Totally Baked Sweets, LLC

When the Indiana community needs a celebration made truly unforgettable, the name that frequently comes up is Totally Baked Sweets, LLC. This delightful, local business, which proudly operates as a family-owned bakery, has firmly established itself as the go-to expert for custom cakes and specialty baked goods in the Salem, IN area and beyond.

Totally Baked Sweets, LLC isn't just about crafting desserts; it's about bringing imagination to life in a way that is both visually stunning and, most importantly, phenomenally delicious. Their reputation is built on the passion and expertise of Mackenzie and her dedicated team, who are lauded by local customers for being "absolutely amazing." The core of their business is transforming a sweet idea—from a simple birthday treat to a complex, themed wedding cake—into a flawless reality.

Local customers consistently praise the quality, noting that they have "never had anything didn't like." Whether it's the towering elegance of a wedding cake, the playful joy of birthday treats, or seasonal items like Valentine's Day cookies, every product from this bakery is made with a personal touch that resonates deeply with the Hoosier value of home-cooked goodness. For those seeking bespoke cakes with incredible attention to detail and a taste that earns compliments long after the event, Totally Baked Sweets, LLC has secured its business "forever."

Location and Accessibility

Totally Baked Sweets, LLC is conveniently located to serve the residents of Salem, Indiana, and the surrounding regions. Situated in a practical, accessible spot, it’s designed for easy pick-up of custom and daily orders, making it a favorite for those planning a Quick visit.

The specific address for this charming bakery is: 1305 W Mulberry St ste b, Salem, IN 47167, USA.

Accessibility and convenience for their Indiana clientele are key priorities, offering:

• Ample Parking: Customers can take advantage of a Free parking lot right at the location, eliminating the hassle of searching for a spot.
• Accessibility Features: The premises include a dedicated Wheelchair accessible parking lot, ensuring that all members of the community can access their delicious baked goods with ease.
• Service Options: The primary mode of service is Takeout, making it perfectly suited for customers to pick up their large custom cake orders, pre-ordered treats, or daily delights efficiently.
• Payment Flexibility: Payments are made simple with the acceptance of major options, including Credit cards and Debit cards.

This centralized location on W Mulberry St ensures that picking up that perfect cake or a box of specialty treats is always a smooth, stress-free experience for local users in the 47167 zip code and beyond.

Services Offered

As a specialist Bakery, Totally Baked Sweets, LLC focuses on highly customized and specialty baked goods for a wide variety of events and personal treats. Their services are tailor-made to meet the unique requirements of their customers.

The core services provided to the Indiana community include:

• Custom Wedding and Birthday Cakes: Their signature service, specializing in custom cakes for major milestones. They are known for exceptional decorative detail and personalized themes, ranging from traditional wedding tiers to complex, imaginative designs (like Harry Potter/Lord of the Rings themed cakes mentioned in customer reviews).
• Wide Range of Cake Flavors: Offering a robust selection of flavors for cakes and cupcakes, including classic options like Chocolate, Vanilla, Marble, and Strawberry, as well as specialty choices such as Lemon, Peanut Butter, and Cheesecake.
• Variety of Frosting Options: Custom cakes can be paired with delicious frostings like Chocolate, Vanilla, Blackberry, Strawberry, Peanut Butter, Cream Cheese, Maple, and Coconut Creme.
• Custom Sizing and Shapes: Cakes are available in various sizes and shapes, including traditional Circle and Rectangle forms, as well as sheet cakes (Small 8x12, Medium 14x18, Large 20x24) to accommodate parties of any size.
• Cupcakes and Specialty Treats: In addition to large cakes, they prepare incredible cupcakes, specialty cookies, and seasonal treats, often catering to large holiday orders (e.g., Valentine's day treats).
• Gluten-Free Options: Demonstrating a commitment to accommodating dietary needs, they offer gluten-free versions of key cake flavors like Chocolate, Vanilla, and Marble, with accompanying frosting options.
• Takeout Service: All products are prepared for Takeout or pick-up, perfect for customers bringing specialty desserts to their event venues.

These focused services solidify their reputation as the premier choice for custom-designed desserts in Southern Indiana.

Features / Highlights

Totally Baked Sweets, LLC is distinguished by several key features that set it apart as a favorite among Indiana locals, especially those planning significant celebrations.

The highlights of choosing this bakery include:

• Unmatched Customization and Creativity: They are praised for their ability to execute complex and imaginative cake designs exactly as the customer envisioned, such as the impressive Harry Potter/Lord of the Rings cake. This high level of bespoke design capability is a major draw for custom orders.
• Phenomenal Taste: While aesthetics are important, their most crucial feature is the superior flavor. Customers repeatedly stress that the taste is "phenomenal" and "sooo good," ensuring that the dessert is remembered for its quality long after the event.
• Family-Owned and Hometown Charm: The bakery is cherished as a "cutest little home town family owned bakery." This local, personal touch ensures attentive service and a commitment to quality that larger operations often lack.
• Reliability for Major Events: Local users trust the bakery implicitly for their biggest days, consistently choosing them to make wedding cake and key family birthday cakes, a powerful endorsement of their reliability and quality.
• Accommodation of Dietary Needs: The availability of specific Gluten free cake batter and frosting flavors is a significant feature, showing their dedication to serving all members of the community in Indiana.
• Comprehensive Dessert Offerings: Beyond just cakes, they provide a full range of celebratory sweets, including custom cookies and seasonal baked goods, making them a one-stop-shop for dessert platters.

These highlights demonstrate the bakery’s commitment to combining exceptional artistry with phenomenal flavor, all within a friendly, local business atmosphere.

Contact Information

To discuss a custom order for a wedding or birthday, or to inquire about the current selection of specialty treats, local users in Indiana can contact Totally Baked Sweets, LLC using the following information:

Address: 1305 W Mulberry St ste b, Salem, IN 47167, USA

Phone: (812) 844-2831

Mobile Phone: +1 812-844-2831

The team is highly recommended for their friendly and patient assistance when deciding on the perfect cake or treats for any occasion.

What is Worth Choosing

Choosing Totally Baked Sweets, LLC means opting for a guaranteed highlight for your event, crafted by a trusted local family. In the crowded market of bakeries, this Salem, IN gem stands out as the specialized choice for custom confectionery needs in Southern Indiana.

Specialization in High-Stakes Baking: Their repeated success with wedding cake orders, which are arguably the most important dessert of anyone's life, speaks volumes about their professionalism and quality control. When a product needs to be beautiful, delivered perfectly, and taste incredible, local patrons repeatedly put their trust in Mackenzie and her team. This track record is worth more than any price.

The Perfect Combination of Artistry and Flavor: The ability to flawlessly execute a detailed, niche theme—like a multi-themed fantasy cake—while ensuring the taste is "phenomenal" is what makes them unique. They don't sacrifice substance for style; they deliver both at the highest level. For Hoosiers planning a themed party or wedding, their creative flair is second to none.

A True Local Partnership: As a "cutest little home town family owned bakery," every order supports a local Salem family and is treated with the care and attention of a personal project. Customers become loyal, lifelong patrons because they feel the warmth and personal dedication in every bite. For residents of Indiana who value supporting local business and receiving personalized service for their most cherished events, Totally Baked Sweets, LLC is the clear, and sweet, choice.

Totally Baked Sweets, LLC

1305 W Mulberry St ste b, Salem, IN 47167, USA