The Nerdy Baker LLC Introduce
The Nerdy Baker LLC, located in Rumford, Rhode Island, is a local bakery that has garnered a reputation for its distinct and flavorful baked goods. The business has been a topic of conversation among community members, with a mix of feedback that highlights both its culinary strengths and its challenges with customer service. On the one hand, the bakery is celebrated for its delicious products. A customer who attended a local event, the "RI food fights cupcake wars," praised the banana pudding and s'mores cupcakes, noting that they were "super moist and flavorful." The bakery's pizza strips also received a positive mention for having the "perfect amount of sauce." This kind of positive feedback on the products themselves is a testament to the quality of the baking and the flavors offered. The moistness of the cupcakes and the balanced flavor of the pizza strips suggest that the bakery has a strong foundation in its craft. The bakery's products are clearly capable of making a strong impression and have earned it a following of people who enjoy its unique offerings. However, the customer experience at The Nerdy Baker has been a point of contention for some patrons. The provided reviews reveal a pattern of communication and service issues that have caused significant frustration. One long-time customer, who had been a patron since the bakery first opened, shared a detailed account of their experiences. They noted that while the product itself is great, the service "leaves something to be desired." A specific instance involved a birthday cake order for the customer's wife, which, on the day of pickup, had not been started, despite a pre-arranged plan. The customer let this go, understanding that things can happen. However, a later attempt to order a birthday cake for their daughter proved to be the final straw. The customer and his wife had questions about the order and asked to speak with the owner, who would be handling the cake. They were repeatedly told by a staff member that the owner was "too busy" to speak with them. The staff member's inability to answer their questions and the repeated deflection led to a frustrating and ultimately unsuccessful attempt to place the order. This experience left the customer feeling that their time was not valued and that the business was not willing to accommodate a potential sale. The customer concluded that they would not be returning to the establishment, regardless of how good the product is. This kind of feedback is a critical piece of information for potential customers, as it shows that a business's success is not solely dependent on the quality of its products but also on the quality of its service and communication. The dichotomy between the deliciousness of the products and the reported poor customer service creates a complex picture of The Nerdy Baker LLC. It suggests that while the culinary talent is there, the operational side of the business may be inconsistent, leading to a potential for both great experiences and deeply disappointing ones. This is a crucial point for anyone in the Rhode Island community to consider before engaging with the bakery.
The Nerdy Baker LLC is located at 237 Newman Ave, Rumford, RI 02916, USA. This address places the bakery in a residential and commercial area of Rumford, a village within the town of East Providence. Its location on Newman Avenue is a key detail for residents, as it makes the bakery a familiar and accessible spot for local patrons. For those in the wider Rhode Island region, Rumford is a well-known area, making the bakery a viable destination for anyone willing to make the trip. The accessibility of the location itself is straightforward, but the operational aspects of the business affect the overall customer experience. As a local bakery, its location is convenient for those living nearby, but the reported issues with customer service and communication mean that a physical visit may not always be a successful one. The address is the point of contact for the business, but the journey to and from the bakery is colored by the quality of the service received. The ease of access to the physical building is a benefit, but the emotional accessibility—the feeling of being welcomed and valued as a customer—is where the bakery, according to some reviews, falls short. The business's location on Newman Avenue is a fixed point, but the customer's perception of that point is in flux. The fact that the bakery is situated in a known part of Rumford means that it is a part of the community, but the negative reviews suggest that its relationship with that community is not always as strong as it could be. The physical location is a simple address, but the business's reputation at that address is a complex tapestry of both praise for its products and frustration with its service. The ease of getting to the bakery is a positive, but the potential for a negative interaction once you are there is a significant risk for potential patrons. The location is a convenient starting point for a customer journey that, for some, has ended in disappointment and a decision not to return. This is a crucial detail for anyone in the Rhode Island region to be aware of when considering a visit.
Based on the provided information, the services offered by The Nerdy Baker LLC are focused on providing a variety of baked goods, particularly cupcakes and pizza strips. Their services include:
- The sale of cupcakes, with flavors like banana pudding and s'mores being noted for being "super moist and flavorful."
- The sale of pizza strips, which have been praised for having a "perfect amount of sauce."
- The creation of custom cakes for special events, such as birthdays and baby showers. A specific example is a baby shower cake that came out "beautifully and everything was perfect."
- The ability to handle special orders, but with a potential for communication breakdowns and logistical issues, as highlighted by a customer's experience with a birthday cake order.
- An in-store experience where customers can ask questions about their orders, although the responsiveness of the staff and owner has been a point of contention.
The features and highlights of The Nerdy Baker LLC are a mix of product quality and service-related issues. These include:
- Delicious and high-quality baked goods, with cupcakes and pizza strips receiving high praise for their taste, flavor, and texture.
- The ability to create beautiful and perfect custom cakes, as evidenced by a baby shower cake that was a complete success.
- A creative and unique product line, as demonstrated by the flavors of the cupcakes and the presence of pizza strips.
- A reputation for poor customer service and communication, with the owner allegedly being "too busy" to speak with customers and staff providing unhelpful answers.
- A lack of value for customer time, which is a major factor in customer dissatisfaction.
- The business's participation in local events like "RI food fights cupcake wars," which shows its presence in the community.
- The unfortunate loss of long-time, loyal customers due to ongoing service-related issues.
For more information, you can contact The Nerdy Baker LLC directly. The address is 237 Newman Ave, Rumford, RI 02916, USA. They can be reached by phone at (401) 414-7606. These contact details provide a clear way for customers to reach out to the business. However, based on the public reviews, it is advisable for potential customers to be very clear and persistent with their orders and to perhaps check on the status of their orders ahead of time to avoid potential issues with communication and preparedness. The contact information is a starting point, but the follow-through and communication from the business have been reported as inconsistent.
In conclusion, The Nerdy Baker LLC is a suitable choice for locals in the Rhode Island region who are primarily seeking delicious and unique baked goods, particularly cupcakes and pizza strips. The products themselves have a strong reputation for being moist, flavorful, and of high quality. However, potential customers should be aware of the recurring issues with customer service and communication that have been reported. For those who prioritize a smooth and responsive ordering process, the bakery may not be the ideal fit. The business’s strengths lie in its culinary creations, but its weaknesses are in its operational and relational aspects. For locals who are willing to navigate these potential challenges for the sake of a great-tasting product, The Nerdy Baker offers a unique option. The business’s success is a testament to its baking talent, but the loss of long-time customers serves as a cautionary tale about the importance of consistent and respectful customer service. For anyone in Rumford and the surrounding areas, The Nerdy Baker presents a dichotomy: a place with incredible products and a service model that, according to some, leaves a lot to be desired. It is a business that holds both the promise of a delicious treat and the risk of a frustrating experience.
The Nerdy Baker LLC Food & drink
Beverages
- hot coffee US$2.00
- hot tea US$2.00
- iced coffee US$3.25
- iced tea US$3.25
- bottled water US$1.75
- Minute Maid apple juice US$2.25
- Del's lemonade US$3.00
- Yacht Club soda US$2.50
Cola, Cream, Root Beer, Ginger Ale
- soda can US$1.50
Diet Coke, Sprite, Wild Cherry Pepsi, Mountain Dew Baja Blast, Yoo-Hoo
- Mojo OJo US$3.50
Orange juice infused with pineapple & mango
- Pinky & the Lemonade US$3.25
Lemonade infused with strawberries, watermelon & raspberries
Sweets
- cupcakes US$4.00
- cookies US$2.25
- french macaron US$2.00
- bread pudding US$6.50
- choc. lava cake US$7.50
- grapenut custard US$6.50
- fruit bars US$3.50
- gourmet cookies US$2.75
- brownies US$3.00
- cannoli US$2.75
- eclair US$4.00
- cheesecake slice US$5.25
- cake slice US$5.75
- pie slice US$5.50
- cupcake US$4.50
Gluten-Friendly Option
- brownie US$4.25
Gluten-Friendly Option
Breakfast
- egg & cheese sandwich US$5.00
on an English Muffin
- meat, egg & cheese sandwich US$6.25
on an English Muffin. Choose bacon, sausage or ham
Build-Your-Own Wrap
- Build Your Own Wrap US$8.00
includes 2 eggs. Choose your wrap: white, wheat, spinach or roasted red pepper. Choose your protein: bacon, sausage or ham. Choose your cheese: American, provolone, Swiss or Shredded Mexican. Choose your veggies: spinach, tomato, onions, peppers, banana peppers, jalapeno
Toast
- Avocado Toast US$9.00
avocado, mixed greens, pico de gallo on multigrain toast
- Peanut Butter / Nutella Toast US$8.00
peanut butter or Nutella, granola, strawberries, banana slices, honey on multigrain toast
Bowls
- Greek Yogurt US$8.50
yogurt topped with up to 4 items: granola, chia seeds, strawberries, blueberries, banana slices, mini choc chips, peanut butter, honey, almonds, walnuts
- Oatmeal US$7.50
oatmeal topped with up to 4 items: granola, chia seeds, strawberries, blueberries, banana slices, mini choc chips, peanut butter, honey, almonds, walnuts
Smoothies
- Jolly Green US$8.75
spinach, kale, banana, pineapple & mango. Made with whole milk.
- Moose US$9.50
chocolate protein, peanut butter, chocolate swirl, Greek yogurt, banana. Made with whole milk.
- The Cap US$9.50
vanilla protein, strawberries, blueberries, Greek yogurt. Made with whole milk.
- Butter Beer US$8.75
Greek yogurt, banana, vanilla, cinnamon, butterscotch swirl. Made with whole milk.
- Blue Galaxy US$8.75
coconut, rice milk, pineapple, dragonfruit.
- Punch Buggy US$8.75
strawberries, pineapple, mango, passion fruit puree, orange juice.
Lite Lunch Fare
- BLT US$9.00
includes a bag of chips & pickles
- Grilled Cheese US$4.75
white or wheat bread only. Includes a bag of chips & pickles
- Tuna Salad US$6.25
Finger Sandwich. Includes a bag of chips & pickles
- Egg Salad US$5.25
Finger Sandwich. Includes a bag of chips & pickles
The Nerdy Baker LLC Details
From the business
- Identifies as women-owned
- Small Business
Service options
- Delivery
- In-store pick-up
- In-store shopping
- Takeaway
Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible car park
- Assistive hearing loop
- Wheelchair-accessible seating
- Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Offerings
- Coffee
Dining options
- Breakfast
Amenities
- Wi-Fi
- Wi-Fi
Crowd
- LGBTQ+ friendly
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Parking
- Free of charge street parking
- Free parking lot
- On-site parking
The Nerdy Baker LLC Photos










The Nerdy Baker LLC Location
The Nerdy Baker LLC
237 Newman Ave, Rumford, RI 02916, USA
The Nerdy Baker LLC Reviews
chocolatepricespizzafrostingmuffinscannolislemon squaresbreakfast sandwichsmorescost
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1Went for RI food fights cupcake wars, we tried the banana pudding cupcake and s’mores cupcake they were both super moist and flavorful. As well as grabbing some pizza strips that’s had the perfect amount of sauce.
April 07 · Kaylin FoleyMy wife and I have gone to the Nerdy Baker a few times and they have a great product but the service leaves something to be desired. For context, we have been patrons of this establishment since just about the time it opened. We enjoyed their product so much that I decided to get my wife's birthday cake from them. The day came to pick it up and I was informed that I wasn't supposed to pick it up until the late afternoon and nothing had been started. This was never communicated, to my knowledge, but I let it go as things happen. My wife's baby shower cake was then ordered and it came out beautifully and everything was perfect. Our most recent visit was anything but. We came in to order our daughter's birthday cake. We had a couple questions regarding it and asked to speak to the owner, who would ultimately be handling it. The gentleman out front informed us that she was "Too busy". When we started to ask questions in regards to the order he kept going in the back to ask the owner and coming back with answers having nothing to do with what we asked. We once again asked to speak to the owner and was once again told "She is too busy" and to come back later. I don't own a business myself but being "Too busy" to speak with a potential customer and not valuing their time is no way of doing business, no matter how good of a product you may have. I won't ever force a business to take my money, so we will not be returning to this establishment again.
May 20 · Eric TorresOrdered for a group of students. Their comments were as follows:The large lemonade was sweet and delicious!! I enjoyed every sip and chug!!The bagel was delicious!Best vanilla cake I ever tasted!!Really good grilled cheese. Best on the planet!!Best smoothie on the planet. So fresh! So fragrant!! OB - SESSED!One of the top 2 cookies I have ever tasted.Pretty good vanilla and raspberry cupcake. The white chocolate was the bomb!!Thank you!!
May 13 · Connie Orsogna MuirA million stars if I could ! Anita & the rest of her team are AMAZING all around ! I’m blown away every time with her services , the beautiful works of art she creates with our cakes, the way they taste, all of the things she offers …the food is wonderful too ! She has been absolutely incredible with me and my family …patient and kind …I’m just truly grateful for her and her work ..coming through for us on our special days, even the ones that are difficult yet so special to us, like our infant sons birthday that passed away. Wonderful person and bakery that I wish I found sooner but will continue to come to for every special event 🩶🩶 here are 3 of our beautiful cakes that she went above and beyond for us making !! Calling now to order another and been meaning to write this review ! Thank you so much for EVERYTHING!
March 26 · Laura MurphyUsed Anita and Nerdy Baker for our wedding cake and cupcakes! We were so thrilled with how everything came out. The guests thoroughly enjoyed the cupcakes and they didn’t last long at all! We loved our single 6” cake for our private cutting. Would 100% recommend The Nerdy Baker to anyone!
September 07 · Tony Ball
Categories
Top Visited Sites
Arevik Bakery4.0 (106 reviews)
Diamond Donuts4.0 (78 reviews)
Bagel Boss Burbank4.0 (323 reviews)
Mochill Mochidonut4.0 (259 reviews)
Albertsons Bakery0.0 (0 reviews)
Premiere Pastry4.0 (43 reviews)Top Searches
Trending Bakery Tales Posts
How to Create the Perfect Caramel Apple Pie: Expert Tips and Flavor Secrets
How to Create a Perfect Dessert Buffet with Your Favorite Pastries
How to Make the Best Pumpkin Churros from Scratch at Home
How to Make the Perfect Homemade Cinnamon Roll Cake
How to Bake the Best Homemade Apple Crisp with Real Flavor
How to Make Perfect Chocolate Lava Cakes from Scratch 
