Tiffany’s Dessert Bar

Tiffany’s Dessert Bar: North Shore’s Destination for Custom-Crafted Sweetness

Located in Mequon, a northern suburb of Milwaukee, Tiffany’s Dessert Bar has quickly established itself as a must-visit Bakery for Wisconsin residents seeking high-quality, made-from-scratch custom desserts. Far from being a typical walk-in pastry shop, Tiffany’s operates with a modern, intentional focus on quality and freshness, specializing in personalized and pre-ordered confections.

This business is distinguished not just by its delicious offerings but also by its identity: it Identifies as Black-owned and Identifies as women-owned, bringing a unique and valued perspective to the local Mequon business community. Their philosophy centers on using the highest quality, often organic, ingredients, ensuring that every cake, cupcake, or cheesecake is mixed and baked as close to the pickup time as possible for maximum flavor and moisture.

Customers consistently praise the richness and quality of the final product. One patron, who ordered a 6-inch caramel cake for a birthday, exclaimed, "It was delicious! It was moist and very rich in taste," a common sentiment that speaks to the bakery's dedication to flavor perfection. Furthermore, their expertise extends beyond just baking; another reviewer specifically mentioned Tiffany’s helpful guidance on how to properly pack a custom cake for a long journey, highlighting the exceptional, personalized service that accompanies every order.

Tiffany’s Dessert Bar is your premier choice in the North Shore for special occasion desserts, whether you need a stunning Custom Tiered Cake for a wedding, a perfectly moist Caramel Cake for a party, or just a slice of decadent cheesecake to enjoy with a cup of Coffee.

Location and Accessibility for Mequon and Milwaukee Area Residents

The bakery is situated in the Mequon commercial district, offering easy access for customers traveling from various parts of Milwaukee County and the surrounding areas. Its location is set up to facilitate convenient and efficient customer service, particularly for pre-ordered items.

Address: 6340 W Industrial Dr, Mequon, WI 53092, USA

The physical space and service model are designed for maximum convenience:

• Wheelchair accessible entrance: Ensures the facility is welcoming and easily navigable for all customers.
• Wheelchair accessible parking lot: Provides reserved and accessible parking spaces right outside the entrance.
• Ease of Access: The service structure caters to a Quick visit but primarily runs on an Appointment required model, ensuring that staff are ready with your fresh order immediately upon your arrival.
• Amenities for a Brief Stay: Though it primarily handles pre-orders, the availability of Wi-Fi is a bonus for customers who may need to quickly confirm details during pickup.

Comprehensive Services and Decadent Offerings

Tiffany’s Dessert Bar specializes in a wide spectrum of sweet treats, from individual snacks to monumental celebration cakes. Their services are structured around pre-ordering to guarantee the freshest possible product, distinguishing them as an upscale, quality-focused Bakery.

Key Products and Service Options:

• Custom Celebration Cakes: Specializing in Custom Tiered Cakes for large events like weddings and parties, offering a variety of flavor profiles including Birthday Cake (Vanilla or Chocolate), Carrot Cake, Lemon, Vanilla, and their famous, made-from-scratch Caramel Cake.
• Signature Cheesecakes: Known for their silky smooth New York style cheesecakes, available in sizes from 7-inch up to 11-inch, with classic flavors like Plain, Cherry, and Strawberry, as well as a monthly seasonal specialty. Gluten-Free Cheesecakes are also offered.
• Individual Treats: A selection of Cupcakes (Traditional, Deluxe, and Gourmet), Bundt Cakes, Loaf Cakes (like Blueberry Lemon Loaf), Cheesecake Jars, and Blondies are available for smaller gatherings or personal indulgences.
• Inclusive Diet Options: The bakery is attentive to dietary needs, providing specific Gluten Free and Nut Free baked options to accommodate various allergies and preferences.
• Multiple Service Methods: Offers exceptional flexibility with options for In-store pickup (via appointment), convenient Curbside pickup, standard Takeout, and local Delivery within the Metro Milwaukee area.
• Payment Ease: Accepts all major Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, simplifying the transaction process.

Distinct Features and Highlights

Tiffany's Dessert Bar sets itself apart from conventional bakeries by integrating modern business practices with a commitment to traditional baking excellence, creating a uniquely appealing experience for the Wisconsin consumer.

Highlights that Make Tiffany’s Special:

• Made-From-Scratch Freshness Model: To ensure maximum enjoyment, the business model is built around baking only upon order. This is a crucial highlight, as it guarantees that their desserts are not sitting in a display case but are made the day of, or the night before, pickup.
• High-Quality & Organic Ingredients: A defining feature is the use of the highest quality and, where possible, organic ingredients, which translates directly into the rich, decadent flavor profiles customers consistently rave about.
• Famous Caramel Cake: A standout specialty is their Caramel Cake, made with a caramel sauce that is cooked from scratch, delivering the "very rich in taste" experience that has earned them high marks from local patrons.
• Outstanding Service & Logistics: Customer reviews attest to "great customer service via phone and in person," including the helpful logistical advice provided for safe cake transport—an invaluable service for customers traveling with custom orders across Wisconsin, such as to the Madison area.
• Strong Business Identity: Operating as a Black-owned and Women-owned enterprise adds a layer of community significance, encouraging local users who value supporting diverse and independent businesses.

Contact Information

To place a custom order, inquire about event services, or arrange a tasting, local residents can contact the Mequon Bakery using the details below.

Bakery Name: Tiffany’s Dessert Bar

Address: 6340 W Industrial Dr, Mequon, WI 53092, USA

Phone Number: (414) 509-8003

Why Tiffany’s Dessert Bar is Worth Choosing

For Wisconsin residents, particularly those in the Milwaukee North Shore region, choosing Tiffany’s Dessert Bar is choosing a top-tier, quality-focused experience for all your dessert needs. It is worth choosing for two primary reasons: the guarantee of fresh, custom quality and the effortless customer experience.

Firstly, the business model ensures you receive a product at its peak. The Appointment required system means your custom order, be it a multi-tiered cake or a simple Blueberry Lemon Loaf, is prepared with a clean slate, utilizing high-quality ingredients and baked fresh specifically for your pickup time. This dedication to maximum freshness results in the highly-praised, moist, and rich flavor that customers seek and appreciate. The specialized Caramel Cake and extensive cheesecake selection stand out as guaranteed crowd-pleasers.

Secondly, the operational excellence makes the entire process stress-free. From the easy online ordering to the friendly, professional phone communication and the convenient options for Curbside pickup and Delivery, the customer service is designed to be exceptional. Knowing your delicate custom cake will be properly boxed and that the staff can provide expert advice on its transport—even for a trip out to the Madison area—offers peace of mind that a standard bakery often cannot provide. You are not just buying a dessert; you are investing in a worry-free, high-quality centerpiece for your special occasion from a local, proudly Women-owned and Black-owned business.

Tiffany’s Dessert Bar

6340 W Industrial Dr, Mequon, WI 53092, USA