All the Crumbs

Introduction / Overview

Located in the scenic heart of Genesee Depot, Wisconsin, All the Crumbs is a highly-specialized, family-owned business that has rapidly become the premier destination for custom-decorated cookies in Waukesha County and the surrounding areas. Led by the husband and wife team of Alia and Eli Darling, this bakery is far more than a simple sweet shop; it is a creative studio dedicated to producing edible art. Their specialty lies in made-to-order, custom-designed decorated sugar cookies, which customers consistently praise as both "amazing" in taste and having a "beautiful presentation."

The foundation of their success is the signature vanilla bean sugar cookie, topped with smooth royal icing. These cookies can be customized in virtually any shape, style, design, or color imaginable, making them the perfect, personalized centerpiece for any Wisconsin event—from baby's first birthday parties and graduation celebrations to corporate events and simple, thoughtful gestures. The genuine care and attention to detail, which customers describe as service that goes "above and beyond," includes kind gestures like personal door delivery. This dedication to both the quality of the product and the quality of the customer experience ensures that All the Crumbs is a non-negotiable choice for anyone in the region looking for a memorable dessert. They even cater to specialized needs, offering a selection of Keto/diabetic-friendly treats made to order, further showcasing their commitment to serving the diverse needs of the local community.

Location and Accessibility

All the Crumbs is conveniently situated at S42W31370 WI-83 Unit 5, Genesee Depot, WI 53127, USA. This location places the bakery accessibly within the Genesee Depot community, making it a manageable drive for customers throughout Waukesha County and the western suburbs of Milwaukee.

As a custom, made-to-order specialty business, All the Crumbs is structured for efficient customer interaction, primarily through takeout and pickup of pre-arranged orders. The facility ensures accessibility with a wheelchair accessible parking lot, demonstrating a commitment to serving all members of the local Wisconsin community comfortably. Given that the business operates on a part-time, made-to-order model, communication and pre-planning are essential. While their primary service option is takeout, the business is known to provide flexible and personalized services, including personally delivering orders to customers' doors—a highly valued, kind gesture that goes "above and beyond" for clients who are often busy setting up for their events. For customers planning an order, note that the owners work full-time and manage the bakery alongside raising a family, so it is recommended to inquire well in advance for events, as their calendar fills up quickly.

Services Offered

• Custom Decorated Sugar Cookies: Specializes in vanilla bean sugar cookies topped with royal icing, customized to match any theme, color scheme, or design for special events (birthdays, weddings, announcements, corporate logos).
• Specialized Cookie Sets: Offers tiered pricing for designs ranging from simple (Decorated with Royal Icing) to highly detailed (Character cookies, Logo/Corporate cookies), with prices starting around $69.00 to $75.00 per dozen for standard 3.5-4 inch cookies.
• Mini Cookies: Smaller, bite-sized cookies (1.5-2 inches) are available for large gatherings or as simple party favors.
• Alternative Icing Options: Buttercream icing is available for decorating cookies seasonally (though not available for shipping).
• Interactive Cookie Kits: Provides 'Paint Your Own (PYO)' cookie sets, which include the cookie 'canvas,' edible paint palette, and brush, starting around $69.00 per dozen for a fun, engaging activity.
• Dietary Specialty Treats: Offers made-to-order Keto/diabetic-friendly treats, catering to the health-conscious and those with specific dietary requirements in the Wisconsin market.
• Shipping and Takeout: Offers local takeout (pickup) in Genesee Depot and ships cookies country-wide, ensuring safe, boxed delivery for customers outside the immediate local area.

Features / Highlights

• Artistic Excellence and Presentation: Customers consistently rave about the "creative & delicious" quality, noting the cookies are "absolute works of art" and provide a stunning presentation for any party.
• Signature Vanilla Bean Cookie: Uses a proprietary vanilla bean sugar cookie base that is celebrated for its delicious taste, ensuring the treat is as enjoyable to eat as it is to look at.
• Personalized Customer Service: The owners are noted for going "above and beyond" in service, including personal delivery to busy clients and building long-term relationships, resulting in repeat customers.
• Specialization in Milestones: Has a proven track record for executing complex, high-stakes orders like pregnancy announcements, gender reveals, and first birthday parties, demonstrating high reliability and quality for important events.
• Dietary Inclusion: The availability of made-to-order Keto/diabetic-friendly treats broadens the appeal and utility of the bakery for a wider range of Wisconsin consumers.
• Flexible Shipping/Pickup: Offers both local takeout at the accessible Genesee Depot location and country-wide shipping, extending their reach beyond Waukesha County.

Contact Information

Address: S42W31370 WI-83 Unit 5, Genesee Depot, WI 53127, USA

Phone: (262) 201-4525

What is Worth Choosing

For Wisconsin residents, choosing All the Crumbs for your event is worth it because you are investing in unmatched quality, presentation, and deeply personal service. Unlike generic store-bought items, these cookies are truly custom works of art, guaranteed to elicit compliments and ensure your event stands out. Customer testimonials repeatedly underscore the dual excellence of the product: they look incredible and they "taste delicious," a critical balance that many custom bakeries struggle to achieve. When guests are asking who made the cookies and taking extras for the road, as one reviewer noted, you know the product is exceptional.

The level of personalized attention is another non-negotiable factor. The team's willingness to go "above and beyond" with personal delivery, especially for clients busy setting up, is a highly valued service that removes a common point of stress in event planning. Furthermore, their ability to create special dietary items, such as Keto/diabetic-friendly treats, means no guest has to be left out, demonstrating a true commitment to inclusive service for the community.

Given the high demand—as evidenced by customers making them a "non-negotiable" part of subsequent family events—placing an order with All the Crumbs means securing a premium, artisan dessert that elevates any celebration in the Waukesha County region. It is the perfect choice for those who value craftsmanship, personalized detail, and exceptional customer experience.

All the Crumbs

S42W31370 WI-83 Unit 5, Genesee Depot, WI 53127, USA