Top Tier Pastry in Mantua, OH: Gourmet Desserts, Inclusive Vibe, and the Famous Heavenly Roll for Northeast Ohio

Top Tier Pastry Introduce

Introduction / Overview

Nestled in the quaint, charming community of Mantua, Ohio,

Top Tier Pastry

is a local gem that has quickly become a beloved destination for residents across Portage County and Northeast Ohio. This establishment is not just a

Bakery

; it is a purveyor of high-quality, French-American fusion pastries, focusing on utilizing the finest ingredients available. Proudly identified as a

women-owned

Small business

, Top Tier Pastry is led by professionally trained Pastry Chef Tracey Garrett, whose expertise ensures every item lives up to the promise of being "top tier."

The bakery’s reputation is built on exceptional taste and an incredibly welcoming atmosphere. One customer’s glowing review perfectly captures the experience, saying the pastry truly makes you feel like "an angel came down and kissed your tongue." Another highlights the combination of "Delicious pastry. Quality ingredients. Cute indoor and outdoor seating." This dual focus on culinary excellence and a delightful customer experience is what draws people from all over Ohio to 4668 E Prospect St. They are dedicated to creating extraordinary pastries with exceptional customer service, a philosophy that has created a loyal following of patrons who are willing to drive 30 minutes or more just to pick up a box of their amazing treats.

The Mantua bakery provides a refreshing experience that encourages both a

Quick visit

for a coffee and treat, or a relaxing break utilizing the comfortable seating and

Wi-Fi

. More than just a place for sweets, Top Tier Pastry also stands out as a genuinely

LGBTQ+ friendly

and

Transgender safespace

, making it a truly inclusive and warm environment for everyone in the local Ohio community to enjoy a moment of sweetness.

Location and Accessibility

Top Tier Pastry is conveniently located at the heart of Mantua, making it an easy and accessible stop for local patrons and those traveling from the greater Northeast Ohio area. The exact location is

4668 E Prospect St, Mantua, OH 44255, USA

. Being situated in downtown Mantua, the bakery is part of a charming village setting that adds to the overall pleasant customer experience.

The bakery is committed to ensuring a comfortable visit for all. For customers arriving by car, the location provides

Free street parking

, eliminating the hassle of finding paid spots. Furthermore, accessibility is prioritized with a dedicated

Wheelchair accessible parking lot

, ensuring that patrons with mobility considerations have convenient access to the storefront. This combination of a central location and practical accessibility features ensures that the trip to this Mantua gem is always easy and straightforward for Ohio users.

Services Offered

Top Tier Pastry offers a highly personalized and focused range of services, concentrating on exquisite pastry craftsmanship and customer convenience in Mantua, Ohio.

Daily Baked Goods and Signature Pastries: A wide selection of French-American fusion pastries, made with high-quality ingredients like European-style butter, including fan favorites such as the gluten-free
Heavenly Roll
, very berry oat bars, locally sourced fruit tarts, and savory scones.
Custom and Celebration Cakes: They offer a variety of beautifully decorated signature cakes (e.g., Wavy Pearl, Cascading Rosette, Ombre Drip) in multiple sizes, ideal for Ohio birthdays, anniversaries, and special events.
Dietary-Specific Options: A commitment to inclusivity is shown through specialty offerings like the gluten-free
Heavenly Roll
and the availability of
Vegan
and
Gluten Free
options for all of their signature cakes.
Beverages and Refreshments: To perfectly complement their sweet treats, Top Tier Pastry offers
freshly brewed coffee
from Schuil Coffee Roasters and various Harney & Sons teas, providing a full café experience.
In-House and Takeout Options: Customers can enjoy their delicious treats right away with
Onsite services
in the cute indoor and outdoor seating areas, or take them home with quick and convenient
Takeout
.
Wholesale Services: The business has a history of supplying local businesses, like coffeehouses, with their special treats, indicating a capacity for larger
Wholesale Inquiry
orders.

Features / Highlights

Top Tier Pastry distinguishes itself from other bakeries in the Ohio region through a blend of premium ingredients, specialized skill, and its dedication to a welcoming environment.

Gourmet, Professionally Crafted Pastries: The owner,
Tracey Garrett
, is a professionally trained Pastry Chef, ensuring a level of technique and quality in the French-American fusion pastries that is considered "top tier" by local patrons.
Commitment to Premium Ingredients: The bakery insists on using only the finest ingredients, including European-style butter, Madagascar vanilla, Italian cocoa, and often utilizes
locally sourced produce
and organic eggs from local farmers, ensuring a superior taste and quality that Ohio customers notice.
Dietary Inclusivity with Excellence: A significant highlight is the famed
Heavenly Roll
, which is made with
gluten-free ingredients
but maintains a delicious taste that satisfies all customers, not just those with dietary restrictions. They also offer
Vegan
and
Gluten Free
versions of their signature celebration cakes.
Inclusive and Safe Environment: The bakery explicitly identifies as
LGBTQ+ friendly
and a
Transgender safespace
, fostering a community atmosphere where all Ohio patrons feel comfortable, welcome, and respected.
Atmosphere and Amenities: The availability of
Cute indoor and outdoor seating
combined with free
Wi-Fi
makes it an ideal spot for meeting a friend, a quick remote work session, or simply enjoying a relaxing break in downtown Mantua.

Contact Information

Top Tier Pastry is readily available to take orders and answer questions from the Mantua and greater Northeast Ohio community.

Address:

4668 E Prospect St, Mantua, OH 44255, USA

Phone:

(330) 289-1999

Mobile Phone (Confirmation):

+1 330-289-1999

What is worth choosing

Top Tier Pastry is absolutely worth choosing for anyone in Ohio seeking a truly exceptional baked good experience. The core reason to choose this Mantua bakery is the unparalleled quality driven by Chef Tracey Garrett's professional training and her unwavering commitment to

Quality ingredients

. The difference is palpable in every bite—one reviewer noted they were coming back specifically to get the

focaccia

, indicating the strength of their savory bakes as well as their sweets.

Beyond the delicious taste, choosing Top Tier Pastry means supporting a local,

women-owned

Small business

that actively promotes inclusivity as an

LGBTQ+ friendly

and

Transgender safespace

. This commitment to community values makes spending your money here feel good. Furthermore, the convenience of the store—offering

Free street parking

Wheelchair accessible parking

, and the option for a

Quick visit

or a leisurely stay with

Wi-Fi

—ensures a perfect customer experience every time. The fact that they cater to specific needs with an amazing, widely-loved

gluten-free Heavenly Roll

and

Vegan

cake options solidifies their standing as a top-tier choice for any craving or celebration across Northeast Ohio. You will not be disappointed—this bakery lives up to its name and its reputation.

Top Tier Pastry Details

From the business
Identifies as women-owned
Small business

Service options
Onsite services
Takeout
Delivery

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Amenities
Wi-Fi
Wi-Fi

Crowd
LGBTQ+ friendly
Transgender safespace

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Parking
Free street parking

Top Tier Pastry Photos

Top Tier Pastry Location

Top Tier Pastry

Ohio Portage County Mantua East Prospect Street

4668 E Prospect St, Mantua, OH 44255, USA

Top Tier Pastry Reviews

An average rating of ★5 from 30 user reviews.

tartsdonutscroissantingredientscoffeefocacciachoosing

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Delicious pastry. Quality ingredients. Cute indoor and outdoor seating. The owner, Tracey, and her employees are friendly and helpful. Heavenly Roll is absolutely delicious, made with gluten-free ingredients. Located in downtown Mantua Ohio. Totally worth the trip! Give it try, you won’t be disappointed.
November 13 · Missy Etling
Listen. You're going to read these reviews and maybe think "surely that one reviewer is being a little dramatic. A pastry can't really feel like an angel came down and kissed your tongue."I'm here to tell you that if anything, they undersold it. This was the best bakery I've ever been to in terms of taste and very cute and friendly to boot. Absolutely worth a trip. I'll be coming back to get focaccia next time.
January 18 · K. Rose Luczywo
This little shop is perfect. It's very quaint and the pastries are top notch. The only downside is that they are so good that they often sell out 😁 if you see anything you like posted on social media, you have to get right down there or else it's gone. Also I recommend calling before making the trip to ensure that they are open and still have items in the case. I've made the truck out to Mantua twice just specifically to go here only to find both times they sold out and closed early lol.But the times I've made it in have been totally worth it. So much care goes into every piece. It's truly 'crafted' food. I've never been disappointed by anything I've purchased!The staff are welcoming and polite. I will continue to be a long-term customer.
June 14 · Shannon Campbell
Cozy and beautiful place to have coffee or tea with homemade pastries 🍰 .I love this place.
March 23 · Hani
Just when I thought I have had it all… Top Tier does these amazing breakfast pizzas. The toppings are delicious and the Focaccia bread is perfect!! I love the tarts, cheesecakes, and croissants. I love it all!!
April 15 · Patrick Yackmack