The Upper Crust Overland Park KS: Premier Pie Shop for Gourmet Desserts and Coffee on Santa Fe Drive

The Upper Crust Introduce

Introduction / Overview

For residents across the Kansas City metro area, and particularly for those in Overland Park, Kansas, The Upper Crust has established itself as the premier destination for extraordinary pie. More than just a simple bakery, this specialty Pie shop on Santa Fe Drive is a celebrated local institution that has perfected the art of the pie, offering an expansive and diverse menu that caters to every conceivable craving and dietary need. The business is proudly identified as women-owned, contributing to the strong entrepreneurial spirit of the Overland Park community.

What immediately sets The Upper Crust apart is the sheer breadth and depth of its offerings, which showcase a masterful dedication to flavor and variety. The menu is meticulously organized, featuring everything from deeply traditional fruit pies to rich, creamy chilled pies and savory quiches. Customers are consistently impressed by the quality, with one patron describing their Pecan Pie slice (served with ice cream) as "🔥🔥🔥" and another raving about a Keylime pie that was "super tart and delicious." This high praise confirms the exceptional quality and execution found in their products.

The Upper Crust is not just about the product; it is equally focused on the experience. Customers note the exceptional hospitality, describing the ladies who run the business as "so welcoming and kind," making the visit "great" and establishing the vital "relationship with customers" that helps local businesses truly grow. This combination of "great food and hospitality" is what makes The Upper Crust a cherished local favorite in the Kansas community. Whether you are seeking a comforting classic like the Sour Cream Apple, an exotic treat like German Chocolate Pie, or a thoughtful option like their Sweet Corn And Bacon Quiche, The Upper Crust is equipped to provide an unforgettable gourmet experience, reinforcing its status as the top pie shop in Overland Park.

Location and Accessibility

The location of The Upper Crust is a major highlight for local Kansas customers, situated right in the heart of Downtown Overland Park on the iconic Santa Fe Drive. The physical address is: 7943 Santa Fe Dr, Overland Park, KS 66204, USA.

This central location within the 66204 zip code ensures easy access for residents throughout Overland Park and surrounding Johnson County communities. Being on Santa Fe Drive means the shop is part of a vibrant, historic area, making a visit to The Upper Crust a pleasant part of a local shopping or dining excursion. The business recognizes the importance of convenience and accessibility for its patrons.

To facilitate easy visits, the location offers Free street parking, which is highly convenient for customers making a "Quick visit" to pick up a slice, a dozen cookies, or a full pie order. Furthermore, The Upper Crust demonstrates a clear commitment to inclusivity by providing key physical access features. This includes a Wheelchair accessible entrance, ensuring that all customers can easily enter the premises. A dedicated Wheelchair accessible parking lot is also provided, significantly enhancing the convenience for patrons who require accessible parking close to the shop. The combination of a charming, central location and essential accessibility features makes The Upper Crust a seamless and welcoming experience for everyone in the Overland Park, Kansas community.

Services Offered

The Upper Crust provides a focused, yet diverse, range of services, centered around their expertise as a Pie shop, ensuring they can meet virtually any pie-related need in the Kansas region.

Extensive Full-Size Pie Sales: Offers an enormous variety of full-size pies, divided into two main categories: Full Size Chilled (e.g., Peanut Butter Pie, Coconut Meringue Pie) and Full Size Non Chilled (e.g., Pecan Pie, Cherry Pie).
Specialized Dietary Options: Provides a selection of Full Sugar Free Pies, including Sugar Free Apple, Sugar Free Blueberry, and Sugar Free Strawberry Rhubarb, catering to health-conscious or restricted diets.
Savory Offerings: Expands the menu beyond sweets with high-quality Quiche, such as the popular Sweet Corn And Bacon Quiche, suitable for light meals or appetizers.
Cookie and Bar Production: Offers a large selection of Cookies and Bars by the dozen or half-dozen, including staples like Chocolate Chip Cookie and unique options like Salted Caramel Pecan Bars and Game Day Shortbread.
Beverage and Scoop Service: Provides both Coffee and Pint Ice Cream, perfectly complementing their pie slices and cookies.
Convenient Transaction Models: Facilitates easy purchasing through In-store pickup, In-store shopping, and Takeout, catering to both spontaneous and pre-ordered needs.
Specific Meringue Pickup Times: Clearly communicates that all meringue pies, such as the Butterscotch Meringue Pie, will be available for pickup after 12pm (noon) on the designated day, ensuring freshness and quality control.

Features / Highlights

The Upper Crust is highly regarded in the Overland Park community due to several distinct operational and philosophical features that enhance the customer experience.

Women-Owned Local Business: A distinguishing feature, emphasizing community support for local, female entrepreneurship in Kansas.
Unmatched Menu Depth: Offers one of the most extensive pie selections available locally, with nearly 40 distinct flavors across all categories, ensuring choice for every occasion and taste preference.
Exceptional Hospitality: Consistently praised for having staff who are "welcoming and kind," enhancing the overall experience and fostering strong customer relationships.
Gourmet Flavor Execution: Products like the Keylime Pie are noted for being "super tart and delicious," showcasing a dedication to bold, authentic, and high-quality flavor profiles.
High Accessibility: Provides key physical accessibility features, including Wheelchair accessible entrance and parking lot, ensuring service to all members of the Kansas community.
Modern Payment Convenience: Accepts modern payment methods, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, making transactions quick and effortless.

Contact Information

For Overland Park and Kansas residents ready to place an order for a full-size pie, grab a cookie, or simply enjoy a slice with coffee and ice cream, The Upper Crust can be reached at the following details. It is always best to call ahead for custom or large orders.

Address: 7943 Santa Fe Dr, Overland Park, KS 66204, USA

Phone: (913) 642-2999

What is worth choosing

For any user in the Kansas region, choosing The Upper Crust is an easy decision rooted in the guarantee of product quality, immense variety, and superior customer service. What makes this local establishment truly worth choosing is its status as a highly specialized, women-owned business that has achieved mastery in its field. The commitment to pie is evident in the remarkable menu depth, offering unique and classic options, including a full line of Sugar Free Pies, which is an invaluable service for the health-conscious or diabetic community in Overland Park. The fact that the savory Sweet Corn And Bacon Quiche is also "incredibly good" proves their culinary excellence extends beyond just desserts.

Furthermore, patrons are assured of a delightful interaction every time they visit. The consistent reports of "welcoming and kind" hospitality demonstrate that The Upper Crust prioritizes the customer experience, making every purchase enjoyable. The physical accessibility (Wheelchair accessible entrance and parking) combined with modern payment options (NFC mobile payments) ensures that every member of the Kansas community can conveniently and quickly access their products. By choosing The Upper Crust on Santa Fe Drive, you are not only getting the best pie experience—whether it’s a slice of their famous Pecan Pie or a dozen Decadent Chocolate Cookies—but you are also supporting a beloved, dedicated, and inclusive local Kansas business.

The Upper Crust Vibe

Full Size Pie - Full Size Chilled
All meringue pies will be available for pickup after 12pm (noon) on designated pickup day
Banana Cream Pie $38.00
Homemade vanilla pastry cream loaded with fresh sliced bananas and topped with freshly made whipped cream. Please note: Cream pie orders will be ready to pick up by 12pm.
Butterscotch Meringue Pie - PICKUP AFTER 12PM $38.00
Good old-fashioned butterscotch pudding with a mount of meringue to top it off! Pre-order your cream pies at least 48 hours in advance. We do not make large quantities of these daily...these are a specialty pie and the meringue is magical! All meringue pies will be available for pickup after 12pm (noon) on designated pickup day
Chocolate Cream Pie $38.00
Homemade chocolate pastry cream topped with freshly made whipped cream. Cream Pie orders will be ready for pickup after 12pm
Chocolate Meringue Pie - PICKUP AFTER 12PM $38.00
Homemade chocolate pastry cream with a mound of meringue to top it off! All meringue pies will be available for pickup after 12pm (noon) on designated pickup day
Coconut Cream Pie $38.00
Homemade vanilla pastry cream enhanced with sweet, shredded coconut, beautifully finished with freshly made whipped cream and toasted coconut.
Coconut Custard Pie $35.00
This pie will take you back in time! Granny's old fashioned custard pie enhanced with sweet coconut.
Coconut Meringue Pie - PICKUP AFTER 12PM $38.00
Homemade vanilla pastry cream enhanced with sweet, shredded coconut and finished with a mound of meringue and toasted coconut. All meringue pies will be available for pickup after 12pm (noon) on designated pickup day
Lemon Curd Pie $33.00
Sweet and tart lemon curd made with lots of fresh lemon juice and zest. This pie is like a lemon bar baked into our signature all butter pastry crust.
Peanut Butter Pie $36.00
This may sound like kids' stuff, but this mousse-like filling and chocolate ganache makes for a decadent treat that appeals to adults & kids alike! Please note: Contains Nuts
Pumpkin Pie $34.00
A smooth creamy fall favorite with just the right blend of spices
Sour Cream Apple $35.00
Layers of Apples with a spiced sour cream mixture, then topped with lots of crumbly streusel.
Sour Cream Blueberry Pie $34.00
Wild blueberries baked in a creamy filling and finished with a crumble topping. This pie is always a hit!
Sour Cream Raisin Meringue Pie - PICKUP AFTER 12PM $38.00
Nutmeg spiced custard filled with plump raisins finished with a mound of meringue. This one will take you back to Grandma's kitchen! All meringue pies will be available for pickup after 12pm (noon) on designated pickup day
Sour Cream Raspberry $34.00
The perfect combination of sweet and tart! Raspberries baked in a creamy filling and finished with a subtly spiced brown sugar crumble topping

Full Size Pie - Full Size Non Chilled
Apple Crumb Pie $35.00
Thinly sliced apples with a hint of nutmeg and topped with a streusel crumble topping.
Apple Pie $36.00
Grandma's recipe made with fresh sliced apples and a hint of nutmeg.
Apple Rhubarb Pie $35.00
Thinly sliced apples mixed with tart rhubarb and a hint of cinnamon. Finished off with a walnut crumble topping, this pie is sure to delight.
Blackberry Pie $34.00
Plump blackberries fill up this delicious pie!
Blueberry Pie $34.00
Wild blueberries are the star of the show in this delicious pie
Bumbleberry Pie $34.00
Blueberries, blackberries, raspberries and apples heaped into our all-butter flaky pastry crust and finished off with a brown sugar crumble topping
Caramel Apple $38.00
Homemade caramel sauce and pecans heavily drizzled on top of cinnamon spiced apple pie.
Cherry Pie $35.00
Sour cherries make this one of our most popular flavors.
Chocolate Chess Pie $34.00
Chocolate Chess Pie is a rich and indulgent cross between a brownie and pudding pie. Lots of chocolate flavor packed into a flaky crust!
Chocolate Chip Pecan Pie $35.00
Our signature pecan pie recipe loaded with chocolate chips!
Chocolate Pecan Pie $35.00
A decadent and delicious combination of pecans and melted chocolate
German Chocolate Pie $35.00
This handsome pie is chocolate heaven loaded with coconut and pecans “Best Thing I Ever Ate” -The Cooking Channel / 2020
Harvest Apple Pie $35.00
Packed with fall flavor, we add a splash of orange juice to this wonderful mix of Apples and Cranberries then finish it off with a walnut streusel topping. *Contains Nuts *Only available early November. *GRATEFUL topper not included.
Oatmeal Brown Sugar Pie $33.00
If you are a fan of oatmeal cookies, this pie is a sure bet! A rich brown sugar, cinnamon and oat filling that is great for breakfast, lunch and dinner. Serve warm with vanilla ice cream!
Peach Blueberry Pie $34.00
A winning combination of wild blueberries and juicy peaches with just a hint of vanilla
Peach Pie $34.00
Sweet peaches with a hint of cinnamon baked inside our signature pie crust.
Pecan Pie $35.00
Rich and gooey filling loaded with pecans, one of the great American classics
Raisin Pie $36.00
Cinnamon spiced filling loaded with plump and juicy raisins baked inside of our all butter, flaky pie crust
Strawberry Rhubarb Pie $34.00
An all-time favorite fruit pie full of strawberries and rhubarb baked with a pinch of nutmeg and orange zest.

Full Size Pie - Quiche
Sweet Corn And Bacon Quiche $33.00
Our savory sweet corn, green onion, bacon and cheese quiche - delish! Perfect for a Sunday brunch or pair it with a salad for quick and easy dinner

Full Size Pie - Full Sugar Free Pies
Sugar Free Apple $41.00
Grandma's Apple pie recipe made with fresh sliced apples and a hint of nutmeg. *The sugar free version is made with plant-based sugar alternative: Erythritol & Monk Fruit.
Sugar Free Blueberry $39.00
Our traditional Blueberry pie made with wild blueberries and plant-based sugar alternative: Erythritol & Monk Fruit.
Sugar Free Peach Pie $39.00
Our traditional Peach pie made with plant-based sugar alternative: Erythritol & Monk Fruit.
Sugar Free Rhubarb $39.00
Our traditional Rhubarb pie made with plant-based sugar alternative: Erythritol & Monk Fruit.
Sugar Free Strawberry Rhubarb $39.00
Our traditional Strawberry Rhubarb Pie made with plant-based sugar alternative: Erythritol & Monk Fruit.

Full Size Chilled
All meringue pies will be available for pickup after 12pm (noon) on designated pickup day
Banana Cream Pie $38.00
Homemade vanilla pastry cream loaded with fresh sliced bananas and topped with freshly made whipped cream. Please note: Cream pie orders will be ready to pick up by 12pm.
Butterscotch Meringue Pie - PICKUP AFTER 12PM $38.00
Good old-fashioned butterscotch pudding with a mount of meringue to top it off! Pre-order your cream pies at least 48 hours in advance. We do not make large quantities of these daily...these are a specialty pie and the meringue is magical! All meringue pies will be available for pickup after 12pm (noon) on designated pickup day
Chocolate Cream Pie $38.00
Homemade chocolate pastry cream topped with freshly made whipped cream. Cream Pie orders will be ready for pickup after 12pm
Chocolate Meringue Pie - PICKUP AFTER 12PM $38.00
Homemade chocolate pastry cream with a mound of meringue to top it off! All meringue pies will be available for pickup after 12pm (noon) on designated pickup day
Coconut Cream Pie $38.00
Homemade vanilla pastry cream enhanced with sweet, shredded coconut, beautifully finished with freshly made whipped cream and toasted coconut.
Coconut Custard Pie $35.00
This pie will take you back in time! Granny's old fashioned custard pie enhanced with sweet coconut.
Coconut Meringue Pie - PICKUP AFTER 12PM $38.00
Homemade vanilla pastry cream enhanced with sweet, shredded coconut and finished with a mound of meringue and toasted coconut. All meringue pies will be available for pickup after 12pm (noon) on designated pickup day
Lemon Curd Pie $33.00
Sweet and tart lemon curd made with lots of fresh lemon juice and zest. This pie is like a lemon bar baked into our signature all butter pastry crust.
Peanut Butter Pie $36.00
This may sound like kids' stuff, but this mousse-like filling and chocolate ganache makes for a decadent treat that appeals to adults & kids alike! Please note: Contains Nuts
Pumpkin Pie $34.00
A smooth creamy fall favorite with just the right blend of spices
Sour Cream Apple $35.00
Layers of Apples with a spiced sour cream mixture, then topped with lots of crumbly streusel.
Sour Cream Blueberry Pie $34.00
Wild blueberries baked in a creamy filling and finished with a crumble topping. This pie is always a hit!
Sour Cream Raisin Meringue Pie - PICKUP AFTER 12PM $38.00
Nutmeg spiced custard filled with plump raisins finished with a mound of meringue. This one will take you back to Grandma's kitchen! All meringue pies will be available for pickup after 12pm (noon) on designated pickup day
Sour Cream Raspberry $34.00
The perfect combination of sweet and tart! Raspberries baked in a creamy filling and finished with a subtly spiced brown sugar crumble topping

Full Size Non Chilled
Apple Crumb Pie $35.00
Thinly sliced apples with a hint of nutmeg and topped with a streusel crumble topping.
Apple Pie $36.00
Grandma's recipe made with fresh sliced apples and a hint of nutmeg.
Apple Rhubarb Pie $35.00
Thinly sliced apples mixed with tart rhubarb and a hint of cinnamon. Finished off with a walnut crumble topping, this pie is sure to delight.
Blackberry Pie $34.00
Plump blackberries fill up this delicious pie!
Blueberry Pie $34.00
Wild blueberries are the star of the show in this delicious pie
Bumbleberry Pie $34.00
Blueberries, blackberries, raspberries and apples heaped into our all-butter flaky pastry crust and finished off with a brown sugar crumble topping
Caramel Apple $38.00
Homemade caramel sauce and pecans heavily drizzled on top of cinnamon spiced apple pie.
Cherry Pie $35.00
Sour cherries make this one of our most popular flavors.
Chocolate Chess Pie $34.00
Chocolate Chess Pie is a rich and indulgent cross between a brownie and pudding pie. Lots of chocolate flavor packed into a flaky crust!
Chocolate Chip Pecan Pie $35.00
Our signature pecan pie recipe loaded with chocolate chips!
Chocolate Pecan Pie $35.00
A decadent and delicious combination of pecans and melted chocolate
German Chocolate Pie $35.00
This handsome pie is chocolate heaven loaded with coconut and pecans “Best Thing I Ever Ate” -The Cooking Channel / 2020
Harvest Apple Pie $35.00
Packed with fall flavor, we add a splash of orange juice to this wonderful mix of Apples and Cranberries then finish it off with a walnut streusel topping. *Contains Nuts *Only available early November. *GRATEFUL topper not included.
Oatmeal Brown Sugar Pie $33.00
If you are a fan of oatmeal cookies, this pie is a sure bet! A rich brown sugar, cinnamon and oat filling that is great for breakfast, lunch and dinner. Serve warm with vanilla ice cream!
Peach Blueberry Pie $34.00
A winning combination of wild blueberries and juicy peaches with just a hint of vanilla
Peach Pie $34.00
Sweet peaches with a hint of cinnamon baked inside our signature pie crust.
Pecan Pie $35.00
Rich and gooey filling loaded with pecans, one of the great American classics
Raisin Pie $36.00
Cinnamon spiced filling loaded with plump and juicy raisins baked inside of our all butter, flaky pie crust
Strawberry Rhubarb Pie $34.00
An all-time favorite fruit pie full of strawberries and rhubarb baked with a pinch of nutmeg and orange zest.

Quiche
Sweet Corn And Bacon Quiche $33.00
Our savory sweet corn, green onion, bacon and cheese quiche - delish! Perfect for a Sunday brunch or pair it with a salad for quick and easy dinner

Full Sugar Free Pies
Sugar Free Apple $41.00
Grandma's Apple pie recipe made with fresh sliced apples and a hint of nutmeg. *The sugar free version is made with plant-based sugar alternative: Erythritol & Monk Fruit.
Sugar Free Blueberry $39.00
Our traditional Blueberry pie made with wild blueberries and plant-based sugar alternative: Erythritol & Monk Fruit.
Sugar Free Peach Pie $39.00
Our traditional Peach pie made with plant-based sugar alternative: Erythritol & Monk Fruit.
Sugar Free Rhubarb $39.00
Our traditional Rhubarb pie made with plant-based sugar alternative: Erythritol & Monk Fruit.
Sugar Free Strawberry Rhubarb $39.00
Our traditional Strawberry Rhubarb Pie made with plant-based sugar alternative: Erythritol & Monk Fruit.

Cookies & Bars - Dozen Cookies
Banana Cookie - 1 Dozen $51.00
They taste like a heavenly bite of banana bread with the addition of a smooth brown sugar frosting. And yes, they are that big! Please note: You are ordering 1 dozen of this item. When specifying quantities, please keep that in mind.
Breakfast Cookie - 1 Dozen $48.50
A hearty combination of dates, raisins, almonds, oats, grape-nuts cereal, oat bran and more! Our made-from scratch cookies are ever so yummy and large at 4-5" in diameter! Please note: You are ordering a 1 dozen of this item. When specifying quantities, please keep that in mind.
Chocolate Chip Cookie - 1 Dozen $38.00
A brown sugary flavor full of mini chocolate chips with a crisp edge but slightly soft center. Our made-from scratch cookies are ever so yummy and large at 4-5" in diameter! Please note: You are ordering 1 dozen of this item. When specifying quantities, please keep that in mind.
Coconut Macaroon - 1 Dozen $40.00
This cookie is for the coconut lover! Naturally gluten free and approximately 4" in diameter. Please note: You are ordering 1 dozen of this item. When specifying quantities, please keep that in mind.
Decadent Chocolate Cookie - 1 Dozen $51.00
Soft and rich brownie cookie loaded with pecans, walnuts and chocolate chips. Cookie is approximately 4-5" in diameter. Please note: You are ordering 1 dozen of this item. When specifying quantities, please keep that in mind.
Lemon Sugar Cookie - 1 Dozen $38.00
Fresh squeezed lemon juice and lots of lemon zest baked into to this soft and refreshing lemon treat. Our made-from-scratch cookies are ever so yummy and large at 4-5" in diameter! Please note: You are ordering a 1 dozen of this item. When specifying quantities, please keep that in mind.
Molasses Crinkle - 1 Dozen $38.00
Perfectly spicy, soft and flavorful. Please note: You are ordering 1 dozen of this item. When specifying quantities, please keep that in mind.
Oatmeal Raisin Cookie - 1 Dozen $38.00
Crisp on the edge, soft & chewy in the middle. Just good 'ol fashioned made from scratch cookies. Please note: You are ordering 1 dozen of this item. When specifying quantities, please keep that in mind. 4-5" in diameter.
Peanut Butter Cookies - 1 Dozen $38.00
And old fashion favorite, this cookie is packed with peanut butter! Please note: You are ordering 1 dozen of this item. When specifying quantities, please keep that in mind. 4-5 inch diameter
Salted Caramel Pecan Bars - 1/2 Dozen (Qty: 6) $36.00
Rich salted caramel filling with pecans layered on top of a brown sugar shortbread crust. Highly addictive! 1 bar is approximately 5"x 5". Please note: You are ordering a 1/2 dozen of this item. When specifying quantities, please keep that in mind. If you would like a dozen, please order 2 of this item.
Shortbread Cookies (Apples) - 1 Dozen $53.00
Our best butter cookie is rolled out thick and topped with Sprinkles! Approximately 4" Please note: You are ordering 1 dozen of this item. When specifying quantities, please keep that in mind.
Snickerdoodle Cookies - 1 Dozen $38.00
An old-fashioned cinnamon & sugar favorite! Our made-from-scratch cookies are ever so yummy and large at 4-5" in diameter! Please note: When specifying quantities, please keep in mind that you are ordering 1 of this item.
Game Day Shortbread - 1 Dozen (Qty: 12) $53.00
How about those CHIEFS!! Our best butter cookie cut out just for the Chiefs and ready to add to the dessert table for all of your watch parties! Approximately 4"x 3"Please note: You are ordering 1 dozen of this item. When specifying quantities, please keep that in mind. If you would like one dozen, please order 1 of this item. If you would like two dozen, please order 2 of this item.
Monster Cookies - 1 Dozen $38.00
Peanut butter, oats, chocolate chips, and m&m's - all the good things you'd expect in our from-scratch monster cookie. Please note: You are ordering 1 dozen of this item. When specifying quantities, please keep this in mind. 4-5" in diameter
Game Day Shortbread - 1/2 Dozen (Qty: 6) $26.50
How about those CHIEFS!! Our best butter cookie cut out just for the Chiefs and ready to add to the dessert table for all of your watch parties! Approximately 4"x 3"Please note: You are ordering 1 /2 dozen of this item. When specifying quantities, please keep that in mind. If you would like one dozen, please order 2 of this item.

Dozen Cookies
Banana Cookie - 1 Dozen $51.00
They taste like a heavenly bite of banana bread with the addition of a smooth brown sugar frosting. And yes, they are that big! Please note: You are ordering 1 dozen of this item. When specifying quantities, please keep that in mind.
Breakfast Cookie - 1 Dozen $48.50
A hearty combination of dates, raisins, almonds, oats, grape-nuts cereal, oat bran and more! Our made-from scratch cookies are ever so yummy and large at 4-5" in diameter! Please note: You are ordering a 1 dozen of this item. When specifying quantities, please keep that in mind.
Chocolate Chip Cookie - 1 Dozen $38.00
A brown sugary flavor full of mini chocolate chips with a crisp edge but slightly soft center. Our made-from scratch cookies are ever so yummy and large at 4-5" in diameter! Please note: You are ordering 1 dozen of this item. When specifying quantities, please keep that in mind.
Coconut Macaroon - 1 Dozen $40.00
This cookie is for the coconut lover! Naturally gluten free and approximately 4" in diameter. Please note: You are ordering 1 dozen of this item. When specifying quantities, please keep that in mind.
Decadent Chocolate Cookie - 1 Dozen $51.00
Soft and rich brownie cookie loaded with pecans, walnuts and chocolate chips. Cookie is approximately 4-5" in diameter. Please note: You are ordering 1 dozen of this item. When specifying quantities, please keep that in mind.
Lemon Sugar Cookie - 1 Dozen $38.00
Fresh squeezed lemon juice and lots of lemon zest baked into to this soft and refreshing lemon treat. Our made-from-scratch cookies are ever so yummy and large at 4-5" in diameter! Please note: You are ordering a 1 dozen of this item. When specifying quantities, please keep that in mind.
Molasses Crinkle - 1 Dozen $38.00
Perfectly spicy, soft and flavorful. Please note: You are ordering 1 dozen of this item. When specifying quantities, please keep that in mind.
Oatmeal Raisin Cookie - 1 Dozen $38.00
Crisp on the edge, soft & chewy in the middle. Just good 'ol fashioned made from scratch cookies. Please note: You are ordering 1 dozen of this item. When specifying quantities, please keep that in mind. 4-5" in diameter.
Peanut Butter Cookies - 1 Dozen $38.00
And old fashion favorite, this cookie is packed with peanut butter! Please note: You are ordering 1 dozen of this item. When specifying quantities, please keep that in mind. 4-5 inch diameter
Salted Caramel Pecan Bars - 1/2 Dozen (Qty: 6) $36.00
Rich salted caramel filling with pecans layered on top of a brown sugar shortbread crust. Highly addictive! 1 bar is approximately 5"x 5". Please note: You are ordering a 1/2 dozen of this item. When specifying quantities, please keep that in mind. If you would like a dozen, please order 2 of this item.
Shortbread Cookies (Apples) - 1 Dozen $53.00
Our best butter cookie is rolled out thick and topped with Sprinkles! Approximately 4" Please note: You are ordering 1 dozen of this item. When specifying quantities, please keep that in mind.
Snickerdoodle Cookies - 1 Dozen $38.00
An old-fashioned cinnamon & sugar favorite! Our made-from-scratch cookies are ever so yummy and large at 4-5" in diameter! Please note: When specifying quantities, please keep in mind that you are ordering 1 of this item.
Game Day Shortbread - 1 Dozen (Qty: 12) $53.00
How about those CHIEFS!! Our best butter cookie cut out just for the Chiefs and ready to add to the dessert table for all of your watch parties! Approximately 4"x 3"Please note: You are ordering 1 dozen of this item. When specifying quantities, please keep that in mind. If you would like one dozen, please order 1 of this item. If you would like two dozen, please order 2 of this item.
Monster Cookies - 1 Dozen $38.00
Peanut butter, oats, chocolate chips, and m&m's - all the good things you'd expect in our from-scratch monster cookie. Please note: You are ordering 1 dozen of this item. When specifying quantities, please keep this in mind. 4-5" in diameter
Game Day Shortbread - 1/2 Dozen (Qty: 6) $26.50
How about those CHIEFS!! Our best butter cookie cut out just for the Chiefs and ready to add to the dessert table for all of your watch parties! Approximately 4"x 3"Please note: You are ordering 1 /2 dozen of this item. When specifying quantities, please keep that in mind. If you would like one dozen, please order 2 of this item.

Ice Cream & Coffee - Ice Cream & Coffee
Pint Ice Cream $5.00
Vanilla Ice Cream Vanilla Flavored Ice Cream made the Belfonte way, Pure & Rich. *1 Pint

Ice Cream & Coffee
Pint Ice Cream $5.00
Vanilla Ice Cream Vanilla Flavored Ice Cream made the Belfonte way, Pure & Rich. *1 Pint

The Upper Crust Details

From the business
Identifies as women-owned

Service options
In-store pickup
In-store shopping
Takeout
Delivery
Dine-in

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings
Coffee

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Parking
Free street parking

The Upper Crust Photos

The Upper Crust Location

The Upper Crust

Kansas Johnson County Overland Park South Lakes Santa Fe Drive

7943 Santa Fe Dr, Overland Park, KS 66204, USA

The Upper Crust Reviews

An average rating of ★4.8 from 310 user reviews.

cookiesflightquichepecansmellscoconutbumbleberry piekitchenstrawberry rhubarbblueberry pie

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

We were here visiting our grandkids, and they told us about this pie shop. Needless to say it was really, really good! I had a slice of bacon and corn quiche that was incredibly good. The grandkids had a Keylime pie that was super tart and delicious wife had a snickerdoodle cookie and we have yet to dive into the other cookie, but we can already tell it’s gonna be delicious.
April 18 · Darrin Campbell
I want to say how AWESOME 💯 this location is! First, I have never had a real Pie before 🙈 but let me tell you the Pecan Pie slice I had (with ice cream) was 🔥🔥🔥 Now, food of course is important but to me business grow due to relationship with customers! The ladies who are the backbone of the business were so welcoming and kind 😊 This made my experience with my wife great 🙌 So if you want to experience some great food and hospitality come check out The Upper Crust!
March 29 · Amal S
Upper Crust has been a must stop on all our cross country road trips. I always plan to pass through KC during their open hours because the pie is worth the stop!The strawberry rhubard pie is so delicious, and their crust is perfect. We love the cutie pies for a perfect sized road trip treat.
July 24 · Ashley Fairbanks
Stumbled onto The Upper Crust by chance and was completely, happily surprised! We left with 3 mini pies and all were delicious but the Cherry 🍒, not shown due to being inhaled, was amazing!!Also, the cookies are great!! The shortbread was thick and buttery, simple yet perfectly baked.We will absolutely be back to try more fun flavors and the pie flights!Shown are Keylime and Blueberry Buttermilk.
February 22 · Jeanette Potter
Came in on my birthday yesterday July 3rd to treat myself. It took 10 minutes for anyone to acknowledge me and the young lady that did made me feel that I was truly putting her out. We made our selection, she rang us up and then immediately walked away. My daughter & I were shocked by her lack of caring and I had to stand there another 5 minutes because she failed to give me my receipt and finally she acknowledged me, I asked her for the receipt which she gave me and quickly walked away because chatting with her coworker's were more important than a customer like me. Her customer service skills are horrible!UPDATED REVIEW 7/11/25I want to give a new review. I want everyone to know that the owners Kellie & Lisa truly cared enough about my experience they wanted to speak with me personally. All I can say is their phone call made me feel that I am a valuable customer and that I truly matter to them. They truly have an amazing bakery, if you are a lemon lover do yourself a big favor & special order their Lemon Meringue Pie, it is the most amazing pie ever!! Trust me you will not regret it!! Kellie & Lisa thank you for reaching out to me and making feel like a valued customer. I am looking forward to trying other yummy treats, we will be visiting your bakery more!!!
July 11 · Lori Cunningham (Lori Cunningham)