items, like the Long Johns, Cream Puffs, and German Chocolate Cake, are staples in countless Eastern NC households.

While some long-time customers occasionally note that the "flavor and overall experience" can feel different over time—a natural occurrence for any business serving multiple generations—the commitment by the family to uphold the legacy, utilizing the same recipes, starter dough, and deep-rooted community values, remains constant. When you visit Mickey's Pastry Shop, you're not just purchasing a dessert; you are participating in a cherished Goldsboro and North Carolina tradition.

Mickey's Pastry Shop

2704 Graves Dr, Goldsboro, NC 27534, USA