The Treatery Long Island

For New Yorkers seeking a truly exceptional sweet escape, particularly when venturing out to the scenic Hamptons or the North Fork, **The Treatery Long Island** in Jamesport stands out as a destination worth the drive. This isn't just another bakery; it's a haven for handcrafted delights, renowned for treats so compelling they inspire genuine addiction and prompt customers to order them from across state lines.

The Treatery Long Island positions itself as a purveyor of high-quality, memorable baked goods, with a special emphasis on their highly praised cookies. But their offerings extend far beyond, encompassing a range of goodies designed to satisfy every sweet tooth and even cater to significant life events like weddings. What truly sets them apart, as highlighted by glowing customer reviews, is the personal touch and genuine passion infused into every creation, particularly by the owner, Christina.

The essence of The Treatery is about creating joy through expertly crafted confections. It's a place where the pursuit of flavor innovation meets a commitment to classic comfort. Whether you're a local resident looking for a daily treat, a weekend visitor exploring the East End's culinary landscape, or someone far away craving a taste of Long Island's finest, The Treatery aims to deliver an experience that is both delightful and deeply satisfying. Their dedication to freshness, even for mailed orders, underscores their commitment to quality regardless of how you receive your treats.

Moreover, The Treatery doesn't just bake; they build relationships. The personal connection with customers, evidenced by thoughtful gestures and a bubbly personality, transforms a simple purchase into a memorable interaction. This human element, combined with their delectable products, makes The Treatery Long Island a standout in the vibrant New York food scene and a must-visit for anyone with a love for exceptional baked goods.

The Treatery Long Island is conveniently located at **1564 Main Rd, Jamesport, NY 11947, USA**. This address places the bakery in the charming heart of Jamesport, a picturesque hamlet nestled on Long Island's North Fork. The location on Main Road (often referred to as Route 25) is highly advantageous, as it's a primary artery for travel through this beautiful wine country region.

For those traversing the North Fork, Main Road serves as a central route connecting various towns and attractions, making The Treatery an easy and logical stop. Whether you're embarking on a wine tour, visiting local farms, or simply enjoying the scenic drive, the bakery's prominent position ensures it's simple to find and access. Ample parking in such a location is typical for businesses catering to both local and tourist traffic, allowing for convenient stops.

Jamesport itself is known for its serene atmosphere and is a popular destination for those seeking a quieter, more relaxed experience compared to the bustling Hamptons. The Treatery's presence here adds to the local appeal, providing a beloved spot for both residents and the many visitors who frequent the area. Its accessibility makes it a perfect place to grab treats for a picnic at a nearby vineyard, pick up a custom cake for a local event, or simply indulge in a sweet craving while exploring the North Fork's unique offerings.

Even for New Yorkers in Manhattan or other distant parts of the state, the bakery's location makes it a worthwhile destination for a day trip or weekend getaway, especially given the positive reviews that encourage making the journey. The option for mail order also extends its reach beyond immediate physical accessibility, ensuring its renowned treats can be enjoyed by a wider audience.

• Gourmet Cookies: The Treatery is highly acclaimed for its delectable cookies, particularly the Triple Chocolate Chip and the Peanut Butter (Chocolate) Chip varieties. These are described as "game changers" and "addictive," indicating a mastery of cookie baking.

• Custom Wedding Cakes: The bakery specializes in creating personalized wedding cakes. Christina, the owner, is noted for her ability to listen to visions and "nail the design," offering flavors like Chocolate Strawberry Shortcake that are indistinguishable from non-vegan options.

• Vegan Baking Options: A significant offering is their expertise in vegan baked goods, specifically highlighted by their successful vegan wedding cake. This caters to a growing demand for dietary-inclusive options.

• Variety of Other Goodies and Treats: Beyond cookies and wedding cakes, the bakery offers a "host of other goodies and treats," including delicious cupcakes, suggesting a broad range of desserts and pastries.

• Mail Order/Shipping Services: For customers unable to visit in person, The Treatery provides mail order services. Products are carefully packaged to ensure they arrive "just as delicious and fresh" as if picked up from the shop, providing nationwide accessibility.

• Personalized Customer Experience: Owner Christina is lauded for her "loveliest, bubbliest person" and her active engagement with customers, making the process of ordering, especially for custom cakes, a joyful experience.

• Mobile Dessert Bar (Stella): While not explicitly in the provided reviews, public information indicates The Treatery operates "Stella," a 1964 Shasta Airflyte Camper converted into a mobile dessert bar, offering sweet and savory bakes for events. This expands their service beyond the physical storefront for catering and special occasions.

• "Game Changer" Cookies: The triple chocolate chip and peanut butter (chocolate) chip cookies are repeatedly highlighted as exceptionally delicious and addictive, setting a very high standard for their cookie offerings. The "game changer" description indicates a unique and superior product.

• Exceptional Vegan Baking: The ability to create a wedding cake that is "amazing" and where "you can't even tell that it is vegan" is a significant highlight, showcasing high-level skill in alternative baking.

• Highly Personalized Customer Service: Christina, the owner, receives extensive praise for her joyful personality, attentiveness, and ability to translate customer visions into reality, especially for custom orders like wedding cakes. This personal connection is a strong differentiator.

• Consistent Quality (Even Through Shipping): The fact that mail-ordered cookies arrive "just as delicious and fresh as if I went into the bake shop" speaks volumes about their commitment to product integrity and quality control, even across distances.

• Broad Appeal and Versatility: Catering to everyday cravings with cookies and cupcakes, as well as significant life events with custom wedding cakes, demonstrates a versatile appeal to a wide customer base.

• Ideal for North Fork/Hamptons Visitors: Positioned as a "must treat yourself to" stop when "venturing out to the Hamptons, the North Fork, etc.," it's a recognized and recommended destination for those exploring Long Island's East End.

• Strong Customer Loyalty: The desire of a customer to mail order cookies to Manhattan because of their "immense addiction" highlights a powerful level of customer loyalty and satisfaction.

• "Stella" Mobile Dessert Bar: The existence of a mobile dessert bar expands their reach for events, offering a unique catering option for parties and gatherings.

Address: 1564 Main Rd, Jamesport, NY 11947, USA

Phone: (631) 779-2883

Mobile Phone: +1 631-779-2883

For New Yorkers residing on Long Island, particularly in the Jamesport area and across the North Fork, The Treatery Long Island is an exceptionally suitable local bakery that offers far more than just baked goods. Its appeal for locals is deeply rooted in its commitment to high-quality products, personalized service, and a versatile range of offerings that cater to various needs and occasions.

Firstly, the sheer quality and unique appeal of their signature items, especially the **"game changer" cookies** like the Triple Chocolate Chip and Peanut Butter Chip, provide a compelling reason for local patronage. For daily indulgence or a specific craving, having such highly acclaimed treats readily available in the neighborhood is a significant advantage. The ability to cater to specific dietary needs, such as creating an "amazing" vegan wedding cake, further broadens its appeal to a diverse local community.

Beyond the product, the unparalleled **personalized customer service** delivered by owner Christina is a standout feature. Her genuine kindness, bubbly personality, and dedication to listening to customer visions create a welcoming and reassuring experience, particularly for significant custom orders like wedding cakes. For locals, this means working with a business that not only delivers on taste and design but also cares deeply about the customer's experience, fostering a strong sense of trust and community connection.

The bakery's strategic location on **1564 Main Rd in Jamesport** makes it highly accessible for residents of the North Fork and surrounding areas. It's a convenient stop during daily routines, weekend outings, or when entertaining guests. Furthermore, the option for **mail order** extends its suitability even to New Yorkers in Manhattan or other parts of the state who might crave their favorite cookies during the off-season or when they can't make the trip out east. This flexibility ensures that the delicious treats remain accessible year-round.

In conclusion, The Treatery Long Island isn't just a bakery; it's a beloved local institution that delivers exceptional flavor, heartwarming service, and a versatile range of products. For anyone in the New York region seeking top-tier baked goods, custom celebratory cakes, or simply a delightful treat backed by genuine care, The Treatery Long Island is a truly outstanding and highly suitable choice that continuously delights its local and distant patrons alike.

The Treatery Long Island

1564 Main Rd, Jamesport, NY 11947, USA