Miss Amy's Bakery Wooster, OH: Gourmet Cakes, Cupcakes, and Gluten-Free Options

Miss Amy's Bakery Introduce

### Introduction / Overview: Gourmet Baking and Custom Creations in Wooster, Ohio

Miss Amy's Bakery is a true standout in the Wooster, Ohio culinary landscape. Identifying as a women-owned, gourmet, small-batch bakery, this establishment has elevated the standard for sweet treats in Wayne County. Unlike mass-production bakeries, Miss Amy's focuses on creating new, fresh things each and every morning, ensuring every item—from their famous cupcakes to their decadent cheesecakes—is crafted with precision and passion.

This bakery is a versatile destination, perfect for everyday indulgences, major holiday pre-orders, and large-scale events like weddings. They constantly push the boundaries, offering unique seasonal items alongside everyday favorites like their generously sized brownies and signature flavor creations, such as the Buckeye Cheesecake. What truly sets them apart in Ohio is their dedication to inclusivity, with an extensive and growing selection of Gluten Free and Keto options available daily. Customers frequently praise the quality of their items, noting that their wedding cakes and cupcakes are always "amazing" and exactly what was wanted.

---

### Location and Accessibility: Convenient Access with Amenities on E Smithville Western Rd

Miss Amy's Bakery operates from a convenient storefront location at 1494 E Smithville Western Rd Suite C, Wooster, OH 44691, USA. Positioned for easy access, the bakery is situated right next to C R Blooms Floral, a familiar landmark for Wooster residents, and centrally located between Cleveland Rd (State Route 3) and Canaan Center Rd.

The location is designed with customer comfort and ease in mind, making it a stress-free spot for Ohio patrons:

In-Store Shopping and Dining: The bakery features an indoor dining area and even offers outdoor seating during the warmer summer months.
Accessibility: The facility includes a Wheelchair accessible entrance and a Wheelchair accessible parking lot, ensuring comfortable access for all guests.
Parking and Amenities: They provide a Free parking lot directly on-site, a valuable convenience for shoppers. Public Wi-Fi and a Restroom are also available for those enjoying their treats inside.
Service Options: Customers can utilize In-store pickup for pre-orders, In-store shopping for their daily case items, and Takeout for quick grabs.
Quick Visit Planning: The operation is structured to accommodate a Quick visit for busy customers needing a fast treat or coffee.
Flexible Payments: They accept various forms of payment, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

---

### Services Offered

Miss Amy's Bakery offers a comprehensive range of custom and daily-baked goods, catering to diverse needs, from single servings to large event catering in Wooster, OH:

Custom Cakes and Wedding Desserts: Specializing in Custom Cakes for all occasions, including tiered Wedding Cakes, with extensive options for cake size, flavor (e.g., Almond Wedding, Buckeye, Lemon Raspberry), frosting, and filling.
Gourmet Cupcakes: Offering a wide, ever-changing selection of flavors by the dozen (e.g., Buckeye Cupcakes, Raspberry Swirl, Chocolate with Ganache), as well as themed seasonal selections for holidays like Valentine's Day and Easter.
Specialty Cheesecakes: A deep selection of house-made cheesecakes, including New York Style Cheesecake, Buckeye Cheesecake, Pumpkin Cheesecake, and Caramel Pecan Cheesecake, available whole or by the slice.
Breakfast and Brunch Items: Baking Full Size Quiche, Sticky Pecan Rolls, Cinnamon Rolls, and Breakfast Muffins for convenient morning cravings.
Diverse Pastries and Treats: An array of small-batch desserts like Macarons, Mini Cannolis, Traditional and Specialty Eclairs (Peanut Butter, Blueberry), Scones, and large Brownies.
Dietary Restriction Catering: Dedicated offerings include Gluten Free Cupcakes, Gluten Free Pies, Gluten Free Pumpkin Roll, and daily Keto options, with continuous efforts to expand their Vegan selection.
DIY and Activity Kits: Providing unique interactive products like Paint Your Own Cookie and Cookie Decorating Kits for family fun or gifts.

---

### Features / Highlights: Small-Batch Quality and Inclusive Options

What makes Miss Amy's Bakery a standout gem for Ohio residents is its commitment to quality, creativity, and customer-first service.

Gourmet, Small-Batch Baking: Items are baked fresh daily, often without a fixed menu, encouraging new and exciting finds every visit and reflecting a dedication to mastering new pastry techniques and trends.
Expert Customization & Event Planning: Their structured process for Custom Cakes and Wedding desserts, including filling out inquiry forms and speaking directly with staff, ensures flawless execution for large, important events. Customers testify that the results are exactly what they envision.
Unmatched Dietary Inclusivity: The bakery’s extensive and daily availability of Gluten Free and Keto options sets them apart from typical bakeries, making high-quality treats accessible to almost everyone in the Wooster community.
The Ohio Staple: Offerings like the Buckeye Cupcakes and Buckeye Cheesecake specifically cater to local Ohio pride and regional tastes, making them a perfect choice for game-day or local gatherings.
Friendly and Responsive Service: The business is noted for handling customer issues "with class" and going above and beyond to ensure customer satisfaction, highlighting the personalized touch of a local, women-owned business.

---

### Contact Information

To discuss custom orders, inquire about daily case flavors, or pre-order seasonal items at this fantastic Wooster, OH bakery, please use the details below:

Address: 1494 E Smithville Western Rd Suite C, Wooster, OH 44691, USA

Phone: (330) 804-0000

Mobile Phone: +1 330-804-0000

---

### What is Worth Choosing: Custom Quality and Community Care

For Ohio customers, Miss Amy's Bakery is undeniably the superior choice when quality, customization, and dietary needs are a priority. When you choose Miss Amy's, you are choosing a bakery that constantly strives to "SPREAD THE SPARKLE" with decadent treats made with genuine care and high-quality ingredients, from the buttercreams made with "real rich creamy butter—No Shortening. EVER" to the finest chocolates.

The ability to find everything from your morning Cinnamon Rolls to a custom, multi-tiered Wedding Cake in one spot—along with excellent Gluten Free options—makes this bakery highly practical. The fact that customers consider their cupcakes and brownies to be huge, amazing, and delicious solidifies its reputation as a local Wooster gem. Whether you need a festive holiday cake, a unique Paint Your Own Cookie kit, or simply a delicious slice of NY Style Cheesecake, Miss Amy's Bakery promises a delightful, high-quality experience that elevates your bakery standards.

Miss Amy's Bakery Vibe

Miss Amy's Bakery Valentines Day Pre Order Online Menu 2025
Valentines day is right around the corner! We have put a few of our best selling items on the preorder menu to help make it easier on our customers. If you don't see what you want please give us a call and we will do our best to accommodate you!
Valentines Day 2025 Bow-tique Treat Box[?] $26.50
This bow-tique treat box is sure to be a hit with all the Valentines in your life! The box includes a super cute decorated cakesicle, chocolate covered oreo, chocolate covered strawberry macaron, raspberry macaron, peanut butter buckeye heart, homemade strawberry pop tart, handmade heart shaped cosmic brownie and a homemade little debbie heart cake. The beautiful box is finished off with a beautiful bow! We make it delicious and easy for you! [?]
One Dozen Valentines Day Cupcake Selection $30.00
Choose any of your 12 favorites! Mix and match however you would like to make the perfect box! Choose from our list of selected Valentines flavors which will all be beautifully decorated for this holiday of LOVE as well as delicious!
One Dozen Chocolate Dipped Strawberries $29.95
Juicy Strawberries dipped in an assortment of Belgian milk chocolate, dark chocolate and white chocolate. Decorated beautifully for this holiday of Love! [?] You may customize your chocolate selection if you would like! We pride ourselves on using the highest grade quality strawberries and REAL tempered Belgian Chocolate! You will taste the difference! These strawberries are beautifully packaged in a specialty box, completed with a bow & card! [?]
Mascarpone Cheesecake Stuffed Chocolate Dipped Strawberries $21.95
These are the ULTIMATE Valentines treat! 6 Large, Beautiful fresh ripe strawberries are stuffed with our homemade mascarpone cheesecake filling. These beauties are dipped in pure Belgian milk chocolate and accented in edible gold. Once you try these you'll be hooked! Trust us, your Valentine will thank you for these!! [?]
1/2 Dozen Chocolate Dipped Strawberries $17.50
Juicy Strawberries dipped in an assortment of Belgian milk chocolate, dark chocolate and white chocolate. Decorated beautifully for this holiday of Love! [?] You may customize your chocolate selection if you would like! We pride ourselves on using the highest grade quality strawberries and REAL tempered Belgian Chocolate! You will taste the difference! These strawberries are beautifully packaged in a specialty box, completed with a bow & card! [?]
Valentines Day 6 Pack Cupcake Selection $18.00
Choose any of your 6 favorites! Mix and match however you would like to make the perfect box! A ton of great flavors to choose from, all decorated in the spirit of valentines day!
NY Style Cheesecake
Our soft and creamy classic New York Style cheesecake with a honey graham cracker crust that practically melts in your mouth. This comes in several specialty flavors or can be topped with one of our delicious fruit compotes or ganache. The 10 inch serves 14-16 people and the 6 inch serves 6-8 people.
Cheesecake cake by the individual slice [?] $8.00
This cheesecake cake is a GAME CHANGER! Two layers of cake encasing a cheesecake layer in the middle! Its the best of both worlds! The slices are more than generous so you can share one after dinner or snack on them for a couple days!
1 Dozen Macaron Box-Valentines Theme $30.00
One dozen of a delicious assortment of our most popular flavors of our melt in your mouth French macarons! Adorably decorated to match the festivities of the Valentines season! Flavors are Creme Brulee, Cookie Butter, Chocolate Truffle, Red Velvet, Fruity Pebbles. Cookies & Cream, Chocolate Peanut Butter, White Chocolate Raspberry, Vanilla Bean, Birthday Cake, Lemon Raspberry & Strawberry!
Gluten Free Cheesecake
Our GF honey oat crust knocks this cheesecake right outta the park! This is a favorite among our team! Available in 6in and 10 in and many flavors. A gluten free cheesecake is the perfect way to end your Valentines dinner! The 10 inch serves 14-16 people and the 6 inch serves 6-8 people!
Valentines House Sugar Cookies? $19.50
One dozen of our soft house sugar cookies in the shape of a heart! Topped with fluffy buttercream and happy sprinkles [?]
Individual Slice of Cheesecake $6.00
A individual generous slice of our homemade cheesecake! Choose from many of our specialty flavors for the holiday of love! We recommend refrigerating cheesecake until you are ready to eat it!

Pies
Apple Crumb Pie
With a delicious flaky pie crust, fresh chopped apples topped with our sweet streusel crumble.
Pumpkin Pie
With a flaky pie crust, and creamy smooth pumpkin filling topped with fresh whipped cream. Perfect centerpiece for your dinner table!
Pecan Pie
Our delicious flaky pie crust filled with our homemade pecan pie filling that just melts in your mouth!

Breakfast Pastries
Sticky Pecan Rolls $21.50
Eight delicious gooey pecan rolls drizzled in a sweet, sticky caramel sauce with fresh pecans on top. Perfect way to start any holiday morning!
Cinnamon Rolls $21.50
Eight sweet cinnamon rolls, filled with sweet cinnamon sugar and topped with our irresistible cinnamon cream cheese frosting.
Breakfast Muffins - Six Pack $18.00
Six of our delicious muffins coming in an assorted pack of blueberry, pumpkin cheesecake, and apple spice muffins.
Full Size Quiche $24.00
A flaky pastry crust filled with a delicious savory egg custard and cheese.

Sweet, Treats, and More to Eat!
Pumpkin Roll $18.00
Our delicious pumpkin cake rolled up with sweet layers of cream cheese frosting. Perfect for any pumpkin lover!
Thanksgiving Royal Icing Cookies $40.00
One dozen royal icing cookies in tons of adorable designs. Perfect display for any Thanksgiving dessert table.
Paint Your Own Cookie $6.00
This is the perfect holiday activity for any sweet kiddo! Each cookie comes with a food coloring paint palette and brush, with several designs!
Sticky Pecan Bars $21.00
Six of our chewy, gooey sticky pecan bars.
Mississippi Mud Tart $20.00
Chocolate wafer cookie crust topped with a layer of fudgy chocolate cake with crushed pecans, a creamy layer of chocolate pudding, and fresh whipped cream. Serves 8-10 people!
Tiramisu $55.00
Our tiramisu is an elegant and rich layered Italian dessert made with ladyfinger cookies, soaked in coffee and layered between sweet mascarpone cheese. Full size tiramisu serves 10-12 people.
Pumpkin Bars - 6 Pack $18.00
Six of our classic pumpkin bars topped with sweet cream cheese frosting.

Gluten Free Choices
Gluten Free Pumpkin Pie $24.00
Our flaky gluten free pie crust filled with our creamy, smooth pumpkin pie filling topped with fresh whipped cream.
Gluten Free Pecan Pie $24.00
Our flaky delicious gluten free crust filled with our chewy pecan filling.
Gluten Free Pumpkin Roll $22.00
Our gluten free pumpkin cake filled with our sweet, cream cheese frosting rolled up and topped with powdered sugar.
Gluten Free Pumpkin Bars - Six Pack $24.00
Six of our delicious pumpkin bars topped with our sweet cream cheese frosting.
NY Style Cheesecake
Our soft and creamy classic New York Style cheesecake with a honey graham cracker crust that practically melts in your mouth. This comes in several specialty flavors or can be topped with one of our delicious fruit compotes or ganache. The 10 inch serves 14-16 people and the 6 inch serves 6-8 people.

Cheesecake
New York Style Cheesecake topped w/ Strawberry $55.00
The perfect display for your Holiday dinner table, our classic New York Style Cheesecake! This serves about 12-14 people!
Pumpkin Cheesecake $55.00
The perfect display for your Holiday dinner table, our creamy delicate pumpkin cheesecake topped with fresh whipped cream! This serves about 12-14 people!
Caramel Pecan Cheesecake $55.00
Our classic graham crust topped with our perfect caramel cheesecake and crushed pecans. Decorated to be the perfect centerpiece for your holiday dinner table! This serves about 12-14 people!
Buckeye Cheesecake $55.00
The perfect display for your Holiday dinner table, our classic chocolate crust topped with our creamy smooth peanut butter cheesecake! Topped with fresh whipped cream and buckeyes! Serves 12 to 14 people!
White Chocolate Raspberry Cheesecake $55.00
The perfect display for your Holiday dinner table, our house favorite White Chocolate Raspberry Cheesecake has a graham crust with chunks of white chocolate melted into a thin layer, topped with our classic cheesecake batter and swirled with fresh raspberry compote. Serves 12-14 people!

Macarons
Dozen Assorted Macarons $26.00
One dozen macarons in assorted flavors and Thanksgiving designs. Perfect sample pack for any macaron fan in your life!

Cupcakes
Dozen Assorted Thanksgiving Cupcakes $27.50
Twelve of our delicious cupcakes coming in an assortment several different flavors and festive designs! The perfect treat for anyone to eat!
Dozen Cupcakes - by the flavor $27.50
One dozen of our delicious cupcakes with several varieties and flavors to choose from!

Cupcakes
Easter 2023 Cupcake Selections
Easter 2023 Cupcakes - 1 Dozen $27.50
These springy and fun cupcakes are sure to make your Easter Celebration a hit!
Easter 2023 Cupcake Selection- 1/2 Dozen $16.50

French Macarons
Easter 2023 French Macaron Selections
Easter 2023 Assorted Macaron Box $30.00
Receive a box of 12 of our most popular assorted macaron flavors hand picked by our team all decked out for the Easter Holiday!
Easter 2023 Macarons $30.00
Our ever popular french macarons make the perfect treat for your holiday gathering! naturally gluten free and delicious!

Easter Treats
Easter 2023 Specialty Treats
Individual Strawberry Pies $4.50
My sweet grandmas strawberry pie! With a delicious shortbread like crust and yummy ripe strawberries!
Cookie Dough Brownie Stack $37.50
These have been super popular in our case lately! So we decided to make a 6 inch version for your table at home! Layers of peanut butter cookie dough, brownie and ganache make this treat irresistible!
Bunny Rolls -6 pack $9.00
Adorable dinner rolls that look like bunnies! Kids of all ages are sure to love these!
Peanut Butter Eggs $2.95
Best Seller! Homemade Peanut Butter Filling Covered With Our Delicious Belgium Milk Chocolate! You'll Never Eat A Store Bought One Again!
Hot Cross Buns -6 pack $9.00
An Easter Staple! Homemade hot cross buns!
Bunny Cookie Torte $4.95
Adorable and Festive Bunny Cookie Torte w/ Mini Macaron
Individual Key Lime Pie $4.50
Zesty and Fresh! These Individual Key Lime Pies are the perfect size!!

Easter Cake
Easter 2023 Cake
Easter 2023 Bunny Specialty Cake $40.00
This adorable bunny will make the perfect centerpiece to your Easter table! It serves 12-18 and comes in several flavors!

Cheesecake
Easter 2023 Cheesecake
New York Style Cheesecake topped w/ Strawberry $55.00
The perfect display for your Holiday dinnner table, our classic New York Style Cheesecake! This serves about 12-14 people!
NY Style Cheesecake
Our soft and creamy classic New York Style cheesecake with a honey graham cracker crust that practically melts in your mouth. This comes in several specialty flavors or can be topped with one of our delicious fruit compotes or ganache. The 10 inch serves 14-16 people and the 6 inch serves 6-8 people.
Buckeye Cheesecake $55.00
The perfect display for your Holiday dinner table, our classic chocolate crust topped with our creamy smooth peanut butter cheesecake! Topped with fresh whipped cream and buckeyes! Serves 12 to 14 people!

Day-To-Day Offerings
Dozen Rosette House Sugar Cookies $22.50
By the dozen.Soft sugar cookies topped with a fluffy vanilla bean buttercream rosette flower. Our house sugar cookies are generously sized!Disclaimer: Decoration and color may vary due to supply availability. Standard buttercream color is white although seasonal colored buttercream may be available upon request.
Dozen Sprinkle House Sugar Cookies $22.50
By the dozen.Soft sugar cookies topped with a fluffy white vanilla bean buttercream and sprinkles. Our house sugar cookies are generously sized! Disclaimer: Decoration and color may vary due to supply availability. Our standard sprinkle color is gold but other colors may be available upon request!
Dozen Chocolate Chip Cookies $25.00
By the dozen.Scratch-made, quality chocolate chip cookies, made with only the finest chocolate. Made with love and crafted to satisfy the biggest cravings. Perfect for sharing (or savoring all to yourself), these aren't just cookies-they're a treat that's larger than life!
Dozen Salted Caramel Chocolate Chip Cookies $25.00
By the dozen.A customer favorite over the years. Scratch-made, decadent chocolate chip cookies with caramel bits and oatmeal throughout, topped with sea salt flakes. You will love this elevated flavor and never look at a regular chocolate chip cookie the same way! These cookies are generously sized! You won't be disappointed giving them a try!
Six Pack of Brownies $23.70
Six-packClassic soft chocolate brownies with three topping options. These brownies could feed 3 people, they are big! Flavors are: Triple Chocolate (topped with chocolate buttercream, chocolate ganache, and chocolate candy), Peanut Butter (topped with peanut butter buttercream, chocolate ganache, and peanut butter candy), or Powdered Sugar. * Assorted Variety includes two Triple Chocolate, two Peanut Butter, and two Powdered Sugar Brownies. Disclaimer: Decoration and color may vary due to supply availability. Flavor request modifications may be available upon request. (Example 3 triple chocolate & 3 powdered sugar)
Dozen Triple Berry Scones $32.50
By the dozen.A soft tender scone with fresh blueberries, strawberries, and raspberries throughout, topped with a light lemon zest and sugar topping.
Dozen Blueberry Scones $32.50
By the dozen.A soft tender scone with fresh blueberries baked throughout, topped with a light lemon zest and sugar topping. These are a customer favorite and sell out daily!
Dozen Mini Cannolis $25.95
By the dozen.Indulge in the ultimate Italian dessert experience with our cannoli-crispy golden shells filled to the brim with a velvety-smooth ricotta cream that's just the right balance of sweetness and richness! Studded with chocolate chips for an extra touch of indulgence!
Dozen Traditional Eclairs $42.50
By the dozen.A large classic eclair filled with mousseline cream, topped with silky smooth chocolate ganache.
Dozen Peanut Butter Eclairs $42.50
By the dozen.Large chocolate eclairs filled with a delicious peanut butter mousseline cream, topped with peanut butter buttercream, peanut butter sauce, and candy pieces. Disclaimer: Decoration and color may vary due to supply availability.
Dozen Blueberry Eclairs $42.50
By the dozen.Large classic eclair shells filled with delicious blueberry mousseline cream, topped with blueberry buttercream and fresh blueberries. These are a customer favorite!
Dozen Assorted Cupcakes $30.00
By the dozen.Each day brings a fresh lineup of extraordinary flavors made from the finest, real ingredients. Our cupcakes are baked daily, our buttercreams are made with nothing other than real rich creamy butter-No. Shortening. EVER. Pure vanilla, hand picked fruits and high end imported chocolate are among some of the ingredients that set us apart-pure deliciousness. Every cupcake is a mini masterpiece, beautifully decorated to delight your eyes as much as your tastebuds. From classic favorites to daring new combinations, our flavors change daily, offering a new adventure with every visit or order. Indulge in the ultimate treat, where quality meets creativity in every luscious, bite-sized cake! -We will select a dozen assorted cupcakes from our case that day. Please put in the special requests if there are flavors you prefer us to avoid and we will do our best to accommodate!
Dozen Almond White Cupcakes $30.00
By the dozen.Our almond wedding white cupcake is a delicate celebration of flavor and elegance. Moist, tender almond cake with the perfect partnership of almond and vanilla bean extract topped with a fluffy, buttery vanilla buttercream. This cupcake can be topped with the sprinkle color of your choice or decorated with a white rosette buttercream flower. Please specify and we will to do our best to accommodate you!
Dozen Brunch Bunch Cupcakes $30.00
By the dozenAlmond white cupcakes filled with mousseline cream, topped with fresh whipped cream and berries. This cupcake is refreshingly light and extremely popular! People love filled cupcakes and our fresh whipped cream compliments this cake and delightful pastry cream beautifully! You definitely want to give these a try! Refrigeration required.
Dozen Buckeye Cupcakes $30.00
By the dozen.A moist chocolate cupcake topped with whipped peanut butter buttercream, draped in milk chocolate ganache and topped with a mini buckeye candy. This is every chocolate & PB lovers dream come true as well as a STAPLE at every Ohio State Buckeyes Party!
Dozen Chocolate with Ganache Cupcakes $30.00
By the dozen.Our most popular chocolate cupcake! This is the ultimate indulgence for chocolate lovers! This rich, moist chocolate cake is deeply flavored and perfectly soft, creating a delicious foundation for the buttery vanilla bean buttercream dunked in silky smooth milk chocolate ganache topped with a swirl of chocolate buttercream and chocolate curls. A simple, elegant cupcake that delivers pure satisfaction.
Dozen Confetti Cupcakes $30.00
By the dozen.It's a party! White vanilla cupcakes with sprinkles baked in, topped with vanilla multi-colored swirled buttercream and sprinkles. How fun! Swirl color can be accommodated upon request!
Dozen Cookies and Cream Cupcakes $30.00
By the dozen.White cupcakes with Oreo pieces baked in, topped with cookies and cream buttercream, a chocolate ganache drizzle, and Oreo crumbles. These are a crowd pleaser for young and old alike!
Dozen Oreo Cupcakes $30.00
By the dozen.A delicious chocolate cupcake with Oreo crumbles baked in, topped with cookies and cream buttercream, a velvety chocolate ganache drizzle, and a mini chocolate-dipped Oreo. (upon availability) These Oreo cupcakes go over great at birthday parties, work gatherings, family celebrations and more! Disclaimer: Decoration and color may vary due to supply availability.
Dozen Raspberry Swirl Cupcakes $30.00
By the dozen.This is a contender for our most popular flavor! A light almond white cupcake with a fabulous raspberry compote swirled and baked in, topped with a vanilla buttercream rosette flower or vanilla buttercream and fresh raspberry. Please specify your preference of topping.
Dozen Strawberry Cassata Cupcakes $30.00
By the dozen.They are filled. They are light. They are flavorful. They are our favorite! Cassata Cupcakes- A lovely white vanilla bean cake filled with both Italian mousseline cream and strawberry compote then topped with fresh whipped cream and fresh strawberries. If you haven't tried this cupcake, you absolutely should! Cassata cupcakes do require refrigeration.
NY Style Cheesecake
Our soft and creamy classic New York Style cheesecake with a honey graham cracker crust that practically melts in your mouth. This comes in several specialty flavors or can be topped with one of our delicious fruit compotes or ganache. The 10 inch serves 14-16 people and the 6 inch serves 6-8 people.
Gluten Free Cupcakes
Our same delicious cupcakes, that come in a variety of flavors, but catered to those with gluten intolerance! Our gluten-free cupcakes are crafted with care and attention. We pride ourself on using high quality gluten-free ingredients and recipes perfected for flavor and tenderness. While we follow best practices to minimize cross contamination in our kitchen, please be aware that we are not a certified gluten free only facility, and cross-contact with gluten ingredients may occur. We take every precaution possible to keep our gluten-free treats safe and scrumptious!

Cookies
One Dozen Royal Icing Cookies $40.00
How can you resist these adorable royal icing cookies? Our royal icing cookies come packaged by the dozen in beautiful boxes! Get one for yourself or give one as a gift!
One Dozen Cutout Cookies $25.00
These are our classic house sugar cookies decorated in tons of festive shapes and designs! It's not Christmas without some classic cutout cookies!
Assorted Cookie Box
An assortment of our most popular Christmas cookie choices boxed beautifully. This comes in either one dozen or four dozen with a variety of brownie cookies, fudge, macarons, thumbprints, rolled gingerbread cookies, biscotti, nut clusters, shortbread cookies, royal icing cookies, hot coca brownie cookies, soft glazed gingerbread cookies, eggnog cookies, chocolate bark, spritz, date nut pinwheels, and peanut butter blossoms.
Paint Your Own Cookie $6.00
This is the perfect holiday activity for any sweet kiddo! Each cookie comes with a food coloring paint palette and brush, with several designs!
Cookie Decorating Kit $35.00
Each kit comes with a dozen unfrosted sugar cookies, a few tubs of frosting, and loads of sprinkles! Perfect for a snowed in holiday craft for any family!
Paint Your Own Gingerbread Man Kit $15.00
This kit comes with an large gingerbread cookie, frosted white for decoration! Stocked with royal icing, lots of sprinkles, and a food coloring paint palette! The perfect gift for any little artist in your life!
Paint Your Own Gingerbread Wall Kit $15.00
This kit comes with one wall of a large gingerbread house, stenciled with a festive design! Each kit comes with royal icing, a food coloring paint palette, and tons of sprinkles!

Gluten Free Choices
One Dozen Gluten Free Cutout Cookies $32.00
These are our classic Gluten Free house sugar cookies decorated in tons of festive shapes and designs! It's not Christmas without some classic cutout cookies!
NY Style Cheesecake
Our soft and creamy classic New York Style cheesecake with a honey graham cracker crust that practically melts in your mouth. This comes in several specialty flavors or can be topped with one of our delicious fruit compotes or ganache. The 10 inch serves 14-16 people and the 6 inch serves 6-8 people.
Gluten Free Cookie Decorating Kit $40.00
Each kit comes with a dozen unfrosted gluten free sugar cookies, a few tubs of frosting, and loads of sprinkles! Perfect for a snowed in holiday craft for any family!

Cupcakes
One Dozen Assorted Christmas Cupcakes $27.50
Grab a variety of our beautifully decorated Christmas cupcakes, our choosing! The flavors we are offering are our German Chocolate, Almond, Chocolate, White Chocolate Peppermint, Chocolate Peppermint, Buckeye, Gingerbread, Confetti, Hot Cocoa, Chocolate with Ganache, Lemon Raspberry, Almond Winterberry, Peanut Butter Blossom, Red Velvet, and Strawberry Cassata.
One Dozen Cupcakes - All One Flavor $27.50
Choose one dozen of one flavor of our adorable Christmas cupcakes!

Bread
Honey Butter Rolls - 6 Pack $8.50
My GOODNESS! These rolls are the way to anybody's heart! Soft and tender, these rolls are brushed with honey butter and just melt in your mouth! Compliment to any meal! Don't miss out on these this Holiday season!
Nutella Cinnamon Star Bread $8.50
A soft, sweet cinnamon brioche bread braided with Nutella in a festive star shape. Perfect to display on your Holiday dinner table and enjoy for dinner or dessert!

Cake Pops
Assorted Holiday Cake Pop Box $30.00
This adorable box comes with a dozen of our classic vanilla, confetti, or chocolate cake pops, dipped in milk chocolate and topped with red and green sprinkles! The perfect treat for any cake pop lover! Assorted flavors, our choosing.

Yule Logs
Chocolate Cheesecake Yule Log $46.00
A classic yule log in a moist chocolate cake filled with a delicious cheesecake filling, beautifully decorated for a holiday dinner table.
Winter Berry Yule Log $46.00
A classic yule log in a white cake filled with a delicious mixed berry compote, beautifully decorated for a holiday dinner table.

Christmas Morning Cravings
Full Size Quiche $24.00
A flaky pastry crust filled with a delicious savory egg custard and cheese.
Breakfast Muffins - Six Pack $18.00
Six of our delicious muffins coming in an assorted pack of blueberry, gingerbread, and eggnog.
Cinnamon Rolls $21.50
Eight sweet cinnamon rolls, filled with sweet cinnamon sugar and topped with our irresistible cinnamon cream cheese frosting.
Sticky Pecan Rolls $21.50
Eight delicious gooey pecan rolls drizzled in a sweet, sticky caramel sauce with fresh pecans on top. Perfect way to start any holiday morning!

Sweet Treats
Tiramisu $55.00
Our tiramisu is an elegant and rich layered Italian dessert made with ladyfinger cookies, soaked in coffee and layered between sweet mascarpone cheese. Full size tiramisu serves 10-12 people.
Christmas Tree Treats - Six Pack $24.00
This is our take on everyone's favorite little snack, made with vanilla cake and coated in chocolate, you can't stop at just eating one.

Cheesecakes
Chocolate Peppermint Cheesecake $55.00
This is a twist on our classic New York style Cheesecake, bite into a creamy cheesecake with pops of chocolate and peppermint in every bite!
New York Style Cheesecake topped w/ Strawberry $55.00
The perfect display for your Holiday dinnner table, our classic New York Style Cheesecake! This serves about 12-14 people!

Macarons
Dozen Assorted Macarons $26.00
One dozen macarons in assorted flavors and Christmas designs. Perfect sample pack for any macaron fan in your life!
1 Dozen Macaron Box-Valentines Theme $26.00
One dozen of one flavor of our melt in your mouth macarons in one of the gourmet Valentines menu flavors. Adorably decorated to match the festivities of the season!

Cake
This will be our only set design for preorder cakes, but we are taking custom orders for the week of Christmas and will also be fully stocked in our case with case cakes.
Christmas Tree Cake $18.00
A single layer cake decorated like a Christmas tree!

Specality Cakes
These are the four gorgeous cakes we are offering for the holiday season! These cakes are the perfect centerpiece for any dinner table! Each cake is a 6 inch triple layer cake that serves about 12-18 people!
Ho Ho Ho Hot Cocoa Bomb Cake (Design #1) $45.00
No cup of hot cocoa is too big, especially when it's made of cake! This is our classic FAN FAVORITE hot cocoa bomb cake. Inisde are layers of chocolate cake filled with fluffy marshmallow and frosted in our classic fluffy buttercream in the design of a mug with a full sized hot cocoa bomb on top! Choose from two different designs!
Merry Christmas Hot Cocoa Bomb Cake (Design #2) $45.00
No cup of hot cocoa is too big, especially when it's made of cake! This is our classic FAN FAVORITE hot cocoa bomb cake. Inisde are layers of chocolate cake filled with fluffy marshmallow and frosted in our classic fluffy buttercream in the design of a mug with a full sized hot cocoa bomb on top! Choose from two different designs!
Rudolph the Red Nosed Gnome Cake $45.00
Bring one of these adorable reindeer gnome cakes GNOME with you this holiday season! Inside is our delicious winter mixed berry swirl cake frosted with our classic fluffy vanilla buttercream!
Winter Wonderland Cake $45.00
This gorgeous cake is our delicious six inch confetti cake filled with our classic fluffy vanilla buttercream decorated as a whimsical winter wonderland! The epitome of everyone's Christmas dreams!
Decandent Holly Cake $45.00
This festive masterpiece is a chocolate cake filled with raspberry compote and topped with a decadent dark chocolate ganache. Decorated with macarons, holly, and gold splatter. Put this on any dinner table to compliment your Christmas dinner!

Cupcakes
One Dozen Assorted Christmas Cupcakes $27.50
Grab a variety of our beautifully decorated Christmas cupcakes, our choosing! The flavors we are offering are our Chocolate w/ Ganache, Buckeye, Almond Filled w/ Raspberry, Chocolate Peppermint, Gingerbread, Almond White, Hot Cocoa, German, Red Velvet, Peanut Butter Blossom, Confetti, White Chocolate Peppermint, Vanilla, Brunch Bunch, and Mixed Berry Swirl!
One Dozen Cupcakes - All One Flavor $27.50
Choose one dozen of one flavor of our adorable Christmas cupcakes!

Bread
Braided Challah Wreath $8.00
This adorable bread wreath is an enriched challah bread that is soft and slightly sweet! Pairs perfectly with any jam!
Cranberry Pistachio Babka $10.00
Our cranberry pistachio babka is a sweet braided bread swirled with cranberry compote and tons of pistachios! A delicious bread for any Christmas meal!
Honey Butter Rolls - 6 Pack $8.50
My GOODNESS! These rolls are the way to anybody's heart! Soft and tender, these rolls are brushed with honey butter and just melt in your mouth! Compliment to any meal! Don't miss out on these this Holiday season!
Rum Raisin Panettone $10.00
Studded with raisins, and soaked in a bit of rum, its flavors befit the season perfectly and is an indulgent treat to celebrate the holiday!

Cheesecake
New York Style Cheesecake topped w/ Strawberry $55.00
The perfect display for your Holiday dinnner table, our classic New York Style Cheesecake! This serves about 12-14 people!
Chocolate Peppermint Cheesecake $55.00
This is a twist on our classic New York style Cheesecake, bite into a creamy cheesecake with pops of chocolate and peppermint in every bite!

Cake Pop Assorted Boxes
Assorted Holiday Cake Pop Box $30.00
This adorable box comes with a dozen of our classic vanilla, confetti, or chocolate cake pops, dipped in milk chocolate and topped with red and green sprinkles! The perfect treat for any cake pop lover! Assorted flavors, our choosing.

Cookies
One Dozen Royal Icing Cookies $38.00
How can you resist these adorable royal icing cookies? Our royal icing cookies come packaged by the dozen in beautiful boxes! Get one for yourself or give one as a gift!
One Dozen Cutout Cookies $24.00
These are our classic house sugar cookies decorated in tons of festive shapes and designs! It's not Christmas without some classic cutout cookies!
Paint Your Own Cookie $6.00
This is the perfect holiday activity for any sweet kiddo! Each cookie comes with a food coloring paint palette and brush, with several designs!
Gluten Free Paint Your Own $6.50
This is the perfect stocking stuffer for any sweet kiddo! Each cookie comes with a food coloring paint palette and brush, with tons of designs to choose from! The santa list comes with a edible marker to write your own list!
Mini Gingerbread House Kit $12.50
This is the perfect craft for any family holiday! Each kit comes with the sides to build the house, royal icing, a food coloring paint palette, and lots of sprinkles to decorate! These are awesome for kids who want to do their own gingerbread house!
Paint Your Own Gingerbread Man Kit $12.50
This kit comes with an large gingerbread cookie, frosted white for decoration! Stocked with royal icing, lots of sprinkles, and a food coloring paint palette! The perfect gift for any little artist in your life!
Paint Your Own Gingerbread Wall Kit $12.50
This kit comes with one wall of a large gingerbread house, stenciled with a festive design! Each kit comes with royal icing, a food coloring paint palette, and tons of sprinkles!
Assorted Cookie Tray $50.00
This assorted cookie tray comes with 3.5 dozen assorted classic Christmas cookies including Snickerdoodles, Mint Chip, Ginger Molasses, Thumbprints, Buckeyes, Pizzelles, White Chocolate Cranberry, Butter Pecan, Peanut Butter Blossom, Peppercocker, Sugar Cookie, Peppermint Shortbread, and Peppermint Patties. The perfect assorted for any holiday get together!
Cookie Decorating Kit $35.00
Each kit comes with a dozen unfrosted sugar cookies, a few tubs of frosting, and loads of sprinkles! Perfect for a snowed in holiday craft for any family!
Elf on the Shelf Pizza Cookie $5.50

Yule Logs
White Raspberry Yule Log $45.00
A classic yule log in a white cake filled with a delicious raspberry compote, beautifully decorated for a holiday dinner table.
Chocolate Yule Log $45.00
A classic yule log in traditional chocolate cake, beautifully decorated for any holiday dinner table.

Miss Amy's Bakery Details

From the business
Identifies as women-owned

Service options
In-store pickup
In-store shopping
Takeout
Delivery

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Breakfast

Amenities
Wi-Fi
Wi-Fi

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Parking
Free parking lot

Miss Amy's Bakery Photos

Miss Amy's Bakery Location

Miss Amy's Bakery

Ohio Wayne County Wooster East Smithville Western Road

1494 E Smithville Western Rd Suite C, Wooster, OH 44691, USA

Miss Amy's Bakery Reviews

An average rating of ★4.8 from 285 user reviews.

cupcakesgluten freeweddingcheesecakechoicesbrowniesfrostingchocolate chip cookiesblueberryscones

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Ordered our wedding cake and 3 different flavors of cupcakes for our wedding celebration last weekend. Just perfect! Everyone said how amazing the cupcakes were and the cake was exactly what I wanted.
August 21 · Karly Lowe
Ordered 2 dozen assorted cupcakes and 1/2 dozen brownies for an event. Everything looked amazing and I was told that the flavors were awesome!! Unfortunately I didn't get to try the cupcakes.The brownies are huge and enjoyed by all!! What a gem this place is. It was my first time ever going there but I will definitely be back!!
April 16 · Beth Liggett
Honestly, these are the best gluten free desserts I’ve ever had! We got them for our wedding since I have to be gluten free. They were a total hit—every treat was gone by the end. Even people who usually skeptical on “gluten free” desserts couldn’t believe how good they were. Highly recommend!
September 21 · vikki escola
I am not familiar with Wooster but was in the area and Googled 'best bakeries in this area' and Miss Amy's popped up. It was only 5 minutes away so I was on my way. This bakery is a spiritual experience! There is a wide variety of baked goods from huge bars, cookies, cheesecake, cupcakes, cakes and more. Everything is homemade from scratch, no 'one dough for 10 varieties of cookies' here! This is a bakery-lovers bakery. I purchased a wide variety of items and every single one was fresh and delicious. The buttercream frosting on the cupcakes is delicious and not overly sweet, the raspberry cheesecake and peach cheesecake were creamy and delicious and the salted caramel chocolate chip cookies are to die for. I live over an hour away and will make a road trip just to go to Miss Amy's Bakery. It is worth every mile!
July 26 · T Annmarie
Very impressed, drove all the way from Cleveland to Wooster for this amazing taste, texture, and the most beautiful, very creative decorations! Their cheesecake and cupcakes are absolutely divine! The icing isn't too sweet, and different cupcakes obviously have different flavors, but also different and unique textures! I am so thrilled that my Mom found this little gem of a bakery! And a patient, amazing worker really took her time with us, explaining all the different types of cakes and various selections. I just wish they'd open one in Cleveland! I would love for them to commercialize this, put one on every corner, like Starbucks! It'd be epic! Stay amazing Miss Amy!
March 06 · Cristina Grace