Savarese Italian Pastry Shoppe

Savarese Italian Pastry Shoppe is more than just a dessert shop; it's a piece of Brooklyn history. For over a century, this beloved bakery has been a cornerstone of the Bensonhurst neighborhood, serving up authentic, old-world Italian pastries and baked goods to generations of New Yorkers. Established in 1918 by the Savarese family, who brought their traditional baking techniques from Naples, Italy, the shoppe has maintained its commitment to quality and tradition. In 1962, the Giura family took over, and owner and master pastry chef Mario Giura has continued the legacy, ensuring that every item is handcrafted with the finest ingredients and a passion for old-world artistry. Savarese is a place where you can taste the dedication in every bite, from the flaky cannoli to the rich, creamy cheesecakes. It's a destination for locals and a must-visit for anyone seeking a genuine taste of Italian-American heritage.

The bakery’s reputation is built on its unwavering focus on fresh, high-quality products. It's a place that prides itself on creating a wide variety of handmade delicacies, with many recipes passed down through generations. While some customers have experienced mixed results, with some praising the freshness and quality while others have had disappointing experiences, the shoppe remains a local favorite for its dedication to traditional baking. The passionate team, led by Mario, works tirelessly to create a welcoming environment where customers can find everything from a quick espresso and a pastry to a show-stopping cake for a special occasion. Whether you're celebrating a milestone or simply craving a sweet treat, Savarese Italian Pastry Shoppe has become a go-to spot for many in the community.

The shop’s long-standing presence in Bensonhurst speaks to its significance in the community. It has become a symbol of tradition and a gathering place for families. The aroma of freshly baked bread and pastries fills the air, creating an inviting atmosphere that draws you in from the moment you approach the door. The bakery has successfully blended its rich history with a modern approach to customer service, offering a full range of products and even wholesale options to other local businesses. Savarese is more than just a place to buy dessert; it's a place to experience a slice of authentic Italian culture right here in New York.

The dedication of the team at Savarese is evident in the artistry of their creations. Each item, from a simple butter cookie to an elaborate tiered wedding cake, is crafted with meticulous care. The bakery is a testament to the idea that some things are best done the old-fashioned way—by hand, with love, and with a deep respect for tradition. This is the kind of place where you can feel the passion that goes into every dessert, a passion that has been nurtured and passed down through generations.

It is this combination of history, passion, and traditional craftsmanship that sets Savarese Italian Pastry Shoppe apart. The shoppe has not only survived but thrived in a competitive market by staying true to its roots. In a city that is always changing, Savarese remains a constant, a reliable source of delicious, authentic Italian desserts that bring a little bit of old-world charm to the bustling streets of Brooklyn.

The shoppe is located at 5922 New Utrecht Ave in Brooklyn, New York, 11219. Situated on the corner of 60th Street and New Utrecht Avenue, its classic storefront is a familiar sight to locals. For those traveling by public transportation, the bakery is easily accessible. The N train stops at the New Utrecht Avenue station, which is just a short walk away. Several bus lines also service the area, making it a convenient stop whether you're coming from another part of Brooklyn or a different borough. The bustling neighborhood provides a vibrant backdrop for the shoppe, with plenty of other local businesses and attractions nearby.

The location in the heart of Bensonhurst makes it a perfect stop for a treat after a day of shopping or dining in the area. The neighborhood itself is a melting pot of cultures, but Savarese stands out as a beacon of its Italian heritage. The accessibility of the location, combined with the timeless appeal of its products, ensures that the shoppe is a well-loved destination for people from all over the city. Whether you're a lifelong resident or just passing through, Savarese Italian Pastry Shoppe is a can't-miss spot that is easy to get to and well worth the trip.

At Savarese Italian Pastry Shoppe, the menu is a celebration of Italian-American baking traditions. The shop offers a wide array of options to satisfy any sweet tooth.

• Pastries: From classic cannoli with homemade fried shells and fluffy cream to flaky sfogliatelle filled with sweet ricotta and candied fruit, the pastry selection is extensive and authentic. Other popular pastries include lobster tails, rum baba, and a variety of fruit tarts. The bakery's handmade pastries are a testament to traditional techniques and fresh ingredients.

• Cakes: Savarese specializes in both everyday cakes and custom creations. They offer a range of delicious options like New York-style cheesecake, red velvet, tiramisu, and cannoli cake. They also excel at crafting stunning, personalized cakes for special occasions, including custom birthday and wedding cakes. Each cake is a work of art, designed to be the centerpiece of any celebration.

• Cookies and Biscuits: The cookie selection is a major highlight, featuring traditional Italian biscuits and cookies sold by the pound. You'll find classics like pignoli, rainbow cookies, and 'S' cookies with a light touch of cinnamon. These are perfect for holiday platters, parties, or just a sweet treat with your coffee.

• Gelato and Italian Ices: As an authentic Italian shoppe, Savarese offers house-made gelato and Italian ices. Their Italian ices are naturally flavored with real fruit, and the gelato is a creamy, delightful treat. They even offer specialty gelato cakes for a unique dessert experience. The bakery also provides wholesale gelato and Italian ices to local pizzerias and restaurants.

• Coffee and Beverages: To complement their desserts, Savarese serves a selection of beverages, including fresh espresso, cappuccino, and latte, providing the perfect pairing for any pastry. A hot cup of coffee with a fresh cannoli is a quintessential New York experience that many locals cherish.

Savarese Italian Pastry Shoppe has a number of features that make it a standout destination in New York City.

• Generational Recipes: The bakery prides itself on using old-world recipes that have been passed down for generations. This commitment to tradition ensures that the flavors and techniques remain true to their Italian roots, offering an authentic taste that is hard to find elsewhere.

• Handcrafted Quality: Every baked good at Savarese is made by hand on the premises. This hands-on approach allows for a level of quality and attention to detail that mass-produced bakeries simply cannot match. The dedication to this craft is evident in the beautiful and delicious final products.

• Custom Cake Expertise: The shoppe has a reputation for its custom-made cakes, particularly wedding cakes. They work closely with customers to create unique and memorable designs that taste as incredible as they look, making them a go-to choice for life's most important celebrations. The team's passion for their craft is especially apparent in these elaborate creations.

• Wholesale and Catering: In addition to serving individual customers, Savarese provides wholesale products to other businesses and offers catering services for events. Their cookie trays and pastry platters are a popular choice for parties and gatherings, bringing their beloved desserts to a wider audience.

• Local Institution: Having celebrated its 100th anniversary in 2018, Savarese Italian Pastry Shoppe is more than just a bakery; it is a long-standing institution in the Brooklyn community. Its history and longevity are a testament to its enduring quality and the loyalty of its customers.

Address: 5922 New Utrecht Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11219, USA

Phone: (718) 438-7770

For locals in New York, Savarese Italian Pastry Shoppe is a true treasure. It's a place where you can find a piece of the city's rich history and culture, all wrapped up in a perfectly delicious dessert. The shoppe’s commitment to authentic, handcrafted Italian recipes ensures a quality that is unmatched, making it the ideal choice for any occasion, from a simple afternoon coffee break to a major life event. The fact that the bakery has thrived for over a century is a powerful testament to its enduring appeal and the love it receives from the community.

Whether you're celebrating a birthday with a custom cake, bringing home a tray of traditional Italian cookies for a family gathering, or just stopping by for a perfectly fried cannoli, Savarese offers an experience that feels both special and deeply familiar. It's a place that brings people together, where a shared love for delicious pastries creates a sense of community. The team's passion for their craft is a source of pride for the neighborhood, and their dedication to quality makes every visit a rewarding one. In a fast-paced city like New York, Savarese Italian Pastry Shoppe stands out as a place that honors tradition, celebrates community, and consistently delivers an unforgettable taste of old-world Italy.

The mixed reviews from customers, which include both high praise for beautiful and delicious cakes and criticisms of stale products, are a reminder that even long-standing businesses can have off days. However, the overwhelmingly positive sentiment and the shoppe's deep roots in the community suggest that for many New Yorkers, Savarese remains a cherished and reliable source for their dessert needs. It’s a neighborhood staple where you can taste the heritage and feel the passion in every single bite.

Savarese Italian Pastry Shoppe

5922 New Utrecht Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11219, USA