Pie, Pie My Darling

Introduction / Overview

For residents of Illinois seeking a truly exceptional and inclusive bakery experience, look no further than Pie, Pie My Darling. Nestled in the vibrant West Town/Ukrainian Village neighborhood of Chicago, this bakery has cultivated a dedicated following that spans far beyond the vegan community. Since its inception in 2014, the bakery has been delighting customers with 100% vegan sweets that are so rich, creative, and indulgent, many patrons are surprised to learn they are completely free of animal products.

Owner Heather Bodine-Lederman, a dedicated vegan for many years, started the business out of a desire for decadent, high-quality vegan desserts that matched the classic treats of her childhood. What began as a local passion project quickly grew into a celebrated institution, recognized by publications and loyal customers alike. The atmosphere is friendly and professional, offering what the owner describes as "sweet treats for the misfit soul," perfectly blending high-quality baking with a fun, unique aesthetic. Whether you're celebrating a major milestone, looking for a satisfying weekend treat, or catering an office dessert bar, this bakery promises an unparalleled experience that is deeply rooted in Chicago's local culinary scene.

The commitment to quality and imaginative flavor combinations, like the popular Cake Flavor Of The Month—such as Red Velvet—has solidified Pie, Pie My Darling’s reputation. Customer reviews frequently highlight the incredible taste and texture of the baked goods, noting that even non-vegans become instant fans. One reviewer, whose husband recently became vegan, mentioned ordering the carrot cake and a chocolate chip cookie and found them "AMAZING" and "super soft," stating they would return even if the dietary need wasn't present. Another customer, hosting a dessert bar for Pride month, noted that the rainbow cakes were a massive hit and that "No one realized they were vegan until after I told them." This consistently high praise underscores the bakery's success in creating universally loved confections.

Location and Accessibility

Pie, Pie My Darling is conveniently situated in Chicago's West Town/Ukrainian Village area, making it an accessible stop for many living in or traveling through the Illinois region. Its address is 2636 W Chicago Ave Suite 1, Chicago, IL 60622, USA. This location offers the benefit of being part of a bustling, creative neighborhood, providing an enjoyable destination for a quick visit or a scheduled pickup.

For local users concerned about accessibility, the establishment ensures a welcoming environment for all patrons by providing a wheelchair-accessible entrance. The bakery operates with specific hours for walk-in availability and pre-order pickups, making it essential for customers to check the current schedule before planning a visit, especially for those making a longer trip. For those utilizing public transportation, the W Chicago Ave corridor provides connectivity to Chicago’s extensive network. For those driving, the location is a straightforward destination within the city grid, though visitors should always be mindful of Chicago's dynamic street parking situation.

Services Offered

• In-store pickup: Conveniently collect pre-ordered whole cakes, pies, and dozen-cupcake orders at the specified location and time slot.
• Takeout: Purchase individual slices of cake, brownies, cookies, and other treats during the limited walk-in hours, perfect for a quick indulgence.
• Onsite services: While primarily focused on pickup and takeout, the bakery provides a direct and friendly service experience during operating hours.
• Whole Cakes and Cupcakes by the Dozen: Pre-order specialty items like the Red Velvet cake or a dozen custom cupcakes for parties and events.
• Individual Treats: Offering a rotating selection of ready-to-eat items such as Cake Slices, Brownies, Pie (available in mini or full-sized options), Cake Jars, Oatmeal Creme Pies, Salted Choc Chip Cookies, Cap´N Crunch Cookies, and Rice Crispy Treats.
• Beverages: Serving fresh Coffee to pair perfectly with any of the sweet treats.

Features / Highlights

• 100% Vegan Baking: Every single item is completely free of animal products, including dairy and eggs, making it a safe and celebrated choice for vegans, those with allergies, and anyone seeking delicious, plant-based options. The results are cakes and treats that consistently satisfy both vegan and non-vegan palates.
• Creative and Decadent Menu: The bakery is known for its inventive flavor profiles and visually stunning designs, often incorporating a fun, sometimes gothic, aesthetic. Beyond the staple Red Velvet cake, the menu features specialty pies, imaginative cookies, and rotating seasonal flavors.
• High-Quality, Scratch-Made Goods: Products are baked fresh from scratch, ensuring a premium taste and texture that defies the outdated stereotype of vegan desserts being dry or flavorless.
• Ease of Payment: The location accepts modern payment methods for a smooth transaction, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.
• Fast Service Model: Optimized for a Quick visit, the bakery’s structure is ideal for locals on the go who need a rapid pickup of their pre-orders or a grab-and-go treat.
• Community Acclaim and Professional Recognition: The bakery’s reputation is built on enthusiastic customer reviews and recognition within the vegan and general food communities, with customers frequently declaring the cakes to be among the best they have ever had.

Contact Information

Address: 2636 W Chicago Ave Suite 1, Chicago, IL 60622, USA

Phone: The primary public phone number for the bakery is not explicitly listed in the core data, but customers are often directed to contact the bakery via online channels (email/website) for detailed pre-order inquiries, and a number is used for easy door access during pickup, as noted by a reviewer.

What is Worth Choosing

For residents of Illinois, choosing Pie, Pie My Darling is an opportunity to support a unique, local Chicago business that has genuinely mastered the art of vegan baking. The key value proposition lies in the bakery's ability to produce desserts that are not just "good for vegan," but are truly spectacular, high-quality cakes and treats by any measure. The commitment to being 100% vegan eliminates the barrier for those with dietary restrictions or ethical preferences without sacrificing flavor or creativity.

Whether it's the rich, moist texture of the Red Velvet cake, the comforting nostalgia of the Brownies, or the surprisingly soft Salted Choc Chip Cookies, the reviews speak volumes. This is the ideal choice for those who want to impress guests (many of whom may never guess the desserts are vegan), celebrate with an unforgettable specialty cake, or simply treat themselves to a delightful afternoon pick-me-up like a Cake Slice or an Oatmeal Creme Pie. Its quick-visit model and dedication to accommodating special orders make it a professional and reliable partner for all your sweet-tooth needs across the Illinois region.

Pie, Pie My Darling

2636 W Chicago Ave Suite 1, Chicago, IL 60622, USA