Petee’s Pie Company at Gotham West Market: Your New York Pie Destination

Petee’s Pie Company at Gotham West Market Introduce

Welcome to the vibrant world of New York City's culinary scene, where every neighborhood holds a unique gem waiting to be discovered. Nestled within the bustling energy of Hell's Kitchen, Petee’s Pie Company at Gotham West Market stands out as a true artisanal treasure, a haven for anyone with a sweet tooth or a craving for a perfectly crafted, classic pie. This article is your local guide to everything you need to know about this exceptional bakery, from its delectable offerings to its convenient location and unwavering commitment to quality. As a local New Yorker, you understand the value of finding a reliable spot that feels both familiar and extraordinary, and Petee’s Pie Company is exactly that. It's a place where tradition meets modern urban life, creating a memorable experience with every single slice.

For many of us, the word “pie” evokes feelings of warmth, comfort, and home. Petee’s Pie Company takes these feelings and elevates them, creating an experience that is both nostalgic and refreshingly new. They are not just selling pies; they are selling a moment of pure, unadulterated joy. Whether you're a long-time resident of the city or a recent transplant, finding a local spot that you can count on for quality and flavor is a true asset. Petee’s has cultivated a reputation for doing just that. Their pies are the result of careful, time-honored techniques and a passion for using the very best ingredients available. This dedication is evident in every bite, from the flaky, buttery crust to the rich, flavorful fillings. It's the kind of place you'll want to revisit for a special occasion, a casual treat, or a last-minute dessert for a gathering.

The story of Petee’s Pie Company is one of passion and a commitment to simple, honest food. Their mission is clear: to create the best pies using high-quality, locally sourced, and seasonal ingredients whenever possible. This philosophy is at the core of their operations and is why they have garnered such a loyal following in the competitive New York City market. The pies are made from scratch, with a dedication to the craft that is rarely seen today. This attention to detail is what sets them apart and makes them a beloved fixture in the local food scene.

Petee’s Pie Company’s location inside Gotham West Market makes it a particularly accessible and convenient stop for many New Yorkers. The market itself is a destination, a vibrant hub of various culinary vendors, and Petee’s fits right in, offering a sweet counterpoint to the savory options. Situated at 600 11th Ave, New York, NY 10036, the bakery is easily reachable from various parts of the city. Being in Hell's Kitchen means it’s close to major transit lines and a short walk from many residential and commercial areas. Whether you're coming from the Theater District, the Hudson Yards area, or the Upper West Side, getting to this location is straightforward. The address is 600 11th Ave, New York, NY 10036, USA, placing it within a bustling and well-connected part of Manhattan. Its presence within Gotham West Market also means you can grab a delicious meal from another vendor and cap it off with a perfect slice of pie, making for a comprehensive and satisfying dining experience. The convenience of this location is a huge plus for busy New Yorkers looking for a quick and delicious treat without having to travel far.

The accessibility of the location is one of its major draws. You can easily get there via public transportation or even a short walk from nearby neighborhoods. This makes it a great spot for a spontaneous dessert run, a scheduled pick-up for a party, or simply a place to sit down and enjoy a moment of peace with a slice of pie and a cup of coffee. The ease of access combined with the welcoming atmosphere of Gotham West Market makes for a truly pleasant visit. It's a place where you can feel at home while still enjoying the unique energy that only New York City can provide.

Petee’s Pie Company at Gotham West Market offers a range of services designed to meet the needs of their New York customers. Their commitment to excellent service is evident, as seen in glowing reviews from real customers who appreciate their dedication. The services they offer go beyond just selling pies and aim to provide a full and satisfying experience.

In-store purchases: Customers can visit the location in Gotham West Market to purchase a slice or an entire pie. This is a great option for those who want to see the selection firsthand and enjoy the atmosphere.
Pies for special occasions: Petee’s is a go-to for events, parties, and holidays. Their pies are a perfect centerpiece for birthdays, family gatherings, and other celebrations, with options like Chocolate Chess and Apple Crumb that have received high praise.
Online and phone orders: For added convenience, customers can place orders in advance. This is especially useful for busy holiday seasons or when you need to secure a specific type of pie. The phone number to place an order is (646) 494-3630.
Delivery services: As mentioned in customer reviews, Petee’s offers delivery, which is a huge benefit for those who cannot make it to the store. Their commitment to ensuring the correct and delicious pie arrives safely at your door is a testament to their exceptional customer service.

Petee’s Pie Company at Gotham West Market has several standout features that make it a local favorite. These highlights are what keep customers coming back again and again, cementing its place as a top-tier bakery in New York.

Exceptional Customer Service: As highlighted in a customer review, their team goes "above and beyond to coordinate delivering the correct pie." This level of dedication to customer satisfaction, even when facing hiccups with couriers, is a rare and highly valued trait.
High-Quality, Consistent Products: Customers note that their pies are "absolutely delicious" and "always consistent." This consistency across different locations and over time is a hallmark of a truly well-run business with a strong commitment to quality. The use of seasonal and local ingredients is a major factor in this.
Diverse Pie Selection: With a variety of pies like Chocolate Chess and Apple Crumb, there's something to satisfy every palate. Their menu often reflects the seasons, ensuring fresh and flavorful ingredients are used in every pie.
Artisanal, Handmade Pies: The pies are crafted with care and a dedication to traditional techniques. This is not mass-produced dessert; it’s a true artisanal product made with love and expertise.
Prime Location within Gotham West Market: Being located in a popular and vibrant food hall adds to the overall experience. Customers can enjoy the lively atmosphere while savoring their dessert, making it a social destination as well as a quick stop.

For all your pie needs, here is the essential contact information for Petee’s Pie Company at Gotham West Market.

Address: 600 11th Ave, New York, NY 10036, USA

Phone: (646) 494-3630

Phone (Mobile): +1 646-494-3630

In conclusion, Petee’s Pie Company at Gotham West Market is more than just a place to buy dessert; it’s a beloved local institution that delivers on its promises of quality, flavor, and exceptional service. For New Yorkers, this bakery is a perfect fit for many reasons. Its convenient Hell's Kitchen location makes it an easy stop whether you're heading home from work, meeting friends, or simply exploring the city. The commitment to using fresh, local ingredients means you can feel good about what you're eating, and the consistently delicious pies ensure that every visit is a treat. The glowing reviews about their outstanding customer service speak volumes about the care and professionalism they bring to their business, making it a reliable and trustworthy choice. Whether you need a full pie for a birthday celebration, a couple of slices for a cozy evening in, or a quick, sweet pick-me-up, Petee’s Pie Company is the kind of local business that truly enhances the community. It’s a place where you can taste the dedication in every bite, making it an essential destination for anyone in New York who appreciates the simple, timeless pleasure of a perfectly baked pie.

Petee’s Pie Company at Gotham West Market Services

Drinks
Topo Chico (12oz) US$4.00
Sparkling mineral water.
Saratoga US$3.25

Sides
Chocolate Slice Cream (4oz) US$4.00
Pint Of Maple Whipped Cream US$7.70
Is it life changing? Yes.
Maple Whipped Cream (4oz) US$1.65
Is it life changing? Yes.
Pint Of Chocolate Chess Ice Cream US$9.90
Luscious chunks of Salty Chocolate Chess Pie swirled into our homemade vanilla ice cream.
Pecan Slice Cream (4oz) US$4.00
Pint Of Pecan Pie Ice Cream US$9.90
Gooey chunks of our Brown Butter Honey Pecan Pie swirled into our homemade vanilla ice cream.
Vanilla Bean Ice Cream (4oz) US$3.30
Made in-house and churned fresh daily.
Pint Of Vanilla Bean Ice Cream US$9.90
Made in-house and churned fresh daily.

Whole Pies
Cherry Crumb Whole Pie US$44.00
Contains nuts.
Wild Maine Blueberry Whole Pie US$44.00
A fresh and delicious pie made with scrumptious organic wild blueberries from Josh Pond, Maine. Only a quarter cup of sugar in a whole pie to let the natural sweetness and flavor of the blueberries shine through.
Blueberry Crumb Whole Pie US$44.00
Contains nuts.
Lavish Chocolate Cream Whole Pie US$49.50
A rich, old-fashioned chocolate pudding made with bittersweet chocolate and cocoa, topped with dollops of fresh whipped cream and real gold leaf-adorned chocolate flakes.
Hudson Valley Apple Whole Pie US$44.00
New York State grows more apple varieties than any other, and our single varietal apple pies are a celebration of classic New York and heirloom varietals. We add just enough sugar and spices to enhance their natural flavor.
Banana Cream Whole Pie US$49.50
Old-fashioned vanilla pudding topped with fresh banana Whole Pies and dolloped with whipped cream.
Gingerbread Chess Whole Pie US$45.00
All the warm and spicy flavors you love in a classic gingerbread, but in the form of a buttery chess pie.
NY Sour Cherry Whole Pie US$44.00
We use Montmorency cherries from upstate New York in our Sour Cherry Pie-- and we don't sugarcoat 'em either. We let their vibrant, tart flavor take center stage. Add a scoop of ice cream to this bright red cherry pie and it will really knock your socks off!
Salty Chocolate Chess Whole Pie US$44.00
Chess pie is a classic southern dish based on some of our favorite ingredients: butter, eggs, buttermilk, and sugar. This version is flavored with sea salt, bittersweet chocolate and cocoa.
Key Lime Whole Pie US$49.50
We squeeze fresh limes to make a creamy tart filling. It's baked into a coconut crust and it's a tropical vacation in a pie shell!
Apple Crumb Whole Pie US$44.00
Contains nuts.
Farm Fresh Pumpkin Whole Pie US$45.00
We roast a variety of locally grown pumpkins and winter squash to make this classic autumn pie.
Eggnog Cheesecake Whole Pie US$60.00
Our light, not-too-sweet cheesecake with a holiday twist. Made with Ronnybrook eggnog and a touch of rum, and baked into a subtly spiced buttery gingerbread crust.
Cheesecake Whole US$52.80
Petee’s cheesecake is exquisite and unique. We use the best cream cheese you can find (Ben’s Cream Cheese from Spring Valley, New York). We scrape real vanilla bean pods and zest fresh oranges to flavor it. Whipped egg whites make the batter light and airy. The crust? It's a crumb crust, but instead of bland graham crackers crumbs, we crumble our famous pie crust and add a little extra butter and sugar. An initial blast of heat gives the cheesecake plenty of height and a rustic, burnished top. (It may have cracks and dark spots- we see these as features, not defects.) Enjoy it with fine company and cup of coffee.
Brown Butter Honey Pecan Whole Pie US$44.00
Instead of the traditional corn syrup, we bake our pecan pie with NY apple blossom honey and organic brown sugar. Browned butter lends an extra layer of flavor.
Nesselrode Whole Pie US$48.00
Nesselrode is an NYC classic. It is a fluffy chestnut custard with rum soaked cherries and dollops of cream on top.

Pies by the Slice
Brown Butter Honey Pecan Slice US$7.98
Instead of the traditional corn syrup, we bake our pecan pie with NY apple blossom honey and organic brown sugar. Browned butter lends an extra layer of flavor.
Eggnog Cheesecake Slice US$10.00
Our light, not-too-sweet cheesecake with a holiday twist. Made with Ronnybrook eggnog and a touch of rum, and baked into a subtly spiced buttery gingerbread crust.
Salty Chocolate Chess Slice US$7.98
Chess pie is a classic southern dish based on some of our favorite ingredients: butter, eggs, buttermilk, and sugar. This version is flavored with sea salt, bittersweet chocolate and cocoa.
Cheesecake Slice US$8.80
Petee’s cheesecake is exquisite and unique. We use the best cream cheese you can find (Ben’s Cream Cheese from Spring Valley, New York). We scrape real vanilla bean pods and zest fresh oranges to flavor it. Whipped egg whites make the batter light and airy. The crust? It's a crumb crust, but instead of bland graham crackers crumbs, we crumble our famous pie crust and add a little extra butter and sugar. An initial blast of heat gives the cheesecake plenty of height and a rustic, burnished top. (It may have cracks and dark spots- we see these as features, not defects.) Enjoy it with fine company and cup of coffee.
Farm Fresh Pumpkin Slice US$7.98
We roast a variety of locally grown pumpkins and winter squash to make this classic autumn pie.
Nesselrode Slice US$8.80
Nesselrode is an NYC classic. It is a fluffy chestnut custard with rum soaked cherries and dollops of cream on top.
Apple Crumb Slice US$7.98
Contains nuts.
NY Sour Cherry Slice US$7.98
We use Montmorency cherries from upstate New York in our Sour Cherry Pie-- and we don't sugarcoat 'em either. We let their vibrant, tart flavor take center stage. Add a scoop of ice cream to this bright red cherry pie and it will really knock your socks off!
Wild Maine Blueberry Slice US$7.98
A fresh and delicious pie made with scrumptious organic wild blueberries from Josh Pond, Maine. Only a quarter cup of sugar in a whole pie to let the natural sweetness and flavor of the blueberries shine through.
Banana Cream Slice US$8.80
Old-fashioned vanilla pudding topped with fresh banana slices and dolloped with whipped cream.
Lavish Chocolate Cream Slice US$8.80
A rich, old-fashioned chocolate pudding made with bittersweet chocolate and cocoa, topped with dollops of fresh whipped cream and real gold leaf-adorned chocolate flakes.
Key Lime Slice US$8.80
We squeeze fresh limes to make a creamy tart filling. It's baked into a coconut crust and it's a tropical vacation in a pie shell!
Gingerbread Slice US$7.98
All the warm and spicy flavors you love in a classic gingerbread, but in the form of a buttery chess pie.
Hudson Valley Apple Slice US$7.98
New York State grows more apple varieties than any other, and our single varietal apple pies are a celebration of classic New York and heirloom varietals. We add just enough sugar and spices to enhance their natural flavor.
Cherry Crumb Slice US$7.98
Contains nuts.
Blueberry Crumb Slice US$7.98
Contains nuts.

Petee’s Pie Company at Gotham West Market Details

Service options
Delivery
Takeaway

Payments
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Petee’s Pie Company at Gotham West Market Photos

Petee’s Pie Company at Gotham West Market Picture 1

Petee’s Pie Company at Gotham West Market Picture 2

Petee’s Pie Company at Gotham West Market Picture 3

Petee’s Pie Company at Gotham West Market Picture 4

Petee’s Pie Company at Gotham West Market Picture 5

Petee’s Pie Company at Gotham West Market Picture 6

Petee’s Pie Company at Gotham West Market Location

Petee’s Pie Company at Gotham West Market

New York New York County New York 11th Avenue

600 11th Ave, New York, NY 10036, USA

Petee’s Pie Company at Gotham West Market Reviews

An average rating of ★4.3 from 29 user reviews.

slicesthanksgivingpackagingappleprice

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Had 2 pies delivered for my daughter’s birthday and she loved them. Chocolate chess and Apple crumb.
April 26 · Summer Shelton
I can’t say enough great things about Petee’s Pies! I ordered two pies for family gatherings this week. One of the pies I received wasn’t what I ordered (understandable during the busy holiday season), their customer service went above and beyond to coordinate delivering the correct pie.There were a few hiccups with the courier, they handled everything so professionally and made sure I got the right pie. It’s rare to find a business that takes this much care to make things right. Plus, their pies are absolutely delicious. I used to work across the street from their Clinton Hill location, and I've had a few slices at their Essex St location. They're always consistent. Highly recommend!
December 24 · Monica Ford
I have to second the comment on stinginess from this location.Ordered several slices and most only fit 2/3 of the packaging whilst the apple pie barely covered 1/3 of the box. For 7.50 a slice you’d think they’d fill the whole of the packaging they chose.As some slices are double the size it’s clear they can cut them larger but chose not to.
November 16 · Sabrina Glinz
Delicious seasonal raspberry pie. It was delivered exactly on time as stated. Great experience.
September 15 · Chet Conklin
I ordered three different pies: sweet potato, key lime, and blueberry apple crumble.Each slice was small, soggy, with little flavor, and salted heavily.The sweet potato slice tasted like water and salt.The meringue, custard, and pie crust of the key lime were heavily salted. Crust had no flavor.The apple blueberry crumble and no cinnamon flavor or typical crumble heartwarming goodness.Waste of $45 bucks.Will not order again.
December 30 · Rachel Danis