PieGirl

Introduction / Overview

For New Jersey residents seeking a bakery experience that goes well beyond the ordinary, PieGirl in Hightstown has quickly established itself as a must-visit destination. This small-batch bakery, led by baker Chelsea Frost, is not just a place for dessert; it’s a celebration of local, farm-fresh ingredients translated into remarkably creative and delicious baked goods. PieGirl is renowned for its pies, elevating a classic comfort food into an art form with a constantly rotating menu that features both traditional favorites and unique, seasonal creations.

Operating primarily on Fridays and Saturdays, the anticipation for the weekly menu drop is a local tradition, highlighting the care and limited availability of these handcrafted treats. Customers consistently praise the quality, noting that the products taste genuinely homemade but are elevated by professional skill and inventive flavor combinations. Beyond the signature pies, the bakery offers a satisfying array of other baked goods, including savory items like quiches and fresh bread, making it a perfect weekend stop for a delightful breakfast, a satisfying lunch, or a spectacular dessert. The cozy, inviting atmosphere adds to the charm, creating a welcoming spot in Central Jersey that emphasizes community and the joy of good food.

Location and Accessibility

PieGirl is conveniently located in the quaint, bustling community of Hightstown, New Jersey, making it an accessible spot for customers across Mercer County and the broader Central Jersey area.

The bakery’s physical address is:

117 W Ward St, Hightstown, NJ 08520, USA

This location is designed for customer ease and convenience, especially considering the brisk pace of a weekend rush. Practical amenities are in place to ensure a smooth visit for all patrons. The establishment provides a free parking lot, which is a major benefit in a town setting. Furthermore, the bakery is attentive to accessibility needs, offering a wheelchair-accessible parking lot, ensuring that more members of the community can enjoy their delicious offerings without hindrance. Whether you are running in for a quick cup of coffee or picking up a pre-ordered pie, the location and its facilities support a seamless “Quick visit” experience.

Services Offered

PieGirl is a specialized, high-demand bakery that focuses on exceptional quality and a friendly, streamlined service model during its limited operating hours (Fridays and Saturdays, 10 a.m. until 2:00-ish, or until sold out). The core services are centered on efficient delivery of their small-batch, fresh-baked goods.

• Takeout Service: The primary service model, designed for quick and convenient pickup of all baked goods.
• Specialty Pie Assortment: Offering whole pies and slices of sweet and savory varieties, with flavors changing weekly to reflect seasonal ingredients.
• Savory Baked Goods: A rotating selection of savory items, most notably quiches (including the locally-beloved Pork Roll quiche) and savory galettes.
• Broad Baked Goods Menu: Providing an assortment of non-pie treats every weekend, including cakes, scones, muffins, cookies, cinnamon buns, and fresh focaccia.
• Freshly Baked Sandwiches (Saturdays Only): Offering a limited selection of sandwiches utilizing their freshly baked bread, available starting at 11:30 a.m. on Saturdays.
• Beverage Offerings: Serving Coffee to perfectly complement the sweet and savory baked items, making it an ideal brunch or breakfast stop.
• Payment Options: Accepting modern payment methods including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments for a fast transaction.

Features / Highlights

PieGirl has built a dedicated following across New Jersey due to several distinctive qualities and highly-praised menu items. These highlights are what make the bakery truly special and worth the trip.

• Unique, Farm-Fresh Pies: The core offering, distinguished by inventive, gourmet flavors like Salted Honey Lavender, Sweet Jersey Corn Custard, Cranberry Chess, and Sun Tea Pie. These often feature locally sourced New Jersey ingredients.
• The Savory Selection: Highly-rated savory items, such as the fantastic Pork Roll and Potatoes Quiche, which pay homage to New Jersey’s food heritage and provide a satisfying meal option beyond sweet treats.
• Small-Batch, Handcrafted Quality: The commitment to small-batch baking ensures every item, from the perfect pie crust to the cinnamon roll, is made with attention to detail and real butter, resulting in an elevated homemade taste.
• Exceptional Cinnamon Buns: Customer reviews frequently call the cinnamon roll one of the best they’ve ever had, noting the generous amount of delicious cream cheese frosting.
• Rotating Weekly Menu: The menu is constantly changing, posted online on Thursday and Friday nights, encouraging repeat visits and ensuring customers always have something new and seasonal to try. This keeps the offerings dynamic and fresh.
• Beloved Breakfast and Brunch Items: Beyond pies, the bakery offers delightful breakfast options, such as the highly-praised egg and cheese on toasted brioche with maple aioli, perfect for starting the weekend.
• Convenient Accessibility: The availability of a free parking lot and wheelchair-accessible parking greatly enhances the convenience for customers driving to the location.

Contact Information

For up-to-date information on the weekly menu, operating hours, or to inquire about availability, customers can use the following contact details. Note that the menu is typically posted on social media and the bakery recommends arriving early to secure specific popular items, as they often sell out.

• Address: 117 W Ward St, Hightstown, NJ 08520, USA
• Phone: (609) 833-4243 (Primary)
• Mobile Phone: +1 609-833-4243

What Is Worth Choosing

Choosing PieGirl is a decision to support local craftsmanship and experience the pinnacle of New Jersey’s contemporary baking scene. What makes this bakery truly worth choosing, and what local patrons deeply appreciate, is the dedication to inventive, high-quality baking using ingredients that connect the food directly to the Garden State's seasonal bounty. This is not a mass-production bakery; it is an artisan shop where every pie, quiche, scone, and cinnamon bun is made with passion.

For a local user, the commitment to farm-fresh, creative flavors is the ultimate draw. You can find a standard apple pie, but you’ll also find flavors like Strawberry Rhubarb or Sweet Jersey Corn Custard—pies you simply won't encounter elsewhere. The savory side of the menu is equally compelling, transforming the New Jersey staple of pork roll into a gourmet quiche that has garnered rave reviews. The enthusiasm from other customers, who describe the treats as "delectable delights" that hit "a different and wonderful flavor," affirms that PieGirl consistently delivers an experience that elevates a weekend outing into a culinary event. For the highest quality, most inventive, and freshest baked goods in Central New Jersey, PieGirl is the indisputable local favorite, but remember the golden rule: arrive early on Fridays or Saturdays before they sell out!

PieGirl

117 W Ward St, Hightstown, NJ 08520, USA