Sunday Supper Bakery

Introduction / Overview

Sunday Supper Bakery is a distinctive culinary establishment in Palm City, Florida, that goes far beyond the traditional definition of a mere Bakery. Founded by Chef Matthew Wasson, this concept is designed to capture the "spirit of Italian gatherings" and the profound comfort of a shared family meal, often associated with a traditional Sunday Supper. While they certainly offer delicious baked goods and desserts, their menu is uniquely centered around gourmet, handmade Italian classics, specifically designed to be dairy-free and highly inclusive without compromising on bold, authentic flavors.

This Palm City gem is less about grabbing a quick pastry and more about sourcing a spectacular, complete meal or dessert for a family celebration or a gathering of friends. The entire operation is rooted in tradition but delivered with modern, health-conscious ingenuity. Their offerings range from savory, Nonna-approved Italian dishes to an array of delectable homemade desserts, ensuring they serve as a one-stop-shop for creating an unforgettable, immersive culinary experience right here in the Florida community. They aim to make every meal feel like a special occasion, characterized by "long tables, loud conversations, and plates that just keep coming."

Location and Accessibility

Sunday Supper Bakery is conveniently situated in Palm City, positioning it as an accessible resource for gourmet meals and desserts for residents throughout Martin County and the surrounding Florida area.

The exact location is:

5303 SW Leighton Farm Ave, Palm City, FL 34990, USA

This address places the business within a local hub, making it easy for customers to drive to and collect their pre-ordered items or prepared meals.

While the facility's main operations focus on the preparation of specialty foods, the physical location offers essential conveniences for the community, including a Wheelchair accessible parking lot. This feature ensures that all customers, regardless of mobility needs, can easily access the location to pick up their orders for their next gathering. Because the business emphasizes custom and specialty items, it is recommended that local customers verify service details and operating hours directly before visiting.

Services Offered

Sunday Supper Bakery offers a unique suite of services that blends the high-quality standards of gourmet Italian cooking with the flexibility and indulgence of a specialty bakery, catering to both everyday needs and grand celebrations across the Treasure Coast.

The key services provided by this distinct Palm City establishment include:

• Gourmet Prepared Meals: Specializing in ready-to-eat or easy-to-heat savory Italian meals, available in both individual and Family Size portions, perfect for weeknight dinners or large gatherings.
• Specialty Italian Dishes: Offering a unique focus on Nonna-approved, dairy-free versions of classic recipes, such as Italian Sausage Lasagna, Three Cheeses Lasagna, Eggplant Parm, and Fusi alla Vodka.
• Inclusive & Allergen-Conscious Cooking: A major service feature is the commitment to dairy-free preparation, often utilizing high-quality plant-based ingredients like Elmhurst creamy oatmilk and Abbott's plant protein to ensure flavor without compromise.
• Artisanal Baked Goods: Providing classic bakery items, including homemade desserts, specialty pastries, and comfort treats like challah, chocolate chip cookies, pies (such as banana cream pie, blackberry crumble pie), and seasonal desserts.
• Weekly / Rotating Menus: Operating with an ever-changing menu that features different comfort foods and international influences, such as "Heat wave tacos," Mediterranean spreads, and special seafood dishes, ensuring variety for regular customers.
• Catering & Event Planning: Though not explicitly listed as a service option, the name and concept strongly suggest the ability to supply food and desserts for events, aligning with the "Sunday Supper" philosophy of communal dining.
• Online Ordering/Pickup: Based on their product presentation and focus on prepared foods, their service model likely involves easy online or phone ordering for collection, prioritizing customer convenience.

Features / Highlights

Sunday Supper Bakery is defined by its innovative approach to traditional comfort food, offering features that cater directly to the modern Florida patron looking for quality, convenience, and inclusive dining options.

• Fearless, Dairy-Free Italian Comfort Food: The most distinguishing highlight is their success in crafting Nonna-approved Italian classics that are entirely dairy-free. They use high-quality plant-based alternatives to achieve creamy, rich flavors in dishes like lasagna and vodka sauce, removing the compromise often associated with inclusive dining.
• Focus on Tradition and Celebration: The bakery’s entire brand is built around the feeling of a shared, celebratory "Sunday Supper," encouraging a sense of community, with every dish rooted in tradition and meant to be shared.
• Gourmet Quality Prepared Meals: Customers can purchase chef-crafted meals, simplifying the process of serving a high-end, complex dinner at home without spending hours in the kitchen—a huge convenience for busy Florida families.
• Diverse Dessert Selection: Beyond the savory meals, the bakery offers a rotating, robust selection of freshly baked desserts, ranging from pies and crumbles to gourmet cookies and scones, ensuring the sweet portion of the meal is just as memorable.
• Menu Adaptability: The bakery constantly introduces new and unique menu items, from different cultural influences (tacos, Mediterranean) to seasonal desserts (peach galette, strawberry shortcake), keeping the offerings fresh and engaging for repeat customers.

Contact Information

For Florida users in Palm City, Stuart, and the greater Martin County area interested in ordering gourmet prepared meals or specialty baked goods for their family gatherings, the location of Sunday Supper Bakery is:

• Address: 5303 SW Leighton Farm Ave, Palm City, FL 34990, USA

Customers are encouraged to check the bakery’s current weekly menu and service hours online or call directly to inquire about placing an order, especially for their famous lasagna or any specialized baked items.

What is Worth Choosing

Sunday Supper Bakery is an outstanding choice for the Florida resident seeking a meal or dessert that combines gourmet preparation with unparalleled convenience and dietary consciousness. What is most worth choosing about this establishment is its unique specialization in making dairy-free Italian meals taste authentic and deeply satisfying. If you or someone in your family has dietary restrictions but still craves the rich, complex flavors of classic comfort food like lasagna, this bakery/kitchen offers a no-compromise solution.

Beyond the excellent inclusivity, the business model solves a significant problem for modern Florida living: the desire for an elevated, home-cooked meal without the extensive preparation time. By offering Family Size portions of chef-prepared dishes and a rotating selection of fresh, homemade baked goods, Sunday Supper Bakery allows patrons to host a memorable, celebratory meal—a true "Sunday Supper"—any day of the week with minimal effort. It’s an investment in quality time and quality food, making it the premier choice in Palm City for those who value tradition, flavor, and convenience equally.

Sunday Supper Bakery

5303 SW Leighton Farm Ave, Palm City, FL 34990, USA