The Bagel Nook: Exploring Unique Bagel Flavors in Princeton, NJ

The Bagel Nook Introduce

For residents of Princeton, New Jersey, and beyond, who are on the hunt for a bagel experience that goes beyond the ordinary, The Bagel Nook has established itself as a destination for creativity and innovation in the world of bagels. In a state where bagels are practically a religion, The Bagel Nook stands out for its audacious approach to flavors and toppings, aiming to deliver a unique twist on this beloved staple. As professional content writers specializing in local business SEO, we understand the importance of highlighting businesses that offer distinct experiences to their community. The Bagel Nook, with its bold flavor combinations and wide array of options, certainly provides a memorable, if sometimes debated, take on the classic New Jersey bagel.

The Bagel Nook is renowned for its expansive and often experimental menu, particularly its "fun" and unique bagel flavors and an equally impressive selection of "overload" cream cheeses. While the foundation remains a traditional bagel, the creativity truly shines in their inventive combinations, aiming to offer something for every palate, from the purist to the adventurous eater. Beyond just bagels and schmears, they also provide breakfast sandwiches, aiming to be a comprehensive stop for morning meals. The establishment strives to offer a diverse selection that stands out in the competitive New Jersey bagel market. While customer experiences with service and certain flavor profiles can vary, The Bagel Nook's commitment to pushing the boundaries of bagel creativity remains a core part of its identity, offering a memorable and distinct option for those seeking something different in their daily bagel routine.

The Bagel Nook is conveniently located at 301 N Harrison St, Princeton, NJ 08540, USA. This address places it within a prominent and accessible area of Princeton, making it a viable destination for residents throughout the town and its surrounding communities. North Harrison Street is a well-known thoroughfare in Princeton, ensuring relatively easy navigation for those traveling by car. For customers driving to The Bagel Nook, parking availability in the vicinity is generally manageable, allowing for a reasonably convenient stop to pick up orders or enjoy a quick bite. Being situated in Princeton means it’s part of a vibrant and educated community, often leading to a discerning clientele. While public transportation might have specific routes serving this area, the primary mode of transport for many in this part of New Jersey is by personal vehicle. Its location within a commercial hub ensures that it is easily integrated into daily routines and weekend excursions for locals seeking their bagel fix.

The Bagel Nook specializes in offering a highly diversified and often inventive menu centered around bagels and their accompaniments. Their services cater to both traditional preferences and those seeking unique culinary experiences.

Extensive Bagel Flavor Selection: They offer a vast array of bagel flavors, ranging from classic "normal" options to highly innovative and "fun" creations. This includes specialty bagels like the "Jalapeno Cheddar Hot Cheetos bagel" and "Cookie Monster Overload" bagel, designed to push the boundaries of traditional bagel experiences.
"Overload" Cream Cheese Spreads: The Bagel Nook is famous for its wide variety of unique cream cheese "schmears" that often incorporate candies, cereals, and other unexpected ingredients, designed to complement their specialty bagels.
Breakfast Sandwiches: They provide a selection of breakfast sandwiches, allowing customers to choose their favorite bagel or roll with various egg, cheese, and meat combinations.
Coffee and Beverages: A range of coffee and other beverages are available to complete the breakfast or snack experience.
Custom Orders and Catering: While not explicitly detailed, the nature of their diverse offerings suggests the potential for custom orders or larger quantities for events, given the unique bagel and cream cheese combinations.
Dine-In and Take-Out Options: Customers can typically choose to eat at available seating within the shop or opt for convenient take-out service for on-the-go enjoyment.

The Bagel Nook distinguishes itself through several key features and highlights that have shaped its unique identity in the competitive New Jersey bagel market, drawing in customers eager for something different.

Innovative and "Fun" Bagel Flavors: This is arguably their most defining feature. The Bagel Nook is known for its highly creative and unconventional bagel flavors, such as the Jalapeno Cheddar Hot Cheetos bagel and Cookie Monster Overload, which aim to provide a novel experience.
Expansive "Overload" Cream Cheese Selection: Complementing their unique bagels, the vast and often indulgent array of specialty cream cheese "schmears" is a major draw, allowing for highly customized and adventurous flavor combinations.
Strong Bagel Base: Despite varied feedback on the "fun" flavors, there is an acknowledgment from some long-time customers that their underlying bagels are fundamentally "great" and "awesome," indicating a solid foundation for their more experimental offerings.
Commitment to Variety: The sheer number of options ensures that customers have plenty to explore, making each visit potentially a new flavor adventure.
High Recognition for Uniqueness: The Bagel Nook has gained significant attention for its distinct approach to bagels, standing out in a crowded market by offering something truly different.

For those in Princeton, New Jersey, and the surrounding areas eager to experience the unique and diverse offerings of The Bagel Nook, here is their contact information:

Address: 301 N Harrison St, Princeton, NJ 08540, USA
Phone: (609) 356-0370
Mobile Phone: +1 609-356-0370

The Bagel Nook presents a unique proposition that makes it suitable for locals in New Jersey, particularly those in the Princeton area, albeit with certain expectations. Its primary appeal lies in its audacious and extensive array of "fun" bagel flavors and "overload" cream cheeses. For residents who are tired of the conventional bagel offerings and are looking for an adventurous and Instagram-worthy culinary experience, The Bagel Nook fills this niche perfectly. It caters to a demographic that enjoys trying new, creative, and sometimes unusual food combinations, making it a novel destination for weekend treats or a spontaneous indulgence.

While some feedback suggests that the "fun" flavors might not always live up to their imaginative names for every palate, and customer service can sometimes be perceived as transactional, the inherent concept of The Bagel Nook provides a distinct value. For locals, it represents a place where the beloved New Jersey bagel is reimagined, offering a talking point and a unique item to bring to gatherings. The very act of offering such a wide variety means there's always something to pique curiosity. Therefore, for those who value novelty, extensive choice, and a memorable departure from the traditional, The Bagel Nook remains a highly suitable and intriguing local option, providing a unique facet to Princeton's diverse food scene.

The Bagel Nook Food & drink

Sandwiches & Wraps
The Stallion US$16.00
House Made Roast Beef topped with arugula, hot cherry peppers, provolone cheese, and horseradish aioli on a fresh Artisan Hero
Chicken Caesar Wrap US$14.00
Fresh romaine lettuce, grilled chicken, parmesan cheese, 'croutons, tossed in our Caesar dressing.
The Manhattan US$15.00
Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers and balsamic glaze.
BLT US$14.00
Bacon, lettuce, and tomato.
Kickin Chicken US$14.99
Boars Head Ever Roast Chicken topped with lettuce, tomato, Cheddar cheese, bacon, and house made jalapeno ranch on a fresh Artisan hero
The American Honey US$18.00
House Made Chicken Cutlets pilled high with lettuce, tomato, swiss cheese, bacon, and honey mustard on a fresh Artisan hero
The Soprano US$18.00
House made Chicken Cutlets piled high with Arugula, Fresh Mozzarella, Prosciutto, and Balsamic Drizzle on a fresh Artisan Hero
The Classic US$14.00
Turkey, roast beef, cole slaw and russian dressing.
Turkey Club US$15.00
Sliced turkey, bacon, lettuce, and tomato.
The Reuben US$15.00
Hot pastrami piled high with sauerkraut, melted swiss, on grilled rye bread, with russian dressing.
The Italian US$14.00
Ham, salami, provolone, lettuce, tomato, o&v.
Heavenly Ham US$14.00
Sliced ham and melted swiss with a dijon aioli.

Overloads
Chocolate Fudge Overload US$10.99
A chocolate lovers dream! Cocoa puff bagel, fudge brownie cream cheese on both sides, and crushed brownies in the middle.
Oreo Overload US$10.99
Oreo bagel, witour delicious Oreo cream cheese, and Oreo cookies in the middle.
Cookie Monster Overload US$10.99
Oreo bagel with cookie monster cream cheese, Oreos, and chocolate chip cookies.
Fruity Pebble Overload US$10.99
Light and fluffy fruity pebble bagel with birthday cake cream cheese and freshly sliced strawberries in the middle.
Coco Puff Overload US$10.99
Cocoa puff bagel, Nutella cream cheese on both sides and freshly sliced bananas in the middle.
Cannoli Donut Overload. US$12.00
Cannoli french toast bagel, cannoli cream cheese, and a cannoli donut.
Sugar Cookie Overload. US$10.99
Tye dye bagel, sugar cookie cream cheese, sugar cookies, and sprinkles.
Dorito Overload US$10.99
Dorito bagel with jalapeno cheddar cream cheese on both sides, and Doritos in the middle.
Triple Chocolate Chunk Overload US$10.99
Chocolate chip bagel, M&M cream cheese on both sides and chocolate chip cookies in the middle.
The Elvis US$12.00
Ooey gooey french toast bagel, with peanut butter swirl cream cheese on both sides, freshly sliced bananas and crispy bacon in the middle.
Crumb Cake Overload US$10.99
French toast bagel, with crumb cake cream cheese on both sides, and a piece of crumb cake in the middle.
Blueberry Crumb Overload US$10.99
Blueberry french toast bagel, blueberry crumb cream cheese on both sides, with crumb cake in the middle.
Cookie Dough Overload US$10.99
Cocoa puff bagel, with cookie dough cream cheese on both sides, and chocolate chip cookies in the middle.
Flaming Hot Cheetos Overload US$10.99
Flaming hot cheetos bagel with ghost pepper cream cheese and flaming hot cheetos in the middle.

Pancakes & French Toast
Fruity Pebble French Toast US$15.00
Challah bread dipped in our secret batter and encrusted with fruity pebbles with a vanilla drizzle!.
Chocolate Chip Pancakes US$14.00
Delicious fluffy pancakes, studded with irresistible chocolate chips.
Joe's Berries & Chocolate US$15.00
Chocolate chip pancakes topped with freshly sliced strawberries and chocolate chips.
Golden Brown Pancakes US$13.00
A stack of buttery pancakes, typically includes syrup on the side.
Short Stack Cakes (2) US$10.00
2 pieces.
Stuffed French Toast US$15.00
Challah French toast stuffed with sweetened cream cheese and fresh strawberries.
Crazy Chocolate Chip French Toast US$15.00
Challah French toast stuffed with Nutella and sliced bananas.
French Toast US$13.00
Three pieces of homemade challah bread dipped in our secret batter.
Chunky Monkey US$15.00
Three golden brown pancakes topped with freshly sliced banana and crunchy granola.
Blueberry Pancakes US$15.00
Fresh blieberries within delicious, fluffy pancakes

Salad Sandwiches
Veggie Tuna US$13.99
Veggie tuna sandwich with a variety of bagel options including plain, egg, sesame, and unique flavors like blueberry, chocolate chip, and jalapeno cheddar; also available on white or wheat bread/wrap.
Egg Salad US$8.99
Choose from a vast selection of bagels or bread, with options like everything, sesame, pumpernickel, or unique choices like tye-dye and flamin' hot cheeto. pair with coleslaw, macaroni salad, or a variety of chips.
Chicken Salad US$12.99
Chicken salad on choice of bagels (including plain, multigrain, various flavored bagels, and more) or breads (white, wheat) and wraps, with side options of coleslaw, macaroni, or potato salad.
Whitefish Salad US$15.99
Whitefish salad sandwich with options for bagels including plain, egg varieties, flavors like blueberry, cinnamon, savory options like jalapeno cheddar, plus wraps and traditional breads.
Tuna Salad US$13.99
Tuna salad sandwich with diverse bagel options including plain, egg varieties, sesame, and themed flavors like blueberry or jalapeño cheddar. Also available on kaiser roll, white, or wheat.
Spicy Chicken Salad US$13.99
menu description chicken salad with a spicy kick. choice of numerous bagel flavors or bread, including gluten-free and wraps. pair with coleslaw, macaroni salad, or variety of chips.

From the Grill
SouthWest Inside Out Grilled Cheese US$13.00
Jalapeno Cheddar Bagel, Mozzarella, Pepper Jack Cheese, Bacon, Bacon, Bacon and More Bacon
Grilled Cheese US$6.99
Add extras for an additional charge.
3 Cheese Grilled Cheese US$11.00
A perfect blend of cheddar, pepper jack and muenster.
Chicken Fingers & Fries US$14.00
Crispy golden chicken tenders served with a side of delectably seasoned fries.
Cheese Quesadilla US$9.00
Add chicken for an additional cost.
Cajun Chicken Sandwich US$15.00
Tender grilled chicken breast with Cajun seasonings, topped with crispy bacon, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayo.
Philly Cheese Steak US$15.00
Thinly sliced beef sauteed with mushrooms and onions topped with melted cheese.
French Fries US$6.99
Crispy golden strips of deliciousness served hot and seasoned to perfection.
Chicken Ranch Wrap US$13.50
Crispy chicken, with bacon, Vermont cheddar, lettuce, tomato, onion, and a ranch drizzle.
Buffalo Chicken Wrap US$14.00
Breaded chicken tossed in our blazing buffalo sauce with melted Vermont cheddar, crispy lettuce, and ranch dressing.

Breakfast Sandwiches
Generously Genoa US$12.00
Thinly sliced salami grilled with two eggs and cheese.
Avocado Blast US$15.00
Eggs, and pepper jack cheese, double hash brown and avocado with lettuce and tomato.
Double Nooker US$15.00
The ultimate triple decker breakfast sandwich. Bacon egg and cheese sandwiched under a porkroll egg and cheese.
The Popeye US$15.00
Eggwhites with spinach, grilled turkey and swiss.
Meat And Cheese US$10.00
Choose from a variety of bread including bagels like sesame, multigrain, or cinnamon raisin, and other options like kaiser roll or wheat wrap. Served with meat and cheese.
Sausage And Egg Sandwich US$13.00
Add hash browns for an additional charge.
Pork Roll & Egg Sandwich US$13.00
Add hash browns for an additional charge.
Bacon & Egg Sandwich US$13.00
Add hash browns for an additional charge.
2 Eggs & Cheese US$9.00
Two eggs and cheese on your choice of bread, ranging from various bagels like plain, multigrain, and unique flavors to wraps and classic white or wheat bread.
2 Eggs Sandwich US$7.50
Two eggs prepared your way, nestled in a choice of bagels including classic, savory, sweet flavors, wraps, or breads. variety spans from plain to jalapeno cheddar, even maple bacon.
Steak N' Cheese US$14.00
Two eggs with sautéed sliced steak and provolone.
Juevos Burrito US$13.00
Scrambled eggs with onions, jack cheese, sausage, avocado and salsa in a wrap.
Just Meat US$8.00
Breakfast sandwich with choice of meat on assorted bagels, including specialty flavors like jalapeno cheddar and maple bacon, or traditional wraps and bread.
Turkey Bacon & Egg Sandwich US$13.00
Add hash browns for an additional charge.

Egg Breakfast Platters & Omelets
3 Eggs Platter US$9.99
Scrambled.
Western Omelet US$16.00
Three eggs with shaved ham, peppers and onions.
Very Veggie Omelet US$16.00
Eggwhites with sauteed mushrooms, spinach, tomato, and onion.
The Porker US$16.00
Shaved ham, chopped bacon, and cheddar.
Cheese Omelet US$15.00
Three eggs with your choice of cheese.
Leo US$18.00
Three eggs fresh lox and onions.
Southwestern US$16.00
Three eggs with peppers, ham, and pepper jack cheese.
Greek Omelet US$16.00
Three eggs with spinach, tomato, onion and feta.

Panini
Grilled Chicken Panini US$13.99
Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, and balsamic glaze.
Caliclub Panini US$13.99
Sliced turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato and avocado.
Spicy Chicken Panini US$13.99
Pulled chicken in a spicy sauce topped with jack cheese, lettuce, tomato, and ranch dressing.
Caprese Panini US$10.99
Fresh mozzarella, and fresh tomatoes, with a pesto spread pressed on our hot panini griddle.
BBQ Chicken Panini US$13.99
Chicken breast in our zesty BBQ sauce, grilled onions and jack cheese.
The Jersey Boy US$13.99
Hot roast beef, sauteed onions, and provolone, with a horseradish aioli.

Chips and Drinks
Naked US$6.00
Blue Machine, Green Machine, Strawberry Banana, Red Machine
Core Power US$5.50
An energizing beverage designed to support your energy needs, typically includes a blend of vitamins and nutrients.
Nesquik US$4.00
Chocolate Milk, Strawberry
Dr Pepper US$4.00
Dr pepper diet dr. pepper
Chips US$3.75
Selection of chips including Dorito Cool Ranch, Cheetos, various Lays flavors, White Cheddar Popcorn, Kettle Cooked Jalapeño, Fritos Original, and Sweet Maui Onion.
Water US$3.00
Clear, refreshing bottled water.
Soda US$4.00
Assorted sodas: Coke, Coke Zero, Diet Coke, Sprite, Fanta Orange.
Tropicana US$4.00
No pulp, Some Pulp,
Sprite US$4.00
Sprite
Vitamin Water US$4.00
XXX, Orange, Tropical Mango
Snapple US$4.00
Lemon,Diet Lemon, Raspberry, Diet Raspberry, Peach, Diet Peach, Orange, 1/2 &1/2

Bagels & Spreads
Bagel & Butter US$4.00
Choose from a vast selection of bagels, including plain, whole grain varieties, and unique flavors like Oreo or jalapeno cheddar. Paired with butter options from garlic herb to siracha honey.
6 Assorted Bagels US$13.00
6 Assorted Classic Bagels
1/2 Pound Plain Cream Cheese US$7.00
A 1/2 pound of our freshly prepared plain cream cheese, ready to complement any bagel of your choice.
12 Assorted Bagels & 1 Pound Cream Cheese US$34.00
12 Assorted Classic Bagels Accompanied with 1 pound of Plain Cream Cheese
1 Pound Plain Cream Cheese US$12.00
House-whipped plain cream cheese, typically enjoyed with a variety of bagels.
Bagel & Cream Cheese US$5.50
Get any spreads and bagels. VEGAN CREAM CHEESE AVAILABLE
1 Pound Scallion Cream Cheese US$13.00
Scallion cream cheese, freshly whipped, infused with chopped scallions, prepared for spreading.
1/2 Pound Veggie Cream Cheese US$8.00
Cream cheese blended with a variety of fresh vegetables.
Bagels, Cream Cheese & Jelly US$5.99
Choice of bagels ranging from plain to inventive flavors like Oreo and flaming hot Cheeto. Paired with cream cheese options, including vegan and unique blends like cannoli and ghost pepper.
12 Assorted Bagel US$24.00
12 Assorted Classic Bagels
1/2 PoundScallion Cream Cheese US$8.00
A half-pound of cream cheese blended with chopped scallions, ready to accompany your favorite bagels.
1 Pound Veggie Cream Cheese US$13.00
Whipped cream cheese blended with a variety of fresh vegetables.
6 Assorted Bagels & 1/2 Pound Cream Cheese US$21.00
6 Assorted classic bagels accompanied with a 1/2 pound of plain cream cheese
Bagels & Jelly US$4.75
Choice of bagel served with jelly. Options include plain, egg, several everything varieties, assorted flavors like blueberry, chocolate chip, and unique blends like flaming hot cheeto, among others.

Truck Sandwiches
Big Daddy US$11.50
Cheesesteak, chicken tenders, mozzarella sticks, French fries, lettuce, tomato, ketchup and mayo.
The Wrecker US$11.50
Cheesesteak, chicken tenders, mozzarella sticks, bacon, and more bacon.
The Promise Land US$11.50
Chicken tenders, mozzarella sticks, bacon, cheese, French fries and hot sauce.
The Mother Clucker US$11.50
Cheesesteak, chicken tenders, bacon, egg, lettuce, tomato, French fries, mayo and ketchup.
The Captain US$11.50
Chicken tenders, mozzarella sticks, onion rings, with BBQ sauce.

Deli Sandwiches
Pastrami US$9.99
Thick-cut pastrami layered in your choice of over 30 bagels or breads, including unique flavors like dorito or jalapeno cheddar.
Oven Gold Turkey US$9.99
Oven gold turkey sandwich with a choice of various bagels, including plain, multigrain, flavored, or wraps. Options also include specialty bagels like jalapeno cheddar and maple bacon.
Homemade Roast Beef US$9.99
Homemade roast beef sandwich with over twenty bread options, including various bagels, flats, wraps, and rolls; classic, sweet, and spicy flavors available.
Genoa Salami US$7.50
Genoa salami on bagel or bread. choose from an extensive variety of bagel options or wraps including savory, sweet, and unique flavors like tie dye, smores, and jalapeno cheddar.

The Bagel Nook Details

Service options
Delivery
In-store pick-up
On-site services
Takeaway
Dine-in

Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Breakfast

Amenities
Toilet

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Parking
Free parking lot

The Bagel Nook Photos

The Bagel Nook Location

The Bagel Nook

New Jersey Mercer County Princeton North Harrison Street

301 N Harrison St, Princeton, NJ 08540, USA

The Bagel Nook Reviews

An average rating of ★4 from 495 user reviews.

avocadocheetosflavorsveganhash brownghost peppercannolicookie monsterthe menudonuts

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

I have always enjoyed The Bagel Nook since it’s opening. I will always give a great two thumbs up to their bagels. They have a great bagel and many great options to go on the bagel. Recently the breakfast sandwiches have been far less desirable as they once were and twice now the bagels were overdone giving the bagel a much harder chew. What I have been most disappointed in is the customer service they now provide. It’s more like the Seinfeld episode on soup. Next! I went today and the gentleman who waited on me which I think is a manger or someone in the know basically took my order asked me if I wanted a receipt and started taking the next order. Never once in the transaction was there a how’s your day going or maybe even a hello or thanks for coming. Nothing. I was just a transaction. I wish I had gotten the name of the young man that gave me my bagel because he at least smiled and said have a nice day. Customer Service has definitely declined from when it first opened. I will still say the bagels are awesome but I do have options to go to another bagel place where I know I will be thanked for my patronage.
April 09 · P G
Bagels + schmears are mediocre at best.The “fun” flavors fail to live up to their names. One of my friends ordered a Jalapeno Cheddar Hot Cheetos bagel and was confused when it didn’t taste like cheetos. I felt the same about the Cookie Monster Overload. You’d think a bagel stuffed with cookies would be cloying but it tasted…bland? I was left questioning how the sum could be less than its parts. The cream cheese was oddly salty too in a way that didn’t work with the rest of the bagel.The “normal” flavors are ok but can’t compete with almost every other spot I’ve tried in NJ / NYC (15+).
April 09 · Denalia
Fine establishment. Friendly staff, good coffee, good bagels, it's all fine. What's not fine are the outrageous prices lately. THIRTEEN DOLLARS for a bacon egg and cheese on a bagel? Are you fckin kidding me? I love their food, but the pricing is so out of control I can't even go here anymore. Hopefully they bring it down to something more reasonable and maybe I'll start going back, but for now I'll look elsewhere for bagels and sandwiches in the princeton area.Edit: went back today to give them another chance, because I was hungry and desperate. Not only did they screw up the order again (see attached), but the coffee was bland. Don't support this place until they get their act together.
May 05 · George H
I enjoyed the bagel. Very light cream cheese. Chocolate chip bagel was really good. The cream cheese is piled on which is great especially cuz its a light taste to it. I will go again.
June 15 · Thomas Woodward
An awesome place to get breakfast and drinks. I enjoyed the food and found it to be very delicious. I did have two hiccups with my visit. The lady taking my order was very grumpy and didn’t have a good customer service. She also ordered me the wrong sandwich. But the issue was fixed and the food was delicious. So I can’t really knock just because of one miserable employee.
February 04 · Kevin Manrique